Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

45 colt keyhole one out of about every 10 rounds.

Featured Replies

Hi all

  As the title suggests I am having a little difficulty with this load.  I am loading:

255gn Hornady cowboy action lead bullet (.454")

once fired winchester brass

CCI large pistol primer

7.5gn universal clays

  I am shooting a 6" taurus Judge.  Before you blame the judge it is only reloads that screw up here, not any factory ammo I have tried yet.  Believe it or not, I have some of the best groups with this pistol.  I can not correlate the keyhole to and particular chamber in the cylinder.  Sometimes I got two in a row and then none for 20 rounds.  I shot 50 rounds and had 4 keyhole.

I gave these a fairly good roll crimp, just enough to see the lip dig into the lead.  I did all 50 on a rockchucker and I know that I had no more than a .1 gn variation in powder.  I was getting an average of 840 FPS with a 20FPS variation. 

I honestly find rifle reloading much simpler.  I only recently started loading for pistol so any help is appreciated.

 

Ken

Most often when tumbling becomes an issue, it is directly related to the load.  Not enough charge or too much, bullet seating, or crimping.

 

At 7.5 gr you are near the upper end of loading data.  I would back off to 6.8 to 7.0 for starters.  Working up to see if problem changes.

Check case mouth flaring when loading, too little will cause hard seating of the bullet and distort loading. Hornady lead is fairly soft.

Finally, re-check the crimping.  Too little or to heavy a crimp will cause problems.  It is easy to overcrimp swaged lead bullets.

.45 ACP should be taper crimped and not roll crimped.  They headspace on the rim and if you over crimp they sit to far up.  Get a calipers and go to about .001".  

  • Author

Most often when tumbling becomes an issue, it is directly related to the load.  Not enough charge or too much, bullet seating, or crimping.

 

At 7.5 gr you are near the upper end of loading data.  I would back off to 6.8 to 7.0 for starters.  Working up to see if problem changes.

Check case mouth flaring when loading, too little will cause hard seating of the bullet and distort loading. Hornady lead is fairly soft.

Finally, re-check the crimping.  Too little or to heavy a crimp will cause problems.  It is easy to overcrimp swaged lead bullets.

I worked my way up to this load starting at 6.5.  I stopped at 7.5 because that is where my best accuracy came in.  I myself am sort of leaning to the crimp as the problem.  When I bell the cases the bullet slips in about 1/16 with very little force and seats the rest of the way nice and smooth with no lead shaving.  Ill try to get a good picture of one of my crimped rounds and post it here to get some input.

I do have some hardcast SWC heads I may try.  I am sticking with the Hornadys for now because this is the load I have worked up and I can shoot the center out of a target at 20 yards.  This is the most accurate load I have come up with yet

I might start working up a load  with the other heads in the meantime.

Thanks

Ken

  • Author

.45 ACP should be taper crimped and not roll crimped.  They headspace on the rim and if you over crimp they sit to far up.  Get a calipers and go to about .001".  

Im loading 45 colt, as in old school 45 long colt ;) 

Ken

With the additional information, I too would work on the crimp first.  I assume this head has a crimp grove and your rolling your brass into it.  I would back off the crip and restart only crimping enough to seat the end of the case into the the groove.  Over crimping sometimes will cause a bump in the case before going into the groove.  Run you finger down the side of the case towards the case mouth.  If you feel a lump before coming to the end of the case, overcrimping comes into play.  Hope you understand, hard to explain without pics.

With the additional information, I too would work on the crimp first.  I assume this head has a crimp grove and your rolling your brass into it.  I would back off the crip and restart only crimping enough to seat the end of the case into the the groove.  Over crimping sometimes will cause a bump in the case before going into the groove.  Run you finger down the side of the case towards the case mouth.  If you feel a lump before coming to the end of the case, overcrimping comes into play.  Hope you understand, hard to explain without pics.

 IIRC, Hornady lead bullets do not have crimp grooves. The bearing surface of the bullet is knurled and the dry lubricant is applied. The lead is very soft and a roll crimp will "bite" into the bearing surface. I, too am inclined to go with expanding/belling/crimping being the problem. At the velocity you are driving them, are you getting any leading?

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

  • Author

Bob is correct.  I am not getting any leading at all.  At lower charges I was not getting accuracy.  Almost every charge was weighed since I am working up a load.  The weird part is I got one or two keyholes at lower charges and the bullets where all over the place.  At the current charge the keyholeing got a little worse and the accuracy got a lot better.  I can almost put a hole through a hole except for the wild keyhole rounds.  I think I am going to re evaluate my belling and crimp and try again.  I am also wondering if this is due to the shallow rifling in the judge.  I know taurus redesigned the rifling a bit to help the performance with .410 shotshels.  If thats the case, this really sucks.  I have never been so accurate with a pistol...ever.  Maybee the lead is just too soft?  I'll have to start working up a load with the DJ hardcast bullets and see if its better, worse, or the same. 

The rifling in the barrel is clean and sharp. When I cleaned the pistol last night it was no dirtier than any other load and there was no significant  lead fouling. 

 

Im open to all ideas.

Thanks

Ken

Ken,

 

I believe that your crimp is taking the .454's and "smuushing" them down a couple thousandths every-so-often, thus making the rounds rattle-down the newly-designed bore with thin rifling, resulting in key-holes.  A similar problem developed in a Suave .58 I was firing with 555 gr. Minnie's with a thin skirt.  Not enough bullet was engaging the rifling, so the bullets tumbled and made a shotgun-style pattern.  Using a harder lead so as to inhibit compression of the bullet's nose by the crimp might help your situation.  So would a gas check.  One other thing to consider is the angle the round itself is seated at.  If every once-in-a-while you might have a bullet head of soft lead that "straightens itself out" as it's forced into the case when it's seated, it MIGHT just be seated at a minute angle?  This minute angle is further compromised by the huge distance a .45 Colt round has to travel in order to reach the forcing cone.  Since using a Rockchucker isn't an EXACT science, and since NO key-holing was noted with ANY factory rounds you've tried, I would put money on the key-holing being the result of "a perfect storm":

 

1.  Too much crimp making the rounds slightly under-size due to soft lead.

 

2.  Thin rifling (used so the .410 shot pattern is improved).

 

3.  Inconsistent angle of the bullet heads.  Those that are straight shoot really well, while a few others in the same batch key-hole.

 

If you have a friend that has a single-action .45 Long Colt or a Smith and Wesson Model #25 in .45 Long Colt, I'd be interested to learn of the accuracy of these rounds in those guns so as to rule-out the rifling depth  and cylinder length issues.

 

Good luck and I hope I've been some help.

 

Dave

I prefer a Redding Profile Crimp Die for all roll crimping.

Have you pulled any seated bullets and measured the OD to be sure you are not swaging the bullet down?

Usually, I would say to slug the barrel and determine the barrel's groove diameter and make sure the bullets, after seating, are still at least 0.001" larger than the groove diameter.

Are the bullet fairly snug slip fit in the cylinder's throats? They can be a bit larger, and COL needs to adjusted for that, but they can't be much smaller than the throat diameters.

  • Author

Ken,

 

I believe that your crimp is taking the .454's and "smuushing" them down a couple thousandths every-so-often, thus making the rounds rattle-down the newly-designed bore with thin rifling, resulting in key-holes.  A similar problem developed in a Suave .58 I was firing with 555 gr. Minnie's with a thin skirt.  Not enough bullet was engaging the rifling, so the bullets tumbled and made a shotgun-style pattern.  Using a harder lead so as to inhibit compression of the bullet's nose by the crimp might help your situation.  So would a gas check.  One other thing to consider is the angle the round itself is seated at.  If every once-in-a-while you might have a bullet head of soft lead that "straightens itself out" as it's forced into the case when it's seated, it MIGHT just be seated at a minute angle?  This minute angle is further compromised by the huge distance a .45 Colt round has to travel in order to reach the forcing cone.  Since using a Rockchucker isn't an EXACT science, and since NO key-holing was noted with ANY factory rounds you've tried, I would put money on the key-holing being the result of "a perfect storm":

 

1.  Too much crimp making the rounds slightly under-size due to soft lead.

 

2.  Thin rifling (used so the .410 shot pattern is improved).

 

3.  Inconsistent angle of the bullet heads.  Those that are straight shoot really well, while a few others in the same batch key-hole.

 

If you have a friend that has a single-action .45 Long Colt or a Smith and Wesson Model #25 in .45 Long Colt, I'd be interested to learn of the accuracy of these rounds in those guns so as to rule-out the rifling depth  and cylinder length issues.

 

Good luck and I hope I've been some help.

 

Dave

 

 

Interesting points. 

I would like to believe that the bullet heads are seating square since they fit the bullet seating cup perfectly.  But, if the bullet isnt perfect to begin with..... 

I kind of wondered about the long cylinder on this gun too.  That is a great distance before the forcing cone. 

Unfortunatly I am the only one in my group that has any love for the 45 colt.  I may pick up another 45 wheel gun in the near future though. 

The really odd thing is the wild rounds are still fairly accurate at 25 yards.  I would imagine that further out they would be all over the place though. 

What I have decided to do in the meantime is to reduce the load by .1 grain and try again with the same technique I am using now.  I think that just maybe the rounds that where on the high side of 7.5 might be the ones that are causing the problems.  I strive for precission in rifles and get a little lazy on weighing powder with pistols.  The rounds I did weigh ( about 30 in 50) did vary by .1 gn or so.  I just loaded 50 rounds and hope to get to the range within the next day or two to see what happens.  I have also loaded different (200gn) hardcast lead bullets to a similar velocity to compare against.  Ill add to this post after a range trip.

Ken

  • Author

I prefer a Redding Profile Crimp Die for all roll crimping.

Have you pulled any seated bullets and measured the OD to be sure you are not swaging the bullet down?

Usually, I would say to slug the barrel and determine the barrel's groove diameter and make sure the bullets, after seating, are still at least 0.001" larger than the groove diameter.

Are the bullet fairly snug slip fit in the cylinder's throats? They can be a bit larger, and COL needs to adjusted for that, but they can't be much smaller than the throat diameters.

I did pull a couple rounds and the bullet did measure rite.  It has a decent crimp groove in it but the rest of it measured out correctly.  They fit the cylinder like a glove.   If my adjustments dont fix it I may just give up on the 255gn hornadys and continue my search. 

Thanks

Ken

Ken

  • Author

make sure there is no over crimp and add 2 grains to the charge..

Really?  That puts it a full grain over max in my load charts.  Im not bashing your suggestion  but I am curious where that info came from? 

Thanks

Ken

Interesting points. 

I would like to believe that the bullet heads are seating square since they fit the bullet seating cup perfectly.  But, if the bullet isnt perfect to begin with..... 

I kind of wondered about the long cylinder on this gun too.  That is a great distance before the forcing cone. 

Unfortunatly I am the only one in my group that has any love for the 45 colt.  I may pick up another 45 wheel gun in the near future though. 

The really odd thing is the wild rounds are still fairly accurate at 25 yards.  I would imagine that further out they would be all over the place though. 

What I have decided to do in the meantime is to reduce the load by .1 grain and try again with the same technique I am using now.  I think that just maybe the rounds that where on the high side of 7.5 might be the ones that are causing the problems.  I strive for precission in rifles and get a little lazy on weighing powder with pistols.  The rounds I did weigh ( about 30 in 50) did vary by .1 gn or so.  I just loaded 50 rounds and hope to get to the range within the next day or two to see what happens.  I have also loaded different (200gn) hardcast lead bullets to a similar velocity to compare against.  Ill add to this post after a range trip.

Ken

 

Good luck and keep us informed.  You also may want to try this at 50 yards to check for spread on the groups.

 

Dave

  • Author

Unfortunately I dont have pics.  I have a half broken phone at the moment.  I do have the targets though.  Its a clear as day sideways impact.

Ken

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.