Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

How Many Permits to Carry a Handgun have we seen?

Featured Replies

Not police/armed guard

 

With all the police we have here, and a couple Title II FFLs, I figure some people have run into private investigators, judges, and politically connected. I'm sure what is diner conversation in the free world is classified Top Secret in New Jersey but I figure it wouldn't be unreasonable to give some sort of estimated count about what you've run into and which of those categories the people fell in.

i really have no idea. but my step mom is a judge, so ive been thinking about applying for mine here in jersey. i doubt it would pass muster though. anyone here think its worth it for me to apply?

i really have no idea. but my step mom is a judge, so ive been thinking about applying for mine here in jersey. i doubt it would pass muster though. anyone here think its worth it for me to apply?

 

If you have a chance, why not? Worst thing they can say is no...

i really have no idea. but my step mom is a judge, so ive been thinking about applying for mine here in jersey. i doubt it would pass muster though. anyone here think its worth it for me to apply?

I would think you can ask her before you do anything else. She couldn't hear your case as that would be a conflict of interest.

i really have no idea. but my step mom is a judge, so ive been thinking about applying for mine here in jersey. i doubt it would pass muster though. anyone here think its worth it for me to apply?

Well, if you do and actually get one, wham bam, suddenly we've got a compelling case.

If you have a chance, why not? Worst thing they can say is no...

 

Actually if they deny the application it is a PITA because every time he tries to go purchase another handgun he has to say he has been denied for the carry permit and explain why. Granted it sounds cut and dry, you know how simple things get completely screwed up in this state.

 

However if he got approved, it could open a nice case for changing the justifiable need req's or at least set a better standard instead of leaving it up to human discretion.

I think that would meet the justifiable need. I mean someone could get mad at her and go after her family to get back at her.

If you did get one, especially if your step mom put a word in for you, you cannot use that as a compelling case. What would end up happening if you tried, it would open up the wrong can of worms. Might cost her her seat and anyone involved would be in trouble.

I think that would meet the justifiable need. I mean someone could get mad at her and go after her family to get back at her.

If there are any documented threats against her family. They might give it to you anyway since this is NJ.

Last I heard there were 1200 carry permits besides LEOs. Lots of Jewelers,judges, etc.

  • Author

Maybe I should contribute my own experience sicne I'm the one that brought it up. I knew one judge (at least) that had one. And, he was a federal judge, not a New Jersey judge. I think I know others as well but have only recently started following up asking about it.

well i wouldnt ask her to help me by by doing any favors. she just became a judge earlier this year in a different county than i live in. i could definitely ask her if there have been any threats against her tho. she has told me that she has had nightmares about someone coming after her tho. i recommended that she get a gun and a carry permit but she refused. shes not exactly pro 2a but isnt against it either. she believes in the system and thinks the police will be there. it is probably a longshot right now but if she is ever publicly threaten i think i would stand a good chance.

My best friend had a restricted one for work as a security guard.  He went through hell with his town to get one (waiting over 8 months after submitting with the letter of need).  After he received it, he got a letter from the judge saying in a threatening tone "I don't give these out. I really hate giving these out. I will be watching you. If you f up, we will nail your balls to the wall." (in fluffier language)

There was someone who posted an image of one here but it was a restricted permit.

 

What I want to know is why judges hate giving them out. Is it that they don't want to be liable? Don't like guns? Power trip? Nudge from politicians? In New York there are judges who grant permits with little resistance. A friend of mine is a landscaper and he got a permit from a judge in Orange County NY. He doesnt carry a lot of cash. Just a lawn care guy. Easy peasy. If I lived there I could get one I was told.

 

But in NJ that wouldn't happen. Even a guy like Daniel PiszcAtoski who worked for the FBI got threats from Islamists was denied.

 

I don't get it. Or maybe I do. But I would like to find out what you guys think.

One. Local politician. 

What I want to know is why judges hate giving them out. Is it that they don't want to be liable? Don't like guns? Power trip? Nudge from politicians? In New York there are judges who grant permits with little resistance. A friend of mine is a landscaper and he got a permit from a judge in Orange County NY. He doesnt carry a lot of cash. Just a lawn care guy. Easy peasy. If I lived there I could get one I was told.

 

But in NJ that wouldn't happen. Even a guy like Daniel PiszcAtoski who worked for the FBI got threats from Islamists was denied.

 

I don't get it. Or maybe I do. But I would like to find out what you guys think.

 

I think judges deny permits to cover their asses.  It's solely up to their discretion, so it's safer to deny a permit than stick their neck out by issuing one.  It's not like a "shall issue" state where judges are compelled to issue by default.

In this state where the permit issuance is very low, like hooligan said they have to deny applications to cover their asses. The permit numbers are small enough that if the person they issued the permit to goes out and shoots people I could totally see the politicians coming back to the judge and saying why didn't you see they were not fit to be issued a permit blah blah blah. If its job related like security guard the employer now accepts all the liability by arming the individual making the judge feel better about allowing the permit.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.