Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

State troopers making a lot of mistakes

Featured Replies

http://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2013/08/watchdog_nj_state_police_failing_to_catch_too_many_mistakes_by_troopers_on_the_road.html

 

And these are the guys in charge of our firearms? I know patrol and administrative are different but they are still the same.

 

TRENTON — Troopers patrolling New Jersey’s highways are breaking State Police rules at a “troubling” rate, and supervisors are not doing enough to catch the mistakes and fix them, according to a new report by the state Attorney General’s Office.

 

The report, which covered the first half of 2012, found the State Police failed to identify mistakes by troopers ranging from excessive force to improper vehicle searches in nearly a third of the 155 stops they were required to examine.

 

That shortcoming was made worse by the fact that the Attorney General’s Office recently allowed State Police supervisors to review fewer stops overall, with the caveat that they do a thorough job analyzing them.

 

“This is a very disturbing report,” said Samuel Walker, a national expert on police reforms who consulted for the federal government during its oversight of the State Police. “By the time you reach 30 percent, that’s getting pretty serious.”

 

The report also cited the State Police for using police dogs on a disproportionate number of black drivers, for not issuing Miranda warnings to suspects and for failing to properly activate and store recordings from patrol car cameras.

 

The findings were released online last month by the Office of Law Enforcement Professional Standards, which was created to ensure the State Police followed its own rules after federal authorities stopped monitoring the division in 2009.

 

The sampling of traffic stops reviewed by State Police and the professional standards office were only a fraction of the more than 400,000 made by troopers each year, and the division’s examination is designed only to suggest areas of misconduct or improper procedures that need attention.

 

Though the report said the majority of troopers play by the rules, it noted a “troubling trend of increasing numbers of errors made during motor vehicle stops” even though the office repeatedly raised concerns about the problems over the past several years.

 

“The fact that OLEPS was able to note 46 stops with an error not caught out of the stops that the State Police did review, is troubling,” according to the report. “The State Police need to employ more detailed reviews and properly note all errors.”

 

Leland Moore, a spokesman for the Attorney General’s Office, which oversees the State Police as well as the professional standards office, said in a statement the majority of the report’s concerns could be addressed with better training.

 

He also said disagreements over troopers’ use of force were in part due to differences in interpretation.

 

“The State Police continues to do an excellent job of protecting New Jersey citizens while ensuring overall, continued compliance with the various monitoring standards and criteria,” Moore said.

 

A spokesman for the State Police, Lt. Stephen Jones, said the division will act in response to the report, but gave no specific examples of what was being done to eliminate the problems identified.

 

“The OLEPS report is not the end of the review process,” Jones said. “We answer those findings and refine our processes based on them. It’s the checks and balances designed in this system that allow for improvement.”

He added that the office has “unfettered access” to the State Police.

 

“Their job is finding areas for improvement, and ours is making those improvements,” he said.

 

Use of force

 

Among the problems, the oversight report said, were three instances in which troopers used force against motorists. The State Police reviewed the incidents and said the force was appropriate, but the office disagreed and investigations were opened.

 

The report said the office was unable to determine if force used in four other instances was appropriate because they took place outside the view of dashboard cameras mounted in the trooper patrol cars on the scene.

 

Dashboard recordings continued to be a problem, the report said, because many cruisers had incomplete audio or video. The office was unable to examine 51 stops — about 15 percent of those reviewed — because of “missing or unavailable” recordings.

 

The recordings, which were required as part of federal oversight, are critical to defend troopers from false claims in court and to protect the public from trooper misconduct such as excessive force.

 

The professional standards office also raised red flags about statistics showing troopers used police dogs disproportionately on black motorists, a trend that “has increased steadily for the last two reporting periods.”

 

“White drivers made up 48 percent of all stops, yet only 30 percent of motor vehicle stops with canine deployments,” the report said. “Black drivers made up 39 percent of all stops and 61 percent of canine deployments.”

 

The report stopped short of accusing troopers of bias, and noted all the canine deployments were appropriate.

 

Miranda violations

 

The report also sounded an alarm about the 49 instances in which troopers made an arrest but failed to inform suspects of their Miranda rights, which can lead to lawsuits against the state and increased legal costs for taxpayers.

 

“Not only are these violations occurring in stops without supervisory review, they are occurring in stops with supervisory review and not being noted or leading to interventions,” the report said.

 

The problem with Miranda warnings dates to a 2009 state Supreme Court ruling that tightened standards for vehicle searches. But despite subsequent training for troopers on the new rules, the problem persists, the report said.

 

“The State Police may want to conduct random reviews of stops with arrests to determine the extent of the Miranda issue,” the report said.

 

‘Considerable progress’

 

Wayne Fisher, a professor at the Rutgers School of Criminal Justice, said that while it may seem the State Police are making a lot of mistakes, many of the problems are related to paperwork or other things that should not raise much alarm.

 

“There are some shortcomings in some specific areas, but I think taken in total, this report is further evidence that the State Police have made considerable progress,” Fisher said.

 

 

Go to link for more.

I say let them continue doing it. When they lose a bunch of cases in court because they f'ed up they'll get the message. 

I have had two interactions with State Police in both instances the trooper was very nice and polite. I wasn't doing anything wrong, I was just on the phone parked in a rest stop.   I guess they have people doing things they shouldn't be while parked at a rest stop. The second was when I cut him off going from the middle lane to the left lane. He was pissed that I cut him off but he gave me a break after we talked for awhile.

 

The problems seem to come from the young cops on the job and they seem to think they need to prove themselves as being a tough cop!! I think some of the small town cops have a bit of an inferiority complex. One young cop said to me" there will be no speeding from now on in my sector" I laughed so hard he got a little upset.

 

I would never want the job!! I understand how they could go off on people when they see so many scumbags daily!!

I say let them continue doing it. When they lose a bunch of cases in court because they f'ed up they'll get the message. 

Really? I get where you were trying to go with that, but I don' t think allowing misconduct to continue until it "fixes itself" is a great idea. Its about more then just winning/losing court cases:

http://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2013/08/nj_attorney_general_agrees_to_pay_425000_to_man_beaten_by_nj_state_police_troopers.html

 

They really do think they are ABOVE the law:

http://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2013/02/nj_state_police_trooper_seeks.html

"A State Police trooper who was disciplined in connection with the beating of a mentally disabled man contends officials broke the law by waiting too long to punish him, and has filed a lawsuit seeking dismissal of the charges."

Isn't that ironic?

 

"State law requires the State Police to file disciplinary charges against troopers within 45 days after obtaining "sufficient information" to substantiate the complaint."

So, when do the rest of us get a 45-day statute of limitations for violent crimes; 'cause there are a few people I'd like to kick the crap out. I mean hey, as long as you duck prosecution for a month and half, you're forever in the clear, right?

 

"The state Supreme Court found in a past ruling that the clock starts in such instances when a case is given to the superintendent for review.

The law, signed in 2002, is intended to protect troopers from unreasonable delays in disciplinary proceedings, which can hold up career advancement or delay retirement."

Yeah, THAT's what's important here.....:sarcasm:

 

"Neither trooper was criminally charged in connection with the incident, and both deny any wrongdoing."

A.) Why the hell not? The AG has determined they plainly "breached the Ag's use of force policy" (from the first article linked above), the NJSP internal affairs saw enough to "charge" them with excessive force. So, as far as I'm concerned, they should no longer have any special privileges/protections associated with their job or union. They are now common criminals/thugs, and should be treated and charged accordingly, with assault and battery, and whatever other charges the "rest of us" would be subject to for the same acts. They belong in PRISON! At the very least, they should be IMMEDIATELY fired, and become "prohibited persons" for firearms ownership purposes. Clearly they have violent tendencies. 

 

B.) Of course they "admit no wrongdoing". Why would they? They clearly assume they are above the law.

I don't know what else to say.

 

When you draw attention to it, you're a cop hater, cops aren't paid enough, cops should walk off the job and let criminals reign free, bla bla bla. 

 

You leave it alone and everyone is happy except those who encounter the (few) bad eggs. 

 

So it's best to just leave it alone.

:popcorn:

I say let them continue doing it. When they lose a bunch of cases in court because they f'ed up they'll get the message. 

Hell no. That means people who shouldn't be dragged to court are being dragged to court and are effectively being punished for something they shouldn't be punished for. (At a minimum it costs them money). 

 

It also wastes my tax dollars on losing court cases because someone can't do their job right. 

 

That's pretty much the worst solution for everyone. 

 

AT least one of these things is pretty simple to fix, and that's the in car video being absent.  The fix? any citation can be contested for video evidence. No video log, case gets tossed. No ifs ands or buts. It's broken? The car doesn't roll. Not the correct number of vehicles out on the road that day? Fine the state superintendent. The gear that does this job has decreased in price so dramatically, and become so generally available since this was put in place that there should be ZERO excuse for this. 

Hell no. That means people who shouldn't be dragged to court are being dragged to court and are effectively being punished for something they shouldn't be punished for. (At a minimum it costs them money). 

 

It also wastes my tax dollars on losing court cases because someone can't do their job right. 

 

That's pretty much the worst solution for everyone. 

 

AT least one of these things is pretty simple to fix, and that's the in car video being absent.  The fix? any citation can be contested for video evidence. No video log, case gets tossed. No ifs ands or buts. It's broken? The car doesn't roll. Not the correct number of vehicles out on the road that day? Fine the state superintendent. The gear that does this job has decreased in price so dramatically, and become so generally available since this was put in place that there should be ZERO excuse for this. 

 

 

Great. So who's going to make that happen? The legislature? AG? Christie? 

I don't know what else to say.

 

When you draw attention to it, you're a cop hater, cops aren't paid enough, cops should walk off the job and let criminals reign free, bla bla bla. 

 

You leave it alone and everyone is happy except those who encounter the (few) bad eggs. 

 

So it's best to just leave it alone.

 

 

I agree.....

 

Let's leave it alone....

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.