I know the topic has probably been asked many times on the forums, but In the next two days I am purchasing my first 1911 and want to gather everyone's opinion.

 

So, leave your opinions as to which size I should get.

 

Will probably be used at the range 95% of the time, maybe CCW outta state.

The full size. That way, when you stick it into the bad guy's ribs, he'll know you're not foolin around

Full size your target acquisition will be much better... 

Full size. Three-quarters of an inch really doesn't help that much with concealability. It is the butt that's a problem and that's the same on both. So unless you are looking at a CCO configuration or a bobbed MSH, stick with the 5" gun.

 

JMHO

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

I've been carrying 1911s for about 40 years. I have a Combat Commander for nearly and don't find any advantage to it. A LW Commander will save you a few ounces but I don't see that being much of a concern. I carry a full size.

Full size for your first 1911(it wont be your last, trust me), then go for a higher end commander!

John Moses Browning designed the 1911 on a 5" barrel and thats the reason its the most reliable on the full size model.

 

I have had a few commanders but ended up selling them for one reason or another. The commander is a little less pleasant to shoot from the increased muzzle flip. Easily manageable but somewhat annoying.

Full size all the way.

^{Ya gotta get one of each!}

I have a few full size 1911's - I do not own a commander but I think it's my next purchase 

 

I will end up doing like mag1 suggested and get a higher end piece - 

 

Why?  Just because...

Not enough choices!  I like my Colt Officer's .45 for many reasons, and I can hit quite well with it.  I've probably had it for a couple decades by now.  It's sitting in its' Mitch Rosen Kant-Forward holster right now.  I use Wilson or Chip McCormack Officer's mags, so I get the 7th round into the mag instead of the usual 6.  In Condition #1, I've got 8 rounds of .45 Black Talon for the bump in the night.

 

I actually see no advantage to a Commander-sized platform.  The Officer's-sized platform is smaller both on the slide and the grip and therefore more easily concealed, doesn't "print" like a full-size and is quite comfortable for wearing while seated.

 

And eventually you'll want BOTH, lol!

 

When playin' the IDPA gun game, some guys show-up with pipsqueak 9's for BUG Matches.  I show-up with my .45 Officers.  Did fairly well the last BUG Match too!

 

Dave

My big concern is the accuracy of both..I had my eye on the commander, just because its something different..  but seem like the full size is the way to go from this poll.. 

I voted full size due to better balance and slightly softer recoil. Now, if NJ ever allows CCW then I mould carry my commander size.

Thanks or the comments and opinions. I have had my eye on a Ruger SR1911 for awhile. For some reason I find the Ruger very attractive looking.

 

I found both stocked locally at different places and went to check both out. After debate, an driving back and forth some, I went with the

 

FULLSIZE

A 1911 always works best in the 5" full size length (and in .45 ACP too)!

Took my new full size 1911 to the range today and was very impressed. I have never shot a 1911 before, and it might have been the smoothest gun I have ever shot. Very happy with the purchase thus far.