Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

H.R. 3199 Bill would permit Military Personnel and Civilians to OC on Stateside Bases

Featured Replies

Finally a true "Common Sense" gun law. I think it has a very slim chance of being approved, and I have yet to see the actual bill, but at least someone is thinking.

 

http://www.armytimes.com/article/20130927/NEWS/309270010/Bill-would-let-troops-civilians-carry-guns-stateside-bases

Bill would let troops, civilians carry guns on stateside bases

 

Sep. 27, 2013 - 02:39PM

 

By Rick Maze

Staff writer

Service members and federal civilians could carry personal firearms on military bases under a bill introduced Thursday by Rep. Steve Stockman, R-Texas, that would reverse a 20-year-old policy on firearms.

 

“Why are civilians at a restaurant allowed to defend themselves but soldiers trained in firearms aren’t?” Stockman said. “Why can’t we extend common-sense gun laws like open carry to our soldiers?”

 

The Safe Military Bases Act, HR 3199, is Stockman’s response to the Sept. 16 shooting at the Washington Navy Yard and is similar to legislation introduced after the 2009 mass shooting at Fort Hood, Texas.

 

Stockman said mass shootings could be stopped if people on base carried their own guns.

“Our disarmed military bases are vulnerable targets for terrorists, as we saw in Fort Hood and the Navy Yard,” he said in a statement. “Despite that, soldiers trained to use guns cannot carry on base. The result is two mass killings where defenseless soldiers had to watch as their friends were murdered.”

“Saving lives by allowing trained soldiers to carry firearms should be an easy fix,” Stockman said. “No reasonable person can oppose that.”

His bill has six original cosponsors. It was referred to the House armed services and judiciary committees for consideration.

Firearms policies had been largely left to base commanders until 1992, when the Defense Department revised its regulations to limit who could carry weapons. At stateside installations, firearms were restricted by a Defense Department directive to law enforcement and security personnel, those guarding prisoners and those taking firearms training.

 

“The authorization to carry firearms shall be issued only to qualified personnel when there is a reasonable expectation that life or DoD assets will be jeopardized if firearms are not carried,” the directive said. “Evaluation of the necessity to carry a firearm shall be made considering this expectation weighed against the possible consequences of accidental or indiscriminate use of firearms.”

Current policy, revised in 2011 after the Fort Hood shooting, adds another line to the policy: “Overriding factors in determining whether or not to arm are the mission and threat.”

 

Although this original directive was issued in February 1992, Stockman and other opponents of the military’s policy on carrying personal firearms refer to this as a “Clinton-era” policy because the Army issued a separate instruction reinforcing the DoD policy in 1993

 

 

Finally, a "knee jerk" reaction/response to a shooting "incident" that actually does call for  "common sense gun laws"!!

It makes way too much sense to be passed. No way enough politicians will vote for it. They will be worried about the politics of it and not the people. It's funny how even though military bases are pretty closed off communities we have civilian politicians who have little relation or involvement to these military communities deciding our right to protect ourselves.

 

Also it does include civilian employees. Which I think is good but even less of a chance for that part to pass. The only people it excludes are civilian visitors. Civilian visitors carrying is fine with me but I understand this will never be included and I think the military has the right to choose who carries on its bases.

I understand the restriction to military personnel and DoD civilians as both have had some type of background check to be in their positions. There would need to be language in the law to permit transport to work to deal with state lawsl like NJ's.

 

It makes sense. That's why it won't get anywhere.

I never did understand why military personnel weren't allowed to carry loaded firearms wherever they went. They are better trained in the handling of firearms and heavy weapons than anyone else in the entire nation.

 

Why would they have to shell out the money to buy their own firearms though? They are all issued M16A2 (or A3 or A4?) rifles already by the Army. Just mandate that ammunition be made available for those weapons. I'd rather see soldiers with their M16 rifles than with personal sidearms. Pistols are of little use in the types of firefights they are trained for, and the bulk of their training is with their service rifle. Would it not make sense to allow them to use that training with the weapon that they are trained with? This would maximize their effectiveness.

I like it. Unfortunately I do not see this passing. The democrats can't afford to pass it due to the fact that it puts a hole in their argument that If more people were armed would not have helped. Especially at this time where they are trying to use every bit of fear of firearms from the mass shootings in the past year in order to push for more gun control.

I never did understand why military personnel weren't allowed to carry loaded firearms wherever they went. They are better trained in the handling of firearms and heavy weapons than anyone else in the entire nation.

 

Why would they have to shell out the money to buy their own firearms though? They are all issued M16A2 (or A3 or A4?) rifles already by the Army. Just mandate that ammunition be made available for those weapons. I'd rather see soldiers with their M16 rifles than with personal sidearms. Pistols are of little use in the types of firefights they are trained for, and the bulk of their training is with their service rifle. Would it not make sense to allow them to use that training with the weapon that they are trained with? This would maximize their effectiveness.

 

Unfortunately that doesn't make sense in the real world for many reasons. Countries like Israel allow their soldiers to keep their weapons at home with ammo but that is a different situation. M9 pistols could be issued out but the army would be more worried about the cost and liability of that. Also battle drills don't really apply to the type of one on one gunfight you would expect stateside.

a pistol is a fine personal defense weapon. They could have quick response teams on base as backup to personal defense if a mass shooting happened. The majority of service members already own firearms.

 

The main thing that's retarded about current laws is that states and federal government don't recognize military at all as people that should be carrying off duty while LEO have LEOSA and all these other laws that guarantee them the right to carry in different states.

 

For instance NJ army national guard or Active duty here at Fort Dix. Carry all types of weapons when training here in NJ. pistols, fully automatic machine guns, etc. 30 round mags, lots of banned things. And those of us in combat arms probably get more range time than any Leo's in the state. But somehow when it comes to carrying off-duty it's the exact same as any civilian and there is no way you'll get a permit. While private security guards and judges can get CCW easily.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.