Apparently Hogue makes both types of grips. 

 

Upon reading the reviews it would seem that the rubber grip is better in terms of actual gripping and is a better compensator for recoil.

 

The nylon seems to be the favorite for those who carry because it wont snag on clothes.

 

Does anyone have experience with either, pros and cons? 

Rubber Houges on P226 & 686+, way better for gripping. During hot weather, the plastic ones get slippery. I also have Pachmayr grips for BHP, those are  great, not as sticky as the Houges, but feel better. Don't know about carry, that's not my bag, man

I have the rubber on P229 Elite. They're a good part of the reason I bought that gun. Great grip.

Have the rubber on my 92FS and love them.

 

Sent from my XT1080 using Tapatalk

 

 

I added the rubber ones on my 229 a couple weeks ago and love em.

Love my Hogue rubber side panels on my 1911. Grips like it's glued to your hand.

hogue monogrip on my snubbie..  feels WAY better than the plastic