went to Ottomanelli's today in search for a fullsize 45 and couldnt decide between the two. While im familiar with glocks this will be my first pistol of my own. I really liked the trigger and ergos on the FN but im worried it will be too heavy in the rear with 15rds in the mag, the g21 felt more balanced over all...thoughts?

 

 

PS-im not sure if it was the FNX45 or FNP/FNS 45...it was all black but not the tactical version

Don't get the SF, get a Gen4. It's the same thing, but newer and better in almost every measurable way.

I own 3 Glocks and an FNX45..actually just put 100 rounds through the FNX today and to me there are no balance issues with it..IMHO I don't think it would be hard to transition from a Glock platform...that grip is a deal breaker for some (some say the raised checkering is too sharp) but if it works for you then go for it...mine has been 100% reliable, accurate and fun to shoot..

Don't get the SF, get a Gen4. It's the same thing, but newer and better in almost every measurable way.

they had the Gen4 for the same price, with the shorter grip on the rear its the same diameter to hit the mag release? 

 

I own 3 Glocks and an FNX45..actually just put 100 rounds through the FNX today and to me there are no balance issues with it..IMHO I don't think it would be hard to transition from a Glock platform...that grip is a deal breaker for some (some say the raised checkering is too sharp) but if it works for you then go for it...mine has been 100% reliable, accurate and fun to shoot..

I just have trouble comfortably reaching the mag release with my thumb without moving my hand on the regular fullsize models. I have a second permit, thinking of which that G19 fit my hand like a glove 

they had the Gen4 for the same price, with the shorter grip on the rear its the same diameter to hit the mag release?

 

 

The SF and Gen4 grip without any backstraps are the same size. You get the new dual RSA (recoil spring assembly) with the Gen4. The Gen4 handles the recoil better. I traded my Gen3 SF for the Gen4 and I am happy with the decision.

 

I never had and FN 45 of any kind and probably never will. I handled one and felt it was much bigger than the Glock. I also feel there is much more aftermarket support for the Glock then the FN.

I would get the FNX if you like the ergos..its a great gun...when you can just buy a Glock also..problem solved.

the G21 gen4 ended up following me home today

the G21 gen4 ended up following me home today

Pics or it doesn't count

 

 

This signature exceeds the 15 character capacity

Pics or it doesn't count

 

 

This signature exceeds the 15 character capacity

yes...until pics Liar Liar pants on fire!