Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Can we own a "firearms" other then handgun, rifle, or shotgun in NJ?

Featured Replies

I've looked around and this has continued to allude me. I am interested in the following.

 

1. Virgin AR lower transferred as "other" (or maybe as a handgun?)

+

2. A pinned/non-threaded/non-flash-hiding less then 16" barrel

+

3. A pistol style buffer tube (no stock)

And?

4. A FVG

= greater then 26" OAL

 

My understanding is that this would NOT be an NFA firearm. This Would NOT be a handgun. This would NOT be a rifle. This WOULD be a "Firearm."

 

I also think this would be one hell of a cool way to build a good, 'short' barreled 300BLK home defensive "Firearm."

 

Besides the normal, "I would not want to be he test case" answers, what do you think? Maybe I'm missing a law, but it seems legit (and badass).

 

Thanks for taking the time to read my very first thread!

 

 

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Pretty sure "others" are federally controlled class III and IS NFA. So, no. 

I've looked around and this has continued to allude me. I am interested in the following.

 

1. Virgin AR lower transferred as "other" (or maybe as a handgun?) Legal with FPID or P2P

+

2. A pinned/non-threaded/non-flash-hiding less then 16" barrel  Rifle must have a barrel 16"+ including fixed brake. Shotguns are 18".

+

3. A pistol style buffer tube (no stock) Good luck getting the weight under 50 oz.

And?

4. A FVG

= greater then 26" OAL ???

 

My understanding is that this would NOT be an NFA firearm. This Would NOT be a handgun. This would NOT be a rifle. This WOULD be a "Firearm."  In NJ, all firearms are transferred either on a COE or P2P.

 

I also think this would be one hell of a cool way to build a good, 'short' barreled 300BLK home defensive "Firearm."

 

Besides the normal, "I would not want to be he test case" answers, what do you think? Maybe I'm missing a law, but it seems legit (and badass).

 

Thanks for taking the time to read my very first thread!

 

 

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

  • Author

PK90,

 

Thanks for the input.

 

1. Copy good to go

2. I'm not interested on building a "rifle" or a "shotgun". I'm interested in building a "firearm" without it being legally a handgun or a rifle.

3. I understand the "handgun" limits. That is why I'm thinking of a "firearm"

4. My understanding is that the BATFE....ect...ect... Now considers handgun to only include those firearms that are made to be "concealable" and defining that as under 26". Also, a SBR only applies if you first have a "rifle" then modify it (thus no stock).

 

As for the COE or P2P, I understand those things and they would not hamper my objectives here. Heck, Paul, you transferred a few lowers to me back at your shop. I was thinking of building one of those virgins up.

 

Bottom line is, I think there is a place now for a "Firearm" that is NOT a handgun or rifle. This would need to have never been a rifle (ie virgin lower) and have an over all length of more then 26". Then the barrel length would not matter (shorter than 16" being cool). It would not be a handgun and thus all the silly handgun rules are out. Like 50oz, barrel shrouds, and 'those thingies that go up'. I would only need to watch out for the normal "evil" features and mags.

 

PK, I think I'm on to something, but as always, that's a long shot in this state.

 

Updated with this as a baseline for a home build.

http://www.franklinarmory.com/PRODUCTS_XO-26.html

I doubt that you will come up with any combination of parts that functions like a firearm that isn't regulated - if that's what you're trying to do.  If it doesn't fit the regular categories, it can be a "short barreled rifle", "any other weapon" or "destructive device" and not allowed in NJ and requiring a stamp from the ATF if you are lucky enough to live in America.

I'm a little confused on exactly what you are trying to accomplish?

 

When you refer to 'other" I am guessing you get that from the form 4473

(Section B - #18) where the type of weapon is to be classified (HG, LG or Other)

in which case "other' refers to a lower frame which can be built into either a rifle

or a Hand gun.

 

Without getting to a long, drawn out explanation - here is the Readers Digest Condensed Version:

 

If your build turns out to be a Pistol and it's over 50oz., or has the Evil Features sited on the NJ Banned 

weapons list - you are committing a felony.

 

If your build turns out to be a rifle that has a barrel less than 16", or an overall length of 26" - you have

an NFA item w/o a tax stamp and again, have committed a felony.

 

So what is the point of trying to shoe horn something called 'Other"  instead of just building either

a pistol or a rifle? I don't get it........................????

I only sold two AR receivers that the purchasers used a Handgun Permit. All others were sold on a COE. So you bought a receiver that can only be built into a long gun while still in NJ.

  • Author

I understand everything in NJ is regulated. I just think that since the BATFE made this ruling / legal interpretation / regulatation / letter from a boss in 2011, NJ has not had a chance to make up its own silly regulations controlling this "firearm" that is not a handgun, a rifle, a SBR, or AOW. 'So...I'm saying there's a chance'. But, then I'm here to find out if this is all just a 300BLK pipe dream....

  • Author

Thanks Paul. I have not checked the papers on the lowers I picked up from you as I have yet to get started on this proposed build. Does this mean that you did not transfer any lower as 'other'. I guess I took that for granted as that is what I expected. I have a sweet AX556 on order that I'll have transferred as an 'other' that I am interested in making into a sweet 300BLK.

 

JT, the whole point is I think I may be able to build a good, maneuverable, effective home defense firearm in 300BLK. So what if it turns out to be completely ineffective at any of those things. I'm having fun with a hobby I enjoy regardless of how it turns out. BUT, first I must ensure that my hobby stays on the correct side of the law. I'm sure almost no one would post online asking for pointers on where to look for a law unless they were doing their best to stay legal. Anyone can commit felonies in Nj with firearms. Only those of us who really care to take the time to research and seek advice (though not legal in this case) are able to stay felon free here.

JT, the whole point is I think I may be able to build a good, maneuverable, effective home defense firearm in 300BLK. So what if it turns out to be completely ineffective at any of those things. I'm having fun with a hobby I enjoy regardless of how it turns out. BUT, first I must ensure that my hobby stays on the correct side of the law. I'm sure almost no one would post online asking for pointers on where to look for a law unless they were doing their best to stay legal. Anyone can commit felonies in Nj with firearms. Only those of us who really care to take the time to research and seek advice (though not legal in this case) are able to stay felon free here.

I understand the fun of building something from scratch; and the fun of building something new, but i think'you need to do some research on 

AOW weapons and their legality in NJ.

 

But then the 300 blackout as a Home Defense weapon - That really has me scratching my head............

  • Author

Thanks for the link Jon. I searched but came up empty.

 

So, did anyone ever produce an AG opinion on this? I read about police opinion, but in the end they can at worse (and it's bad) arrest you for something that is not illegal. They don't get to write or interpret the law.

 

It sounds like the consensus is that in NJ it has to be a handgun or rifle. I don't know that I agree. If so, then how can a lower be transferred as an other?

 

 

"Other" is only for the 4473 form that is used when you purchase a firearm. Dealers log receivers in their books as "frames" or "receivers".  This is NEW JERSEY. You can only buy firearms as either a "long gun" or "handgun", so a FPID or P2P must be used. Save your dreams for when you move to a free state.

  • Author

PK90,

So in NJ is a "long gun" not a way to go about this? As another option, could one buy a lower out of state? Even one other thought is, what if someone moved to NJ with one of these 'firearms'? Would that not be legal?

 

You are correct in that the best answer is move to America. I am working on that as well. On that note, congrats on your move.

So in NJ is a "long gun" not a way to go about this? I would buy a lower with a Permit. As another option, could one buy a lower out of state? No. It is against Federal Law. Even one other thought is, what if someone moved to NJ with one of these 'firearms'? :unknw: Would that not be legal? Very questionable and IMO, not worth the risk.

  • Author

Thanks for the input. I think I'll just move and start buying tax stamps.

I understand the fun of building something from scratch; and the fun of building something new, but i think'you need to do some research on 

AOW weapons and their legality in NJ.

 

But then the 300 blackout as a Home Defense weapon - That really has me scratching my head............

What do you need to buy AOW in New Jersey? I brought this up before and nobody seemed to know. They are listed as allowed in all the NFA by state databases but I don;t see them in the MG language of the law.

 

As for .300 BLK for home defense - sounds like an excellent choice to me. It's hard to beat a mid-caliber rifle carbine for SD. Small, low recoil, hard to miss, tremendous affect on target, quick follow-up shots.

I only sold two AR receivers that the purchasers used a Handgun Permit.

And I still have one of them in my safe, for such future time as one of my jersey-legal AR pistols suffers a failure of its lower, necessitating replacement.

  • Author

I think that as long as it's over 26" OAL it is not an AOW.

  • Author

I think that as long as it's over 26" OAL it is not an AOW.

NEED? No one needs more than one gun.

"I don't know" would have been sufficient.

 

Anybody else?

here is the ultimate problem you face... 

 

in NJ it is one or the other.. 

 

k. "Handgun" means any pistol, revolver or other firearm originally designed or manufactured to be fired by the use of a single hand.

m. "Rifle" means any firearm designed to be fired from the shoulder and using the energy of the explosive in a fixed metallic cartridge to fire a single projectile through a rifled bore for each single pull of the trigger.

 

so you are building the "firearm"

are you going to put it against your shoulder and fire it? if so then it is a rifle.. 

are you NOT going to put it against your shoulder? and instead hold it like a pistol? if so then it is a handgun.. 

 

the reason "single hand" is important is because "handguns" with things like barrel shrouds or front grips are illegal in NJ for the most part under the AWB... 

 

if it is a handgun 

per NJ law it is an assault weapon..

 

if it is a rifle

per NJ law it is a sawed off shotgun...

 

while those interpretations may be a stretch.. I am pretty comfortable that is how they would charge you given the chance... 

 

you can certainly try.. but remember the mindset in this state is to control and limit ANY military style firearms.. so throw a curve ball and something that is not clearly legal.. and you are definitely stacking the odds of being the test case... 

 

using anything that is not clearly legal for a HD shoot seems questionable at best.. you could turn a clean shoot into something that gets scrutinized... 

 

 

 

 

why not a 14in AR with a perm affixed brake? I would not hesitate to use a light 16in carbine inside the home.. 

  • Author

Thanks for the insight. This was the most helpful yet. I think this is what PK90 was telling me, but now it makes more since to me. I was hoping for this to not be a handgun and that requires the forward grip and for this to not be a rifle due to the lack of a stock. If I understand you and PK9, NJ in a round and about (assault weapons banning) way prohibit any 'firearms' which federally are not handguns, rifles, or AOW.

 

The start down this line of thinking was simple. I am interested in building a 300BLK and the optimum barrel length between maneuverability and ballistics seems to be around 10". So having a 14.5 + pinned muzzle brake to total 16" seemed like a waste of barrel length and a negative in maneuverability. Well, so it it. For as long as I'm stuck here I'll have to stick to rifles (16") for such things.

 

So....who here knows what the best 14.5" 300BLK barrel is..........new thread.

 

Thanks all

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Thanks for the insight. This was the most helpful yet. I think this is what PK90 was telling me, but now it makes more since to me. I was hoping for this to not be a handgun and that requires the forward grip and for this to not be a rifle due to the lack of a stock. If I understand you and PK9, NJ in a round and about (assault weapons banning) way prohibit any 'firearms' which federally are not handguns, rifles, or AOW.

 

The start down this line of thinking was simple. I am interested in building a 300BLK and the optimum barrel length between maneuverability and ballistics seems to be around 10". So having a 14.5 + pinned muzzle brake to total 16" seemed like a waste of barrel length and a negative in maneuverability. Well, so it it. For as long as I'm stuck here I'll have to stick to rifles (16") for such things.

 

So....who here knows what the best 14.5" 300BLK barrel is..........new thread.

 

Thanks all

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

 

while I know that technically it is not a rifle or a handgun.. I think the risk you run is this...

 

prosecutor stands in front of a firearms dumb jury.. and reads the definition of a rifle and then of a handgun.. 

he then points out that there is no stock.. 

he then holds it by the pistol grip alone pointing it 

 

at this point he states that regardless of any other grip.. or accesory on the gun.. you have created a "handgun"

 

he then reads the NJ AWB.. and states why this handgun you created is illegal per that definition.. all the while sneaking in there that you made this illegal handgun by buying a stripped receiver to "skirt the law"

 

 

 

I think given the right set of circumstances a conviction might be fairly easy... 

 

 

 

 

as far as your new question.. I have no idea.. but I dont think the extra 6 inches is going to be a killer in overall performance of the gun...

and the trade off is using a gun you KNOW is legal to the letter of the law.. 

  • 2 weeks later...

Seems to me that NJ would, just like Commifornia, consider this to be a pistol.

And one that has way too many 'evil features' to be civilian-legal for us sheeple.

 

So just like a law-abiding PA resident with his war-carried M1 Carbine, you can't bring this puppy to the Garden State either.

Seems to me that NJ would, just like Commifornia, consider this to be a pistol.

And one that has way too many 'evil features' to be civilian-legal for us sheeple.

 

So just like a law-abiding PA resident with his war-carried M1 Carbine, you can't bring this puppy to the Garden State either.

 

I agree with this statement.. 

 

barrel length is not a factor for pistol in NJ.. so this is by all practical reading of the law.. a pistol.. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.