Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Legality of carrying concealed in condo association "common area"

Featured Replies

http://www.delawareonline.com/story/news/crime/2014/03/18/nra-wins-delaware-supreme-court-ruling-on-public-housing-/6582109/

 

 

In a surprising blow to public housing officials and a clear win for the National Rifle Association, the Delaware Supreme Court has ruled that the Wilmington Housing Authority cannot set limits on residents' rights to carry guns in common areas of public housing.

 

Ok, so regarding NJ's limitation on carrying a gun off of your property, how does our law apply to condo associations, specifically down the shore where immediately leaving one's private (owned) room means walking outside on a "common area" balcony, pool area, or stairwell?  I understand this was SCODE and not a US District Court ruling, but does the same criteria apply in NJ?  Consider that the owner of a condo is a partial owner (percentage based on number of units in complex) of all common areas.  I'm not talking about open carrying where anyone would know, but CCW, especially while hanging outside at nighttime.  No one would ever know unless an incident occured and it had to be used on common area (shared) property.  Would the resident be charged with illegally carrying in public?

I'm not 100% certain, but I believe that pertained to residents with permits to carry. The idea is that it's considered government property, or some other hogwash.

 

Edit: If you have a NJ CCW you're good to go. otherwise you're probably spending 3-5 years at Rahway.

Would the resident be charged with illegally carrying in public?

 

I'm not a lawyer, so I'm guessing here even more than the lawyers would be...but this being NJ, I'd think you would certainly be charged.

 

Whether or not you'd be convicted, I have no idea.

If you're not a CCW holder and you cannot prove without a doubt you're within an exemption, you're a felon.  I wouldn't even think about it much less try it unless you've always wanted an orange jumpsuit and a small concrete bedroom.

How does any of this apply to NJ?  This is a Delaware SC ruling.  You bring a gun to a common area in NJ, you will be arrested (unless you have a valid NJ CCW,which pretty much means that you will be arrested since no one has them).  Almost 100% guaranteed.  Doesnt matter if im a lawyer or not, that's just common sense here in NJ.  (sad, but true)

 

Common area in condo associations are not your personal property line.  You have access to use it.  It's not like walking around your yard in a house.. 

  • Author

How does any of this apply to NJ?  This is a Delaware SC ruling.  You bring a gun to a common area in NJ, you will be arrested (unless you have a valid NJ CCW,which pretty much means that you will be arrested since no one has them).  Almost 100% guaranteed.  Doesnt matter if im a lawyer or not, that's just common sense here in NJ.  (sad, but true)

 

Common area in condo associations are not your personal property line.  You have access to use it.  It's not like walking around your yard in a house.. 

 

I wasn't saying that this ruling specifically applied to NJ.  It just made me think about the condo "common area" issue in NJ since I've never seen it documented specifically before. 

 

Regarding personal property, condo association bylaws and even the deeds for condos state that the common area is owned by the owners of the condos and that each condo has a 1/x share in ownership, so yes, that is (shared) personal property.  That being said, I understand what you guys are saying about the technicalities in NJ. 

I suppose each condo association would have their own rules, but (IMO) a "share" in the ownership of common areas does not constitute being able to legally carry around a gun since you dont have full ownership.. 

 

i don't live in a condo, so im guess others may have different ideas (?)

Bottom line:  Unless you plan on being the TEST CASE, don't carry in Common Areas!  Sometimes it cracks me up to think that a Poster here will do what another Poster (here) says regarding JAIL TIME!

 

Of course there's nuthin' stoppin' you from hiring the Nappen Law firm to give you an Expert OPINION!  But since they aren't the Judges that will hear the case, you know what they say about OPINIONS:  OPINIONS are like A-Holes; everyone has one and some stink more than others..........

Bottom line:  Unless you plan on being the TEST CASE, don't carry in Common Areas! 

^^^^^^^^^  This..  end of

The superior court ruling in State v Martinez was pretty clear that  you can defend yourself in your dwelling and attached appurtenances like a deck.   If you are NOT in your dwelling or on your deck, the castle doctrine does not apply.   While this is not a direct correlation to a condo's common areas, I don't think anyone argues that the common areas are your dwelling.   If someone else can freely visit the area, it's not YOUR dwelling.   And yes, I realize we're talking about Carry, the point however of carry is to protect yourself.  If you can not legally protect yourself in an area, carrying becomes a moot point.    Self defense would still apply if you cannot retreat, but chances are, you would be able to retreat.

 

I would not be the test case, that's for sure, simply because I believe I would lose the argument.

  • Author

Bottom line:  Unless you plan on being the TEST CASE, don't carry in Common Areas!  Sometimes it cracks me up to think that a Poster here will do what another Poster (here) says regarding JAIL TIME!

 

Guys, relax!  I wasn't about to make myself into the lab rat to test this theory.  I was just hypothesizing and looking to see if anyone had thought about this in the past or if there was any precedent.  The last thing I'd do is risk my family's future by trusting anything that you guys say in an internet forum, no offense!

 

I thought that the DE case brought up a good topic of conversation on something I believe was not discussed until now.

  • Author

The superior court ruling in State v Martinez was pretty clear that  you can defend yourself in your dwelling and attached apertenances like a deck.   If you are NOT in your dwelling or on your deck, the castle doctrine does not apply.   While this is not a direct correlation to a condo's common areas, I don't think anyone argues that the common areas are your dwelling.  

 

I couldn't find this detail on State v Martinez, but was that case referring to a condo, apartment, or a house?  Because with a house, even in NJ, you do not have to be inside the dwelling for carrying to be legal.  You just need to be on your property, for example mowing the lawn, shoveling snow (driveway or walkway from front door, not public access sidewalk). 

 

 

If someone else can freely visit the area, it's not YOUR dwelling. 

 

What about your driveway?  Anyone can freely visit your driveway, but it's private property and you can carry there.

 

 

Condo - You dont own the common area, you have access to it

 

Co-Op - you do own a portion of common area - and your fees are going toward paying off the mortgage of the complex

 

The property with which I am familiar is called a condo by name, but a portion of the common area is deeded, so I guess it is technically a co-op.  It gets confusing, though, because technically the property is leased for 99 years from the developer.  However, the structure and common area (pool, parking garage, balconies/stairwells) are fully owned by the individual condo owners, split evenly between them.  There is no ownership/management company.  All of the owners makeup the "condo association" in full, evenly divided between the number of units. 

 

I agree with you guys - this is way too technical to trust any laws or be the test subject, but it definitely makes for some interesting conversation and thought.

Martinez was a house, but it clearly defined that you may stand at the doorway or attached appurtenances and resist with any means necessary, i.e. no retreat.   The point however is that while you may legally carry anywhere on your property, you may subject to criminal prosecution if you are not in your dwelling.   I.E. You are required to retreat before any other action, nullyfying the primary purpose of carry.

 

 

What about your driveway?  Anyone can freely visit your driveway, but it's private property and you can carry there.

 

You can order someone off of your driveway, legally.  You cannot do that with a common area of a condo.

 

 

Here's the Martinez case from NJ Superior court.  http://www.leagle.com/decision/1989822229NJSuper593_1763.xml/STATE%20v.%20MARTINEZ

Gee, dosent seem to apply to Newark, Camden, Jersey City,etc, etc.  Wonder why?

I live in a "Co-op" which is kind of like a condo association with more annoying rules. i would never carry in any common area EVER. I was initially even ercked by home carry and then figured i "own" the unit itself and it is my "dwelling" so im good. I wonder what would happen if i got a knock from the police one night (for innocent reasons) and i answered the door open carrying. Keep in mind my PD is NJSP.

  • Author

I live in a "Co-op" which is kind of like a condo association with more annoying rules. i would never carry in any common area EVER. I was initially even ercked by home carry and then figured i "own" the unit itself and it is my "dwelling" so im good. I wonder what would happen if i got a knock from the police one night (for innocent reasons) and i answered the door open carrying. Keep in mind my PD is NJSP.

 

You'd get the same reaction if you answered the door of a single family house open carrying...

 

Btw, my original question was about the legality of concealed carrying, not open.  I DEFINITELY agree that open carry in a common area is a bad idea, regardless of the law and its interpretation...unless you live in an open-carry friendly state and have either a permit or don't need one because of the law. 

  • Author

NJ makes no distinction between Open or Concealed carry.

 

Agreed, but my point was that if you open carry in a common area, people are going to freak out about it and make a fuss.  If it was technically legal and you were concealed carrying, there would be no fuss, no calls to the police, etc.  If there was an incident and you had to use it to defend yourself, especially in a situation where you have an outdoor common area and strangers off the street wander through drunk and start fights, frequently, my question is whether you'd be covered by the law.

Here's something else I've always wondered.

 

Say you're going to the range, a gunsmith, hunting or some other exempted location. Forget about having a FID. Let's say you have a handgun (Yes, I know NJ doesn't allow hunting with handguns. You're going hunting out of state. Ignore FOPA for a second, because technically FOPA doesn't apply unless you're in a vehicle.)

 

If you live in an apartment, would you illegally be in possession if you step outside into the hallway with your range bag with the gun(s) in it?

 

What if you live in a house but your car is parked down the street. Would you be illegally in possession if you had to walk to the car? 

What if you had to walk two blocks to a parking garage where you keep your car. I've lived in such a place before, admittedly not NJ (It was Manhattan, NYC). Would you be illegally in possession if it was NJ? 

 

Also, let's say they pass this "reasonable deviations clarification" bill that removes the judge's discretion... see what I mean? 

I asked this same question, albeit open carry, to Nappen.

 

Here is his response:

 

I can not advise you to carry on "common areas." Although I would be happy to defend you, it is a gray area and you do not need to be the test case.

  • Author

Here's something else I've always wondered.

 

Say you're going to the range, a gunsmith, hunting or some other exempted location. Forget about having a FID. Let's say you have a handgun (Yes, I know NJ doesn't allow hunting with handguns. You're going hunting out of state. Ignore FOPA for a second, because technically FOPA doesn't apply unless you're in a vehicle.)

 

If you live in an apartment, would you illegally be in possession if you step outside into the hallway with your range bag with the gun(s) in it?

 

What if you live in a house but your car is parked down the street. Would you be illegally in possession if you had to walk to the car? 

 

What if you had to walk two blocks to a parking garage where you keep your car. I've lived in such a place before, admittedly not NJ (It was Manhattan, NYC). Would you be illegally in possession if it was NJ? 

 

Also, let's say they pass this "reasonable deviations clarification" bill that removes the judge's discretion... see what I mean? 

 

Some very good points.  All you would need is a neighbor to see your rifle case (or large Sig handgun case, since they're not small) and report it to the cops and things could get interesting...

  • Author

I asked this same question, albeit open carry, to Nappen.

 

Here is his response:

 

I can not advise you to carry on "common areas." Although I would be happy to defend you, it is a gray area and you do not need to be the test case.

 

Hey, thanks for checking into this with Nappen!  His response holds more weight to me than the rest of all of our speculation combined since he is THE go-to in NJ. 

Condo - You dont own the common area, you have access to it

 

Co-Op - you do own a portion of common area - and your fees are going toward paying off the mortgage of the complex

Go have that all wrong. A condo you own your unit and a percentage do common area. A Co-Op you own a share of of the corporation and actually rent the unit.

Was that English?

Lmao

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Was that English?

"Olde" english apparently......

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.