Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

What revolver does your wife/gf/sister/mom etc. prefer?

Featured Replies

I think my next handgun purchase will be a revolver.  I want it to be something my gf likes(she loves revolvers) and is comfortable with but her hands are fairly small.  Help steer me in the right direction here. 

 

I'm not picky on brand, color, barrel length, except no snubbies, and I want .357

My gf has small hands and likes the Ruger SP101. In a semi-auto, she owns a BHP.

My wife really likes my Model 10 (mainly because the smooth trigger).

My wife "adopted" one of my S&W Model 10s. My old 4" PD revolver that had an action job (stock springs) and Hogue Mono Grip. If you want 357 get a 13 or 65.

My wife's favorite is a Taurus 605 with a 3 inch barrel which I also installed a Wolff spring kit but what she really likes is my S&W model 27-2.

My next purchase for both of us will probably be a S&W 686 with a 3 inch barrel where I'll swap out the grips for a Hogue rubber just for range days. a option you should investigate also as my wife has small hands too and loves this setup.

Very tough question.  Traditionally a J frame 3" heavy barreled 38spl such as " Lady Smith" is the choice.

Consideration...My sister shoots a Mod 27 4" standard (small) grips.

My wife shoots GLOCK 19.

My wife has a Model 19 nickel finish police revolver that has a sweet trigger, but she "thinks" the gun is too loud. Her favorite (as in she shoots almost nothing else) is a 4" stainless, 7-round S&W 686. It's an L frame gun, which is pretty big, but I got her a crimson trace grip that is smaller than the original grip and she just loves it. It really is a sweet gun, but I never shoot it unless she is out shooting because I don't want to clean it. I never get it clean enough for her.
 

  • Author

Sweet guys thanks for the suggestions. How much do the aftermarket grips affect the length of pull or purchase on a revolver ?

Sweet guys thanks for the suggestions. How much do the aftermarket grips affect the length of pull or purchase on a revolver ?

 

Grips will not change the length of pull on a revolver, diffrent grips might fit your hand better if you have small / medium / large hands.

 

If you want to change the weight of the double action pull to make it lighter , smoother, and easier to pull , a trigger job will be in order. Stoning and polishing engagment surfaces and changing springs out.

  • Author

Grips will not change the length of pull on a revolver, diffrent grips might fit your hand better if you have small / medium / large hands.

 

If you want to change the weight of the double action pull to make it lighter , smoother, and easier to pull , a trigger job will be in order. Stoning and polishing engagment surfaces and changing springs out.

Not necessarily need the trigger weight changed. Her major complaint with the ones we've held is how far away the trigger is compared to her hands.

Not necessarily need the trigger weight changed. Her major complaint with the ones we've held is how far away the trigger is compared to her hands.

 

Smaller grips may remedy that issue then, depending on what grips are already on there.

 

if whatever grips are on there have the backstop of the grip frame visable already, you wont get any closer.

 

She might be more comfortable with a smaller framed gun like the K or L frame ( model 686 / model 15 / model 10 / etc ) over a larger frame like an N-Frame ( 627 / 629 / 625 / etc )

My wife prefers my 686, only using .38 spl no magnum loads.

  • Author

Is the gp100 and 686 similar frame size? I do like the 686 + but I don't know if i want to spend as much for the S&W

Is the gp100 and 686 similar frame size? I do like the 686 + but I don't know if i want to spend as much for the S&W

 

Yes, they're the same frame size--in fact they take the exact same Speed Loaders from HKS.

 

I have a friend who bought the Ruger GP-100.  He can't figure-out how to "stage" the trigger to stop missing the center of the target on double action since the trigger pull is terrible.  He WISHES he bought the Smith and Wesson!

 

I teach approx. 70+ women every year how to hold and fire my Smith and Wesson revolvers at Old Bridge's NRA Women's Day.  I have a 4" tubed Model #19 with rubber Pachmayer grips (my Wife's House Gun), a 4" Model #586 with an action job (my IDPA Gun) with factory wood stocks, a K-.22 Masterpiece w/ 8 3/8" barrel w/ the Model #19 wooden grips and a Model #29 w/ 8 3/8" barrel and Pachmayer rubber grips.  Most women like the Model #19 because they can comfortably reach the trigger and the rubber grips ease the recoil.  Some women with larger hands like the Model #586.  They all like the red ramp front sight combined with the white outline rear sight.  In fact, I can train a complete Noob that's never fired a gun before how to hit the 10-X ring using just (12) rounds from 10 yards away.

 

What a HD gun LOOKS like is of little consequence, since it might be sitting in an evidence locker in a wet basement waiting for your trial........  So what I'm sayin' is buy the damn rubber grips and get her used to THEM, and leave them on the gun.  No playin' switcheroo, since a reliable, KNOWN grip is essential to good muscle memory and center-mass hits.  Especially for smallish hands!

 

One more thing to consider....buyin' a lightly used Model #65 or #586 will be the same or less than the new Ruger--and you'll have a "workable" gun to smooth-out (if need-be).  I'm betting that the #65 won't need any work at all for HD!

 

FWIW:  Women's Day registration is still OPEN!  She gets to shoot ALL DAY with lunch INCLUDED for only $35...........  Saturday May 31st at our outdoor range.  Static Steel, PPC (that's ME), Black Powder, Shotgun.  Revolvers, semi's, even a .45-70 Trap-Door Springfield.  It's a HOOOOT!

 

Dave

Wheelie Owner since 1977

FWIW, I have Talo edition 686+, really short fingers, and the grip will really make the difference when comparing guns. I was looking at L-frame revolvers and according to the internets, the GP100 has a shorter reach to the trigger versus the 686, but my experience was opposite. Of course, it probably boils down to the grips that were on the specific revolvers that I handled.

 

My gun came with two grips, a wooden set with the backstrap fully exposed, and a rubber grip where it's only partially exposed. The fully exposed backstrap makes it very easy for me to reach the trigger, but I don't find the combination of wooden grip and exposed metal backstrap to be very comfortable to shoot, especially with 357mag. But it does look great...if it were customary to wear guns to barbeques in NJ, I'd bring this gun in this configuration. The rubber grip is easier to hold and helps to soak up recoil, but it does make it a bit harder to reach the double action trigger.

 

Honestly, I'm not really a big revolver fan at this point. Maybe I just need to try out more grips, but the higher bore axis and less ergonomic feel bother me.

While I will never contest Alec's ability with a revolver (far surpassing my own) I will point out a few inaccuracies in his posts in this thread.

 

Grips absolutely affect the LOP on a revolver - and he contradicted himself when he talked about covered vs. uncovered backstraps. LOP is the distance the finger has to stretch to reach the trigger. Just stands to reason that covering the backstrap adds to that length.

 

It was then stated that if the LOP is too long with grips that leave the backstrap uncovered that you are SOL. Not so - girth plays a role in the LOP also. If the grip has a large palm swell, it increases the distance to the trigger. For those of you that have trouble wrapping your minds around the idiosyncrasies of wheelguns, think of a 1911 - the distance from backstrap to trigger face can be altered by using slim grips - same applies with revolvers.

 

How effectively you can operate the trigger on a wheelgun is also affected by your grip. Many people place their hand too low on the grip (which increases the LOP). On a S&W the web of the hand should be at the hump of the backstrap - you are actually pulling back & up - not straight back.

 

On the Ruger v S&W size - I'd have to say they are similar, but not exactly the same. Diameter of the circle scribed by passing a line through the chamber axes does not necessarily mean the overall dimensions of the guns in question are the same, even if the diameter of that circle is. I would say the Ruger is slighly larger and heavier by virtue of the frame elements being thicker due to being cast, rather than forged - but the difference is nominal for practical purposes.

 

There are so many grip choices out there, that you should be able to find something that fits - I would advise, if you go for the S&W, to get the round butt frame - it just increases your options.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

While I will never contest Alec's ability with a revolver (far surpassing my own) I will point out a few inaccuracies in his posts in this thread.

 

Grips absolutely affect the LOP on a revolver - and he contradicted himself when he talked about covered vs. uncovered backstraps. LOP is the distance the finger has to stretch to reach the trigger. Just stands to reason that covering the backstrap adds to that length.

 

It was then stated that if the LOP is too long with grips that leave the backstrap uncovered that you are SOL. Not so - girth plays a role in the LOP also. If the grip has a large palm swell, it increases the distance to the trigger. For those of you that have trouble wrapping your minds around the idiosyncrasies of wheelguns, think of a 1911 - the distance from backstrap to trigger face can be altered by using slim grips - same applies with revolvers.

 

How effectively you can operate the trigger on a wheelgun is also affected by your grip. Many people place their hand too low on the grip (which increases the LOP). On a S&W the web of the hand should be at the hump of the backstrap - you are actually pulling back & up - not straight back.

 

On the Ruger v S&W size - I'd have to say they are similar, but not exactly the same. Diameter of the circle scribed by passing a line through the chamber axes does not necessarily mean the overall dimensions of the guns in question are the same, even if the diameter of that circle is. I would say the Ruger is slighly larger and heavier by virtue of the frame elements being thicker due to being cast, rather than forged - but the difference is nominal for practical purposes.

 

There are so many grip choices out there, that you should be able to find something that fits - I would advise, if you go for the S&W, to get the round butt frame - it just increases your options.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

 

 

Yah, that's what I meant to say

 

dont judge, i wrote that post at like 3 in the morning.

 

 

Girth of the grip is a good point, I should of known this one first hand. At one point I decided to try the rubber X-Frame grips, which are a bit wider and have the back strap covered. They absorb recoil well, but it point my trigger finger in such an awkward spot it just wasn't worth it. 

 

Bob is very right about the grip too, any time I see somebody new to revolvers or unfamiliar with grip they are always typically holding the gun way too low, your should be holding the gun as high as possible, with the web of your hand between the thumb and trigger finger (almost) on top of the back strap. ( you shouldn't see any visible back strap )

 

 Also, trigger finger should be the same as when you shoot a semi, alot of times people will over compensate for a heavy double action trigger by inserting too much trigger finger to get leverage, personally I feel using just the pad of your finger is the correct way.

 

Though, take all that advice is just my own personal opinion, plenty of amazing revolver shooters hold the gun in such an awkward and non traditional way and do just fine.

 

best of luck

 

FWIW:  Women's Day registration is still OPEN!  She gets to shoot ALL DAY with lunch INCLUDED for only $35...........  Saturday May 31st at our outdoor range.  Static Steel, PPC (that's ME), Black Powder, Shotgun.  Revolvers, semi's, even a .45-70 Trap-Door Springfield.  It's a HOOOOT!

 

Dave

Wheelie Owner since 1977

Which range and date is the womens day at? might be something to send my wife to.

Thanks.

Which range and date is the womens day at? might be something to send my wife to.

Thanks.

Old Bridge Rifle and Pistol Club's outdoor range, Saturday May 31st.  Go to the Club's web site:   www.obrpc.org  and click on the latest newsletter and scroll till you see the full-page flyer with all of the info.  If you have any trouble, just PM me for phone number of Event Chairwoman.

 

Dave

  • Author

Guys thanks a lot. Insightful stuff there.

 

Dave, I'm working that day but my gf may go with her friend. I think she'd have a lot of fun.

  • Author

Anyone around somerset CTY have a 686 or gp100 we could try out

Anyone around somerset CTY have a 686 or gp100 we could try out

 

We can try (again) to meet up.  Bring  your gf and you can both try my Ruger GP100.  I think my trigger is pretty smoothe.  No work done, just "well" broken in.  :)

 

Shooting 38s through the GP100 has very little recoil.  It is a big, heavy gun.

 

If she isn't dead set on a revolver she can check out my CZ C75B.  9mm semi, all steel.  Being an all steel gun helps with the recoil.  It will be more noticable than the 38s through the GP but it is very managable.  I've put hundreds of rounds through my CZ and haven't had a single problem (FTF, FTE, etc).  Very nice gun.

 

PM me if your free this weekend or some evening since we have more daylight now.  I won't be availble tomorrow or Thursday.

  • Author

We can try (again) to meet up. Bring your gf and you can both try my Ruger GP100. I think my trigger is pretty smoothe. No work done, just "well" broken in. :)

 

Shooting 38s through the GP100 has very little recoil. It is a big, heavy gun.

 

If she isn't dead set on a revolver she can check out my CZ C75B. 9mm semi, all steel. Being an all steel gun helps with the recoil. It will be more noticable than the 38s through the GP but it is very managable. I've put hundreds of rounds through my CZ and haven't had a single problem (FTF, FTE, etc). Very nice gun.

 

PM me if your free this weekend or some evening since we have more daylight now. I won't be availble tomorrow or Thursday.

By Wed and Thurs you mean my 2 days off??? Lol you should know better than to try and meet up with me dude.

 

Yeah I kinda want a wheelie now and we gave plenty of semi's

 

Anyone around somerset CTY have a 686 or gp100 we could try out

GlennP has some Smith and Wesson wheelies and is a member at your club, so maybe give him a shout?

 

And have the GF register soon for Women's Day, as space will fill-up FAST!

 

Dave

  • Author

GlennP has some Smith and Wesson wheelies and is a member at your club, so maybe give him a shout?

 

And have the GF register soon for Women's Day, as space will fill-up FAST!

 

Dave

She emailed yesterday so I hope she gets in. Dave you're gonna be hosting?

I'll be running the PPC Station:

 

Police Practical Competition.  Which is essentially revolvers shooting at old-fashioned, NON-PC Silhouettes.  I'll have Shoot-N-C's, some clay birds on the berm, and maybe some spinners.  We concentrate on grip, trigger control, sight alignment during the ignition and breathing.  In other words, the Basics.  Those with experience can try the harder-to-hit targets and still enjoy themselves.  Those that are brand-new can still hit the 10-x ring of a B-34 by following simple directions.  My revolvers are so smooth, they almost shoot themselves, lol!

 

She'll have a GREAT time!

 

Dave

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.