Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Stopping Power: Myths, Legends, and Realities

Featured Replies

I thought this was a really well thought out article that slays a few sacred cows, and plainly states some of realities of real world terminal ballistics.

 

http://m.policemag.com/article/2426/stopping-power-myths-legends-and-realities

 

When it comes to claims about the effectiveness of handgun ammo, don't believe the hype.

January 16, 2013 | by Sydney Vail, MD

 

As a trauma surgeon and a tactical medical specialist, I am often asked by law enforcement officers what caliber and type of handgun ammunition offers the most stopping power. I can't answer that question. Let me explain why.

 

The ammunition most commonly carried by law enforcement officers is a hollow-point configuration or expanding full metal jacket bullet, typically in one of five calibers, including .38/.357, 9mm, .357 SIG, .40 S&W, and .45 ACP. Other calibers are used in some departments. But for the sake of this discussion, let's stick with the most common rounds. These handgun rounds perform very differently based on a number of key factors that I'd like to discuss.

 

At most agencies it is typical for either the rangemaster or lead firearms trainer to choose specific ammunition (caliber and/or bullet type) based on the results of ammunition being run through a series of ballistic tests, most commonly the FBI's ballistic laboratory testing. Marketing by ammunition companies also influences how agencies choose the specific ammunition for front line officers to carry.

 

Unfortunately, the information that agencies are using to choose the ammo for their officers is generally based on hype as well as the flawed standardized testing using ballistic gel and measurements of the depth of penetration into ballistic gel, degree of bullet expansion, and other factors. Usually, actual data on human body wound ballistics is not available to agencies when they are choosing ammo for their officers.

 

What is most unfortunate is that the testing of modern bullets does not give a complete picture of what a particular ammunition configuration will do in the human body to incapacitate it in a timely fashion, in other words, stopping power. The testing results "infer" or "simulate" what is believed to happen in the human body, but I can tell you that from my experience operating on gunshot patients that this just is not the case.

 

So back to the question at hand about determining stopping power. If you are expecting me to tell you which brand and which bullet caliber and type to use for the best or most reliable stopping power, you are going to be disappointed. But I will tell you about the factors that determine stopping power.

 

Kinetic Energy

 

Most officers think that a larger bullet and higher velocity equal more "kinetic" energy, yielding more stopping power than a smaller bullet with the same velocity. Here's the reality:

 

We know that the equation for kinetic energy is KE = ½mv2 (KE is kinetic energy, m is mass of object, and v2 is velocity squared). This equation tells us how much energy will be derived from a combination of bullet grain weight and muzzle velocity.

 

Now we need to go back a step and define stopping power. Is it the ability of a particular ammunition to:

 

Immediately incapacitate a threat?

Eventually incapacitate a threat?

Slow down a threat?

Render a person less able to remain a threat?

Knock the threat to the ground?

I believe the definition of stopping power should be a particular ammunition's effectiveness to render a person unable to offer resistance or remain a threat to the officer, an intended victim, or self.

 

So how does ammunition accomplish this? You have two options. You can use a really large round at very high velocity like the 30mm cannon rounds from an Apache helicopter's M230 Chain Gun, which produces substantial kinetic energy, or you can place your shot where it has the most effect. Obviously, shot placement is the only realistic option for a law enforcement officer.

 

A .40 caliber bullet shot into the shirtless torso of a person causes a degree of injury due to the body absorbing the bullet's energy and dispersing it in front of and around the path of the bullet. The projectile also tears through the tissue. This means that the kinetic energy of this typically low-velocity (less than 1,500 feet per second) bullet will create both a permanent cavity and to a much lesser extent a temporary cavity.

 

But does this ammunition have acceptable stopping power? Only if it hits a vital structure that would "stop" the target from continuing the fight.

 

The Target Variable

 

Consider that the same ammunition shot into the torso of an officer wearing a ballistic vest involves the same forces, but they are dispersed over a greater surface area in order to dissipate those forces, which, hopefully, prevents penetration of the body and allows the officer to continue in the fight.

 

So is the stopping power the same or different for these two scenarios? The kinetic energy is the same, the tissue injury is different.

 

Another way to look at this is to think about a bowling ball as a projectile and how it might perform in two different scenarios. If someone shoots it out of a cannon into a brick wall, the large mass and high velocity will likely result in a significant hole in that wall. But if the same bowling ball is shot out of a cannon into a strong net made of Kevlar, it will likely have all of its energy taken up by the net and not allow penetration. It has the same energy to lose in its intended target but different targets yield different results. A bowling ball fired from a cannon has high kinetic energy and excellent stopping power that far exceeds any ammo you could carry on duty, but the effect it has on the target is still determined by shot placement and the nature of the target.

 

Real Gunshot Wounds

 

The point here is that no single ammunition that is typically used by law enforcement officers today can reliably claim to have superior stopping power.

 

I have seen a .22 caliber bullet completely incapacitate someone and a .45 ACP fail to achieve that result. People and animals shot with 10mm rounds and .357 SIG rounds have continued to run from the police. I have been on scene as a tactical medical provider when a suicidal person shot himself in the head with a .45 Colt round resulting in instant death. And I have seen the same results in suicides that used smaller calibers, including .22, .25, and .32. I have also seen people hit with 9mm, .40, and .45 without so much as staggering or slowing their verbal or physical activities.

 

So we come back to the original question: Which ammunition has the best stopping power? I can't answer that question. What I can say is that you should look for ammunition that reliably lives up to its claims of penetration and expansion but don't believe that these two factors alone are related to stopping power.

 

The ultimate stopping power rests with your training with your weapon system. Accurate hits in any reasonable caliber will "stop" a person if that person has experienced enough brain or spinal cord damage to interrupt regular neurologic impulses from reaching vital areas of the body or the person has hemorrhaged enough blood to lower his or her blood pressure where the brain no longer is able to function well. You can also stop a person if a major bone shatters after a bullet injures it, but does that stop the fight?

 

Stopping power is a marketing tool and should be dropped from our discussions of ballistic performance until such time as ammunition effectiveness is measured by more means than just the results of gelatin and barrier tests. When ammunition companies or regulatory agencies begin to use computer simulations, simulant tests, animal models, autopsy results, and trauma surgeon operation reports with hospital summaries to determine the effectiveness of their products, then we will know which ammunition can be labeled as having the "best stopping power." And this claim will be based on scientific data rather than incomplete ballistic testing.

 

Until then, shot placement with any commercially available ammunition will offer you the best chance of maximizing your duty ammunition's stopping power.

 

Sydney Vail MD, FACS, is an associate professor of surgery on the trauma faculty at Penn State Milton S. Hershey Medical Center and Penn State College of Medicine in Hershey, Pa. He also serves as director of tactical medicine programs for the Arizona Department of Public Safety and Maricopa County (Ariz.) Sheriff's Office SWAT teams.

The general population of the world will still not agree with this, as well written and accurate as it is.

 

"Well In The Movies!....."

 

We should just start mounting 30mm cannons to the roofs of all patrol cars in the us.

  • Author

The general population of the world will still not agree with this, as well written and accurate as it is.

 

"Well In The Movies!....."

I think you are 100% right.

 

I think how guns, gunfights, and TTPs are portrayed in the movies and on television has done more to inhibit a realistic belief of what guns are capable of than anything out there - they have literally made us dumber as a community.

 

The worst part is that liberals, juries, the media, and legislators are basing emotions, verdicts, biases, and laws due to the same influences.

 

Shot placement! Wow, what a concept!

:rofl: I know! Right?

 

I have said it again and again, placement trumps caliber all day long.

Even placement can be a hard topic to assess. When I was an EMT, I treated a patient who had 3 holes in him, one of which was dead center chest right below the sternum. Despite the "center mass" hit, he was still talking the whole time.

I think you are 100% right.

 

I think how guns, gunfights, and TTPs are portrayed in the movies and on television has done more to inhibit a realistic belief of what guns are capable of than anything out there - they have literally made us dumber as a community.

 

The worst part is that liberals, juries, the media, and legislators are basing emotions, verdicts, biases, and laws due to the same influences.

 

:rofl: I know! Right?

 

I have said it again and again, placement trumps caliber all day long.

 

Not to in any way downplay the dangerous nature of firearms (obviously most of the people on this forurm know the dangers....I hope)

 

Public perception of the effectiveness of guns and getting shot is far askew from the reality of it and all of those liberals, juries, legislators and of course the media base their entire "expert understanding" on this false perception that getting shot with a .45 ACP round from a 1911 will send you flying backwards 20 feet.

 

And of course the always present, "well why couldn't the police have just shot him in the leg or the arm, that would have stopped him!"

 

Anyway I don't want to drag this too far off the original topic but it all comes down to shot placement in the vital areas!

  • Author

Even placement can be a hard topic to assess. When I was an EMT, I treated a patient who had 3 holes in him, one of which was dead center chest right below the sternum. Despite the "center mass" hit, he was still talking the whole time.

The human body is an amazing and resilient machine. It can take a lot of damage and continue to function if the mind that controls that body doesn't want to quit.

 

Oh, and just a q uick point of orrder - Below the sternum is not "dead center" of the chest. ;)

 

Now, please define "center of mass". I bet the true definition is a lot different than what you may think. I am not picking on you, but this is one of the very things I am talking about.

 

Shooters routinely mention "center of mass" because they hear it in movies or on TV without ever knowing the true meaning of the term as it has been completely subverted from what it really means. Simply put "center of mass" is the center of the biggest visible portion of your target.

 

For example, if all you can see is a thigh, and you can identify the thigh as that of your attacker, and that attacker is still a deadly threat - then you aim for the "center of mass" of the thigh and you go to work.

 

Without X-ray vision you can't assess shot placement. Nine times out of ten you won't even see your hits on the body. Knowing your gun/trigger and following your sights is the only indication of whether you may have gotten hits. There is rarely a splash of blood or chunks of meat flying to see when you get a hit. If you are lucky, you may see the threats clothing get disturbed, and that is all.

 

You also don't know what a bullet will do once it enters the body. Even if your sights are perfectly aligned on your targets heart, once that projectile breaks the surface of the clothing and begins to be influenced by fabrics, flesh, bones, organs, fluids, etc... you can't always predict what will happen.

 

You can only assess the change in behavior your shot placement created. Based on that assessment you continue to shoot until you get the desired result.

Unless you're Jerry Miculek there's probably more luck than skill involved in shot placement in a life-and-death situation. The luck factor goes up with one handed shooting, when one or more participants are moving, and with increasing caliber. People have been known to miss at near point-blank range. On the other hand the lowly and nearly recoil-less .22lr is claimed to have killed more people than any other round. 

 

Unless you're talking crazed bad guys on bath salts or meth, or unbelievably bad luck, the truth for individual shooters, in individual situations, lies somewhere between the .45 acp and the .22lr. 

 

(Eagerly anticipating the vitriol from the caliber police).

this false perception that getting shot with a .45 ACP round from a 1911 will send you flying backwards 20 feet.

I just love that one.

It's been said many times before, better to hit with a .22 than miss with a .44.

  • Author

Public perception of the effectiveness of guns and getting shot is far askew from the reality of it and all of those liberals, juries, legislators and of course the media base their entire "expert understanding" on this false perception that getting shot with a .45 ACP round from a 1911 will send you flying backwards 20 feet.

 

It's like people drop 30 IQ points and forget all about the rules of physics when they get a gun in their hands.

 

Don't even get me started on the "shoot 'em in the leg" garbage :facepalm:

 

Unless you're Jerry Miculek there's probably more luck than skill involved in shot placement in a life-and-death situation. The luck factor goes up with one handed shooting, when one or more participants are moving, and with increasing caliber. People have been known to miss at near point-blank range. On the other hand the lowly and nearly recoil-less .22lr is claimed to have killed more people than any other round.

 

Unless you're talking crazed bad guys on bath salts or meth, or unbelievably bad luck, the truth for individual shooters, in individual situations, lies somewhere between the .45 acp and the .22lr.

 

(Eagerly anticipating the vitriol from the caliber police).

Luck is not a tactic. Hope is not a course of action. If that's the case, why train at all. Save the money you would spend on ammo and training and buy beer. If it is all luck, what makes a trained shooter any better than Joe Schmo off the street? What makes a professional better than an amateur?

 

You don't have to be Jerry Miculek to prevail in a deadly encounter. You need to be prepared - equipment, mindset - and proficient - training.

 

As far as caliber, if you are prepared and you have a platform that launches a proven "duty" caliber you don't have to worry about pesky things like penetration or energy transfer, or any of the things the author is talking about. You can remove the "caliber police" from the equation by choosing a decent caliber with which to defend yourself. If you have a .38/9mm/.357/.40/.45 instead if a .22/.25/.32/.380 on the nightstand on the worst night of your life, it's a non-issue. If you choose your defensive firearm based on proven ability balanced by how well you shoot it, instead of how well conceals and how comfortable it is, caliber takes a back seat.

 

Everyone is responsible only for themselves, if some choose a .22 for SD/HD than that's on them.

 

.22 may account for more deaths, I don't know and don't have those stats. If it does I am curious to see if that includes suicides and accidental deaths - which is an entirely different set of circumstances than a defensive/life saving shooting.

It's like people drop 30 IQ points and forget all about the rules of physics when they get a gun in their hands.

 

Don't even get me started on the "shoot 'em in the leg" garbage :facepalm:

 

Luck is not a tactic. Hope is not a course of action. If that's the case, why train at all. Save the money you would spend on ammo and training and buy beer. If it is all luck, what makes a trained shooter any better than Joe Schmo off the street? What makes a professional better than an amateur?

 

You don't have to be Jerry Miculek to prevail in a deadly encounter. You need to be prepared - equipment, mindset - and proficient - training.

 

As far as caliber, if you are prepared and you have a platform that launches a proven "duty" caliber you don't have to worry about pesky things like penetration or energy transfer, or any of the things the author is talking about. You can remove the "caliber police" from the equation by choosing a decent caliber with which to defend yourself. If you have a .38/9mm/.357/.40/.45 instead if a .22/.25/.32/.380 on the nightstand on the worst night of your life, it's a non-issue. If you choose your defensive firearm based on proven ability balanced by how well you shoot it, instead of how well conceals and how comfortable it is, caliber takes a back seat.

 

Everyone is responsible only for themselves, if some choose a .22 for SD/HD than that's on them.

 

.22 may account for more deaths, I don't know and don't have those stats. If it does I am curious to see if that includes suicides and accidental deaths - which is an entirely different set of circumstances than a defensive/life saving shooting.

 I didn't say ALL luck. There's luck (uncertainty) in everything we do. Doesn't mean you don't eat right, train with your gun, or save money. Nor did I say that everyone should carry a .22. I said the truth for every situation, and individual shooters, lies somewhere on the .22-.45 continuum.

 

Even you have a continuum, from 9x17 to .45. See?

 

I wouldn't give my mother in law a .45, or even a .380. I would give one to my wife, but something significantly heavier than my sig p238. 

 

I read an interesting study last night on caliber. If I can find it in my Delicious account I will post it here. Its findings will surprise you.

  • Author

Uncertainty =/= luck

 

Uncertainty can be overcome with confidence, preparation, surprise, speed, and violence of action.

 

Luck goes both ways.

Shot placement is key.  Always has been.  As far back as the Old West, there have been accounts of men being shot a dozen times with .44's (one right through both cheeks--from one side to the other and OUT!) and still ridin' their horses and fighting and returnin' fire.   

 

Which brings me to another point:  Most of the Keyboard Commandos here never practice, and IF they do it's always free-style or at best, strong hand only.  Never here or see any write-ups here about results with weak-hand only shooting.  So does that mean that Good Guys always use both hands, or never get shot on their strong side?  Gimmie a break!  I practice weak-hand only with everything i own, right up to .44 Mag.  I'm not as nimble as I once was.  I might get shot.  But I'm goin' to KILL the SOB that tries to shoot me!  And if that means a weak-hand shot with a semi-auto, there's NO malfunctions in my operation!

I practice mostly weaver stance. It's just how I shot for years. But I've also been practicing one hand shooting with either hand and do surprisingly well.

I even go as far to say, I use my middle finger, (besides just using it for the American wave), as the trigger finger and do fairly well. So I think I got most bases covered. But one thing I finalize all my sets with is are head shots. No doubt they ain't getting back up unless they have a stainless steel skull plate.

 

I have no intentions going into battle at my age and health. Most likely not even having to run and gun. But in case something fails, I know they'll be going down. What we really should not be thinking that it's always as easy as Bruce Willis makes it to be. It's not!

 

I have everything measured out in my home for distance. I can tell you how far it will be from various locations in my home if I'm faced with a perp on the far side of any room or closer. I can also walk blind folded to all my staged weapons. The perp will not get the upper hand in my home unless I'm out cold no matter where I am. Having all this knowledge especially being that if something ever goes down, you will be much better off than panicking not knowing if you can complete the mission. You'll have your weapon skills, lay of the land and the extreme upper hand being on your own ground.

 

 

Sent from my iPad 2 using T2 Pro

I agree with the article 100%.

There was an interesting article I read it in one of the gun magazines recently. The author had collected his data on one stop shots. He found that the 22's, 25s, and 22s had the same or higher percentages of one shot stops as the 38spl/9mm and up. Further research found that many of these one stop shots were result of the person just stopping what they were doing because they didn't want to get shot again. Nothing vital was hit, it was just that they decided to quit before they got shot again. I have personal knowledge of seeing this happen. I'm sure the same thing happens with 9mm, 357, 40, and 45. You have to be careful on what you define as a one stop shot.

If you're serious about defensive shooting you will also practice shooting different positions. I'm not just talking standing, kneeling, etc but also laying on your side, prone, supine,sitting, etc both weak and strong handed and two hands. You're not always going to be fighting from a Weaver using two hands.
Can a.22 work? It sure can. Look at the Reagan assassination attempt. Two of the four victims went down like they were hit by a sledgehammer. 22s can work but I wouldn't count on one.

HE brings up another good point I learned long ago. If your adversary gives you a knee or an elbow for a target you should take advantage of that. That becomes your "center mass". I have seen people in live fire and simulations training not take advantage of a target that was presented to them. They were waiting for a traditional head or "center mass" shot. Some of these were people who participated in gun games and were pretty good at that.

You also need to incorporate using cover in your training.

I have killed animals of all sizes with everything from .22lr up to 3" 12ga slugs.

 

I can say with certainty that there is no such thing as stopping power.  I have never had an animal immediately succumb to the shear impact force of the shot.   I have had animals die very quickly because of a heart or lung shot.  I have had animals drop immediately from a spine shot.  I have had animals die immediately from a carefully placed head shot (including from a .22lr).    But I have never had an animal stopped by the power of the bullet.  I do not believe that stopping power even exists.

Shot placement is key.  Always has been.  As far back as the Old West, there have been accounts of men being shot a dozen times with .44's (one right through both cheeks--from one side to the other and OUT!) and still ridin' their horses and fighting and returnin' fire.   

 

Which brings me to another point:  Most of the Keyboard Commandos here never practice, and IF they do it's always free-style or at best, strong hand only.  Never here or see any write-ups here about results with weak-hand only shooting.  So does that mean that Good Guys always use both hands, or never get shot on their strong side?  Gimmie a break!  I practice weak-hand only with everything i own, right up to .44 Mag.  I'm not as nimble as I once was.  I might get shot.  But I'm goin' to KILL the SOB that tries to shoot me!  And if that means a weak-hand shot with a semi-auto, there's NO malfunctions in my operation!

You're a better man than I am. I practice single hand maybe every 2 weeks, and weak hand maybe...maybe every 4-5 trips to the range. It's depressing to go back from a 5" group at 25 yards to a 4" group at 7 yards, if I'm lucky. But that's what we have to do, assuming we're able to carry.

 

WHICH WE ARE NOT BECAUSE WE DON'T FUKCEN VOTE.

I like the article but.... In my opinion the article oversimplifies some and misses the point of testing a bit. At least as far as any tests and evaluations I was involved in. The point, in my view, isn't exactly to perfectly predict a rounds stopping power, but to get a sense of likely performance. In other words an indication of a new round being something that will possibly perform well or likely to under-perform. So if round x that performed very well in x number of after action reports equates to X penetration, y crush cavity, z temp stretch etc etc, and round y has aar's with terrible performance and it has a different set of measurments, one could draw an expectation that all things being equal, the round that creates the same or close to the same measurments as x will likely perform well and the new round that matches y will not. If a round is brand new, there really isn't much else to go on. When performing this very testing and evaluation thousands of actual shootings were reviewed. The rounds tested and measurements documented to provide the data baseline. Then we would test new rounds and see which proven or poor performing rounds they matched up with. ALL offers for money, free ammo, sponsership etc etc were refused so as to not be beholding to ANY manufacturer. But they paid attention and I believe that they adopted some of the methodology on developing new rounds.

You're a better man than I am. I practice single hand maybe every 2 weeks, and weak hand maybe...maybe every 4-5 trips to the range. It's depressing to go back from a 5" group at 25 yards to a 4" group at 7 yards, if I'm lucky. But that's what we have to do, assuming we're able to carry.

 

WHICH WE ARE NOT BECAUSE WE DON'T FUKCEN VOTE.

 

Try shooting the bad guys on the tv, lol, with the weak hand using an UNLOADED gun.  Sit in the livingroom and actually practice to develop muscle memory with both hands.  Get comfortable so you can work the triggers and know when the sear is gonna break.  Let the wife call you NUTZ, lol and just get it done.  You'll be surprised at the results you'll see!

  • 2 weeks later...

I'd wager mindset on both sides of the coin have more to do with the outcome then anything, even training. With that said training will not doubt improve your mindset.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.