I don't know if I agree with that anymore. I took apart my S&W 642 to do a trigger job. I was shocked to see how many moving parts and little springs revolvers have. A hell of a lot more than any striker fired pistol. I think I would opt for a striker fired pistol for my only pistol. Glock preferred.

G19... unless I really like the P320C... 

Walther ppq m2

I don't know if I agree with that anymore. I took apart my S&W 642 to do a trigger job. I was shocked to see how many moving parts and little springs revolvers have. A hell of a lot more than any striker fired pistol. I think I would opt for a striker fired pistol for my only pistol. Glock preferred.

Good choice but, asking revolver guys, when was the last time you squeezed the trigger on a revolver and could not resolve the problem by squeezing again? 

 

Again we're talking about an ONLY gun, not a favorite gun. 

HK VP9

I see a New Jersey bias here on the Glock 19.

If you weren't limited to 15 rounds (or more likely, the next Democrat Governor makes 10 rounds the max), would you still have the same answer? I find the G17 to be a much softer shooting and accurate gun than the G19. And the extra grip length is appreciated by my big hands.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I see a New Jersey bias here on the Glock 19.

If you weren't limited to 15 rounds (or more likely, the next Democrat Governor makes 10 rounds the max), would you still have the same answer? I find the G17 to be a much softer shooting and accurate gun than the G19. And the extra grip length is appreciated by my big hands.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Another G19 fan here.

 

And even if I wasn't restricted to 15 rounds, I would probably still choose the G19 as my all around gun. While I love to shoot my G17, I am pretty much as effective with my G19, and the size is ideal for carry.

I see a New Jersey bias here on the Glock 19.

If you weren't limited to 15 rounds (or more likely, the next Democrat Governor makes 10 rounds the max), would you still have the same answer? I find the G17 to be a much softer shooting and accurate gun than the G19. And the extra grip length is appreciated by my big hands.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I have both just in case lol, as well as a 26 & 27. I have smaller hands I can shoot any of them. If we're talking SHTF the obvious choice is a 9mm. Especially for ammo availability reasons, that would be what your most likely to come across. Good luck finding .38 special or .357 when scavenging. Gotta say I'm digging the VP9 as well these days. Glock mags would also be easily found compared to other choices. Just really makes the most sense to me. A gun without ammo is a paperweight. It's also hard to point a revolver at someone unloaded and get away with it, in good lighting if you're out and trying to bluff.

I have both just in case lol, as well as a 26 & 27. I have smaller hands I can shoot any of them. If we're talking SHTF the obvious choice is a 9mm. Especially for ammo availability reasons, that would be what your most likely to come across. Good luck finding .38 special or .357 when scavenging. Gotta say I'm digging the VP9 as well these days. Glock mags would also be easily found compared to other choices. Just really makes the most sense to me. A gun without ammo is a paperweight. It's also hard to point a revolver at someone unloaded and get away with it, in good lighting if you're out and trying to bluff.

 

 

Did you ever read "The Road" by Cormac McCarthy? The protagonist in that book had a revolver for self defense and carved bullets out of wood for that very reason. He only had two live bullets. 

 

Did you ever read "The Road" by Cormac McCarthy? The protagonist in that book had a revolver for self defense and carved bullets out of wood for that very reason. He only had two live bullets.

 

I have not, but I will see if it's available on Google books if it's a good read. Sounds good.

I have not, but I will see if it's available on Google books if it's a good read. Sounds good.

 

Excellent book. Very dark. It is about some unexplained apocalypse, and a father trying to survive with his young son. By the same author who wrote "No Country for Old Men", if you saw the movie. 

Excellent book. Very dark. It is about some unexplained apocalypse, and a father trying to survive with his young son. By the same author who wrote "No Country for Old Men", if you saw the movie.

I did see that movie. I will check out this book thanks.

If you have kids, especially a son, it's a tough read.

Cobra derringer in .22 CB!

I understand the "best" or "favorite" gun sentiment running through this thread. I'd definitely include 2 pistols in my top three favorites. But really guys to me an "only" gun is one you use for hunting, self-defense, and recreation, that works without fail, that's easy to maintain.

 

 

Why not a revolver?

I see a New Jersey bias here on the Glock 19.

If you weren't limited to 15 rounds (or more likely, the next Democrat Governor makes 10 rounds the max), would you still have the same answer? I find the G17 to be a much softer shooting and accurate gun than the G19. And the extra grip length is appreciated by my big hands.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Lunk, that may be true, but remember the G19 is a bit compact as well, meaning you can conceal it if need be.  I think for most folks, that's important as only having one handgun means you want one you can do the most with.  At a cost of some barrel length, 2 rounds in the magazine, and a shorter grip, it still holds its own to the 17...

Lunk, that may be true, but remember the G19 is a bit compact as well, meaning you can conceal it if need be. I think for most folks, that's important as only having one handgun means you want one you can do the most with. At a cost of some barrel length, 2 rounds in the magazine, and a shorter grip, it still holds its own to the 17...

That is true. I wasn't factoring concealed carry into it. If you do, it probably overrides the eAsier shooting of the bigger gun. I have never tried concealing a full size service pistol.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Glock 26 all the way, use 10 round mag for concealed carry and put the 15 rounder in when needed.

Change my mind! H&K VP9!

CZ 75

HK VP9

I've changed my vote from G19 to P320 Compact.  Great trigger, 15 rd magazine, factory night sights, and the option to change calibers and size options.

4" GP100.

Same here

I see a New Jersey bias here on the Glock 19. If you weren't limited to 15 rounds (or more likely, the next Democrat Governor makes 10 rounds the max), would you still have the same answer? I find the G17 to be a much softer shooting and accurate gun than the G19. And the extra grip length is appreciated by my big hands.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Really not that much difference in shooting the G17 vs G19 IMO. The 19 is a better all around pistol.

m