@Mrs. Peel:
I just saw this thread and if it is not too late, for what it is worth, here is my experience and process as a bonafide “car guy” when purchasing tires for my vehicles. I will echo the other posters who say that for the most part, Tire Rack usually has the lowest prices for the widest range of tire makes and sizes. If I were you, I would research to determine what your car’s manufacturer (Audi), has recommended as the OEM tires size and make for your specific car model. The OEM tires were selected since they are the most appropriate for your car's weight, chassis and general type of vehicle, (compact, full-size, SUV, truck, etc....). Then, with that information, using the very easy Tire Rack web site, price out a set of four of those specific tires, including shipping costs to you or your installer. Then, what I have done, is take that information to either my BMW or Mercedes-Benz Dealer(s). I first ask the BMW/M-B dealer(s) to give me an itemized price for the same tires, along with the mounting, balancing, removing of old tires, NJ State Tire Fee and of course, NJ Sales Tax. Usually, but not always, the total cost of the new tires offered by the BMW/M-B Dealerships is a more expensive than that from Tire Rack, but not significantly. (Note: As a member of the BMW Car Club of America and the Mercedes-Benz Club of America, I receive discounts on all OEM parts that I purchase from these Dealers). What I end up doing is showing the Dealers what Tire Rack charges for the same tires and the Dealers ALWAYS have met their lower price. That saves me the hassle of having to order the four tires from Tire Rack and having to determine who will mount/balance the tires, etc. Also, the BMW/M-B Dealers provide a one-year road hazard warranty for each of the tires that I purchase from them, that they install, at no additional cost. This process will allow you to purchase the tires that are specifically specified for your model of car by its manufacturer, at close to the lowest price you can realistically obtain without spending much time shopping around.
Also, there are several other factors to consider when purchasing tires for your car, as I have explained in posts in other threads, which you may or may not remember, so here they are again:
Summer / Winter Tires - I am firmly in the camp that believes that in order to get the best performance, enjoyment and safety from your automobiles, whether they are daily drivers or used on occasion, (i.e. long road trips, utility, etc.), one should switch between summer performance tires and winter (snow) tires. This is especially true for cars that are rear-wheel drive.
While it may seem easier and less expensive to go with All-Season tires, if you do you are compromising your vehicle’s performance, something that most of us enthusiasts do not want to do. Therefore, I switch out my summer performance wheels/tires to my winter wheels/tires usually around Dec. 1st and keep them on the vehicles for approximately. five (5) months and switch back around May 1st.
It is a misconception that winter tires are really only needed for driving on snow covered roads. Studies have shown that at about 44 deg. F, and below, the softer rubber compounds in high-performance summer tires AND all-season tires change by becoming much harder. This results in reduced contact with the road. Winter tires are designed with special rubber compounds that will stay soft at the lower temperatures and with tread groove geometry design that increase surface contact and therefore your traction in cold winter conditions. Therefore, winter tires should seriously be considered for all locations where the air temperature will be below approx.. 40 deg. F. for days/weeks/months on end, (i.e. the northeast U.S.)
As far as my experience, I tend to go with the summer and winter tries that are either OEM or recommended by the manufacturer, in my case Mercedes-Benz and BMW. I have the wheels/tires swapped out at my respective BMW/M-B Dealers. During this transition, they take my summer wheels/tires and shrink-wrap them, put them on a pallet and store them in a central warehouse facility during the winter months, all for a nominal fee. For those of us who do not have extravagant garage storage space for these wheels/tires, this option makes quite a bit of sense. Ultimately and despite the large width of these tires, they have proven their dependable performance during the cold winter months and have been more than adequate to get me through snow covered roads. Also, I have been pleased with the performance and longevity of these summer and winter tires, considering my greater than average spirited driving habits
Tire Age Factor - FYI, an often overlooked but very important factor in purchasing new tires for your car, SUV or truck is the actual age of the tires. Specifically, the date that each tire was manufactured and its relation to the date you purchase them and have them installed on your vehicle.
Tire manufacturers recommend that tires should be replaced once they exceed six (6) years in age. This is regardless of the wear level of the tread and is due to the realization that the rubber polymers dry out over time and that dry rot can and does occur not only on the tread surface that is in contact with the road, but also on the sidewalls, creating a potential weak spot that could lead to a blowout.
Every tire sold in the U.S. must have a U.S. Dept. of Transportation (DOT) label that indicates the date that tire was manufactured. You can (and should), locate the DOT code on the tire’s sidewall. The key numbers are the last four digits that indicate the date of production. Of those last four digits, the first two indicate which of 52 weeks and the second two digits refer to the year. So for example, if the last four digits of the DOT code are 2615, that indicates that tire was produced in the 26th week of 2015.
As an example, back in the fall of 2017, I needed to buy new tires for my old roadster. I discovered that only two companies still make tires in the size I need and that Tire Rack did not carry them. The local tire chain store near me told me they have four in stock and could get them the same day. Once I arrived at the store, I checked the DOT code and discovered that each tire was four (4) years old. I refused to buy them and asked the manager to please do some research with their distributers to see if he could locate and obtain four tires that are no more than 12 months old. Ultimately, he was able to do so within a week and those are the tires I purchased.
Most consumers just naively assume that the “new” tires they are purchasing were manufactured at some point in the past 12 months, but that may not necessarily be the case. Your tires may have been sitting on a rack in a warehouse for several years before they were selected for your car. This is especially true for tires that may be an odd size that is not all that common. Many tire retailers, whether they are locals, chains or online sources, do not bother to check the age of the tires since their priority is to sell tires. Therefore, the burden for this issue is on the consumer to ask, check and verify for yourself what the age of each tire is that you are buying.
I hope this helps you and others here. Good luck….
AVB-AMG