Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

unclenunzie

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by unclenunzie

  1. Voting is always a package deal - No one gets to construct their own representative and send them off to do their bidding - not the common man, anyway. Like you, I've got to take the bad with the good when I make my voting choices. I am opposed to RKBA restrictions and constant attacks on 2A. I believe in castle law, public carry with stand your ground (everywhere). I am opposed to a constitutional amendment banning same sex marriage. I am opposed to the constant attacks on abortion rights. I believe the ACA (Obamacare) is a good start, but I'd like to see Medicare open to all ages. I think its awful that common employees or small business owners who reach advanced age will have to spend down their entire life savings to enter a decent long term care facility, in order to qualify for Medicaid. As compared to someone who never saved, spent their money on whatever, and qualifies immediately because they have no assets. No one in the public sphere will represent me on these issues as a package. So I have reached a compromise with myself. I vote for the people who will do the least damage to my package of concerns, and give money to the groups that can help the other causes directly. That is why I am a lifetime member of the SAF, with their record of forcing compliance with the second amendment in the courts; It is also why why I mostly vote for democrats, because they support most of what I require of my government, and they don't want to create second-class citizens out of some people because of who they are. The republican party platform expresses a desire to maintain and further deny marriage equality to gay and lesbian people, which is reason #1 I don't vote for them. If they make a genuine change in both actions and words to change that, I'd reconsider. Liberty for all? What an idea. As a point to your question, I have called and written to my reps expressing my firm opposition to AWB and magazine constraints. I have written to the President about it as well, and added my name to the Aniti-AWB petitions at the whitehouse.gov. More on topic as I think this thread has gone a bit political , do you think the 5-round mag thing could actually reach a vote, and if it got to the governor's desk, would he sign or veto? Also, although I do read a lot on RKBA court opinions, I am at a loss why there is not more discussion on how mag restrictions might violate 2A, and similarly an AWB might, now that heller and macdonald are scotus case law.
  2. CGB: But I have to ask, do you get more grief from gun owners, or progressive democrats when you admit your political leanings AND being a gun owner? Since I live in north jersey and work in NYC, I mostly connect with liberals. With whom I agree mostly, except on guns. So they give me grief on that, but let's say I have gotten their wheels turning some.... One friend can't be reasoned with as there is a hate for guns in his heart. I think I'm a good judge of people's motivation these days, and I think he has personal experience in 'losing control' - a real hot head. This is the source of his hate/fear of guns, and he thinks (I kid you not), that places where crime seems low but guns are not hated, that the LE authorities look away from murder. He refuses to accept state statistics from florida which show CCL revocations are vanishingly small, that gun crime by CCL people is far below that of average population. But at least on occasion he has said, since he knows me a long time, that gun ownership by me is not scary, its the other people out there who could, you know, kill their neighbor over dogshit or something. I told him when it becomes legal, I'll pack in NYC at work, it's in the courts and it's coming. Red and veins popping, LOL. My other work bud is (generally) opposed to gun ownership but it's not religion for him. In fact after numerous political discussions he told me of a close friend who was at a bus station in Queens one night and got his teeth knocked out by two thugs during a robbery. This friend is reported to have been on the hunt for a carry weapon since because he is determined not to be victimized again. I recall $12K for the dental work which he can't afford of course. My bud is a thoughtful man, and expressed clear understanding of why his friend was going toward guns and not away from them. He gets it, but still isn't really there yet, by telling me the story of his friend he is admitting to me that carry is a valid option for people at least under some conditions. I did feel obligated to pass on the felony nature of his friend's expressed desire in NYC, but he says the guy is adamant about it. Personally I think he should take a different route than risk his freedom and rights. I have a close family friend who is very strongly republican, and is fine with gun rights. But she's got the liberty thing a little off, you know the whole social conservative thing. Don't get me wrong, I understand about taxation issues and some of the union and entitlement attitudes issues she's about. But there is a clearly expressed racism in her arguments, which is driven by her personal experiences in life and is not necessarily a reflection of her republican politics. Though I think there are elements like her that are attracted to the R party more so than the D party, for whatever reason. Let me just define where I fit in this: I want the democrats to stop attacking RKBA I want the republicans to stop attacking marriage equality The above are about civil rights and not negotiable. The rest of it is all about money, who pays and who spends, and for what. That is all negotiable. As Sesame Street's Count Von Count might say, "Tyranny, brought to you by the letter D and the letter R". sorry for the rant.
  3. Reading the news of late has further convinced me that respecting liberty, personal responsibility, and civil rights is beyond the majority of most people. I really can't stand the authoritarian pricks of either major party. Five round magazines? This right here is the future of gun control. They will never accept the right to arms as written, they will incrementally strip the right until it is all but gone. Generations in the future will know nothing about American history or how our system of government was designed two work. Hell most people are that ignorant right now. Gun ownership will appear as part of a barbaric past, they will not notice the collar around their necks. I'm a progressive democrat gun owner. I believe in social justice, full equality for all, and the common good. I am 100% opposed to any further restrictions on firearms or their capabilities and capacities. I want to see existing ones rolled back. The agenda to suppress the right to arms must be countered and stopped.
  4. Or to live in a county that will issue a carry license.
  5. I just picked one up today, myself (from Bullethole). Have not had a chance to shoot it yet. The lockup is solid and I really like it. I had considered the Henry survival rifle but couldn't get past the online comments about accuracy. When this 10/22 TD came out I knew I had to have one, and I figure the accuracy will be 10/22 Barrel cleaning will be easier and imo better/safer compared to the standard models, since you can clean from the breach end. I like the stainless too, if I get a little lazy.
  6. I wanted an L size .357 and handled both the 686 and GP100 at Meltzers. The 686 felt better over all to me at the time, and the cost of permits (time, annoying my references, etc) was higher than the price diff. So I got the 686 4" and I'm happy with it. Smooth action and just stupid accurate. I may some day get a GP100, I like the design and know it from my SP101.
  7. Thanks to everyone. Leaving the seller's FPID # out seems best, so long as the receiver's info is complete.
  8. Hello guys, I have a scenario for your consideration: Person 1 and Person 2 live in the same NJ home many years ago. Person 1 hunts, has an FPID, and owns legally purchased long guns bought at dealers in NY state. Person 2 has no interest in hunting or firearms at that time. Move forward a couple decades, person 1 and 2 move to another home in NJ. Person 1 no longer hunts and has no further interest in firearms, and no longer can find their FPID (it's just plain lost), and will not be getting a replacement. Person 2 newly develops an interest in the long guns, and has a valid FPID for the current address (100% valid). They which to transfer ownership from person 1 to person 2. How does a transfer of ownership legally occur if only the receiver currently has their FPID?
  9. At the risk of minor thread hijack: Has there never been an inquiry made to the NJ Attorney General's office on the out of state transport question? I do realize there is risk in just asking but it would seem insane that no hard and fast answer can be had. Or has this question been asked and the AG simply ignores it? For what it is worth, I have in the past flown to Florida with a handgun per the transport rules, and will do so again. I'd just love to have a letter from the AG's office stating something similar to the Don Young letter but specific to NJ residents starting their journey within NJ. Is there no friendly state assemblyman or state senator willing to pose the question to get an answer?
  10. I have never seen any references anywhere even suggesting this, and in my personal reads of NJ statutes have not seen it either. However, I personally do this to reduce the risk of theft. Safe travels.
  11. The point of the bill is to enforce reciprocity among all states that issue licenses or permits at all. If you have a carry permit from your home state you can carry in any state that allows carry at all, subject to the local carry laws for the least restricted permit or license they issue. If you have a license from any state but not one from your own state, you can carry in any carry-allowing state except your home state. Lastly, one key point is that a state cannot increase carry restrictions without impacting retired police, security, or other persons. The bill demands the least restricted carry rules in the state to apply to anyone who carries legally there under this bill. So to screw a citizen from PA carrying in NJ on their PA license, they would also have to screw retired and visiting LEOs, security, etc... At least this is how I see it all laying out, IANAL. This bill would be attached to must-pass legislation such as the national debt limit increase coming up. Attached there, the President will sign it, IMO. With just about everyone but NJ residents able to carry here, it should create tremendous pressure coupled with the federal Muller case to change the laws to shall issue here. Also the courts would take the will of congress stated so clearly and strongly into consideration when deciding cases. It would be a big win for 2A rights.
  12. After each handgun purchase, I make three copies of the purchase permit, one each into large zip-lock bags. One bag stays in the range bag at all times, two at home, and the originals are locked in a small fire-resistant safe. None of this is required by law, but I feel better having documentation available in this gun hostile state. It's like an insurance policy.
  13. I got printed electronically in the Lee County Florida Sheriff's office, and had my application notarized by one of their officers. Nice people - one officer told me in a serious tone, "you know the fbi is going to look at any records, etc." I just laughed with him that they would find me rather boring. While we did this we chatted about the great things in NJ especially hot dogs. I think many of these guys are retired officers who come back part time just to keep busy. I did not have my proof of firearms training with me at the time, so the entire package had to go by mail when I returned north. 40 days later it was in my mailbox. I hear the times are shorter now. Oh and on-topic, the prints must come from law enforcement or possibly their lawful representatives. You can't do it yourself.
  14. Amazing how an anvil hanging above the head can inject clarity and common sense into the thinking. Though as has been said before, undefined "good character" is the same BS NJ is being sued about. Constitutional issues aside for the moment, I'd like to see the new HPID grandfathered to people who have pinks and a valid FPID. If they want to reduce administrative costs, visiting your local PD with a set of these ought to check off "approved" for issuance, period. Let the DMV machinery crank them out but mail/deliver them to the local PD, where you can pick it up. The PD could then compare your face to the photos in driver license and HPID so they feel safe to issue.
  15. Downr@nge, Fair enough, though I do feel the distinction should be clear as it is fundamental to the question. I agree with you that NJ has no legit way to show the law is constitutional. I don't think the plaintiff's lawyers are depending on anything in other states, though. They are busting down the requirement for "need" with no possible "need" actually ever passing muster with NJ officials. Note that to win the facial challenge all NJ has to do is come up with one example of how the law is legal, and to do that they would need to show that a permit was in fact possible to obtain. At least this is how I read the posted arguments of people who know way more than I do (which isn't much). So if you can take this line of reasoning as factual, the lawyers must know that no permits have been issued, all applications have been denied. If not then NJ could present a case where a carry permit was granted and have done with the facial challenge. This seems so obvious to me that I really can't believe any carry permits have been issued post McDonald (to joe or jane citizen). I know the context of the Heller decision regarding "the core lawful purpose of self-defense" was "in the home", however the NJ law as is would violate that judgment of the SCOTUS. For if as SCOTUS has ruled that self-defense is a core lawful purpose, then self-defense is a pure, unquestionable "need" that is valid on its face. So by never approving permits with self-defense as the stated need, NJ law violates the second amendment.
  16. What would be NJ's best defense against the SAF suit? Since its a facial challenge, all the state has to do is just prove one time that their rules are necessary. Could any of us think of any scenario where NJ's justifiable need is necessary? I believe the OP's premise is faulty, in that the defendant (NJ) must show one example where the law is LEGAL, not where it is "necessary". But to answer the question, I believe they could show a case where an ordinary citizen's carry permit was approved... if any have been. Having said this, the legal team prosecuting this case against NJ surely will have done research into the pool of applications submitted, approved, and denied. They surely must know that a total of ZERO applications have been approved (perhaps since McDonald), and thus this argument by NJ cannot be made successfully. Other arguments which would support the current law both in fact and as applied would not seem capable of standing as legal. The arguments all depend on denying an enumerated constitutional right under certain circumstances. Strict scrutiny is the standard usually applied to such rights, and require a compelling state need, and be tailored to meet that need as narrowly as possible. It is my personal non-lawyer opinion that neither test can be met by the state, one because there is simply no evidence in the long history of modern carry in the USA that carry increases crime or violence. Secondly because the law is not narrowly tailed, in fact is is so broad as to deny the right to everyone who would exercise their right. Now let me twist this in another direction: If NJ was magically a pro-gun rights state, or even say moderately positive or neutral, then the CLEOS and the judges might approve the applications, and there'd be a normal distribution of carry permits issued, say anywhere between 2-4% of population in NJ. Then while the law itself might still be unconstitutional/illegal, the facial challenge would probably fail, but as-applied would succeed. It might make NJ look a lot like California, where county sheriffs have discretion and only the accident of geography affects your right to carry.
  17. I've donated to but never joined a gun rights organization before. On the strength of this suit, viewing it as REAL HELP for NJ citizens, I have become a lifetime member of SAF. It's so easy for the state capitol to pass new laws in record time where politically expedient. Some would argue (probably correctly) that the state will fight with everything the taxpayers have to retain their laws which violate the bill of rights. For this reason alone funding is needed. But maybe this suit and the rest to come will provide the violators with political cover to move with great speed to rewrite the laws. Not just for carry but for general compliance with the constitutionally required notion of liberty: Carry in public in non-sensitive places Scrap the handgun permit system and OGAM Scrap ammo restrictions including hollow-points Scrap the so-called AWB and 15 round arbitrary limit Scrap gun transport travel restrictions Yes, it's a good day, and a good week for a thanksgiving
  18. +1 on the bore snake, I use them at the range just before packing up. Lots of people use breakfree CLP, I find it very convenient and without heavy odor. Proper size patches, Q-tips. The Hoppes kit has a good selection of cleaning rod tips (jags) of plastic, you may want to get some brass ones. Tetra Gun makes very good synthetic oil and grease. But you can use any of the well known brands for cleaning and for lubing. You might also want to get polymer safe gun scrubber, you can use it to occasionally degrease and clean out the insides after a lot of rounds. I don't use it often though. A gun cleaning pad with a rubberized back is good for keeping surfaces free of debris, oil, etc. Congrats on your first pistol, I wanted one of those FNP-9s but could not get past the 16 rounds thing (mag block issue). Be safe and have fun!
  19. Stretching the topic a little, is there any 2sum package in 9mm which would stay 15 rounds or less, for NJ purposes? Indeed, good OGAM and also Handgun PP concept, burn just one permit for a single handgun by law. And actually it is because the parts cannot be used to create an additional gun. Kinda like an LCP in there being an aluminum sub-frame with serial number. The rest of it is just parts, including the "grip frame" of polymer. But much cooler : )
  20. "If you ever got stopped in NJ and the cops learn about guns in the car and you're headed towards PA, your destination was a shooting range, right? Also legal if you have a hunting license. " It's true that the strict legality of FOPA protection with regards to transport for carry to PA or for that matter FL has been discussed numerous times here. But the point I am raising has been pretty much lost for whatever reason. I'm just going to point out that our own State Police website specifically states that having a hunting license for your destination state "effectively supplies the proof" of the legality of your possession of a gun in that destination state. The proof required is not specifically a hunting license. All the web site states is that proof is required, and offers a hunting license as one example only. A valid carry license for the destination state also "effectively supplies the proof". Here is the link and the relevant quote in the hollow-point transportation page. It addresses the legality under federal law and what is required for firearms not just hollow points: http://www.njsp.org/about/fire_hollow.html Addressing the manner of transport only, requiring that manner of transport to meet US and NJ law, not why you are transporting even though the example given is the very common sport of hunting: "If the sportsman's club member plans to hunt with a rifle and use hollow nose ammunition in a state where this is permitted, he must comply with the provisions of U.S.C.A. 926A and N.J.S.A 2C:39-6(f) and (6)(g), which is consistent with the federal law, in transporting the firearm and ammunition. The firearm should be unloaded and neither the firearm nor the ammunition should be readily accessible from the passenger compartment. If the vehicle does not have a trunk, the firearm and the ammunition should be contained in a locked container other than the glove compartment or the console. 18 U.S.C.A. 926A." Addressing the NJ resident traveling to another state with a firearm for a legal purpose, in this specific example, hunting. Note that they specifically call out NJ law when discussing hunting in NJ, but call out federal law when discussing hunting in another state: "In addition, the sportsman should have a valid hunting license in his possession from the state in which he plans to hunt and should be familiar with that state's gun laws. N.J.S.A 2C:39-6(f)(2) requires a person hunting in this State to have a valid hunting license in his possession while traveling to or from the hunting area. Hunting with hollow nose ammunition is permitted in New Jersey. In the case of a New Jersey resident traveling to another state to hunt, it logically would follow that the hunting license would be from the state where the hunter is going. Although the federal statute does not require possession of a hunting license, it does require that the person transporting the firearm be going to a state where possession of that object is lawful. A valid hunting license from that state effectively supplies the proof." I'm not a lawyer, and this is what I personally believe. The FOPA requires that one's possession be legal in starting and ending states. I won't go into the starting state because that's not specifically talked about in the NJSP web page. But they do address the destination states, and do so by referencing the federal FOPA statute. It's not likely to happen to me personally. But if I were stopped outside of PA range hours in NJ going to PA, and an NJ LEO somehow asked and I needed to answer, I'd make the simple point: My FL carry license makes possession of my handgun in my destination state 100% legal. My possession of my handgun is legal in NJ, and therefore under federal statute I am protected from NJ law. Doesn't mean I would not have to prove this in court at my expense, but there it is.
  21. http://www.dixiegunworks.com/product_info.php?cPath=22_125&products_id=1043 I kind of like it. Maybe I'll buy one someday when I move to the United States. I'd never burn a handgun permit on this, but even if I could, I wouldn't want any of our FFLs to pop a lung from laughing.
  22. So many observations to make, many or all of which have been discussed in other threads, but I'll just comment: The lack of consistency in permitting procedure across the state is out of control. Misinformation, not necessarily intentionally, being presented as factual or based on statute or case law. When in fact, it's a misinterpretation of what a town PD's role is in the process, and indicates a lack of leadership and direction. I place this fault squarely at the feet of the attorney general, the top law-enforcement officer in the state, for not providing, distributing, or enforcing uniform processes. If I were the AG, I'd be ashamed. As far as individual police officers doing the processing, I cannot fault them for doing their best as they see it. But that's the problem, they have no guidance, or insufficient guidance, so it falls upon their possibly limited understating of the law. Yes, a professional LEO who is unsure should ask, but as in corporate workplaces I am familiar with, there can be consequences for opening up one's mouth. Sucks all around, I guess.
  23. Filed on July 20th, still waiting. Though if past experience holds, I should be seeing them soon. I went down there and had a quick face-to-face with the detective a week ago. In the past that seemed to make the process go quicker, maybe they feel more comfortable once they see you in person.
  24. How about some respect or courtesy? If I was providing a service and someone is being a dick and acting like he's god's gift to firearms then I'd smile, remain courteous throughout the process, then put that app right in the bottom of the pile. "F-him. Who does he think he is?" I really think people respond better to kindness...but hey, that's just me... Dick or not, due process and equal protection of law applies to everyone. So by dropping their app to the bottom of the pile, you would be violating the applicant's rights. I see no difference between this hypothetical retaliatory action and that of self-aggrandizing bureaucrats who delay processing just because they think ordinary people should not be allowed to own or carry weapons.
  25. Lost my best buddy three years ago myself, sorry for your loss. May the pain dissolve leaving only good memories of Sandy in your heart.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.