Everything posted by BigHayden
-
Open Carrier Shot And Killed When Gun Taken By Thug
Just to play a little Devil's Advocate of my own, what's to stop some bad guy from seeing a uniformed cop OCing, walking up to them, and putting a bullet in the back of their head so they can grab that shiny new gun out of the holster?? What makes it a stupid thing for us to do, but sensible for a cop? This moron had his gun taken away from him and shot with it because he was in condition white. He had no situational awareness. When you carry, concealed or open, you need to have a heightened level of SA; even more so when you carry open. Your head needs to be on a swivel. You need to be aware of who is behind you so something like this doesn't happen to you. Open carry isn't a stupid thing to do. Being a sheep while open carrying, on the other hand, is a great way to have yourself removed from the gene pool.
-
Weapon transport
That's the basis of the ANJRPC's lawsuit over OGAM... Speaking of that suit, has anybody else heard any updates? ANJRPC isn't exactly known for timely dissemination of information.
-
TSA saves us again
You and me both. I used to love to fly. It really is one of the best ways to travel. But ever since the inception of the TSA, I absolutely refuse to board an airplane until that security theater agency is disbanded. I work for the FAA, so you can imagine the looks I get when I tell people that I won't fly.
-
1911 Swap Possibilities/Suggestiions
All three of these are easy to replace. The disconnector and slide stop should be drop-in, and the thumb safety requires a little fitting, but you can do it yourself if you take your time and understand what you're trying to accomplish with the file before you begin. I'm still going through my Kimber Compact Stainless II and I'm replacing all the MIM and plastic (yes, Kimber uses plastic on some of their 1911s) stuff with higher quality pieces. So far I've done (from Wilson Combat) a round butt mainspring housing, Bullet Proof mag release, and Bullet Proof guide rod (removed the FGR), along with (from Ed Brown) single side thumb safety, slide stop, and memory bump grip safety. I haven't gone through and replaced the trigger stuff yet, but I think I may do either Ed Brown or C&S stuff (sear, sear spring, disconnector, hammer). I've also replaced the sights with Trijicons, the trigger with a solid aluminum piece (medium length of pull), and the grips with slim cocobolos. By the time I'm done, the only things Kimber on the gun will be the frame, slide, and barrel.
-
Guess the repair Bill! (Anastasia was rear ended)
Wow, you guys who are guessing under $3000 haven't been to a body shop lately, have you? The situation with my wife's van was just a scrape. Minor plastic filler and paint and the bill was over $700. This repair needs more than that, plus parts.
-
Guess the repair Bill! (Anastasia was rear ended)
My wife's minivan had a scrape that was repaired on the front facia. The total? Over $700. Body work is expen$ive, so I'd say the estimates of $4K+ are pretty much on. I had a Mazda3 that got hit in the front a few years back. Everyone said it was repairable, including the body shop. When the priced out the parts, the damage was over $12,000. I got a check for $16,000 to pay off the loan and go get a new car.
-
Walther PPQ
Is the doily grip standard, or is that an option?
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
I guess it's less that I missed the point and more that you suck at teh examples. I did go back and read your scenario again, and if you look at the letter of the law, it does not say that you are exempt if you're transporting between your residences while moving, but it says between residences/businesses. The distinction is actually clear, because in the first part of the section it says "his ... residence". I get what you were trying to say, but I'm not sure how it could've been worded better. Either way, I'm done beating this horse too.
-
Kimber Custom Aegis II
I have an EMP that I picked up December '09 and it's been wonderful. Shoots better than I can and I think it's pretty reliable. The first time I shot it was during a handgun class at SJSC in March of 2010. I brought the gun unfired to the class and ran 175 rounds through it on a misty, cold day and didn't have any failures with the gun. I've since run another 200 rounds though it and again, no problems. I've heard some horror stories with the EMPs, but they do seem to be pretty few and far between. Mine is definitely a keeper. ETA: Pretty Kimber, BTW!
-
question about selling my two gen3 Glock 19s in NJ...
If anybody backs out, I might be interested in one of those G19s. PM me if you lose a buyer.
-
What's your reliability round count?
Keep in mind that a gun might be reliable for > 1K rounds of ball ammo and choke on the first magazine of JHPs (think some 1911's with big open hollow points). You may need to have 2 separate round counts to determine if a gun is reliable.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
I don't think I did. The law says you can transport your gun between residences when moving; it does not specify that it has to be your residence. If you move to NJ and have your guns stored at someone's house in PA, when you bring them into the state you are covered under the "moving" portion of the exemptions, so FOPA wouldn't have to apply.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
I don't think anybody was really talking about states other than the state of origin, i.e. a NJ resident, still in NJ but heading out of state. Which law(s) apply and what protection are you afforded? I, for one, made a mistake in my argument by not reading the actual text of FOPA. And Bonesinium, here is the text from the law: I think the "moving" exemption is pretty clearly spelled out. I didn't read the text of FOPA, but I do know the exemption list for in the state.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
There is a specific exemption for moving. You're good to go under NJ law.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
OK, moment of clarity (sort of). I was under the impression that FOPA said "state" (it helps to read the law sometimes). The fact that it says "place" changes the scope enough to where I believe that Vlad's interpretation is correct. I'm still not convinced that there is no risk of landing in legal hot water due to an ignorant cop and an overzealous prosecutor. Hell, you might even win a case based on FOPA, but you'd go bankrupt doing it. So I still say be cautious and avoid any encounters with LEO just to be sure.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
Yeah, what he said.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
Paul, Do you agree that a law governing interstate travel does not apply until you actually leave the state where your journey originates? FOPA very clearly says that you have to be legal in the state where you originate your journey. The grey area exists because firearms possession in NJ is illegal unless you have a PTC or fall into one of the exceptions, which includes your home. Vlad is arguing that you are legal under FOPA because your journey originates from your home, where you are legal to possess a firearm, therefore you are legal in your state of origin. The alternate argument that Dan, malsua, and I have made is that once you leave your home, and you're not heading to one of the specified legal exemptions in NJ law, then you are not legal to possess your firearm in NJ and, not only are you breaking NJ law, but are also not protected by FOPA since it only applies if you legally possess your firearm in the state where your interstate travel originates. Personally, I get both arguments, and even if Vlad is wrong, it wouldn't stop me from taking my guns out of state because that would just be ridiculous to the Nth degree. But just because it's ridiculous doesn't mean it's legal.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
I think, ultimately, we're on the same page.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
You say my statement is "grossly paranoid".... From State vs Valentine, 1973: Doesn't sound like I'm being paranoid at all. I'm just repeating jurisprudence in NJ.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
From State vs Pelleteri, 1996 Not the kind of people I want to take my chances in front of... The difference between you and me is that you see this issue as black and white, while I see a lot of almost black, almost white, but definitely grey. I'm not suggesting that nobody in NJ should be afraid to take their guns out of state, but I do believe that all of us need to be aware that anytime we do anything with a gun in NJ we are acting "at [our] peril", and that the system is setup to presume guilt when it comes to firearms. That is a statement of fact, not a belief. Is it a huge risk? That's for each of us to decide. But to suggest that there is no risk at all is
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
But a prosecutor trying to make a name for him/herself could argue against those points successfully. Look at Brian Aitken. He was satisfying the NJ exemptions and still landed in jail for 8 years. NJ law doesn't restrict transportation out of state, but it does spell out very clearly where gun ownership is legal (i.e. the exemptions) and where it isn't (i.e. everywhere else), and FOPA only covers you if your "legal in the state of origin", which you are until you leave your house. Is it your contention that the airlines (and perhaps more laughably, the TSA) are all experts on NJ and federal firearms laws? And all of your examples fall into the same category as this: How many drug dealers carry guns on Camden's streets and don't get stopped and arrested? If they do it, it must be legal, right? The more appropriate question would be, How many people have been stopped by police doing one of the things you described, and were let go by police because of FOPA or NJ law? I would argue that none have been stopped, but that doesn't mean what they were doing is legal under NJ law. Don't get me wrong, I'm not contesting your logic, but I think you're overlooking the fact that all NJ firearms laws are designed to ensnare law abiding people so as to discourage gun ownership as much as possible without completely banning possession. The fact that threads like this exist suggests they are fulfilling their stated task beautifully. To correct a post from earlier, it was actually a judge that said "When it comes to firearms in NJ, the citizen acts at his own peril".
-
No CCW Review by the Supreme Court
Actually, I was kidding. Maybe they are waiting to see if there will be a split in the lower courts. I'm actually kind of surprised they didn't want to smack down all the lower courts that have twisted the Ruling in Heller.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
Vlad, I know I'm jumping in this late, but I had to comment about FOPA. It says 'if possession in the origin state is legal' (I'm on my iPhone, so I can't see the exact wording), then you're covered. The grey area comes from the fact that firearms possession is illegal in NJ unless you fall into one of the specific exemptions, which do include your home. But, the minute you leave your home and are not heading to a range/gun store/place of business/etc, you are technically not legal in the state of origin and would not be covered under FOPA in any state along the way. Is it stupid? Absolutely. But as Mark pointed out, there is no court precedence for this, so we don't have anything legal to stand on. Maybe the trooper you talked to has some common sense (which dictates that yes, we should be able to leave the state with a firearm), but maybe the one that stops one of us won't have any. Same goes for the prosecutor. Our definition of common sense and an anti's definition are two different things, and too many antis are in positions of power in the Soprano State. I'm with you, I would make the argument that I'm covered under FOPA, but that argument would have to be made in front of a judge, who is also likely an anti. There are no guarantees in the legal world, even if the outcome should be logical. Maybe you're right and FOPA applies. Maybe you're wrong and Loretta Weinberg's interpretation of states rights is correct when it comes to firearms laws (I know she's not, but I'm trying to illustrate a point). The fact remains that FOPA is not 100% clear, and NJ laws suck and are designed to be open to interpretation (see the "substantially identical" phrase in the NJAWB. Those two things together put gun owners in a precarious legal predicament. I can see both sides. But I bet we can all agree that the laws suck and need to change.
-
No CCW Review by the Supreme Court
They are waiting for Muller vs Maenza...
-
Bryan Miller nervous of National CCW
While there is no reasoning with the PuSHers, it's certainly entertaining to watch them squirm at the thought of their oppression being overturned.