Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

BigHayden

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by BigHayden

  1. Seriously? Instead of the feds stepping in and saying "every state needs to recognize every other state's CCW licenses" you'd rather have, what, what we have now? Where states get into pissing contests over whose training is better, and "we won't honor your permit because you only require 22 hours of training while we require a far superior 22.5 hours". If NJ does go shall-issue and we don't have national reciprocity, we won't have reciprocal agreements with any other states because it's up to the states' AGs to enter them, and our permit won't be good anywhere but here. Our current AG doesn't think you can carry at all, do you honestly believe that she (or any like her) would actively seek out agreements with other states? National reciprocity fixes that, short of national constitutional carry (which should be our ultimate goal, btw).
  2. There isn't a large collective group of people actively seeking to deny carry licenses to the public either. There is a small group of big government liberals who can be classified that way, along with the sheep who follow them believing that rainbow farting unicorns (we really need that as a smiley...) will make everyone peaceful if we could only stop those gun nuts from having easy access to guns. If the anti side was made up of such a huge portion of the public, why does the NRA have 4,000,000 members and the Brady Campaign have ~50,000? Hell, there are actually more gun owners in NJ than members of the Brady Campaign nationwide. That's not to discount the threat to our rights by those who are positions of power, that have oodles of money to throw at it, or both (Bloomberg), but even Lautenmummy has recently said that full on gun control measures are politically impossible. That says a lot right there.
  3. http://pbblocker.com/ I listen to Cope's podcast and, although he's totally a Glock fanboy, he seems to know what he's talking about. Pb Blocker is his creation and he developed it to shoot lead ammo in stock Glock barrels. I'm not affiliated with anyone/anything to do with Cope Reynolds, SWSA, or Pb Blocker, but I figured it was worth mentioning to everyone.
  4. Funny, we don't have the same concerns about federal regulation on driving. The bill in question just says that all states have to recognize each others' permits like they do drivers licenses and marriage licenses. Full faith and credit. The bill does not add any type of federal authority over anything; it just requires the states to recognize licenses from other states. I'm as skeptical of goverment intentions as anyone, but this one really is a good bill (even if it doesn't really help us) if you read it.
  5. That's exactly why they were included in 1934 NFA. The hypocrisy of the government is epic. Suppressor for your gun? BAD! EVIL! TOOL OF ASSASSINS!!!!! Suppressor for your car (i.e. muffler)? Absolutely must have one or you will be fined and/or have your car confiscated. For the record, I don't believe a suppressor has been used in a poaching crime in almost 100 years...
  6. You can't buy a 9mm pistol in PA and just ship it to your house in NJ because federal law prohibits purchasing a handgun in another state without transferring through an FFL in your state, period. A BB pistol is different because it's not a firearm, period. Here's another example of perfectly legal activity. I can purchase 30 round AR magazines in PA legally, as a NJ resident. If I modify them to hold 15 rounds before I enter the state, they are legal. Agreed? If your logic held, it would be illegal for me to purchase the magazines in PA because it's illegal to possess them in NJ. How is your example different? The only difference is in your example, the moving exception would kick in and allow you to personally transport it in your car to your home in NJ. In my example, traveling with the BB gun could be illegal (most likely would be, but you could make a case that you're transporting it from the store to your home, so maybe you could argue that), but shipping it would not be. I'll echo what PK90 said, what laws are broken by purchasing a BB gun in PA and shipping it to yourself in NJ?
  7. Agree 100%. But the illegal possession charge has an exemption for your home. Shipping it to yourself from another state gets it to your home without breaking ANY law, NJ or otherwise. There is no "bashing" of state and federal laws. It's following them to the letter. As a NJ resident, I have to have a HPP for each handgun transferred to me in the state. If I buy a handgun (a real one) in PA, it has to be shipped to an FFL in NJ. The PA dealer doesn't give a sh*t if I have a permit or not; that's the NJ FFL's problem. It's just like buying a gun off of gunbroker.com. I don't have to prove that I have an HPP in NJ for it. They sell it to me and ship it. I can't take possession of it (i.e. transfer) without said HPP, but that all gets handled in NJ. Federal law says BB guns are not firearms, period. NJ law technically runs afoul of that statute, but that's another issue. In every other state, it's not a firearm so the "dealer" doesn't have to follow the laws of the purchaser's state. It's not a regulated item. Once I own it, it's mine. I don't need a permit to transfer it to me because it's mine. I agree that you can't drive it back to your house from another state. We've argued this point endlessly regarding bringing a pistol to another state to carry it for self defense. The general consensus is that FOPA will protect you, or it's plain illegal. Nobody has made any other arguments over the legality. In this case, FOPA will not protect you, since BB guns are not firearms in the fed's mind. So that leaves "it's plain illegal". But, NJ has no jurisdiction over the mail and common carriers. We all agree that we can order handgun ammo online and have it shipped to our homes without showing an FPID (some places do require this, like Midway USA, but I believe they are hyper-cautious), even though NJ requires the seller to log the purchase and see a valid FPID. There are no regulations in the common carriers for BB guns, as far as I know (someone will correct me, I have faith in the naysayers...) so it would be perfectly legal for me to ship a BB gun to myself. I will add the caveat that nobody else can ship me a BB gun, as this would be a "transfer" in NJ, but if I legally own it and ship it to myself, there's no law broken.
  8. Not true. If I ship it to myself, I had possession before I entered the state. Take this example. Say I'm driving to Alaska. I'm legal to have a handgun here, and I'm legal to have a handgun in AK, but I can't drive through Canada with it. I can ship that gun to myself in AK and it's perfectly legal, since, according to firearms laws (and the ATF) I already owned the gun and "possessed" it in NJ, so there's no transfer of ownership. Go back to that case of the guy who lived in Arizona (was a resident there and in NJ...) and he bought a gun there. It was legal for him to bring it back to NJ when he was traveling between his residences, but he didn't need a HPP to go with it. Same would hold true for a BB pistol. If I buy it legally somewhere else, it's mine by all accounts. Then the question becomes transporting it legally home. I say you can't do it if you aren't actually moving from another state to NJ (the moving exception) or if you don't have dual residences (like the guy from AZ). Since BB pistols aren't firearms in federal law, FOPA doesn't protect you, but that also makes it legal to ship it to yourself without overnighting it. The more I argue this point, the more I think it's perfectly legal.
  9. If I buy a BB pistol in PA (a legal transaction) and ship it to my home (also legal, since BB pistols are NOT firearms by definition, and remain legal to ship), I'm not "taking posession" of it in NJ, so I don't need a HPP for it. I argue that I haven't broken any laws, anywhere.
  10. The purpose of this thread is to spark some debate and get peoples' minds moving. The guys over at CalGuns are always coming up with interesting ways to circumvent the "stoopid" laws in CA while remaining 100% legal, i.e. the bullet button. My hypothetical has nothing to do with that, but more of a "could they charge you with XYZ if..." BB guns are classified as firearms in PRNJ. Long gun BB guns are no big deal, especially if you already have an FPID, but BB pistols require a HPP. The rest of the country treats BB guns as toys, and require no ID to purchase. Since HPPs are permits to purchase, and not to own, is there anything NJ can charge you with if you purchase a BB pistol in PA and bring it here to NJ? I'll throw it out there that I don't think there's a damn thing they could do about it, unless they catch you transporting it home. The trick is getting it home legally. This is a new take on the whole "transportation exceptions" in NJ firearms laws and FOPA will not protect you, since BB pistols are not firearms. The only way you'd be legal to transport it, and fall under the exceptions, would be if you are moving to NJ from out of state. I also believe if you shipped it to yourself, you'd be legal. NJ law bars you from taking possession of it without an HPP, but if you shipped it to yourself, you already had possession (Federal laws on firearms allow you to ship handguns to yourself without having to go through an FFL, so there is precedence), so you're not breaking NJ law. I don't believe there are any laws/rules against shipping BB guns through the major carriers (UPS, FedEx, USPS even?). Thoughts? Agree, disagree?
  11. It's obvious. They are there so you can screw two guns together. =@
  12. Do you think he will grant the motion to dismiss, or that he will rule in favor of the State? Not that it makes a difference, because an appeal will be filed post haste, but I'm curious what everybody thinks will happen. BTW, Dow didn't personally write any of the state's briefs.
  13. Only retired LEO are excluded from that count, since they don't have to provide "justifiable need". Armored car personnel and private security (executive protection) are the majority of those ~1K permits, and they do have to have "justifiable need".
  14. Page 11, post #206 has NJ's latest reply. There was at least a page of discussion of the content after that post. That will be the last volley at this level; it's in the judge's hands now. Ruling is expected by September. Appeals are expected to follow.
  15. His character in Pulp Fiction was Jules Winnfield.
  16. To quote the great Jules Winnfield, "English, motherf*cker, do you speak it?!?"
  17. None? Hell son, we went backward on the 1st anniversary of the Heller decision! That's the day OGAM passed. To be honest, we're worse off now than we were before the Heller case even started. I hate this state.
  18. I got the exact same impression when I read it the first time. They seem to focus on the stronger parts of their arguments in this brief. Of course, their strongest argument is that Heller defined the right as the right to a handgun inside the home, which, as much as they would like that to be the case, the relief that was granted to Heller was not the holding of the court. The court held that the second protects an individual right to keep and bear arms, and that D.C.'s ban (which, incidentally was also a "regulation, not a prohibition", as NJ keeps reiterating) on handguns in the home was in violation of that right. That, and they seem to think that if they declare the statute constitutional enough times, it will automatically become so. Sort of like saying "Beetlejuice" 3 times. "It's constitutional. It's constitutional. It's constitutional." The other fallacy they keep harping on is that there is no case law beyond Heller that extends Heller beyond the home. That's a bit like defending segregation before Brown vs. Board of Education. They don't seem to understand that sometimes jurisprudence doesn't exist and needs to be built through new cases. By their argument, McDonald should not have incorporated the 2A against the states because it hadn't been done since Heller (though, I'm not entirely sure they didn't believe that...).
  19. That's the next step. It gets into a judges hand and the feeling is that we'll have a ruling by September. ANJRPC keeps cautioning though, no matter what the outcome, appeals are expected. What does that mean for us? If the ruling goes our way, and NJ appeals it, they'll be granted a TRO against the lower court ruling, so nothing changes until no more appeals happen. If you're impatient, you're hoping the ruling goes our way and no appeals are made (remember Christie saying he doesn't want to fight Obamacare because the state doesn't have the money? Perhaps he can be persuaded to do the same here...), we could potentially be obtaining carry permits by Christmas. This is pie in the sky thinking though. If you're looking at this as a long game, you want to see the appeals right up to SCOTUS, since this will help the most people (i.e. MD, NY, DE, RI, MA, CA, HI). We've been denied our right to carry for decades; I think another 2-3 years of waiting is a worthwhile trade to get carry recognized as a right for everyone.
  20. When the decision from this case gets appealed to the 3rd Circuit. Briefs are the arguments for this round. Gut feeling is that this one gets ruled against us and appealed up. Only one more stop between this case and SCOTUS, and I think this one has the legs to make it that far. It's been interesting, to say the very least.
  21. I'd give up a few dollars, and donuts, to help Fred Madden find a new line of work... Any word on his [potential] opponent yet?
  22. Thanks for the updates guys. As soon as the info is available, please post up the links. So far, everything's been a good read (even the bad NJ responses...).
  23. I'm certainly not speaking with any experience or authority, but FWIW the guy who runs NJCSD says "we're in good hands" with Jensen. Any word on NJ's latest response? Their 3 day extension is up, right?

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.