Everything posted by BigHayden
-
Poll for whether teachers should be permitted CCW
Funny, we don't have to demonstrate proficiency with any of our other rights before we're "allowed" to exercise them. Are you aware that the accident rates among CCW holders in states that have a training requirement are no different than those who have no training requirement at all? This fact alone is proof that required training or not, concealed carry holders are among the most responsible people in society. Getting training is the responsible thing to do, however, if the Government requires it, it's no longer a right but a privilege to be granted by the state.
-
Poll for whether teachers should be permitted CCW
Doesn't that hold true regardless of the firearm carrier's occupation? You're saying that anyone who wants to carry a gun should be trained, and I agree with you. But I don't think they need any special training that would differ from anyone else who wants to carry. Again, I don't think there should be any kind of government mandated training, but getting training is the responsible thing to do. If 99% of teachers aren't carrying, it wouldn't be a very effective plan to "aquire the Teacher's gun." They have a 99% chance of getting it wrong. If the plan is to get the gun from the teacher and then kill people, that isn't a very good plan. If they are planning to kill the teacher first because they might be armed, how does that make the situation any different from if they know that the teacher isn't armed? What "more training" would they need that anybody else who is going to carry a gun does not? Agreed 100%. I'm certainly not upset/angry over this. I'm asking questions to either get you to convince me I'm wrong or so that you might see the error in your view. I believe this thread has been civil and will remain that way even as we disagree. Your property taxes pay for the police force, and they can be sued for shooting someone accidentally. I don't believe that anyone is suggesting we hand out guns to teachers who aren't willing to take the responsibility seriously. When we talk about allowing teachers/faculty to carry in schools, we're talking about responsible gun owners, like all of us. How on earth did you jump to that conclusion? Allowing anybody to carry does not imply that they are to be relied on as security guards. Not sure where you got that idea either... First post said: I don't see anything in there about using teachers to keep the school safe, it was a simple poll about letting adults who work in the school carry on the job.
-
Poll for whether teachers should be permitted CCW
Care to elaborate, or is this one of those "Because I said so!" things? I think there's a bit of a disconnect in your logic. You are claiming that a teacher carrying would be a more likely target for someone to take a weapon from, but I would argue that 99% of teachers would never carry, even if given the option. So would you also suggest that those 99% of teachers would have to be required to take hand-to-hand combat training in the event that somebody thinks they have a gun and they really don't? It occurs to me that the anti's always claim that our guns will be taken from us and used against us, but I don't read about that happening very often. As for the lawsuits? They say that every bullet has a lawyer attached to it, so the risk is no different that if you defend yourself in an apartment and a stray round hits the kid sleeping in the next apartment. Rule 4 applies to everyone who pulls the trigger in defense of their lives, regardless of occupation or location.
-
Poll for whether teachers should be permitted CCW
Not to start a flame war, but I'm interested in the reasoning behind some of you comments. So are you against anyone carrying a gun a public place? "Crowds" can be substituted for the word "kids" and the same thing holds true. And don't you agree that anyone, not just teachers, should get training before carrying a firearm in public at all? I'm not advocating government mandatory training, but as Uncle Owen said, "With great power comes great responsibility." We already have outrage from the anti's about anybody who carries in public. Why should anyone, including teachers, give up their rights to quell the outrage from people who are uncomfortable with others exercising those rights? I don't think anybody is suggesting that teachers should be forced to carry a firearm while on the job. Anyone who has the mindset to carry a gun will go get whatever training they think they need. I would submit that most teachers that you know would never carry a gun at all, let alone on the job, so you can't use them as a fair example. You're also advocating, intentionally or not, for a police state by suggesting that the police should be the only ones allowed to carry in schools, and not giving the same option to all the adults in the same environment. Again, you're blurring the idea of permitting teachers to carry in schools with the idea that ALL teachers should be required to carry in schools.
-
NJ Pre-emption?
(Thanks to BRN169, I now know where to find this info) Clicky-clicky! NJ doesn't have pre-emption in the statutes, but it's been established through judicial ruling. Which basically means that it's only as good as the latest ruling.
-
McCarthy's Mag and Gun Ban Bill
Not to pat myself on the back, but did you read my letter to Andrews? I linked to it in the second post of this thread. It might give you some ideas on what to talk about.
-
THIS IS SICK
But you won't hear any calls for Doctor control laws, or abortion control laws from McCarthy or Lautenberg. This monster killed more people than the Tucson shooter and the anti-rights crowd won't have a thing to say about it.
-
McCarthy's Mag and Gun Ban Bill
Cemetery might not be a ball of sunshine, but both he and Sebastian have this one right. McCarthy's bill is written like ALL NJ firearms laws; declare an item as illegal, and then carve out an exception (in this case, the "grandfather-clause") for an affirmative defense. I don't think it's going to really go anywhere (and Cemetery, co-sponsors don't mean anything... somebody pointed out that AWB-2 had 80 co-sponsors and it went nowhere), but we all still need to contact our reps and express our outrage over this pointless infringement.
-
McCarthy's Mag and Gun Ban Bill
I know that I read in the Courier the other day that Andrews was signing on as a co-sponsor too, but reading the same article today doesn't say he did... I suspect the article was "tweaked" as of yesterday. :ph34r: I wrote to Andrews (mailed it on Saturday) urging him to oppose this bill. If anyone's interested, I posted a copy of my letter on NJCSD.org
-
McCarthy's Magazine Ban Bill
Uh, what part about the .22 rifles is incorrect?
-
McCarthy's Magazine Ban Bill
Sounds like it would exempt .22 tube fed rifles. Funny, some of those are considered "assault weapons" in NJ... It really aggravates me when these idiots write these bills and then exempt law enforcement. Why? If "large capacity ammunition feeding devices" are so dangerous and cause otherwise normal people to go crazy and go on murderous rampages, why exempt law enforcement? (Rhetorical questions, guys. Not really looking for an explanation of the unexplainable) Even her little explanation letter is chock full of bull-plop. First, she acknowledges that we have the right to keep and bear arms, but then she goes on to say it can be restricted. She justifies this by trotting out the tired old yelling "Fire" in a crowded theater is a "practical limit" on free speech. This is the worst comparison I've ever read. It's actually perfectly legal to yell "FIRE!" in a crowded theater if, in fact, there actually is a fire. You will not be charged with a crime for doing so. Also, when you enter the theater, you still retain the capacity to yell "Fire!" and can only be punished for using your voice to incite panic. This means you can be punished for abusing your 1st amendment right. McCarthy's bill infringes on your 2nd amendment right before you have a chance to abuse it. Then she claims, being the firearms expert she is, that the only reason (not one reason, not "a" reason, but the absolute only reason) these magazines exist is to "be able to shoot as many people as possible as quickly as possible". She says there is no reason for these to be available to the "general public". Now, couple those two claims with the fact that she wants to exempt law enforcement and one can logically conclude that Congresswoman McCarthy wants to make it possible for the police to shoot as many people as possible as quickly as possible. (Another rhetorical question: Can this be construed as a terroristic threat against the American public?) And the icing on the cake has to be this gem: "It is a sad fact of reality that we will never be able to prevent every instance of gun violence. We also will not be able to keep these large capacity magazines out of the hands of every criminal who would use them." She admits, in black and white, that her bill will not prevent anyone from getting shot, nor will this do anything to keep hi-caps out of the hands of criminals, which is, ostensibly, the entire purpose of the bill. Tomorrow, I am going to print a copy of Congresscritter McCarthy's summary letter and write a rebuttal letter to send to my Congressional moron (Andrews, D-1) urging him NOT to support this legislation (though I might already be too late.. he might already be a co-sponsor). I'll be curious to see if he even bothers to respond. I'll keep you guys posted.
-
Christie has no opinion on concealed carry
I've never shot either one (I'm more of a handgun guy, but I did buy an AR just in case a few years ago; guess it's time to break that sucker in, eh?), but I'm with you on the AK... Ah crap, I'm agreeing with you again. Seriously though, you do make a lot of good points, including that right now money/taxes is higher on people's priority list than guns in NJ right now.
-
Christie has no opinion on concealed carry
I'm finding myself agreeing with Vlad a lot lately.
-
Transporting a firearm to a range in another state
I didn't say anything about a false name. I believe in almost every state in the union you are required to identify yourself to law enforcement, but most times you aren't required to actually show ID. I simply said it's not a crime to lie to them when they ask you questions. And if it is, I want to see the statute.
-
Transporting a firearm to a range in another state
I have to call BS on this one. I don't believe anywhere in NJ law does it say you cannot lie to the police. In fact, in my Utah CCW class, the instructor told us we should lie to the police in NJ if they ever ask the question, "Do you have any firearms in the car?", since lying to the police isn't a crime. And in the event that I'm wrong, please post the actual law that states that not only is it a crime, but what the punishment is for violating it.
-
Authorization to Transport Handgun to a Range
Actually Vlad, I tend to lean the same way you do. He had a magazine of illegal capacity in NJ... he was wrong and got caught, so he deserved the serve the time for that particular violation. The 7 years he was sentenced to was for illegal possession of a handgun. He should have been covered by the moving exemption under 2C:39-6, but the judge instructed the jury to apply 2C:39-5 to this case, and failed to inform them of the exemption. BTW, the firearm itself wasn't illegal, only the magazine(s). That same exemption is what "permits" us to possess handguns in our homes and to transport them to/from the range, etc. If that exemption is disallowed by a judge, then we all could find ourselves in the same predicament as Brian, even if we don't have evil assault weapons. Brian Aitken is not exactly the poster child we want for highlighting the absurdity of NJ firearms laws, since he did legitimately break NJ law by possessing "high capacity magazines". If it weren't for that little burr under the saddle, he'd be the NJ version of Dick Heller.
-
spousal guns
And then she can't take them to the range without you being present. I hate this state.
-
leosa
How many of those "hassles" have ended in jail time?
-
Authorization to Transport Handgun to a Range
Well, your Creator gave you the right to transport your handgun anywhere you damn well please. The 2nd Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects that right. NJ law, 2C:39-5 effectively removes that right (unless you have a permit to carry, which is impossible, pending the SAF/ANJRPC lawsuit), and 2C:39-6 says you have an exemption to 2C:39-5 if you're transporting your handgun to/from the range from/to your home, as long as you do not make any stops along the way.
-
BB guns in PA
Actually, they'd probably nail you with violating 2C:39( b ) [or ( d ), not sure if BB guns as "firearms" classifies BB gun pistols as "handguns" or "other weapons"]. I don't think there's anything inherently illegal about buying a BB gun (rifle or handgun) in another state and transporting it back to NJ. (That's not to say you couldn't be arrested/charged with something...)
-
Choice of weapon for home defense - potential legalities
I have two words for you: Harold Fish And keep in mind, that was in Arizona, which isn't exactly an anti-gun state. You can't say is has no bearing, because it absolutely can. You can say that is should have no bearing, and I would agree, but reality demonstrates otherwise.
-
What could it be???
SR1911
-
leosa
Even if they aren't, LEO's get special treatment anyway. Do you really think you'd be charged/tried if you get caught with them? I remember a few years ago a PA cop lost his gun on a ride in Ocean City and some kid found it. There were never any charges for him... Do you think the rest of the serfs would have received the same treatment?
-
Bryan Miller on Brian Aitken's Commutation
I don't disagree with what you're saying. I just said what I was thinking. IANAL. I've heard that argument... Unfortunately, like djg0770 says, it doesn't matter what we say/think. It only matters what the prosecution thinks (unless we can get NJ's laws cleared up... then it wouldn't matter anymore).
-
NJ Senate Leader Sweeney seeks NJ Gun Law reform
Carroll is an Assemblyman. Sweeney is the Senate president. Different houses, though that's not to say he doesn't have any influence on what goes on in Sheila's house...