Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

BigHayden

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by BigHayden

  1. Actually, this is mostly ANJRPC's lawsuit. It's their lawyer, not SAF's. SAF is helping fund it and is providing some legal counsel, but the brief is ANJRPC's lawyer. I'm thoroughly impressed with it.
  2. I'm from South Jersey... I don't know all the places up north, so I just ASSumed it was someplace I hadn't heard of.
  3. I suppose I should've known better... a guy named njpilot using "TLA"s (Three Letter Acronyms, for the rest of you...) would be talking about an airport and not a beach resort. I work for the FAA, so I really should've known better. But to answer your actual question, I suppose that traveling to/from the airport should be covered by FOPA, just like driving to PA.
  4. If you were renting a property (or own property there), you are covered, as rentals are considered residences. Of course, if your case is heard by a judge like Morley, even that might not help you avoid the 7 year slam sentence.
  5. That's what I said could happen after I read the brief (posted over on NJCSD). And 3 years ago, when Heller was decided, I read that decision and predicted that because NJ doesn't differentiate between open and concealed carry, that would be the downfall of NJ's may-(not)-issue permit system. It's nice to see the lawyers eating this elephant one bite at a time.
  6. He's taking a page from Paul Helmke's playbook. The Brady Bunch has been pulling that crap a lot recently too.
  7. But that's just the thing... have you ever actually read the NJ law? Handgun possession is patently illegal unless you have a carry permit. That's what the law says. That's what Brian was convicted of. Yeah, there's the the whole next section which carves out exceptions for your home, business, the range, gun store/gunsmith, and traveling directly to/from those places, but what Bob posted is the text of 2C:39-5. The burden of proof is on you, the gun owner, to show that you are exempt under 2C:39-6; otherwise you are charged under 2C:39-5. I'll see if I can dig up the case law that supports that position. Just so we're clear, I don't think it's right. I'm just letting you know how the law gets applied. Technically, taking your gun to a friend's house is illegal possession under NJ law. Nowhere in 2C:39-6 does it say you can possess your gun at somebody else's house, nor does it exempt travel to/from your friend's house. If you get caught, like Brian did, you'll be facing the same 7 years he did. There's also a lot of debate about traveling to PA too, but I fall into the camp of that should be protected by FOPA. ETA: Found the case law. It's State vs. Dunlap http://www.leagle.com/xmlResult.aspx?xmldoc=1981252181NJSuper71_1241.xml&docbase=CSLWAR1-1950-1985 That guy was found to be violating 2C:39-3e (illegal possession of a gravity knife) and the court basically said that the law gives the defendant a way to argue that the knife was possessed for a lawful purpose, but that the presumption of guilt was A-OK with them.
  8. Actually, the article was pretty accurate and not nearly as one sided and some of the others I've read. The bit you highlighted about the carry permit is true. It's missing the bits about going to and from the range and a gun store/gunsmith, but otherwise I'm not sure why you seem to have your knickers in a twist...
  9. I don't think so. All you have to do is establish residency (NJ DL?). Not that it would have mattered in Mr. Aitken's case. NJ FPID only allows you to purchase long guns and handgun ammunition; it is not a permit to carry (which is required for handgun possession, unless you fit into one of the exceptions).
  10. Yeah, I see that now. I went back and looked at the Mossberg site; for some reason I thought the SPX came with a 5+1 mag tube (I was pretty sure I saw one at Dick's in Deptford that was marked "SPX"). Maybe they did come that way at one point? Meh, whatever. Stupid NJ firearms laws...
  11. Then explain to me why he was doing exactly that less than 24 hours before the rally was cancelled? Wrong, wrong, wrong! The press conference you're referring to took place on Dec. 9th, 2010. The e-mail from Brian Aitken to Frank was Dec. 6th, 2010.
  12. Riddle me this, Batman. If your client is in jail and you firmly believe that distancing yourself from 2nd amendment groups is the best thing to do, why on earth do you go on the only nationally syndicated radio program that caters to gun owners to talk about your case? I have a very hard time believing that Evan Nappen had anything to do with the decision to withdraw support from the rally.
  13. Not only has NJ2AS been named in news articles, but the Aitkens have not issued any other C&Ds to any other person/group who is calling for Brian's release. NJ2AS is definitely being treated like the proverbial turd in the punchbowl and I can't figure out why.
  14. There's only one problem with that... His lawyer, Evan Nappen, went on Tom Gresham's radio show a few weeks ago (Frank was a guest on that episode too) and within a few days NJ2AS received their C&D request from Brian. If his lawyer's advice was not to have the rally, then why would he appear on a nationally syndicated radio show promoting the same? If anything, I think it was advice from the state, not from Brian's attorney. Somebody else pointed out that it may have been a scare tactic to get them to distance themselves from a real 2A NJ group to better their chances of clemency. So it would appear that Mrs. Aitken became a political pawn to avoid becoming a political pawn.
  15. Any idea what the penalty was? I know there's a fine + jail time, but I didn't know what he his official punishment for those offenses were. Oh, and for the record, my call to the Governor's office will be about granting clemency solely on the illegal possession charge. Whatever penalties imposed by the magazine/hollow point conviction should stand independent of this effort. While I don't agree that those should be crimes, the fact remains that they are and we should be working to correct that and not just excusing those who break those laws.
  16. Vlad, Was he actually convicted on the magazine/hollow point charges? Nobody has been able to afirmatively say he was...
  17. Mrs. Aitken clearly misses that NJ firearms laws are, in fact, "political" by their very nature. And if her son is released/granted clemency/etc. that too will be a "political" move by Governor Christie. That's the problem with people in NJ. They don't like unjust laws and they want to fight like hell if they get caught up by them, but they will not only sit on their hands but actively work against changing them. I'm torn by this. On one hand, I don't believe that Brian deserves to be in jail. On the other hand, he's biting the hand that feeds him by rejecting the support of the group that has single-handedly brought his case the national attention it needs. So part of me wants him released immediately, but the other part of me wants him to stay in jail and we can make an example out of him there, where his case is more valuable to us "politically". In the end, I'm a bigger person than Mrs. Aitken and feel that her son deserves all the help he can get, even from those of us who are "politically" motivated to change the very laws that ensnared her son. I will be placing a call to the Governor's office by the end of the day today.
  18. Whether this guy likes it or not, his cause has been picked up nationally by many major gun rights voices. That also means that whether or not we NJ gun owners participate or not won't have much of an effect (let's face it, we're just not that powerful a group). This guy really gets my goat. He's run afoul of the worst gun laws in the U.S. He hires the best NJ gun law attorney in the state and accepts money from the NRA to fund his defense. His lawyer goes on a nationally syndicated radio show to talk about his case, and all the while the story has spread like wildfire among the blogs and columns of gun rights writers. Then, out of nowhere, one group gets what amounts to be a C&D order for the rally they were going to hold to champion his release. And now, there's this "Call to action day". Why isn't there a C&D coming from Mr. Aitken or his attorney to put a stop to this phone campaign? Something stinks with this whole thing, but I'm not sure what it is exactly.
  19. BigHayden replied to a post in a topic in Current New Jersey Gun Laws Discussion
    Dude, I almost snarfed my coffee! This post gets a "post of the day" vote from me.
  20. Not to go off on a tangent, but I keep hearing that he had >15 round magazines. OK, trust but verify. Nobody has been able to say for sure that he did and what gun they were for. Yes, possession of high capacity magazines is one of the charges on the arrest report, but I don't know that he was tried for that offense, since the 7 year prison term is for illegal possession of a handgun without a permit to carry. Somebody posted the arrest report on here. Does anybody have a copy of the court records which show which offenses he was convicted on? Frank? You were working with Brian and Evan pretty closely to organize the rally, do you have more info on the magazine charge? OK, back to your post. On this board he would have also been told that hollow points are legal, and yet Brian was still arrested for possession of hollow points. We also would have told him to transport his guns in exactly the manner he did, and none of it would have amounted to a hill of beans because the judge ignored the exemption that allowed him to have the guns in his car. So even if this board is the ultimate resource for NJ firearms laws, it does nobody any good if the government ignores the law to advance their own idealogy.
  21. This is one of those "Yeah, but..." situations. Yeah, you're right, the AG is more than likely going to answer an "is it legal" question with an emphatic NO, but, the AG is also the one who tells prosecutors how to do their jobs. It's legal to possess a handgun in your home or while moving, but tell that to Brian Aitken. Asking the people who are most likely to take away 7 years of your life is a good way to not step into the bear trap of NJ law. We should be working to change the laws in NJ, not hiding our faces behind our hand and hope the AG or the NJSP doesn't hear about the new AK variant (or whatever else comes along).
  22. BigHayden replied to a post in a topic in Current New Jersey Gun Laws Discussion
    For the record, I know this isn't a carry bill. I was simply stating that OGAMadden's HPID bill is better for us than Van Drew's borderline extortion bill being masqueraded as a carry bill.
  23. BigHayden replied to a post in a topic in Current New Jersey Gun Laws Discussion
    It's a better attempt than Van Drew's $100/yr. carry permit bill...
  24. BigHayden replied to a post in a topic in Current New Jersey Gun Laws Discussion
    The Madden bill is a step in the right direction, but it isn't a goal. Our goal is the eliminate the FPID, HPP, HPID, OGAM, AWB, HP restrictions, BB gun as firearm definition, and to have constitutional carry. Those are our goals. We will achieve these goals by keeping up the pressure, as others have said, but also by recognizing when something is a step in the right direction. This HPID bill is a step in the right direction, but we should not be satisfied once it passes. I've said it before, we need to act like the anti's do whenever they get a bill passed. Before the ink is even dry, we come out and say we know this doesn't fix anything, but it's a good first step.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.