Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

mipafox

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by mipafox

  1. There is no law whatsoever that says you can be in DC without registering your firearms and ammo. Her memo telling cops not to enforce it has no force of law whatsoever and provides you no protection from that law. You better do what she wants if you expect that consideration.
  2. That's not the "ruling," that's the police memo. How hard is this? You are breaking DC law by having unregistered guns and ammo. You are using a police memo to protect you from the law about having unregistered guns and ammo - not any law, not any court ruling. If you believe the police memo will protect you, then you better do what the police think is right. If she thinks you need to be licensed in your home state, don't tell me, "that is not the law." You are already breaking the law and relying on her graciousness. It's very simple.
  3.     The memo gives one single example of an out of stater carrying legally in DC. Why have you not quoted it? Here it is: "Scenario 2: The man lives in Vermont, which does not require a license or permit for either open or concealed carry of a handgun. You run his name, and no criminal record is apparent."
  4.   I read it very clearly. You did not refute a single word of what I said. I said you are relying on the CLEO, not the law, for not having registration of firearms of ammo. Neither the law nor the ruling protect you - just the good graces of the CLEO. Miller said you need a license from your own state to carry. You say that's not the law. You are already in violation of the law, registration. If the CLEO thinks you need a license to carry, or a signed letter from the Tooth Fairy, you need it. She gave one example of an out of stater legally carrying in DC in her memo and made a point of the fact that the person was legal to carry in their home state due to the state's carry laws. I think Miller is on to something. Further, Miller and the CLEO are not the only sources of this, other people have been saying the same thing. It's certainly not clear at this point but everything coming out of DC suggests you need to be legal to carry in your home state.
  5. I'm not so sure about that. If you read the memo, they give two cases were a person may carry, and one where they may not. Of the two cases a person may carry, one is a person from DC with a registered firearm, and one is a person from Vermont where they specify no license to carry is needed. She made a point of that. I think Miller may be correct that this is her position. If I were a cop, I would think so, or at least call in about it. The ruling also makes no mention of nullifying the requirement to have firearms and ammunition registered in DC. That is still law. Are your firearms and ammunition registered in DC? No. So, as long as you are in violation of the actual law, and relying on the policy of the CLEO to keep your ass out of prison, I think you might want to do what the CLEO says. I don't think it's 100% clear what the CLEO's intent is at this point with respect to non-resident's authorization to carry in home state. Whatever she says goes if you want to rely on her altruism.
  6. Haven't found a big enough dog?
  7. There are probably 50 rod and gun clubs within 20 miles of Easton that charge $25 to $100 a year for membership. East Bangor charged $5 until recently. And they let you plink, but checking their website, seems they cleaned up the place. You can't stand in the Lehigh Valley without having one or two gun clubs within 5 miles in every compass direction. Where I live most boroughs have 2 and townships have several each.
  8. Maryland will be last. NJ will be never. I have two relatives in DC and I am tempted to visit. Unfortunately, the law does not say I can, the case law does not say I can as far as I can tell, and the Chief of Police does not write the law. And his word does not protect my ass. Further, a stay can occur at any time, and he can change his mind retroactively. Because his policy is not binding law. If by the end of this week this nonsense has stabilized I might indeed go down to visit some relatives. It would be great to exercise my rights guarantied and protected from the Federal Government under The Second Amendment in Washington DC.
  9. The DC police chief does not disagree. None of that came from the ruling, and certainly not from your quote. If Emily on Facebook is reliable concerning the legal peril of years in prison then the DC Police Chief has chosen a path of least possible criticism as a temporary measure.
  10. If you don;t know what to get then get something not on the California authorized list. Bonus points if it is illegal in any other states.
  11. [quote name="mike.one" post="897664" timestamp="1406508486" It could be from efga I'm sorry I wasn't clear. It's not from EFGA, it's from me. EFGA is too far away to hear from Phillipsburg, and they don't allow automatic fire. If you hear automatic fire from P-burg, it's probably us, we're right across the river.
  12. I don't think that quote in and of itself means you don't need a license to possess a firearm or ammunition in DC, which is a separate issue from carrying a handgun in public.
  13. Check it again. Without touching mag release, if you pull charging handle to the rear with mag in place will BCG lock open? Try that with multiple mags just as you have tried with live ammo. Otherwise it is short stroking. You have experimented enough with live ammo, do the same with no ammo. Do you have different TYPES of mags? Perhaps metal vs. PMAGs? My guess is something is slightly out of spec. Follower presentation and/or mag spring strength may or may not help. I would consider replacing BCG release and spring. Then things get down and dirty. Buy an extra BCG release spring and trim some coils from yours so it doesn't require as much force from the follower to activate the BCG stop. If magwell is out of spec, and you can't find mags that will work, last resort is to modify the mag stop and mag catch in the mag to get a v. sl. higher mag presentation. Obviously that is a balancing act with feeding and BCG clearance.
  14. You guys ever hear automatic fire there? It's me, I'm right across the river. Tannerite, too. I'm not aware of any blasting in that location so that's probably us as well. There is blasting once you get north of Bethlehem.
  15.   Does this ruling absolve you of the licensing requirements to possess firearms and ammunition (or ammunition components) in DC? I don't know, sincere question.
  16. If it's similar to AR you should be able to hold BCG way, WAY back by charging handle (or remove it) then reach into ejection port and push empty mag follower up and down with your finger to see how it interacts with BHO and where it might be binding. I guess you ruled out short stroking since it doesn't engage when you rack it by hand.
  17. Let's be realistic. Somebody breaking into your car is probably not going to kill you, and you often have more self defense rights (I'm guessing in Jersey, especially in places with no SYG laws) and certainly better "appearances" if forced to defend yourself in your home. But for some people that would mean they would be robbed on a daily basis because there is no police service, or it takes hours at a minimum. For others, they aren't going to take crap from thugs and are going to use legal force, hopefully with the realization (outside of jersey) that there is always some legal peril in such matters. Not carried by 6 not relevant with the scenario being faced. But "we have to call the cops and hide" is not the way it is done nationwide, there is simply a lack of familiarity with the ways things work most places here. It's also completely impractical in some places, including places in PA.
  18. I don't know if that is true or not in Jersey but it is not true in most states. Using force to expel trespassers or defend property is almost universally legal in the US and doing it does not one bit reduce your ability to use lethal force later if necessary. Initiating a confrontation with somebody engaged in legal behavior is a completely different animal than what we are discussing here, and makes you the aggressor, which puts additional requirements on you (such as retreat, a default in some states) in many states. Back to the PA example, you can certainly use force to expel trespassers or defend property. And, as previously mentioned, on paved areas connected to your house there is a default presumption that you are in fear for your life unless somebody else is authorized to be there. And there is statutory immunity against civil judgment. Just as in my house or my car. So I am not culpable. Like I said, your mileage may vary in Jersey. But this is sort of a three or four way discussion including Newtonian and he accepted opening it up to other places. Not going to dwell on it, just for informational purposes.
  19. Deadly force is not the only force authorized under law. And in most of the United States, police response time is measured in hours or days. Yes, days.
  20. I don't consider that brake "classic." Go Red Dawn or go back to Cuba.
  21. In PA a driveway is a paved area (usually) connected to your house. So just like in your house, anybody with no right to be there provides a default presumption that you are in fear for your life and justified to use deadly force. If it's your mother in law or they are wearing a PP&L Electric hardhat then it is a rebutable presumption but the burden of proof is still on the prosecutor that you were not in fear for your life

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.