Everything posted by mipafox
-
14.5" Upper comparison
I don't have any superior knowledge. It's "Bolt Bounce." Which makes no sense. An AR bolt can't "bounce" once it's locked. I told everybody they were full of baloney. Well, it actually means carrier bounce, and I was just an idiot. Having burnt out my barrel, it became overgassed. So it cycled really fast. In semi, this is not a problem. Hammer waits for you to release the trigger and moves from the disconnector and then you press it and it fires. In auto, it's a problem. The BCG moves forward and once the bolt is locked the carrier trips the sear and drops the hammer automatically. Problem is, there is too much gas, and the cycle is too fast. So, after the bolt is locked, and the sear is tripped, and the hammer is dropped, the carrier bounces off of the back of the bolt lugs and heads backwards, hits the hammer in reverse before the hammer can put full force on the firing pin. Obviously this problem would not happen in Semi, since you are not going to pull the trigger the exact moment the bolt goes into battery after the prior shot. But in auto, for me it only happens with 5.56, not with .223.
-
14.5" Upper comparison
    OK, so you have absolutely no idea what part of the cycle would be affected specifically in auto. I asked you to explain it, you can't. You just assume auto needs more gas. You have no idea why auto needs more gas, and no idea what you are talking about. BTW, the cyclic rate is the same in semi as it is in auto. I doubt you could even explain the cycle of an AR. And, even if you were right, I get a lower cyclic rate with BCM 16" mid-length uppers and even lower with 14.5" BCM carbine uppers than with any other upper from any other manufacturer USING 5.56 AMMO AS EVIDENCED BY VIDEO POSTED ON THIS WEBSITE. AND AS WAS MY ORIGINAL POINT IN THIS THREAD. So, even though you haven't explained how a slower cyclic rate would mess up auto fire vs. semi, even if you were right, the BCM uppers have slower cyclic fire with 5.56. So, by your thinking, BCM uppers should be less reliable in auto. Now, back to my obligation. I finally burnt out the POS chrome-molly barrel of my frankenupper after about 10,000 rounds. It now works perfectly in auto with .223, and works perfectly in semi with 5.56, but is not reliable in auto with 5.56 ammo. Tell me why. This is not a hypothetical, it's real. I burnt out the barrel and it works with both kinds of ammo in semi and only .223 in auto. Somebody told me why and I thought it was impossible. It's a very common issue but I never believed it. I felt like a dumbass once it was explained to me.
-
14.5" Upper comparison
After you explain to me your failure mode, I'll tell you how I previously blew off the explanation of a malfunction in the cycle as BS until somebody explained it to me in detail. So you can get a laugh at my expense. Possibly on top of your I Told you So
-
14.5" Upper comparison
    No, I don't think you are retarded LOL. And there are people here that can tell you for damn sure that I am not always right from personal experience. And, I'm not going to argue with you, either. Can you explain it to me or not? I just wanted to see if you knew something about the function of the cycles that I had missed.
-
14.5" Upper comparison
You know what, there is always the possibility that I missed something, so please forgive me and let me hear you out. So, with the M16, you have two types of firing cycles: 1. SEMI firing cycle 2. AUTO firing cycle Can you please explain to me which part of the cycle causes .223 ammo to be reliable in SEMI but not in AUTO? Which part of the cycle does the "inherently weaker round" fail in AUTO but not in SEMI?
-
Discussion with a PA gun guy
Well, you have to admit, PA gun laws are better than Florida gun laws in every way, and you have FAR more places off limits for carry as well.
-
What kind of bipods do you guys use
I won't laugh. Like I said, I trashed my Harris just rocking it from the bench. But it was just a broken screw I think and a lost nut or something.
-
14.5" Upper comparison
Give it up, you don't know what you are talking about, and I'm certainly not going to argue with you.
-
CALIFORNIA APPROVES SALE OF SMART GUN / Modern Arms
High powered assault pistol.
-
Discussion with a PA gun guy
I don't like the handgun transport laws, either. We will probably get rid of that in the next few years. But the background checks at gunshops are no better in ANY state. All of them use NICS. Only ours never gets backed up for weeks like yours, it's a few minutes 99% of the time although I have heard of any hour on rare occasions. Overall, I think PA is tied with about 3 states for 2nd place in best gun laws in the country, maybe first place. There are a few states that don't require carry permits at all but VT doesn't allow silencers and most of the others have long lists of places that are off limits for carry. PA has one of the shortest lists for off limits for carry. Yeah, PA gun laws overall are about as good as they come.
- FID woes
-
14.5" Upper comparison
Point of clarification, somebody asked me to answer what he said. I thought it was helpful to inform them that I can't see what he said. Your complaint is off topic. In this case, it is the gas port.
-
14.5" Upper comparison
    Holeshot is on my ignore list because he seems gay for me or something, I don't know, he follows me around here and makes insulting comments about stuff I posted years ago even though I have no idea who he is. I have about 20,000 rounds of .223 through 2 uppers on auto without a single malfunction. One is a Colt, the other is a frankenupper. And, it has nothing to do with being cheap, the last several cases of .223 PMC and 5.56 XM193 I bought all for the same price - $290 out the door in 2012. I choose to shoot .223 a lot because it is not as obnoxious in auto from short barrels. Go over to Uzitalk and share that wisdom with them that .223 is not meant to be fired on auto. There are so many SOT dealers and SOT machinegun manufacturers that will laugh you out of the thread. There is no basis for your statement, it's complete bullshit. The BCM is a mid length with a 16" barrel. It's undergassed, it shoots slightly sluggish. Which is why it is so smooth, and why I would expect them to have more problems with .223 or weaker ammo than other rifles. I fired a BCM 14" carbine upper from a member on this board from Jersey and it fired even slower. That was why I went with the 16" md instead of the 14" carbine, since I had fired a 16" mid previously and knew what to expect. So, 3 separate BCM uppers, 2 different lengths and gas systems, all similar results. I documented all of this including my choice of the upper on this forum, and your member posted video of the sluggish fire from his 14". I'm not criticizing BCM, I love mine. They say their uppers are "optimized" for military ammo, and clearly they are, moreso than military guns are.
-
Pellet rifle
Sell it to me half price. It's not a firearm (outside of Jersey) so no FFL required to "transfer" the toy.
-
Mountain lion in Berlin (possible)
There are Cougars in Hoboken.
-
Fall Stripers yet? Any reports
Absolutely. But, it's in her head. I haven't made it for a few years. I'll get her to make it and I'll stand there with a pad. Because when she recites from memory it's never perfect.
-
14.5" Upper comparison
I think BCMs are undergassed, I am not sold on them. Mine malfunctioned once in auto with weak .223. They are very smooth, but to a fault. They even say they are "optimized" to shoot with military 5.56. I would buy them again, but I do not consider them Colts like some others do. Since you are a newbie, and may be using newbie ammo, I'm thinking it's a toss-up between that and the Spikes. I have no experience with Spikes in 5.56, but they seem to have some followers.
-
What kind of bipods do you guys use
I used a Harris and I tore it to shreds in a couple months. I put it back together with bolts and washers and Locktite from Home Depot and it has held for several years.
-
Discussion with a PA gun guy
We don't put EMS in jail when they cross the river to answer a call on the other bank of the river and police find an HP rolling around on the floor of their gunless car.
-
Discussion with a PA gun guy
I agree 100%. I think you should pass a law to protect NJ residents from themselves so they can't move to PA and be miserable.
- Can anyone give a reference for a doctor for a psych evaluation?
-
OK, I admit, equipment matters
You skipped the first part when quoting me: Now lots of people are telling me how you need the best equipment at a range. Lots of thoughtful responses. /sarcasm.
-
PA gun show question
Dennis Todd is a very highly respected dealer in this region. He's also a fucking idiot. If you can deal with the latter, he will deliver on the former.
-
OK, I admit, equipment matters
Well, not sure it matches your discussion but with respect to the thread title Mindset>Tactics>Skills>Equipment Provided you have all four
-
Fall Stripers yet? Any reports
My mom makes the meanest Rouladen you could expect from a woman born in a bomb shelter during WWII She taught me how to make it, of course, but she taught one of my best Xs to make it and hers was way better than mine :|