Everything posted by Vlad G
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
I dunno, first you tell me that there was an absence of religion under communism and I tell you from personal experience that this is untrue. Then you tell me that officially they didn't have it (officially being the word you used) and I show you that officially they did, just as they mostly had in reality. So I'm not really sure how many more ways I can tell you are wrong. I'm not telling you that your are wrong to pick on you. My entire point here is that if you are going to make pro-gun arguments (or any arguments at all, really) you should really check your facts. So far all your "facts" have been wrong. It doesn't matter if what you believe in is right, if you try to convince others you need to use accurate facts not ones that can be proven false with minimal effort.
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
Wrong again. The Soviet constitution included explicitly that freedom: "freedom of conscience, that is, the right to profess or not to profess any religion, and to conduct religious worship or atheistic propaganda". 30 seconds with google would have told you that. It is irrelevant if in practice it was true or not, the same as it is irrelevant what 2A says when applied to NJ, but they most definitely officially have the right to the free exercise of religion.
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
Those are statements not entirely congruent with the truth. Did communists mess with religion? Sure, but they never eradicate religion or seriously try to. Saying the absence of religion is communism is plain factually wrong and a complete misunderstanding of how religion worked under communism. I am NOT a religious person and I spent more time in church in a communist country then I spent in the US. Try having the priests march down 5th Ave in NY at Easter with thousands of people following them and see how that works out, but that was common in communist Romania. To understand what the communists relation was with religion you need to understand how deep religion penetrated into society. When they prosecuted religions they prosecuted mostly various sects, not the dominant easter orthodox church, and very often they did it with blessings of the patriarchs who didn't like the competition. You can tell me that Atheism was the religion of the Soviet Russia, but what exactly is the religion of the US? I'm pretty sure user's manual says we don't have one either.
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
What is your proof exactly? I gave you concrete examples of progress on the firearm front, I pointed out that the good god fearing people of the 50's supported handgun control by an overwhelming margin that was completely turned upside down. Exactly what do you base your statements on besides flawed beliefs on how the past was so much rosier then the present? Really .. this is what you wrote ON THIS VERY PAGE: Stop trying to convert people and they MIGHT leave you alone.
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
I'm going to address the communism vs religion issue some more, because I think it is time to smash some misconceptions. This is an example on how holding a factually wrong belief can hurt our cause. When you make your arguments based on factually wrong statements, it doesn't matter if what you are trying to prove is right, your argument will be dismissed. I grew up in downtown Bucharest, Romania, during the last and worst days of communism. I've witnessed the worst that communism can do to a country and a bloody revolution. I am the LAST person in the world to defend communism. The European and Russian communists did not try to squash religion in any meaningful way. I know this first hand as I grew up with a church in may back yard, and I mean that in the sense that I shared a fence with a church. My alarm clock for a decade was the 7am call to prayer from that church. In the 80's the communists were really fond of demolishing whole sections of the old town to build cement monstrosities and apartment buildings. They had no issue demolishing medieval structures to slap down a housing project, but whenever a church got in the way the built around it or carefully lift it off its foundations and moved it. Don't believe me? Here is a google maps pictures of the churches in Bucharest, and most of these churches are older then the United States, and a lot of them don't even show up at that resolution: Now lets zoom in a bit. In the late 80's Ceausescu decided to mow down about 5-10% of the city to build himself a new palace and "civic center". He ended up building one of the largest buildings on earth as his palace, and in the process he did knock down a few churches but also MOVED a whole pile of them. When it was all said and done, in the middle of his monument to communism, there is a Medieval Monastery 1000ft from his palace, a Medieval Church 2000ft away, and the Patriarchal Cathedral 3000ft away. Now, you can tell me that maybe Romania was different. Ok, let me show you a picture of Moscow's Red Square, and you tell me what you SMACK IN THE MIDDLE OF RED SQUARE:
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
You guys keeps saying that, despite overwhelming proof you are wrong. How many states allowed concealed carry in the 60s? How many do now? What was the legal scholar opinion on the 2A then vs now on the whole individual right thing? All those victories where won by being smart not aggressive. You probably won't like my answer but it is because you think atheists should be like you and should be converted. Stop trying to convert them, stop trying to pass laws that contravene their believes because you think they are "moral" and they will probably leave you alone. Thats actually nonsense. Having lived in a communist country I can assure you religion was not removed from everything not is the removal of religion a mark of communism exclusively, ask the Germans. For some reason conservatives like to paint anyone not agreeing with them as communists but most of them have no idea what communism is or was.
-
Jackson's replacement in Chicago easily wins on Anti-gun platform
Its Chicago .. what did anyone expect? Hell do you actually believe the voting machines work as the should in those kind of places?
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
So are you saying when people like Madison, Jefferson, and Patrick Henry were writing about the wall of separation between church and state, they were just being communists? How exactly do you argue about the the second amendment while at the same time ignoring on of the fundamental tenets of our for of government?
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
I'm tempted to give up and call this a lost cause, but I can't because as long as you go down this path you end up hurting me. The reason the bitter clingers things was said was because it worked. It may have annoyed me and you but it worked, because look who is sitting in the White House. Do not make the mistake of thinking they people managing elections campaigns do not know what they are doing, everything its calculated. They went down that path because they knew it would work. You are not getting to them, they are playing you like a fiddle. I don't care if laws offend god, the man never spoke to me. I care if they offend me and I see plenty of "god fearing people" making laws that suck too. How did the last president work for you? You are happy with the patriot act and all the other crap? Do you think the god fearing man in the white house gave a damn? I don't blame Christians for anything in particular, I blame you for not being able to separate religion from government, as the constitution you say you support dictates. As for where I got that data ... use a google or your favorite search engine. Feel free to search for "US crime rates 20th century" and do your own research. While you at it, get back to explaining to me how the god fearing people in the 50's were so much more opposed to handguns that people are today. How do you reconcile that with your theory that it is lack of god that it is getting us all these new laws?
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
Like it has been winning the argument for the last two decades, as gun rights have been improving. How well is your working exactly? You like giving the president ammo to talk about bitter clingers? Oh really? what research? Like this? Or this the fact that murder rate is a 50 year low? Or the fact that generarly speaking crime levels are less then 20% if what they were in the 1800s? Which were an improvement over the 1700's? Please, if you are going to make arguments, provide some actual proof for made up data. Would you have been happy if they replaced christian prayer in schools with muslim or hindu? Would that work for you? After all we have freedom religion. Oh sure, because the god fearing country of the 50's was 60% for banning handguns instead of 70% against today. If you think God gave you rights that's fine, I don't have a problem with it because I agree with the conclusion if I don't agree with the logic. But if you insist on bringing god into the gun rights argument at least don't say things I can disprove with 30 seconds and a internet search engine.
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
No one is bashing your beliefs, but I don't have to share them. The reason I cringe is not because I have a problem with your beliefs but because I know how your beliefs play to the ears of a lot of people out there. You can complain about how ever so terrible the world is without God, but right this moment we are fighting a fight about guns, not about god, and your approach is turning people off. I don't understand why certain people can't separate one from the other when conversing with someone else. Think of it this way, even in this thread, some people told us that if the rights aren't from god then they must be granted by the constitution, there is no other answer. Well that will play awesome to a person on the fence who doesn't believe in god. If god doesn't exist for them, then the only scenario available to them is that rights are granted by the government? Why even give someone only those two choices. How about every other religion out there? How about those who believe in multiple gods? Who granted them their rights?
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
I'm not sure why everyone has a problem getting stuck on god give or government granted, like those are the only two options. The Constitution grants nothing, it recognizes existing rights. It doesn't matter if those rights are god given, Gaia given, natural rights, rights common to all human, rights common to all living things, etc. You don't need god in the conversation lest we lose the idea of inherent inalienable rights.
-
Time to stop with the "God Given Right"
I disagree, it has worked wonders. The last couple of decades have seen a increased recognition of gun rights like nothing else we've seen before. Sure, a core group of anti-gunners will always wait to dance in the blood of children, but look around, it is all politically driven, there is no real popular support for gun control. We were winning the culture war by correctly modifying the message. It seems silly to me to throw that out because we have a crisis. I cringe when I hear god given right. I'm not a religious person, and last I checked I got no Fedex packages from anyone named god.
-
USPSA OBRPC 2-24-13
Sent Jim an email to fix your division. That's why the results are preliminary.
-
stress levels are a little high methinks!
FFS I'm trying to do you a favor, and you decide to be a combative jackmule. If you can't figure out what I meant to tell you in my previous post then truly you are a lost cause, which will probably hurt our cause in the long run. Welcome to my ignore list.
-
Bass Pro Shop Not Shipping Ammo To NJ
A lot of internet retailers require a copy of your FID before they ship ammo. Some just don't want to bother with it. TBH Bass Pro has done enough stupid in the last few years that I won't support them with my money.
-
stress levels are a little high methinks!
Well it isn't my place to comment on the sentiment behind that, but remember everything on the internet is forever so sometimes it pays to know when to shout your mouth and when to shut your mouth.
-
Ammo situation
I think we must also consider the many many many new shooters that have gotten into the hobby in the last few years, a lot of them who never owned a lot of ammo. Those of us who've seen this before kept extra ammo at hand already, a whole new bunch of people are learning this lesson.
-
stocking up on ammo
I just mix it into my car's gas tank when I'm short just a couple of gallons in the tank, and I add one gallon or two, run my tank down, refill, repeat until the old can is gone.
-
stocking up on ammo
With additives gas will be fine for a year or longer. I know this from personal experience.
-
stocking up on ammo
Be careful with CO getting in your bedroom if it is that close to your bedroom.
-
Are the Fudds our enemy?
You don't, not without going down a path of prohibiting freedom of speech. Everyone has a right to be wrong and scream it from the rooftops. I think the answer is calmly explaining in simple turns to anyone listening why he/she/them standing on the rooftop is wrong.
-
Are the Fudds our enemy?
To the first group answer them with a question, ask them to define semi-automatic. If they struggle with the definition or get it wrong, calmly and politely correct them and explain to them that their are being manipulated. Most don't actually understand the technology and build up fantasies in their minds based on movies and media. To the second, ask her if a basketball player can attempt a second shot at the hoop if he is quick enough or if football players chase a ball they dropped. I
-
Gun permit applications and sales 'skyrocketing' in wake of new legislation
BTW I personally know 4 people who have applied for permits for the first time every in the last few weeks. Actually, there may be more people I know that have done it, its just I know of four of them if that makes sense.
-
Are the Fudds our enemy?
I wasn't saying that hunting isn't a big hobby, I'm saying that every other segment of gun ownership has grown staggeringly faster and the hunter aspect of gun ownership is being overtaken.