Everything posted by Vlad G
-
Should I get a piston ar?
yes, I'm well aware of what I said, but repeating to me is not a technical argument proving me wrong, is it? I've asked for a technical explanation of why you believe I'm wrong besides your random gnashing your teeth.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
Son, what exactly am I wrong about, please provide an actual detailed explanation on how I'm wrong, not just one line answers.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
You really are making yourself look foolish instead of just misinformed.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
hear·say ˈhi(ə)rˌsā/ noun noun: hearsay information received from other people that one cannot adequately substantiate; rumor. "according to hearsay, Bob had managed to break his arm" synonyms: rumor, gossip, tittle-tattle, idle talk; More stories, tales; informalthe grapevine, scuttlebutt, loose lips "that's all hearsay, and I don't care to listen to such tripe" Law the report of another person's words by a witness, usually disallowed as evidence in a court of law. "everything they had told him would have been ruled out as hearsay" You are wrong because the word means that HE would be reporting things he has heard from others. He reported what he has personally experienced or witness. What you want to accuse him of is lying. You sound upset. I'm not, now I'm just amused. Roll your eyes, but do it towards a dictionary.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
LOL. You are also wrong about the definition of heresay. Just though I'd mention it.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
Okie, lets look at what you said No they don't. They did. They don't. They don't but mostly because they don't reset the bolt, so maybe you didn't explain clearly what you meant Nope, the bolt is very different, the carrier is very different, one is short stroke one is not, they don't. No it doesn't, the same dust gets there, oil just handles it differently. It doesn't And now I'm bored. Look, you can believe whatever you want and spend your money any way you want, but personally I get miffed when people spread misinformation. It isn't your fault you believe these things, the internet if full of bad information, but I'll correct you before you convince someone else that things work in a way in which they don't.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
I can explain to you, but I can't make you understand. I don't sound right, I am right, sorry if that gores your goat or something, I'm sorry if you bought a piston AR because you don't understand how a DI gun works and you bought the internet's rumors. I'll put as plainly as I can, my "game" rifle is worth more then my daily driver. If there was any evidence that a piston system would be in any way better, I would spend money on it. I'm not physiologically attached to a particular rifle function system, I care what the end results are. I'll also say that Adams Arms are great guys, support the shooting sports, and if they gave me one of their rifles I'd shoot the crap out of it, but it wouldn't be my primary rifle.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
And I should also add that yes there is small benefit to the Adams arms arrangement, there is less dirt in the action itself (not the chamber as covered earlier) so the BCG does need less cleaning and it does run cooler. I don't view the cooler part as being that important outside fully auto guns and even then I have doubts. It does reduce cleaning, I admit, on the other hand that is a very silly thing to worry about seeing how a properly built AR will run dirty for a very very long time.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
Oh and there are other factors that affect the amount of gas in the action, like bullet dwell time but thats a different topic.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
Okie, let me help you because I think you radically fail to understand how a normal AR functions and how an AK function and what the short stroke systems like Adams do, despite the videos you posted which apparently you don't understand. Please take this in the spirit in which it is intended, lots of people are confused about how an AR works, so don't take this personally. The AR gas system works as follows: Gas is bled from the barrel moved through a tube, and delivered into an expansion chamber formed by the rear half of the bolt and the bolt carrier. The gas is bled slowly so it takes quite a while to fill up that chamber. The gas is retained in that chamber by the front of the bolt being tightly fit to the bolt carrier and the rear gas rings. This creates a piston/cylinder arrangement not unlike a car engine, with the bolt being the piston and the carrier being the cylinder. When the pressure is high enough the bolt can't move forward, so the carrier starts moving backwards. When it moves backwards sufficiently, it starts dragging the bolt with it, it cams on the cam pin, and unlocks. Now where does that gas go? it leaves through holes on the sides of the gas carrier once the bolt moves away from them and out the ejection port and towards the REAR of the bolt. Gas does not escape forward, if it did the part behind the locking lugs would be filthy but oddly it isn't. This is why when you clean an AR bolt the REAR of the bolt and the inside of the carrier are the dirty bits, not the front. The only gas coming towards the chamber is residual gas from the gas tube and guess what that is at the same gas pressure as the barrel itself. Given that they are at the same pressure, do you think the gas tube shoves more gas into the action or the barrel itself which has a much higher diameter and it is .. you know .. attached to the damn chamber? Try running an AR, regardless of design, with an compensator with a high pressure chamber or even worse a silencer, those things push a LOT of gas back into the action through the barrel itself. What the Adams Arms design does is to shove the carrier with a short external piston and then the carrier is in free motion just like it was before. Yes this keeps gases away from the rear of the bolt, but when it comes to the chamber being dirty it makes no meaningful difference. Note that the carrier moves INDEPENDENTLY of the piston beyond the initial short stroke of the piston. Now look at the AK design. The piston is hard attached to the carrier. The carrier moves with the piston all the way though its movement. Now, you can claim that a rod is a rod and a semi-auto is a semi-auto so from that point of view they are same, but thats like saying all semiauto handguns work the same way. Nothing about the Adams Arms design make the chamber any damn cleaner then the DI guns, because the gases from operation of the AR don't end up in the chamber.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
I fear you really don't understand how an AR functions.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
Oil attracts dust? Really? Magnets .. how do they work?
-
Should I get a piston ar?
Not at all. Not even a little bit. The AR piston guns have a short movement piston that shoves the carrier on its merry way, the AK piston has a long stroke that moves along with the bolt for the entire trip.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
I'd think that would be obvious, the design doesn't really permit it, without silly amount of modification. The AR isn't really DI either, not REALLY, it is a rod-less piston system if you think about it, the bolt itself is the piston, sort of, there just isn't a rod there, the gas operates directly on the piston/bolt. To make an AK that way the AK bolt would need to actually have a chamber around instead of just cam'ing surfaces. You can turn an AR into a piston operated format by pushing the carrier with a rod, instead of having the inside pressure pushing it, you can't do the reverse to an AK.
-
Times most dangerous counties in the US
I take issues with those numbers. Pick random Kansas county and look at the loss per capita due to tornadoes vs NJ. We might have higher total numbers because of higher population, but I seriously doubt NJ is a more dangerous place to live due to natural disaster then place that burn down regularly out west, or tornado alley, or Florida and its hurricanes.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
They did : http://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2011/10/19/izhmash-subsidiary-molot-to-manufacturer-russian-ar-15-rifle/ http://molot-guns.com/Rifled-professional http://www.zbroyar.com.ua/z15.php
-
Should I get a piston ar?
It is called marketing. To stand out in a sea of AR manufacturers you need to convince the buying public that somehow your product is better. You will note that Adams Arms sell DI stuff under the Voodoo label, FN makes both DI and piston guns, etc.
-
Hornady or Lee
650 is closest to LnL, but the 550 is also a good press although a bit slower. I run a 550 and I can load about 300 .223 per hour in prepped cases. Pistol I do about 500 per hour.
-
Bipod for SPR...swivel or no swivel?
Personally I found them to be more bother then help for anything but zeroing, but that's me.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
And by yards i mean rounds. Damn iPad.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
Oh, FFS. I laid this challenge before to people say lever guns where best, so what the hell. Bring your whatever, I'll bring mine. I won't even clean it because that's work and I don't clean it now and I'm not going to start for this. We shoot a few hundred yards my way, a few your way, and let's see which one fails first. I need to load some ammo anyway.. Be aware being able to hit targets will be part of the test.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
I hate to break it to you, it isn't the piston that makes some guns more reliable then others in certain conditions, it is the rest of the design. It is more about tolerances and sloppy fit vs tighter fit. It is a trade off if you care about accuracy. I know my competition background makes people think that race space guns are somehow ok to fail and we don't care about that, but you couldn't be more wrong. When it costs me $500+ to attend a match, before travel, ammo, food, a single jam can ruin your match. Our space guns work (and really they are basically SPR's, they are not that crazy) or you don't really compete. In that world, where rifles+optic are north of $3000 and people can pretty much afford any rifle on the market, the rifle of choice is the DI AR with adjustable gas blocks. The only people shooting piston guns are people sponsored by companies that make them, like FN, Adams, etc. I call that another clue.
-
Bipod for SPR...swivel or no swivel?
Consider trying to shoot it without a bipod at all.
-
Should I get a piston ar?
Planning to storm beaches with no logistical support? Ok then, prepare to have every damn gun fail in those conditions.
-
Hornady or Lee
Dillon. Spend your money once and be done with it. Hornady would be a close second.