Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Smokin .50

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Smokin .50

  1. Ray, I'm laughing so hard that I could just pee my pants! THANKS!
  2. Looks pretty Maks! Now all I need is to take off the dots and install some iron sights (with trijicon) and I'm all set, lol!
  3. Sounds like another "Cooperism", lol! We are indeed birds of a feather, for I just adore the 1911's natural pointability, single-action trigger and safeties as they are all second-nature to me. Here's an interesting compromise: A Para-Ordanance P-16 .40 Short & Weak double-stack with magazine floor extensions (ya, I KNOW, NOT in NJ!) that would hold 18 in the mag +1 in the tube, cocked & locked. Or the same Company's P-14 .45 ACP with some magazine work so it hold 16 +1 in the tube. These great double-stacks never seem to get mentioned at all in the 9 vs. .45 dramas as in this thread. The argument always goes to magazine capacity. Well the Para's take away that factor, and you're left with a superior handling, customizable Hi-Cap .45 or .40! I have a P-16 laying around somewhere. I have to get it back to the Gunsmith for some sear work. Take care!
  4. We're sorta both on the same team here. I'm not saying caliber trumps design. I'm saying given everything else being equal--including the availablity of well-made .45 hollow points of the same design as those 9mm ones that weigh half as much, I'll take the heavier slug with more mass for deeper penetration. And the HP cavity of the .45 may be larger than that of the 9mm, with the resultant tissue damage being increased over that of both the .45 ball ammo and the 9mm HP of the same make. So I guess you could quote me as "Heavier is Better", lol!
  5. I LOVE sarcasm, and I can dish it out as well as take it: Thanks for the idea! I betcha it would create a sufficient wound channel even IF I powered it down to a .50 Special! OH! WAIT! You mean somebody already did? Yes friends it's even commercially available! 440 grains (that's a one ounce 12 ga. shotgun slug equiv. for those of you in the PR of NJ) of pure kick-A$$ in a solid lead 1/2" wide flat point gas-check (Keith Style) bullet traveling at 1,100 FPS with an astonishing 1,200 Foot-pounds of energy (Oh Boy--here comes the hydrostatic SHOCK!). A whole new meaning to the phrase, "Feel lucky Punk?" And I'll take mine in the 4" tube with that pretty survival case good for Alaska travel. Where's that saddlemaker--I need some custom gun leather! O-K, sarcasm switch OFF! Not trying to start a WAR, just have some fun. No harm intended! In all seriousness though, if it was up to me and I had my way every Cop would be given the chance at demonstrating proficiency with the largest caliber gun(s) that they felt they could handle. The idea that Cops toss magazines into the air and throw them at each other upon hearing an Officer running-out of bullets in the middle of a gun fight is crazy! Crazier still is the requirement that all of the Police bullets have to be interchangeable. This thought process breeds mediocrity instead of giving those Cops that have demonstrated a willingness to "learn the Gun" as it were, an "edge". One Cop dead due to the Perp absorbing lethal rounds and not dying fast enough is one too many dead Cops IMHO!
  6. This is fine by me! This argument (9 vs. .45) started long before computers existed, and hopefully will continue long past we're all long dead (meaning no one should take our guns away!).
  7. Neither are NJ 's Retired LEO's....
  8. Actually it hasn't really changed much at all. Neither has the human body. Granted, some of the newer generation hollow points have slightly better expansion (under ideal circumstances shooting into exposed ballistic gelatin), but a big heavy slug still penetrates to the vitals better. If TECHNOLOGY is all we needed to drop the Bad Guys by making newer bullets, how come most of our Special Forces, SEALS, Rangers, etc. switched back to the .45? And why aren't big game hunters using the 5.56mm instead of English Double Rifles with .500 Nitro Express slugs that weigh almost two ounces? The sarcasm only proves to show a sort of unwillingness to accept reality. Just because something was written when you might have been in swaddling clothes doesn't necessarily make it automatically wrong. Today's 9mm hollow point bullets are made of the same materials as today's .45 ACP hollow point bullets, so the argument of newer materials is very moot, since the material themselves are somewhat universally available in all calibers. Therefore, at the end of the day, all we're left with, given similar bullet desgns employing the latest technological breakthroughs, is "BIGGER IS BETTER"!
  9. Thanks so much! Quite an interesting read! So after reading a 16 page Pdf from Quantico, I (and Col. Jeff Cooper) have been proven mostly correct in that "bigger is better" and penetration is the key. And that hollow point bullets can fill-up with window glass, clothing and any number of other items that will cause them to FAIL to expand, therefore making the reliance upon expansion very dangerous to the LEO (I'm paraphrasing, but right on the mark). Now all we have to do is pull-out our old .45 LC Peacemakers and put some 250 grain flat point (wide) bullets in them and pump the Bad Guys full of hot lead like back in the "old days". YEEEHAAAW!
  10. I'm NOT saying that you're going to definatley get one of your Sign-Off's---I'm suggesting that it might be possible. Now if you show-up before 9:00 am and volunteer to help set-up a Stage and then hang-around to see what they do, then I'm almost certain Iggy would sign your paper. Then take what ever it is you brought with you to shoot into one of the open Pits and bang away! In this Club, one hand washes the other and being nice doesn't hurt. Have a great day tomorrow. If I get my grill cleaned soon enough, maybe I'll stop-by to say hello. With the weather as nice as it's supposed to be, we're not going to be the only folks there! Dave
  11. Yes, I am aware of that. I was just making a joke! The .40 Short & Weak came about because the 10mm was too much recoil & muzzle blast for the FBI to spend the extra training time necessary at the Academy to teach how to properly handle it. And remember that they had to equalize the playing field with smaller-framed trainees from all walks of life. So the .40 is actually a compromise solution after the testing. This too was written about decades ago by Col. Cooper and other notable Experts in the field at the time.
  12. Iggy is only using the back Pits for OBRAMS Training, Pits #1-#4. So that leaves Pits 5 (a 25 yard Pit), Pit 6 (the 50 yard Range) as well as Pit 7 (the 100 yard Range and the Shotgun Range. So you can still bring something to shoot, AND take a look at what OBRAMS is and maybe get an Observation signed-off. So look at this as an opportunity instead of a problem and have fun! Dave
  13. Why was the gun unloaded to begin with? If this was an "Open Carry" situation, then the two Perps may have spotted the gun/holster and just went to another victim..... Something doesn't quite "sit" right with this...
  14. Shotgun "fit" is the most important thing to consider and comes before looks and other adjustable variables. A $10K gun that doesn't fit you will break less birds than a $300 pump that does fit well! So go to several places and rent loaners or borrow a buddy's shotgun to get a better understanding about how comfortable shotgun shooting is supposed to be. When you shoulder the gun does your head meet the stock and your sight beads line-up without effort, or do you have to adjust the way you hold the gun or tilt your head each time? Try guns from several manufacturers in a "blind" sighting test. Have the store clerk hand you the gun and you just immediately shoulder it without taking the time to look at the shiny metal or the nameplate. You might find that a gun that doesn't fit well was your favorite looks-wise. Find one in a style that fits, check the sizing as far as LOP, weight, barrel length, etc. and then see if the clerk can show you a gun with the same stats in the brand / budget of your choice. Also keep in mind that there exists professional stock benders that customize the fit of your gun to your body (around $200 or so locally) and info about them can be found at most good trap ranges' bulletin boards. Clay target trap guns usually require you to hold the sight bead UNDER your clay as you swing ahead leading it and field guns are usually aimed directly in line with the bird as you lead it. Some guys I know can pick up either and bang away dusting the birds, others miss everything since they forget where to aim / what gun they have in their hands. Good luck with your exploration of over / unders! Dave
  15. That Marlin will last a lifetime and is a great choice! I started my son with a Little Buckaroo Marlin bolt action single-shot boy's rifle when he was four. Made him a NRA Life Member at age five! I'm hoping to be around long enough to teach my grandchildren how to use it! Treasure the time you spend shooting together. Those are my fondest memories (other than his birth & college graduation). Sounds like you're doing a great job! Congrats to you both!
  16. I'm with you Ray! Have a good night!
  17. This is just what I was saying, only re-worded...... And as for hydrostatic shock, JoN, you have to do the "Rosey" Test: Fire a 470 grain .50 caliber lead bullet into a watermellon at 15' distance. I chrono'd the bullet at 1379 FPS. Fired it from my Lyman black powder rifle using 100 grains of black powder. Instead of merely slicing into the watermellon like a .30-06 150 grain machine gun round a la R. Lee Ermey (several rounds into the mellon going straight through) on Mail Call TV show, my single 470 grain slug destroys the mellon leaving only bits & pieces, the largest being the size of approx. 1.25" x 3.5" (and only one or two that big)! The rest has to get washed off of the table the mellon was propped up upon and also washed off of the shooter & his rifle! If that ain't hydrostatic shock, I don't know what the hell is! Rifle velocities of 2000 or 3000 FPS aren't needed for hydrostatic shock to occur. Sectional density & bullet mass have a lot to do with the equation! I find it extremely interesting that what's old is new again, and re-discovered! For instance, did you kids know that Elmer Keith invented the .41 Magnum as the answer to what the Police needed in a hand gun round? The 10mm of today owes it's ballistic upbringing to the ancient .41 Magnum! In a revolver, the .41 recoiled less than the .44 Magnum and allowed Cops to get back on target quicker. It's 200+ grain jacket hollow point projectile did just as much or even more damage as the 10mm (.40 short & weak all grown-up) creating huge wound channels in cadavers. Bullet weight (mass) creates a certain "thumpability" and can knock-down attackers. Examples of 555 grain (slower than crap) .58 caliber Minne Balls going through THREE soldiers in alignment have been eye witnessed by Doctors during the Civil War. Elmer Keith's .44 Magnum 300 grain Keith style bullet has dropped mule deer at more than 400 yards when fired from a 4" tubed revolver. Big heavy bullets get the job done. Nothing beats "thumpability", that sound you hear as a 200+ pound animal hits the ground as its' legs fold-up from underneath itself......
  18. Clinton also good for clay birds in the air too--separate range just down the road before you get to the office......
  19. Too bad that we can't unearth dear Elmer Keith, the famous six-gunner and designer of the Keith-style bullet. He has written THE books on what works as far as bullets are concerned. Penetration tests on human cadavers, the design of the original .44 Magnum, use of 250-300 grain pistol bullets for one-shot stops of African Big Game, etc., etc. Point that I'm making is that this has all been "put-to-rest" several decades ago. Slower, heavier bullets can use their mass to go through things like windows & car doors and still have the "punch" needed to stop a fight. Take that same heavier bullet and give it a higher velocity such as in the case of .44 Magnum, .45 Winchester Magnum (for the Widley), and several others, and the video of the ballistic gelatin test is mind-blowing. Wound channels double the size of what's in the video clip at the beginning of this thread! There are at least two schools of thought when it comes to man-stoppers: 1. Use several (read as 3-4) well-placed smaller rounds in hopes that the SOB will somehow bleed-out fast enough to deny his brain oxygen, thus ending the fight. 2. Use the biggest round (or two) that you can shoot straight and get somewhere near center-of-mass. It's hydrostatic shock will destroy enough tissue & organs & go through enough bone to stop the fight. This is battle-proven, with volumes of one-shot stops both in Europe & Asia. Also of note is the use of heavy bullets in survival guns such as the .44 & .50 caliber wheelguns' use in Alaska, etc. Either way works, and the net result is that a Hi-Cap 9 can't really fight (and be sure to knock-down) any more Bad Guys than a single-stack .45 in the hands of someone who can handle the .45! So as one of the previous posters said (I'm paraphrasing) "I feel confident using this weapons system", and I believe that confidence in a gunfight, combined with a clear head and a steady hand have won many a confrontation. Just remember though, if you're betting your LIFE on a 9mm, train using several rounds per Perp so you come-out on top! I'd say 2 minimum, and 3 is better, then re-asess the situation. Of course, having the situational awareness to not let yourself become exposed to a threat(s) is even better than having to shoot your way out of one.......
  20. The nice thing about the good hi-vis sets is just that--they're usually sold as sets, which means you get 2-4 colors in a package and can change them out at will.......
  21. With gas fast approaching $4.00 a gallon, as Clyde Barrow once was quoted as to why he & Bonnie rob Banks, "It's where the money IS"! This crap will continue to happen until jobs come back to NJ, the economy improves and gas prices fall. Even in the "nicer" neighborhoods like yours (I've been there, bought gas at that station).
  22. Not allowed at most "traditional" Clubs. Only really see them being used on Inlines for hunting. One Club I belong to allows them on rifles, but not pistols. I prefer open, iron sights on my front stuffers and C&B revolvers. This way I can go from one Club to another without problems or handicaps getting in the way of having fun! To be completely truthful, most (in the world of REAL black powder) consider their use an abomination. To better answer your question in regards to effective color of the hi-vis sight material: I would imaging it depends upon the color of your intended target. I prefer green hi-vis on my modern centerfire scatterguns, since clays are orange and the contrasting colors are helpful with leading the clays. If they were the same color, the sights could get "lost" in a sea of color, and you'd be shooting all over the place..... Good luck with what works for you! And remember my offer to shoot front stuffers still stands: 1st, 3rd, or the last Sundays of the month. I'll supply the rifle since you don't own one!
  23. Nice video, but no details of .45 wound ballistics that I could see. And the image of the wound channels was on & off the screen too fast for my liking. The presenter was sort of "fair" as he did say that heavier bullets penetrated better. So I guess we should all be looking at double-stack .45's which would give us the best of both worlds! Keep in mind that this entire controversey started when the 9mm ran outta steam and couldn't get the job done back in '86 in Miami FBI murder case. Jeff Cooper stated back then that a .30-.30 rifle could have ended the fight and saved several lives. Wonder if they ever learned, and are now carrying .30 cal rifles, just like back in the Bonnie & Clyde days. What's old is new again (and rediscovered)!
  24. Very funny Chris! Actually the gun only weighs-in @ 7.3 pounds empty, so it's quite easy to carry and shoulders great! But I'd love to have arms like that, lol! I reload "out-of-the-pouch" (possibles bag) so I'm wearing everything I need to have a really great time. I was at the Pizza Joint a couple days ago and they were all asking if I had any more flyin' chickens I could give them, lol! Must have been good tastin' Bird!

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.