Everything posted by woodentoe
-
Zimmerman to be charged in Trayvon Martin shooting
Too many what ifs is exactly why Z will be let go. Proof beyond reasonable doubt is the requirement in court.
-
Zimmerman to be charged in Trayvon Martin shooting
Please, read the law. Just like we ask everyone to do every time someone comes on the forum saying hollowpoints are illegal or loaded mags are firearms. We tell them to read the law. Google "Florida stand your ground law" , go to the Florida statutes website and read the statute pertaining to use of deadly force/justification There is nothing in the current swath of "evidence" pit forth by the media that shows GZ violated that law. Hopefully for the folks who have decided guilt, there is more evidence. Hopefully, for george Zimmerman, he's telling the truth and there is not more to the story that implicates him.
-
Zimmerman to be charged in Trayvon Martin shooting
I think a lot of this is irrelevant because I am entitled to find someone suspicious for any reason I damn well please. In some cases, I may be right. In most cases, I'd be an asshole. There should be a disconnect between the reality of institutional racism that tells us that GZ profiled TM because of his race, and the application of the law as it is settled. If GZ is immune from conviction in the shoot, it doesn't matter that he's not a racist or is a racist or is a Martian. People are allowed to be racist assholes if they want to be. The case has to prove that a CRIME was committed. Last I checked, being an asshole wasnt illegal. If it were, our incarceration rates would be more off the chart than they are now. I predict either a plea bargain to manslaughter without the gun... Or he walks.
-
Zimmerman to be charged in Trayvon Martin shooting
If you please, read the text of the law regarding duty to retreat. Even if GZ was the aggressor. Even if he provoked TM. Even if he tackled TM to the ground. He is immune under the law. Because the duty to retreat ends if you are the aggressor UNLESS you try to retreat and end the confrontation. If GZ is losing the fight, with him as the provocateur, he has the obligation to run away to end the confrontation. If he has exhausted his ability to retreat and TM is preventing his escape, GZ is IMMUNE under the law jn using deadly force. If someone breaks in your house in Florida, and attacks you. Then, you turn the tide on them... Under the law you are obligated to allow their retreat. If you hinder that retreat, the home invader may be immune from prosecution for killing you under the rubric of self preservation. Just read the law and see what the state is up against here. They need to prove a great many things to convict him. They could charge him with aggravated assault if they can PROVE he was the physical aggressor. Remember, my freedom of speech ends when my fist meets your face. I can stand in times square and call every person I see a MFr, and it isn't a crime. But the moment someone incensed by my stupidity lays me out, THEY'VE committed the crime.
-
Zimmerman to be charged in Trayvon Martin shooting
I hear what you're saying. My point is how this jibes with Florida law. On my reading of the law, the prosecution must prove that Zimmerman had intent to kill under a depraved mind (without respect for life) In thus scenario, the fact that there were struggling and that there was even a fight rather than just a shooting suggests that Zimmerman had respect for life...his own. If he didn't break any law up until the point that he shot, and there was a struggle that restrained zimmermans ability to retreat, then it was a good shoot. The only way, I assess, he is guilty is if they can prove that Zimmerman just flat out hunted and shot martin. Hey, maybe that's what happened! If it did, he should rot, IMHO. But, there us emotion and what you or I think we would have done in a similar situation...and then there is the law and it's fair application. This case cannot put syg on trial in Florida. It is settled law. Likely, the outcome ofthis case will alter syg in Florida. However, GZ is on trial here. Not stand your ground.
-
Zimmerman to be charged in Trayvon Martin shooting
It is possible that I read this wrong. 776.041 Use of force by aggressor.—The justification described in the preceding sections of this chapter is not available to a person who: (1) Is attempting to commit, committing, or escaping after the commission of, a forcible felony; or (2) Initially provokes the use of force against himself or herself, unless: (a) Such force is so great that the person reasonably believes that he or she is in imminent danger of death or great bodily harm and that he or she has exhausted every reasonable means to escape such danger other than the use of force which is likely to cause death or great bodily harm to the assailant; or (b) In good faith, the person withdraws from physical contact with the assailant and indicates clearly to the assailant that he or she desires to withdraw and terminate the use of force, but the assailant continues or resumes the use of force.
-
Zimmerman to be charged in Trayvon Martin shooting
With all due respect, you seem to be injecting a whole lot of speculation in your assessment. The police did an investigation and the state prosecutor said Zimmerman couldn't be held in remand. The new prosecutor says murder 2. You first said 'followed' and then 'stalked'. This inject the assumption that George Zimmerman was in the commission of a crime at the t outset. I would posit that this Is the very thing that hasn't been proven in this case. Seeing someone as suspicious, for any reason, isn't a crime. Calling 911. Not a crime. Getting out of his car is not a crime. "following" trayvon Martin is not a crime (both previous things very stupid IMHO ). Even if he walked up to Martin and shouted in his face! Even if he hurled racial epithets at Martin...this is not criminal action. The only thing that matters is whether George Zimmerman was in the commission of a crime at the outset of the confrontation (i.e., illegally brandishing his firearm). The law doesn't care whether trayvon Martin threw the first punch or George Zimmerman did. If TM threw down, gm is immune through syg. If Zimmerman threw down, and Met his new duty to retreat when the tide turned against him and was restrained by Martin from doing so (this has been stated by eyewitness report), gm is immune under syg. There HAS to be new evidence that we haven't heard in the media (who shouldn't be disclosing evidence anyway) in order to prove that gm was committing a state crime at the outset. If they cant do that, I think the state's case is flawed.
-
Zimmerman to be charged in Trayvon Martin shooting
Everyone needs to take a second and read the law. Stand your ground says you have no duty to retreat. It does NOT apply if you are the aggressor...UNLESS you attempt to retreat and are prevented in doing so by the other party. Eyewitness says Zimmerman was pinned on the ground being beaten and was screaming for help. If his ability to retreat was hindered and he feared for his life (losing either consciousness or control of his firearm), the law renders him immune for shooting Martin. Perhaps he should have had the common decency to give up and let whatever Martin might do to him happen as on the spot punishment for making stupid, albeit seemingly legal, choices. I think murder 2 is a stretch. I think they are hoping he will plea down to avoid trial and jail so that there is a conviction to quell the uproar. But, if this goes to trial and the law is properly applied...I won't be surprised to see him walk. And then, everyone everywhere starts looking over their shoulder.
-
Religion in Schools
And, therefore should be approached and studied very carefully. Lest the whims of man cloud the message.
-
Has anyone actually applied for a NJ CCW?
I see this as a false choice. It implies the current thinking that ones carrying implies offensive intent. Your duty to retreat ends when you cannot further retreat. If someone has the drop on you, you're messed either way. But, if you are able to obtain cover, I'd say you're unable to retreat under fire. The fact that ccw is verboten is a separate problem from the duty to retreat. I see them a mutually exclusive.
-
Religion in Schools
And heads exposed all over the internets.
-
Rahway guild. Telling me I must own a safe to secure...
*facepalm*
-
Rahway guild. Telling me I must own a safe to secure...
With all due respect, repeatedly in this thread I stated that my intention was not to lodge some sort of review of the shop. But rather, the first few posts of mine were made while standing in the shop trying to figure out what was happening. I admit I'm not knowledgable and clear on all the laws. I explained what was occurring as best I could at the time I was deciding whether or not to buy. However, once the thread devolved into a round robin complaining session from the slew of folks who have an axe to grind about the guild, I explained inthe above post. Then, I posted again a clearer picture of my conversation to clarify. I never bad mouthed anyone or suggested not shopping at the store. On the contrary, I expect that I will buy there again for the reasons I've already stated. I apologize if I contributed to this whirlwind of criticism. At the outset, I was just looking for a simple answer to my initial question about a safe.
-
poor experience at shore shot
Either way, it is not out of line to strictly enforce that people must only invade their weapons at the firing line. I know that I don't want anyone uncasing behind MY back. It only takes an instant for someone to get hurt or killed and if you're handling firearms uprange of me, that's not on. RO's house. RO's rules.
-
poor experience at shore shot
Can you elaborate as to why you were threatened with removal?
-
Why Are You in Favor of CCW in NJ?
There is nothing in the transport law that says you are jailbound for eating and refueling. Food, fuel and personal safety are necessities of transport. Food and water are necessary to sustain life, therefore obtaining food is a reasonable deviation. Sitting in a restaurant for an hour is perhaps not necessary for sustaining life. Bit I think your example of fuel and drive thru is over the top. I'd get my ccw though if it were possible. It just eliminates a lot of the silly restrictions. But chances are if they passed it, you wouldnt be allowed to store in your vehicle. So, if you needed to go anywhere that restricted weapons, youd have to leave them home.
-
The Walking Dead
I'm seriously fond of Romero's Day of the Dead. Underrated and usually unmentioned. "IM RUNNING THIS MONKEY FARM NOW, FRANKENSTEIN!!! AND I WANT TO KNOW, WHAT THE F*** YOU'RE DOING WITH MY TIME!!!!"
-
Everyone Have Their Mega-Millions Ticket for Tonight?
The difference in your odds if you play $1 or if you play $1000 is infinitesimal at best. Perhaps just buy your own ticket and hope for the best. Someone has to win.
-
Everyone Have Their Mega-Millions Ticket for Tonight?
I've still got to get mine. I'm fantasizing about a big safe room, a beautiful collection, and a new house/land in a state where I can enjoy a class 3.
-
A Witness Speaks........
First off, this entire incident is troubling to me. It appears to me that a massive misunderstanding took place and as a result one person had to kill another. I definitely feel that it is in everyones best interest to get the straight dope on what happened. If Zimmerman violated his ccw by illegally brandishing his weapon and used arrest powers that he doesn't have, that's a big deal. If trayvon Martin attacked Zimmerman And forced him to stand his ground and the lesson is you fugg with someone at your own risk, that is also a big deal. With regards to this video: the article states that the video shows no obvious injuries to Zimmerman. Semantically, this is true. However, it is only true because the image is not of high enough resolution to show almost ANYTHING. this is an example of the media taking a piece of information and crafting their headline around their desired narrative. There is no WAY you could ascertain how severe of a head injury was on the back of zimmermans head. There is no way, at the angle shown, that you can see whether his nose is swollen or not. I'm sure they took pictures of his injuries for the possible court proceedings. Those will be a little thing called evidence. All it takes is a photo of Zimmerman the next day with two black eyes and you know he got his nose broken. Furthermore, Mark, it is irrelevant if you or anyone else think George zimmerman is 100% innocent beyond a reasonable doubt. Rather, the opposite is true, sir. Do you believe, beyond a reasonable doubt, that George zimmerman is GUILTY? That is the relevant question. Everything else is speculative noise.
-
A Witness Speaks........
NATCH! See above for edited post. Keep in mind that what we THINK transpired and what we FEEL about the case matter not at all. The only relevant thing is what can be PROVEN about what transpired in a court of law.
-
A Witness Speaks........
With all due respect, I didn't offer a theory. You asked how the law would affect z if he had pulled his gun before the altercation with regards to syg and self defense. I offered my interpretation. If Zimmerman brandished a firearm illegally at the outset, he is in the commission of a crime. You offered an awful lot of "what ifs" in your response post. If Zimmerman put his hands on Martin first, he is the aggressor. Martin may defend himself and stand his ground. However, once Martin gains the upper hand and is in a position to kill Zimmerman, zim is protected under self defense if he attempts to flee but is restricted from retreat by martins blows. If Zimmerman reasonably believed he would be killed if he didn't use deadly force(since he couldn't retreat), he should be protected under syg. Unless you believe that George Zimmerman should have allowed trayvon martin to kill him because he was "wrong" for initiating the conflict. If it is true that Zimmerman was subdued, prevented from retreating and was in danger of death then deadly force may have been justified.
-
A Witness Speaks........
I think in this case, the entire self defense "defense" may go out the window for the following reason. I have to read the law again, but I believe that in order to claim self defense, one must not be in the commission of a crime. If Zimmerman brandished his firearm in order to intimidate Martin into submission, he would have illegally drawn his weapon. At that point, trayvon Martin would be the one standing his ground and Zimmerman possibly guilty of unlawful homicide. Granted, this scenario presupposes that Zimmerman pulled his gun initially contrary to his defense that he drew and fired to stop the threat.
-
A Witness Speaks........
Mark, You bring up an Interesting point about who initiated conflict. With regards to Florida law, this is irrelevant. Stand your ground and self defense do not apply unless you are the aggressor UNLESS you have tried to flee the conflict and retreat and the confronted party restricts your ability to retreat and you have a reasonable belief that your life is in danger if you don't get away or use deadly force to end the confrontation. Let's reread the law. Even if Zimmerman initiated physical contact and Martin proceeded to kick his a**. Is George Zimmerman, when subdued by Martin, now obligated to allow Martin to kill him? This is questionable. I think z has a hard road ahead, but I don't think they will be able to charge him.
-
Not good , not good.
I doubt they'll even notice.