Everything posted by Handyman
-
“Papers Please.”
This answers a question that I asked in another thread. If I am interpreting the above correctly, since we are not required to carry the paperwork, an officer should have basically no expectation that a citizen will be able to prove that a weapon they have in their vehicle actually belongs to them. There are some LEOs on here - what would you do if someone has an FID but something seems fishy? Can you get on the horn to the NJSP and get some kind of serial number lookup in anything close to a timely fashion? Big brother makes us send in the paperwork - is there a database somehwere that puts it to use?
-
Scenario question
Even better - how about the distinction between a long gun (which I can apparently keep in my car all the time, and can do a ton more damage) and a handgun (which heaven forbid I have in the car when I stop to get gas on the way home from the range).
-
Transfer of shotgun
Sorry, I'm not advocating anything. I'm just curious - under what circumstances (outside of being actively investigated for a crime) might one have to prove they own a particular firearm? I'm not a hunter, so I don't know - do hunters routinely cary paperwork when they are out hunting that can demonstrate that a particular firearm belongs to them?
-
Transfer of shotgun
Say he just took the gun, no paperwork. How could the state make an issue of it? Is there a database of gun owners such that when a gun owner dies, someone call and asks about the disposition of the firearm?
-
Scenario question
I guess my main interest was in exploring two points: 1. None of this would be an issue in a state where CCW is accepted. The current laws in NJ make it difficult to get involved or to help, even if you are the type of person who would normally do so. Legislators should appreciate this. 2. If you choose to involve yourself in a situation like this, you'd better be very careful about how you are perceived. Joe Citizen walking around a crime scene with a gun in hand has a higher than average risk of getting two in the chest from a jumpy responding officer. As to any of these scenarios being highly improbable, I hope this becomes the case someday. People are in bad situations in every state every hour of every day. Many of those situations are witnessed by others. The folks who read this board have a better than average chance of having access to a weapon - should they choose to use it - to address those situations. My questions are would you, and do you know the consequences? Someone raised the issue of a man is slapping around his girlfirend in a bar. You intervene. He pulls out a knife. You pull out a gun? Even if this scenario stops here, you are going to prison in NJ.
-
Scenario question
Sounds like there is no sense even carrying a gun on your own property outside of your house, then. I know if I was fixing to attack someone, my attitude might be a little different facing a holstered vs unholstered weapon.
-
Scenario question
On your own property, is there a legal distinction betwen carrying it and pointing it at someone? Or I guess the better question is, if someone is exhibiting threatening behavior outside on your property, can you pull it out to attempt to scare someone away?
-
Scenario question
Thanks! That means a lot, coming from a gun-totin' humanist like you...
-
Scenario question
That isn't the issue at hand. If you get arrested in a bar fight, maybe you get simple assault or disorderly conduct. Worst case here is I get my a** kicked and get a summons for my trouble. The issue here is you see a situation that might warrant deadly force. You are not on your property. For whatever reason you have access to a gun. Do you pull it out? If this does not go well, you are going down with a felony.
-
Scenario question
You'll have to quantify "highly unlikely" for me. Based on your own "shit happens" statement, maybe you should downgrade to plain old "unlikely?" Cops occasionally get their asses kicked. This day probably thousands of people will be injured - and some killed - in violent incidents. Many of these incidents will take place in the light of day. When I was a little kid, a guy across the street spent 10 minutes beating up his wife before the cops finally showed up. She was screaming the entire time. How do you respond? Walk over there with a baseball bat? With nothing? With a gun if you own one? I'll go out on a limb and assume you are probably cavalier because you are single. And lest you worry to much about me being a "not get involved" type of person, I can tell you I have decades of experience as a firefighter and EMS provider. I've involved myself in more crappy situations than you could count on your fingers and toes. In fact, if you met me, you'd probably think I was completely awesome. If I get killed helping someone, so be it. I have a ton of insurance. But if I wind up in the pokey, it's game over for my family. While I would not look forward to re-enacting the love scene from "Deliverance" my primary concern remains my family.
-
Scenario question
I'm suffering from some cognitive dissonance here. You have a great view of humanity, and live in an awesome town. Why, then, do you even own a firearm? I guess to paraphrase, you don't really like to consider the potential consequences of your actions. People like Ayoob are pretty clear in teaching that you'd better consider potential consequences of firearm ownership. Just pulling that piece out - not even shooting someone, just pulling it out - might be a life-changing event. Income is not my issue. I consider the primary responsibility in my life to be the welfare of my family. God, fate, nature or karma (whatever you choose to believe in) delivered these people into my care. After their security and welfare are assured, I'll make the rest of the world a better place. If it is in my power to control it, I won't do something that would leave them without a home, food, insurance, or prospects for a better future. In real life, you and I are probably not really far apart in our beliefs. I raised these cases in the hope that some of the dickheads who work for people like Lautenberg troll these boards. What would the esteemed senator say is the right thing to do in these cases? I'd wager you would never get him to answer.
-
Scenario question
Maybe we are just coming from different places. Here are my hypothetical life circumstances: Say I am a relatively young attorney, the sole income for my family. I make a good income, but I also accumulated a ton of student debt to get where I am today. If I get convicted of a felony, I will not only go to jail, I will lose my license and be disbarred and thereby be prevented from ever working in my profession again. My best hope after my release from prison is likely a minimum wage job in some offender reentry program. While I am incarcerated, my wife and four kids will have to go on public assistance and sell essentially everything we own to keep from literal starvation. We will likely never own a home. My kids' education will be seriously in question. Still think it is a good idea for me to be a cowboy? If the laws of this state are not really interested in providing me an opportunity to help, I am not super interested in helping.
-
Scenario question
Monroe Township must be a utopia - how are the real estate prices? I can think of two very affluent Morris County towns where multiple family members have been killed by a deranged family member. These people had neighbors. Cops never have anyone resist arrest? The episodes you see on the "Cops" TV show are the ones that end happily. The others you read about as a line of duty death in the paper. Hypothetical situations are used to consider how a situation might be addressed in a number of settings, including places like law school, medical school and in the military. If you think these are scenarios are outside of the realm of possibility, I hope that will truly be the case in your life.
-
Scenario question
Interesting. I'm not sure how this would be practically applied. In the police officer scenario, it would be legally defensible for me to load a pistol on a public street and brandish it to drive off the attackers? (Hoping, by the way that other responding officers or armed citizens do not mis-interpret the situation and kill me?) Even if it went well, I'm not sure how this would play out. I can't imagine a jury would convict me, but I don't have $50,000 to give to a lawyer to find out. When the law allows for the protection of "others" is others anyone, or just family members? If I hear people screaming and shot fired three houses down the street, I might have a defensible legal right to arm myself and go to that location?
-
Scenario question
Please read carefully. The fact is neither of my scenarios involved myself or my family. They involved an unrelated neighbor and a police office that I presumably would not know from Adam. Your desire to defend your family is admirable, and I share that desire. I am asking would you risk your family's welfare to defend a stranger?
-
Scenario question
Precisely. Read the posts on this forum. People are terrified to drive home from a store with a freaking box of bullets in the car. Law abiding citizens are afraid to have an adjustable stock delivered to their house for the 10 minutes it would take to pin it. It's easy to be a paper (or internet) tiger, but in real life what would you do? If you are terrified of accidently dropping a hollow point in your trunk, would you really shoot someone? It sounds terrible to say, but is it worth the risk to you and your family? To those who think these scenarios are outlandish, I'm not sure what world you live in, but you certainly are not watching the same nightly news I am...
-
Scenario question
Very few, actually. But in their place, I got a double dose of self-preservation instinct. Unfortunaltely, I'm not in a good financial position to run up a $100,000 legal bill and go to jail. Doing so would cause my family to starve to death. When I was a young, single guy maybe I would have chanced doing the right thing. In NJ, it does not pay to do the right thing - it pays to not get involved. I'm not saying that is a happy state of affairs. Ask Kitty Genovese how she liked the "don't get involved" mindset. I didn't say I would not intervene at all. I would do the legal thing - call the cops and hope for the best when they show up (in 10 minutes). Following the incident, I would also be very happy to explain to the Star Ledger that I probably could have effectively intervened but the laws of our great state would not permit it.
-
Scenario question
Here's another scenario. I know what I would like to do, but I am ashamed to say I don't know if would do it... While driving directly home from your practice session at the range (not stopping to eat or go to the bathroom) you see a police officer in distress on the ground at the side of the road. It appears he made a traffice stop. Three young males have gotten out of their vehicle. Two are punching and kicking him in the torso and head and the third is trying to get the officer's gun out of its holster. You are well-trained and have a handgun and plenty of ammo in the trunk. Do you intervene? Or do the only legally defensible thing in NJ and just keep driving on by? Or how about this: After not stopping to help the above officer, you are safely home in your garage and have just finished cleaning your pistol. As you are preparing to case everything up, you hear your next door neighbors screaming. A female goes running into her back yard, covered in blood and slash wounds. Close on her heels is a crazed male with an 11inch chef knife screaming "I am going to kill you!" Though not on your property, this incident is taking place 20 yards away. Do you intervene? Or stay "retreated" in your dwelling as the law asks? Most ranting liberals I know have a help everybody, save the world mentality. I'm sure it would feel nice to save a life, but I'm not sure I am willing to do it if it would risk a prison sentence and cause my family to lose its source of income.
- Coming soon to NJ.......
-
Two of three gun convictions in controversial N.J. handgun case overturned
A man much wiser than all of us once declared that an unjust law is no law at all....
-
LEO or Lawyer question - firearms were taken away by law for non-crime related
Seriously? Guilty until proven innocent?
-
At least he responded...
Still no response from Lautenberg? Someone better check a pulse on the old wretch. I have a feeling he might be like the guy in "Weekend at Bernies." Every time that addled old imbecile farts, a cloud of dust comes out...
-
Neighbors Property (Hypothetical)
If you see someone murdering your neighbor on their front lawn, it sounds like your best bet is to shoot them from your own front lawn...
-
Buying AR rifle out of state
Getting DLs in two different states is usually pretty easy. Get a DL for the Virginia address which will require you to surrender your NJ DL card. Then come back to the Dirty Jerz, go to the DMV, tell them your license is lost and get a replacement card...
-
Firearms taken into evidence!?!?
If you think a hatchet-murderer rapist is about to break into your residence, the best legal chance you stand in NJ is to put your home defense weapon in your mouth and pull the trigger. That way, at least you won't feel the hatchet and raping...