Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

jackandjill

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by jackandjill

  1. I am not contending on the training, testing, bcs. What I am contending is pitfalls of letting Feds setup a "Permit System" with "highest standards" to satisfy NJ. THAT would be heavy infringing of other 49 states. Leave the permitting (or constitutional) aspects to States, which is where it belongs. Feds deal with interstate issues, which is where the Reciprocity Issue belongs.
  2. ^^^^ Sorry to disagree. National Carry Permit is more infringing for reasons that could take a book to elaborate. Least of which is any NCP crafted to serve NJ ridiculous "highest" standard would do nothing but validate the NJ "standard" and finally make that standard as a national standard. NCP would further the "recording keeping" of firearm owners etc at the Fed level, not something many recommend to further handover to Feds. Lets step back and remember, nothing can solve NJ problems, nothing should solve NJ problems but NJ itself. National Carry bills proposed strike the balance of using existing Fed powers carefully while sticking it to states like NJ. They will put NJ in a bind. If NJ wants to get creative with it, then so be it. I dont advise handing the keys over to NJ in "anticipation" of what NJ might do. With NC, NJ existing justifiable-need WILL FALL.
  3. The "commerce clause" is a done deal, already giving Feds enormous powers to the extent that they can (and have) control if you can grow vegetables, in your backyard, for your own consumption. We know we are not going back. Might as well take advantage of it. Read text of those bills you referenced above. Most of them have language "any firearm that is passed / involved in interstate commerce". So smart lawyers (the authors of these bills) are making this as Feds controlling an item that was involved in an interstate commerce. Exact same "loophole" used in the Gun Free Zone act (amended).
  4. People to DC: Can you hear us now ?
  5. ^^^ And there is a work around for that without dramatically disturbing the State's rights. Using the commerce clause, which almost every one of these Pending Bills have. My understanding is that Commerce Clause was successfully used to dramatically increase Feds power (there is another recent thread on that topic).
  6. I asked in other thread. Is there a recent national Bill introduced (and rejected or sitting somewhere) for National Reciprocity ? Edit: Looks like John Cornyn introduced something 2015.
  7. I think we are too stuck in the "permit" mind set. By agreeing to the concept of State Issued Permit, we have invariably made this a State issue. When its really not. 2A says its right of People to keep and bear arms with strong language "shall not be infringed". As a Citizen each person also has right to freely pass through and travel without burden. Limiting that travel is NOT up to the state, and neither enforcing the "free passage" is against State right, isnt it ? IF State's rights trump important rights such as 2A, then we have to go back and undo about 90% of all federal laws. Or we may have to get SCOTUS rule on the "bear" part of the 2A.
  8. We are a LOOONG way from blaming State's rights for lack of National Carry. Gun Free Zone act (and numerous other infringements) were based on either "commerce clause" or "general welfare" responsibility of Feds. For example, if Gun Free Zone act is NOT infringing on State's rights because it uses "involved in interstate commerce", then it can / should equally be used to justify National Carry. Whats good for the goose is good for gander.
  9. If she has any integrity, we wouldnt be in this situation to begin with. Not only will she NOT return any money, she will NOT goto jail, and will be back on HO job of bending over for the Arabs.
  10. Welcome Tom.
  11. ^^^ Interesting interpretation and extrapolation of common sense...... " Although Filburn's relatively small amount of production of more wheat than he was allotted would not affect interstate commerce itself, the cumulative actions of thousands of other farmers just like Filburn would certainly become substantial. Therefore, according to the court, Filburn's production could be regulated by the federal government."
  12. Following the thread (and assuming it can stand ground at SCOTUS), if every Gun can potentially fall into "move on interstate" argument, whats stopping Feds from requiring FFL/NICS for transactions between two private individuals ? Is that the basis for yet to come "Universal Background Checks" discussion ? or something else ? Couldn't that same argument be made for National Carry Reciprocity ?
  13. Did I misread this. The first sentence appear to say guns made in the state are NOT subject to Fed but then you say even if you build gun from local material its subject to fed law.
  14. I recently looked up the Gun Free School Zone act of 1990. Apparently SCOTUS declared it unconstitutional back in the day and the law was word smithed in 1996. What happens if one purchases locally manufactured firearm that never crossed stateline ? Does it still fall under "interstate commerce" clause ? -------- Provisions[edit] 18 U.S.C. § 922(q)(2)(A) states: It shall be unlawful for any individual knowingly to possess a firearm that has moved in or that otherwise affects interstate or foreign commerce at a place that the individual knows, or has reasonable cause to believe, is a school zone. 18 U.S.C. § 922(q)(3)(A) states: Except as provided in subparagraph (B), it shall be unlawful for any person, knowingly or with reckless disregard for the safety of another, to discharge or attempt to discharge a firearm that has moved in or that otherwise affects interstate or foreign commerce at a place that the person knows is a school zone.
  15. This is expected. People who cry "profiling" and "injustice" are the ones here engaged in profiling and harassment.
  16. Post#22......"Unfortunately, the days of discretion are largely gone. We have become a litigious society. We have become society of fear & terror for no apparent reason. Largely it has become a business. Right or wrong, body-cams are in and common sense is out. ". Not sure where you got the impression that I was blaming cops. Prosecutors - absolutely. They have much more discretion and we have prominent cases where prosecutorial discretion was used heavily. I am reiterating the fact that whole system has changed since the good ol' days. Goes back to topic of this discussion - why this dude gets 5 years and someone like Aitken gets 7+. Interestingly, tone of this thread appear to show "we" seem to think Aitken deserves 7+ years and its justified for the real criminal to get 5 years, because it resulted in further convictions. And thats a shame.
  17. 50cents for me. The other half of sign said something about "Prison 2016". BTW, came across some "news" on how folks are getting creating and using mouse traps etc to deter desperate people from stealing Trump signs.
  18. Update: Looks like its a Retired Cop who shot the robber.... http://www.nj.com/bergen/index.ssf/2016/10/retired_nypd_cop_shoots_armed_robber_in_north_jers.html
  19. Isnt our $8 going to hauling that zombie to/from home ?
  20. I didnt mean to imply anything about you.
  21. The way I read this. 1. They raided all coffers and spent all the money 2. Nobody would let them borrow without some solid guarantee 3. What better guarantee than a constitutional "promise" of keeping future taxes in a fund Sweeney loves it because it bring 12B borrowed money into "transportation" projects, which we all know are littered with contracts to friends and family And in practice, there is no guarantee that the funds are not going to be used for something else. Transportation and NJTransit are generic enough umbrellas to burn money on pet projects. I could be totally wrong.
  22. I am not sure if any of this should be directed at LE. We, as society are responsible for this mess. Unfortunately, the days of discretion are largely gone. We have become a litigious society. We have become society of fear & terror for no apparent reason. Largely it has become a business. Right or wrong, body-cams are in and common sense is out. Legal system, being part of society, invariably followed suit. Kids not happy with parents, Cops show up. Husband and Wife argues, Cops show up. Neighbor called on you for cleaning guns outside, Cops show up. A member at the eating club is a PC, Cops show up. And when they show up, they are trained follow the law, arrest & record on body-cam. If they dont, they will end up on TV. Prosecutors got their careers lined up and measured by number of convictions under the belt, common sense be damned. There is plenty of blame to go around, but the current legal system is a net that will catch anything and everything it gets, people's lives be damned. Either you have to bargain away with a bigger fish or have enough money and power to fight it. And thats how your average law abiding firearm owner who pissed his mother off got 10 years. And the dude who sold guns to drug dealers got 5 years. Simple. On a side note, I never understood why everyone assume there needs to be "trust" between Citizens and LE. LE is not a personal psychologist, a butler, a rabbi or a mom. Professional & decent interaction is the only one that must be afforded and expected in return. Anything more is just setting up for disappointment.
  23. We will go in circles here. But any Prosecutor worth his/her salt will tell you, they will take what they can get. There is no such thing as "genuine criminal vs other criminal". For them, simple question is "did you violate the law" and what can you (or your lawyer) bargain away. They may feel bad for you if you are first time offender or got jacked up for silly reasons. Some times they may cut you a deal even if you dont have anything to offer in return. But make no mistake, most of them will not think twice about charging you with 16 round magazine or box of hollow points you forgot to take out of your trunk, if they got enough facts and evidence. And comment about "Aitken should not have said something to his Mom" is a good example. That proves once legal system is involved, they seldom ask "Is this guy a genuine criminal". They are not out there to "get" average Joe on purpose, but they wont pass on if opportunity presents itself. Simple as that.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.