Everything posted by jackandjill
-
Need a favor
Since I am one of those armchair lawyers, I am always going (intent) to or from a range that I have membership at (and some silly stuff to prove it such as membership card, couple of targets etc in the trunk), IF I am transporting my firearms (handguns, HP ammo especially). Nothing in code says I have to come back to same residence should I change my mind on the way. I guess real lawyers do it differently.
-
Need a favor
Here is another kicker from Aitken case. To counter the possibility of Brian not meeting 6(g), the Defense tried to show that the defendant was "moving" between houses. If it was not illegal to just "transport stuff" between houses, there would have been no need for such strategy. One of the Jury from that case commented... see the stressing of "moving" aspect... ---------------------- "Why did you make us aware at the start of the trial that the law allows a person to carry a weapon if the person is moving or going to a shooting range, and during the trial both the defense and prosecution presented testimony as to whether or not the defendant was in the process of moving, and then in your charge for us to deliberate we are not permitted to take into consideration whether or not we believe the defendant was moving?"[16] ----------------------------
-
Need a favor
We are going in circles here.... 2C:39-5(b)(1) makes a blanket statement of possession of handgun illegal and crime of second degree. So there you have it.. in writing. Now, we have the blanket statement, show me an exception to that with respect to OP question. As I said earlier, this is an academic discussion more than anything else. What might happen in practicality is different. --------------------- As to the case involving debate about moving between houses - Brian Aitken case comes to mind.. Quick copy / paste from the google search.. Lot of interesting bits , but one fact is, he was charged with the BS we are discussing.. Nappen Comments / Quotes from the case: "New Jersey Statute 2C:39-6e allows a person to possess firearms when moving between one residence and another. as long as the firearms are unloaded and locked in the trunk of the vehicle. as required by N.J.S. 2C:39-6g. Brian complied with this transportation requirement during his move between his parents' house and his new apartment. However, the judge presiding in the case refused to read this possessory exemption to the jury despite counsel's demands and repeated requests by the jury to learn of the firearm possession exemptions." "The Firearms Owner's Protection Act, 18 U.S.C. 926A, protects persons traveling with firearms between two locations where their firearms are lawfully possessed, if they comply with the transportation requirements. As with the New Jersey exemptions, the judge of the court below refused to read this exemption to the jury, deciding for himself that this provision did not apply and that Brian was not entitled to its protection." Right, wrong or indifferent, there is/was atleast one Judge out there who (mis)interpreted the topic at hand.. and I am aware what happened to that Judge... Whats not clear to me is if this case sets legal precedence around moving between houses..
-
Need a favor
2C:39-6, subsection f talks about ranges - "....in going to or from a place of target practice...." . So range to range could be satisfied, as you are going TO the second range. Slightly offtopic, but the dreaded (locked, direct to / from etc) subsection (g) only talks about b(2), e and f(1,3). It does not seem to apply to subsection f(4). Not that its useful for a regular Joe, but.... ---------------------------------- Subsection f(4): (4)A person from keeping or carrying about a private or commercial aircraft or any boat, or from transporting to or from such vessel for the purpose of installation or repair a visual distress signaling device approved by the United States Coast Guard.
-
Bug repellent?
Did anyone try Permethrin, sprayed on clothes, dry and then wear ? Apparently, military uniforms are treated with it.
-
Need a favor
^^^^ Yes, thats what the client lawyer buddy would say, and he would be correct, in my opinion.
-
Need a favor
Every interpretation of these things is an "opinion" unless backed up by a specific case law that matches exact scenario and circumstances. Even what NJSP tells you is only an opinion. We can beat this bush all day, but the write FACT is, section e that Kevin125 quoted goes to great lengths enumerating possibilities, including - "between one place of business or residence and another when moving, " They could have left that "when moving" part out.. , but they didnt. Who knows what authors was thinking ? Lets not mix "storing", "staging" with carrying (transporting) from/to between different locations. There is no limitation to number of properties / places one can own and accordingly store and carry at that location (subject to any other limitations). But how do you get your handguns to that location, is another matter.
-
Need a favor
Cops can and have provided direction in contrast to written law, especially when done in the interest of the larger community. That does not guarantee same / similar protections in a different situation. They can and will choose to prosecute under different circumstances. Unless someone can show a written law to the contrary, OPs client lawyer buddy is right. Will they prosecute an otherwise lawabiding Joe for such thing ? there is only one way to find out..
-
Defendant living out of a Van
PK90, I thought JohnnyB response was with regard to "fixed place of business". I get that. I am inquiring about Motor Home being used as exempted location under 2C:39:-6, specially "residence, premises or other land owned or possessed by him,".
-
Defendant living out of a Van
Does a "Motor Home" as defined by NJ DMV stand better chance in this type of situation ?
-
Defendant living out of a Van
Interesting. I assume he is resident of NJ and not passing through. If were I were to be on the jury, this is a non-issue, let the person go his way. He already has enough stuff in life to deal with. I personally believe there is hope in favor of the Defendant, with the usual disclaimer that this is NJ.
-
Defendant living out of a Van
I assume no FPID then, and/or this is for handguns. Can a reasonable person (Jury) be convinced that its a residence, dwelling, premise, or place of business ? A mobile home with various amenities - may be. A regular van - unlikely.
-
Cars / Trucks - Is front license plate required ?
Lately, on the way to work, I have noticed couple of trucks (pick up style) on the road without front license plate (back is NJ). I see them almost every day on the way to work. The other day, I saw a Police Car on the corner and a truck without front license plate drove past and no one was pulled over. So, are front license plates required by law ?
-
Does eliminating this iconic symbol achieve anything? (or What's this world coming to?)
BTW, now that the flag discussion is coming to an end (with everyone piled on it), carefully placed "news", "opinions" articles started to come out on "Gun" debate and reasonable restrictions discussion.
-
OGAM exemption timeline
It took about two weeks (dont ask why) for my local PD to send the paperwork to NJSP... then two weeks at NJSP.
-
Need advise - weight loss medication
The following is the disclaimer mentioned on the front page of the mentioned drug. I know every drug has some side effects and NJ has ridiculous (and outright unconstitutional) process, but not sure how a Doc can write a letter for firearms with this disclaimer. And if PD will accept it. I am not suggesting any one of us will experience the said side effects, nor am I judging or implying things. Regardless of facts and circumstances, its all about perception, unfortunately. CONTRAVE can cause serious side effects of suicidal thoughts or actions. One of the ingredients in CONTRAVE is bupropion HCl. Bupropion has caused some people to have suicidal thoughts or actions or unusual changes in behavior, whether or not they are taking medicines used to treat depression. Bupropion may increase suicidal thoughts or actions in some children, teenagers, and young adults within the first few months of treatment. If you already have depression or other mental illnesses, taking bupropion may cause it to get worse, especially within the first few months of treatment.
-
Dealing with Antis on FB need sources for arguments!
Best you can do is challenge them to show up for a range session and meet people. You will not win arguments on internet (much less facebook) with keyboard warriors.
-
Need advise - weight loss medication
You may have to watch out for Question 26 (may be 21, 25, 26 too) on STS-033 form. Your health should be your priority, but I am always wary of any drugs that disclaim side effects such as "suicidal thoughts etc"...Drugs like that tend to cause more issues than problems they solve. In addition to what other posters recommended, if your work/personal life allows, goto middle of nowhere like the national park, and just keep walking .. slow, take your time.. However, if your Doc diagnosed any underlying issues (not just weight gain) that can ONLY be resolved by drugs like that, you know what to do.
-
Laws regarding building a rifle for my dad?
Just to clarify, its not "easy" compared to other states in USA. As FPID holders, you both went through rigorous process of background checks, finger prints, months (if not years) of waiting, having issued a state identification number etc. In addition, you would have (or will) go through the NICS checks for the initial purchase of serialized lower, where its logged at the dealer. As if thats not good enough, you both sign that piece of paper declaring eligibility for the transfer. All that for the pleasure of purchasing and keeping a long gun at home and may be take it to range once in a while. So, compared to other states, NJ drags law abiding citizens through the mud (process) for no apparent benefit to the state or people.
-
Wife, a Convicted Felon, Prevents Husband from Obtaining FPID & Purchase Permits
If you are good enough to live outside and pay taxes, then you should be good enough to exercise your constitutional rights.
-
Because you suck. And we trace you.
To validate the program, isnt it enough for Glock to just collect the coupons provides by Customer instead of going through full 4473 ? Am I missing something here?
-
TIME FOR NEW CELL PHONE & GOOGLE PROJECT FI
With Verizon, we pay 80 for 10GB data and 15 for each smart phone with unlimited voice and text. Not sure if these other plans can beat that.
-
Open Carry Proponent Attacked with Bat in Attempt to Steal His Pistol
Given that NJ doesnt provide any other legal option, is it also stupid for NJ Citizens to Open Carry Unloaded Long Guns with FPID ?
- NICS Denial
-
Short Hills mall carjacker found not guilty of unrelated gun charge
reminds me of Better Call Saul. In all seriousness and with due respect, it puzzles me how some people find good lawyers. Yet we hear law abiding citizens spending thousands of dollars on lawyer to defend against a simple argument with neighbor.