Everything posted by Newtonian
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
What I hate about that .gif is you can't stop it. Or can you?
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
Yes. Well-reasoned post. However, I only brought up Kelo and ACA to illustrate that we can't count on anything from the semi-majority. I did not mention those cases as evidence that the Supremes are vile creatures or that we deserve our "god-given second-amendment rights." If you've followed my many posts, you know that we are in nearly 100% agreement that the only sensible argument for expanding gun rights in this state is experience elsewhere. After all, except for a few backwaters what we all accept as "the right to bear arms" has only existed in this country -- depending on where you calculate the center of mass in states adopting "shall-issue" laws -- for about ten-fifteen years. The 27 year olds I've purchased stuff from in other states don't understand that 30 years ago, the very concept of concealed carry was ludicrous despite the fact that the 2nd Amendment has been there since 1791 (yes, I looked it up). So let's thank the moderators for not moving this thread, although sometimes I wished they would have. Monday, bloody Monday, will tell.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
Vlad, you seem like an intelligent guy. I must hope that you're either a terminal cynic, or are so much smarter than I that you understand these issues more deeply than I'm capable of. Because the alternatives are not very appealing. If by "civilization" you mean places and times that produced Michelangelo, Beethoven, and Shakespeare then bravo. Or are you referring to places and times when individuals were forced to testify against themselves, endured trial by fire (without legal representation or even a codified right to a defense), were executed for petty crimes, and were jailed or killed for expressing themselves? Because those things occurred during "civilized" times in "civilized" places. If you go back further, so did outright religious persecution, crucifixion, and fully sanctioned mass murder (see Constantinople). Having only the rights that you can convince others you have -- another masterpiece of cynicism -- reduces every attempt at codifying, enjoying, and fighting for rights to barbarism. Because what do people do when others remain unconvinced? They attack, beat, kill, and bomb them. That is how many real and perceived violations of "rights" are resolved today. (And please, no lectures on the U.S. bombing Iraq. Nowhere near the same thing.)
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
I agree that the constitution, and our rights, have been under constant assault due to actions of government at all levels. Fighting dictatorship creep is a constant battle, consuming precious resources with no guarantee of victory. Yet to say we have "ignored" the constitution is easily contradicted by fact. Why do you think the Supreme Court and lower courts hear all these cases every year? Somebody, at some level, cares. Your examples: Direct election of senators (17th Amendment), taxation (Article 1, section 8; 16th Amendment). Slavery was legal because Africans were property. Correct about RICO, gold confiscation, Japanese internment. I also agree that we cannot rely on constitutional (or theologic) "right to bear arms" arguments with individuals who believe neither in God nor the rule of law. I've argued many times for arguing on the basis of experience in other states. However, to call the Constitution a "piece of paper" is to hold a view of law that is incompatible with civilization. Without getting too dramatic, Soviet authorities, including the judiciary, ignored their constitution without even the modicum of challenges we enjoy here, to disastrous effect. What's off the table for you in terms off absolute rights? Criticizing, or simply telling the truth, about certain groups already disqualifies us from a range of occupations. Even leftists are not immune, much less centrists or conservatives. Ask Larry Summers, Alec Baldwin, and (in the afterlife) Christopher Hitchens. It will not be long before this cultural and mostly private practice becomes codified, as the thought police recruits graduate from the academy and flock to the legislatures and judiciary. Without first amendment guarantees, as practiced say 40 years ago, speech becomes a cheapened entitlement that government eventually disburses like food stamps, only differing by virtue of the qualification process. Despite centuries of mayors, colonels, governors, and legislators usurping our rights at the point of a gun, at least we have plain language laws to point to. Without those absolute rights we have nothing with which to challenge them except for an antique, a moving target, a rapidly disintegrating "mystical tablet."
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
The demographics are indeed bleak, and getting bleaker. But as I've pointed out several times, here and in other forums, enough democrats are vulnerable. If gun owners and their families voted we could win enough seats to take back the legislature.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
1. The constitution provides for government to take property under fifth amendment, but says quite clearly: "nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation." For centuries this was generally taken to mean to build roads, bridges, in some cases municipal buildings and the like. New London condemned that property for PRIVATE use. Citizens did NOT receive just compensation. It was as clear as day. Why do you think the case went to the Supreme Court?? 2. This one's on you. Please show me where the Constitution authorizes the federal government to take over the healthcare industry -- or any other industry. Where does it give the Feds the power to void contracts entered freely and lawfully, and to force citizens to purchase a product under penalty of law. "If you laahk yo' plan, yoooo can keep yo' plan. Badda boom." I could respect an honest disagreement: "yeah, it's unconstitutional, but it will turn out ok so the end justifies the means." But we're learning that even that particular fantasy is just that. 3. I was making a joke, unlike you who scolded me for using Kelo and the AFA to illustrate a point. I repeat. The appreciation for all our rights in this forum is sadly lacking.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
I'm a scientist by training. I believe in facts, experience, probabilities, and above all demographics. I've got little faith in a system that has failed us on so many occasions (dare I mention Obamacare, and Kelo vs. New London, or is the Central Scrutinizer, Vlad the Impaler, reading this and should I thereby be afeared?). I also hold a very broad appreciation for constitutional rights. As I've written several times, it's more than fukcing guns. Much more. I have even less faith in where a country that will create 20 million new democrat voters within a few years, which whoever wins in 2016, is inevitable. Not to mention millions on millions of stupid, indoctrinated semi-literates graduating from college. I repeat: The gains in favor of gun rights since 1987 were largely a result of legislative action. The court victories have been few and far between. Popular support for the gun culture is vastly, vastly over-estimated in these forums and elsewhere. The courts, as society in general, are moving inexorably leftward. Yet every post I make for change that's predicated on voting meets silence. You can stand on your chairs and yell and scream and call names all you want, you can post and send Loretta Weinberg all the fukcen emails you like. Go ahead, declare that you will "not comply." (I'd love to see the turds falling out of your pants when they come for you, which eventually, they will). But if you and your family members don't vote you might as well shit nickels with Geronimo's likeness on them, the good it will do. The younger members of these boards will, by the time they are my age, see the reverse of the famous .gif file that shows states' adoption of shall-issue concealed carry. We're at the apex now, guys. Unless you get off your asses and stop listening to the various experts, and start a grassroots electoral effort, this is as good as it gets. EVEN if all our prayers are answered in this particular case, it's not over. Not by a long shot.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
I hope you're right, but I think you underestimate anti-gun (or at least anti-2A sentiment) sentiments. I just saw a photo the other day of the son of the sfaceme himself carrying a shotgun. "I support the second amendment," they all scream and yell. Bet you $10 that the majority opinion upholding NJ Law (assuming the case is even heard) will include some mention of respecting the nonexistent "hunting clause" of the 2nd Amendment, or that "several of us are in fact owners of firearms." Heller had nothing to do with CC. However, is it possible to rule on Drake by re-affirming McDonald? If that's what you're saying, then maybe you're right. But even in that unlikely case, you can bet "confiscate, confiscate, confiscate" will not go gently into that good night. They will put up every conceivable barrier you can think of. They can probably stretch the procedural hurdles until 2017. Then they'll pass a five year waiting period, require 300 hours of training, charge a $599 fee, good for 12 months, magazine restrictions that essentially outlaw every gun ever invented. Each barrier will be fought in court, of course, and take many months.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
If you read the news after the case was decided, you'd know that Roberts was playing politics the whole way. He did not want a 5-4 decision, and stated so. He was basically brow-beaten by the court's liberal wing and the administration. His reasoning, that the law violated the commerce clause but not taxing authority, was generally regarded as disingenuous. Even the liberal press was surprised that Roberts found an excuse -- taxation -- that the US Government's attorney had not proposed. Had they gone even deeper into the law, there were issues regarding contracts (e.g. health insurance policies) that the law nullified. Under similar logic you should have no gripe at all with NJ-style gun policy going nation-wide. The 2nd Amendment says nothing about being outdoors. You can "keep" and "bear" to your heart's delight anywhere on your property or domicile. Any gun law can thereby be considered reasonable regulation. Again, I'm astounded at how narrowly so many posters view liberty. Eliminating, in one fell swoop, the health insurance industry, the private contracts between insurers and customers, while forcing individuals to purchase a product, is not merely "bad law."
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
You're giving the court way too much credit. If they believed in the 2nd amendment's plain language, at some point this group would have welcomed a true test case. The court is as political as any other branch of government. The "conservatives" wave the constitution around and talk of original intent. Then they give you the Kelo ruling. These are all big-government guys. Were Roberts' contortions to pass Obamacare not sufficient evidence? The second amendment is not a big deal to them. They feel, "46 states already have liberal concealed carry laws. If NJ wants them they'll elect representatives to reflect that desire." CC is a relatively recent phenomenon. Despite the 2nd Amendment's wording, shall-issue CC was not considered a "constitutional right" until relatively recently. Most states obtained CC through legislative action, not by court order.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
Absolutely. The justices who wish to hear the case, and possibly to overturn the lower court's decision, may be Republicans, and they may be vilified in the press as "ultra right-wing conservatives," but they are not all libertarians. Remember Kelo vs. New London. That case, from the perspective of constitutional law, was at least as important as this one. I'm telling you, beware northeast law-and-order justices of immigrant stock who wave the constitution when it suits them.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
OK, it's all very clear: http://www.scotusblog.com/?p=204909 says Drake vs. J. is still pending and http://www.supremecourt.gov/ clearly lists April 25 as the next date when they may get to this matter. So let's all hold our horses for a week. If they get to it we'll have a lot to say either way. Until then there's not much to post here that hasn't already been posted.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
Can someone who understands what's going on please explain what happened, in plain English, no abbreviations or Latin?
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
I'm sure many NY permit holders thought something similar, "Well at least they didn't touch concealed carry." The goal is achived in degrees. I think what you mean is "your carry permit would be a p2p." But I don't even think that will happen. Even if they omit the justifiable need, they can still keep the p2p system, change to OGPY or add any other impediment they like. Look at what they did in NY.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
This is very informative. Do you know if they stop voting after 4 yeas? Do they disclose who votes (I would doubt it)? Order of seniority: Roberts (chief justice votes first, regardless of seniority), Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, Ginsburg, Breyer, Alito, Sotomayor, Kagan. Thinking through this list...I don't think so guys.
-
S532 Title: Strengthens State's assault weapons ban.
There is only one solution: vote them out of office. We could do it. I went through the numbers of vulnerable democrat legislators, gun owners, voter participation percentages, margins of victory, etc. It's more than possible. We need a network of election volunteers to work in those "vulnerable" districts. Organization. Ask gun shops to carry literature and remind customers to vote...and urge their spouses to vote. Instead of killing a day going to Trenton, spend that day xeroxing fliers and talking to gun shop management. "If we don't get out the vote you could go out of business" is a pretty good start to a fruitful exchange of ideas. Griping here won't do it. Nor will emailing them or calling their offices, or threatening and lecturing them during public testimony. Tony Colandro is a great guy, but "I will not comply" has two effects: laughter and even firmer resolve to fukc NJ gun owners. Don't be surprised if this proposed legislation wasn't some sort of payback. Breaking news: THEY DON'T LISTEN and WE ARE A MINORITY in this state. 12% gun ownership rate, one of the lowest in the U.S. Most people in NJ only think about guns when they hear of a shooting. At best they don't give a crap. At worst they probably believe as an educated, "conservative" 50-year-old member of my family recently told me, chuckling, "Don't you think the 'right to carry a gun' is a bit outdated?" If they are not voted out we are definitely screwed in 2017. Every single one of these cockamamie bills will not only pass, but the next governor is 100% certain to sign every one. 10-round mag, 7-round mag, before you know it six-shooters will become assault weapons.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
Please explain. The DC ruling didn't help us and, as far as I can see, didn't do much for Washingtonians either. You heard about the guy who was dragged into court because of a non-functional shotgun round? This thread has totally ignored one outcome. Let's say everything goes rosy and, some time this fall, every newspaper in NJ runs the headline, "SCOTUS Rules Against NJ Gun Laws." We will all be happy. But the scumbags who occupy our legislature will not be happy. They will drag their feet, delay, and introduce equally draconian requirements that will require another court case. The lower courts will decide that the new restrictions don't violate the SCOTUS ruling, and it will go back to the Supremes, who by then (around 2022 or so) will be 7-3 liberal. You can guess the outcome.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
Many of their conferences are mysterious and private. Probably quite a bit of psychology going on with a case this important.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
I don't know the mechanism by which the justices decide. Does everyone secretly write their vote on an index card, which they all pull out of their robes on the count of three? Or do they announce their votes consecutively, through a roll call? If this is the case, it would take balls for a liberal to be the fourth and deciding vote. Or do they sit around and debate it, to the point where everyone knows what everyone else will do? In my opinion the only good outcome would result from the five non-liberals eagerly deciding to hear the case.
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
If only four justices are interested in hearing it, that implies that five were not. That they were happy to let current law stand. If that's the case, the chances of one or more coming over to the side of sanity after hearing the case are slim to none. We will lose 4-5. I believe they won't hear the case. The two immigrant law-and-order northeast Republicans (Alito and Scalia) are by no means sure votes. By no means. And don't be surprised, if they do hear the case, that one or the other or both write an opinion, separate from that of the four liberals, opinion upholding NJ law.
- I'm a sucker for Fine Looking Italians
-
What Will SCOTUS Do
If it's not heard the outcome is obvious. Don't count on Scalia and Roberts. They're both big-government Republicans. 100% minus. If by some stroke of luck they decide to hear the case -- and that's nowhere near certain -- it's equally obvious that in the case of a 4-5 decision to hear it we lose. Nobody's changing their mind on this issue. 94.281777323% minus. If it's a 5-4 decision to hear it, and nobody dies before September except for those three liberal hags, and assuming they're not just playing around, we win. 53.92843205938% plus. If you're putting money on this, your own money, keep your bet to $20 or less because it's fairly hopeless. In short, we are fukced. Move out of this pathetic state. NOT JUST FOR GUNS....for everything. Just move out.
-
Exploding Guns...VERY graphic
This was a fantastic thread. I learned something: Never assume anything.
-
Just One More Reason To Leave This State
OK I see. You da man, Chloroform, err. Phosgene.
-
Just One More Reason To Leave This State
Great post, so full of meaning for me. You mean "gatz-o!"?? (Italian for almost nothing). Or "1,000 dollars"? My wife always corrects me when I say "broad." I am partial to the term. My boss at Blimpies, 40 years ago, was fond of saying, "sucked, fukced, and blowed."