Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Newtonian

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Newtonian

  1. It's impossible to tell the elapsed time from the news reports. I doubt he had time to make a conscious decision. Should his (correct) reaction been automatic? I'd like to think it should have been but we know very little about the mechanics of this specific accident. No it's not "ok to wave a gun around" but in the tens of millions of circumstances each and every day where individuals pick up a gun it's bound to happen a couple of times, training or no training. Simple statistics. What I would say is that "one in a million it's going to hit you just right and in that instance your reflexes become more important than your training. Sure you can lower the odds by training. You can train a few hours per month to reduce the risk from 1 in 10,000 to 1 in 50,000. You can train four hours per day every day to reduce the odds from 1 in 50,000 to 1 in 100,000, or train 8 hours a day to reduce the risk to 1 in a million. You can spend your whole life mitigating or reducing risks of incidents that will never happen in 100 lifetimes. But no amount of training will reduce the risk to zero. That is the crux of my argument. Risk. You remind me of a chess buddy who used to rag on fellow expert players for losing to scrubs and brag that it never happened to him. "You can always play safe and eventually he'll make a mistake and lose." Well one day he was playing an 80 year old guy who, according to the rating charts, he should beat 999 times out of 1000 games. Ten minutes into the game, on move 12, Mr. Expert resigned. He didn't play badly. The other guy just happened to stumble on 4-5 grandmaster moves in a row by accident. Shit happens.
  2. I do a lot of work through British PR firms, mostly for arranging interviews with big European companies. Today a woman who is paid big bucks to answer editorial queries, and who took 8 days to respond to one from me, blamed it on Brexit, and the "upheaval" it caused. The F-ing Europeans will use any excuse not to work. You can take Britain out of Europe, but you can't take European laziness and excuse-mongering out of the Brits. P.S. The EU, our former Madame Secretary, the Lawn Jockey in Chief, and the Olympics can all drown in their own vomit AFAIC. GO TRUMP!!
  3. And if your finger happens to be on the trigger and you are ready to shoot or quarter-way through your pull when you're startled by something? What happens then? 99.9% nothing. But do you admit an accident is much more likely to occur at this point than if your finger is off the trigger or for chrissake if the gun is on the table? Training aside, have we not now entered the realm of "luck" or more precisely coincidence -- two things happening at the same time? Being a "grown adult" has nothing to do with it. Accept that this was an accident and leave the hapless bastard alone. And stop preaching about your superiority, invulnerability, unsurpassed self-control, and scientifically-proven heat capacities of various shells. I would respect your posts more if you offered to spend 30 minutes going through specific drills with anyone who was interested, for free, than bragging about how this could never happen to you.
  4. I should stop whining because...you got YOUR shirt? I was never whining about YOUR shirt. When did you donate? How many misspellings on the shirt? Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!
  5. And ours is believing that the Constitution covers every circumstance. Not to beat a dead horse but the terror watch lists contain 1.5 million names. How many are for real? Probably a lot less than 1.5 million, but also a lot more than we could reasonably process in a manner that does not trample on liberty "without due process." The question of due process is itself vague -- the constitution leaves it up to us to figure out the details; it's not a set, constitutionally mandated set of procedures as some believe. This is a conundrum of our own creation. I don't know the answer.
  6. Tell you what. I'll meet you at the Starbucks in Hamburg tonight at 7:00. You can see for yourself.
  7. I've had nothing but good luck w/ PayPal and ArmsList. We had one incident where UPS screwed up, and in two other situations I decided not to go through with the transaction because the seller seemed fishy. Other than that I'm 100% happy.
  8. There are interesting similarities between the much-abused abuse designations and the no-fly lists. You can be classified as an abuser or a terror threat for any reason or no reason. It should be easier to disprove the latter based on one's history, much of which these days is documented electronically in some way. Proving you didn't "verbally abuse" (the poor little flower!) a female is impossible. In both cases you don't want the "real deal" to have a gun. Question is how to implement fairly and legally.
  9. There are interesting similarities between the much-abused abuse designations and the no-fly lists. You can be classified as an abuser or a terror threat for any reason or no reason. It should be easier to disprove the latter based on one's history, much of which these days is documented electronically in some way. Proving you didn't "verbally abuse" (the poor little flower!) a female is impossible. In both cases you don't want the "real deal" to have a gun. Question is how to implement fairly and legally.
  10. Thank you. Nobody but you and me seems to believe this though. I think you meant "doesn't" invalidate correct? No more than there being drowning accidents invalidates my belief in water. The Carol Browne comment was for example purposes only. Doesn't really matter if he stabbed or shot or poisoned her. The ease of being designated as such notwithstanding, should domestic abusers be armed? This reminds me of the question about guns and no-fly lists, where the real issue is why we have so many people on that list and not, I believe, in whether someone who would blow up an airplane should own a gun.
  11. It's not much as far as "training" goes. I don't even mention that when people ask. How far should a range go in assuring something like shooting a bystander never happens? CR's orientation doesn't train you for much.
  12. Sorry about that. Not the first time I've had my facts mixed up. OK then, should he have had a gun? And if she'd been given a FID she still wouldn't have been able to carry in her car. No? I realize that was a rare occurrence, but in light of it should domestic 'abusers' own or carry guns? Philosophic question.
  13. We don't want to prohibit domestic abusers from owning guns, yet we mourn for Carol Browne. Wasn't she shot? We blame the father who accidentally shot his. He was evidently not trained or disciplined enough not to have his finger on the trigger. Yet many among us want people to have guns regardless of their training level. In the first case maybe if he knew she was armed he'd have stayed away. OTOH being a crime of passion and murder and everything that goes with it, it's clear he wasn't thinking. So maybe they'd have had a shootout and he would be killed (justice), or maybe she'd be killed. In any event he was a dangerous guy. Were his guns confiscated? Just asking. Although I have a fair amount of training (albeit below average for this group) I don't believe training should be required to exercise your 2A rights. But what if a range, for example required proof of training before allowing individuals to shoot there? What type and level of training would have prevented that calamity? And what level would you require if you owned a for-profit range? An association range? If you were in charge of a public range?
  14. Just saw this on the website: "Under no circumstances should this disclaimer be interpreted as the minutest expression of gratitude real or imagined. You are a New Jersey gun owner and are thereby used to getting it up the ass. Sincerely, POS PO6." So you're probably right.
  15. You're super-human and I applaud you for it. Nothing bad has ever happened to you because you don't allow it. You're trained and disciplined. Your cars all veer away from potential crashes, you're never surprised by the instantaneous smell of metal burning your flesh ("Why it's happened to me 100 times and I've never shot anyone"), your knives never slip, you've never hammered your finger or spilled beer on the rug, you inspect your home's electrical wiring every 30 days, and the only thing that hurts after you fall is the concrete. That's why, being perfectly in control of every twitch your body ever makes, you don't understand that while nobody dies 99.999% of the time a hot shell goes down someone's shirt, one time in 100,000 it happens. It doesn't happen when your gun is on the bench, out of battery, out of ammo; when it's accidentally pointed in a non-lethal direction, when you immediately take your finger off the trigger, etc. In other words you're lucky. Do you train by having people dump hot brass down your shirt? Having somebody stick a hair pin into your kidney? Note this is not the same as deliberately violating safety rules. This was obviously an involuntary act. EVERYBODY makes mistakes. The Intergalactic Seven Gun Champion makes mistakes. If you make one while reading the newspaper nothing bad happens. If you make one while holding a gun that's ready to fire there's a remote possibility that something bad will happen. This time it did. Condemning the father with the obligatory "I feel bad for the family" is the flip side of blaming guns. The main problem with gun-banners is they fail to comprehend the simple facts of statistics and risk. We should know better.
  16. June 10 was 25 days ago. Still waiting. No "thank you," no t-shirt, no patch. Still topless.
  17. Something everyone forgets while assessing blame is that this was an ACCIDENT. You didn't read about the kid who drowned in his wading pool the other day or the guy who fell off the ladder while changing a light bulb did you? We don't know how hot the shell was or his sensitivity to heat. It happened in less than a second. His hand probably jerked around reflexively. Reflexes are beyond our control. Don't say it could never happen to you because you have "close combat training" or any other training. If you believe people should have guns -- and especially that they can own and shoot them with no training -- you have to accept a certain level of risk. The world is not perfect.
  18. * The NJ state senate has decided not to put the override of the most recent gun control bill to a full vote. Thanks to all for emailing your representatives to encourage them to vote exactly the way they would have voted had you not emailed them. Your voice makes a difference. * I've read reports that several Republicans are willing to re-write the bill and vote "yeah". I wonder what we're they're getting in return? A hemorrhoidal massage perhaps. Whatever it is will probably be worth the same to us as the electrons we wasted in emailing them. Get as ye shall give. * I realize that women can get you categorized as an abuser merely for looking at them the wrong way. But what would Carol Brown, the poster-child for arming victims of domestic abuse, think? (I know I misspelled her name -- tough boogers). Maybe we should propose a new law, the "Domestic Shootout Enablement Act of 2016," which arms both abusers and their victims, thus allowing them to settle their disputes peacefully in the privacy of their own driveways. * The more I think about the incident involving that individual who bruises easily and that POS congresswoman the more it rubs me the wrong way. Yeah she sucks big time, but her Visigoth sons' criminal behavior was irrelevant. We regularly entertain notions of redemption when the redeemed profess 2nd Amendment sympathies. Why not for that broodsow's two miscreant children? After all they did use guns to hold up that We-Be-Toys. * This particular dry run for January, 2018 (about 19 months away) is over. I hope y'all enjoyed it as much as I did. Stock up on an appropriate lubricant! And don't forget to email each and every legislator at least a dozen times, say three Hail Marys, two Our Fathers, and an Act of Contrition.
  19. I've been tempted to use this "argument" myself many times. This is why I don't. Reflexive gun haters: These are people whose minds you'll never change, not ever. "Fuck you" is pretty much a conversation-ender so I prefer rejoinders like "so the asshole killed that kid in Flemington because I have guns in MY house, stored and deployed safely?" Or now that I carry that goddamned Phart Smone on me at all times I show them this article as evidence of the utter failure of our criminal justice system and the idiocy of gun laws. Then they call me a racist and I get 10x more fun out of the conversation than if I'd raised the F-finger. Because as you know the only thing worse than a "racist" is a "racist" who loves guns. Politicians (sub-category of mindless haters): This is the only group where a healthy, hearty "Fuck you" is warranted. You're as likely to change their votes as you are of winning the Intergalactic Six-Gun, Laser Category, Championship so have fun. They're in any case despicable so raise your finger with enthusiasm. Even if they're pro-gun they're only whoring for votes and would instantly switch their positions if the winds blew that way. So yes, fuck all of them with a splintery telephone pole, no Crisco. People in the middle: It's amazing how much progress you can make with some people. I take back what I said previously about this being a waste of time. My wife and parents -- all previously deemed hopeless -- now accept my infatuation with the manly arts, and even ask me about it. I'm crossing my fingers that wifey will accompany me to CR's free intro to archery next month. That's HUGE. I also enjoy the tremendous fortune of my daughter marrying a snake-eating, hog-wrassling, swamp-water-guzzling, gun-toting Alabamian. So use that finger, but use it wisely as it can be a deadly weapon.
  20. Newtonian replied to Newtonian's topic in Rifles
    Thanks to everyone who has contributed to my ongoing education on this matter. BTW compared with the advice you get in, say, computer forums ("What color is your mouse and what year was it made?") your responses were extremely informative and BS- and judgement-free. Thanks. I will definitely revisit these posts next time I have the itch, and pass some of these responses on to my son-in-law.
  21. OK I get it now. I mean the words in their actual literal sense. As we know nothing emanating from that shit-hole known as her mouth is true except by accident. When she says "simple" she's reducing a complex issue to banal slogans to serve her purposes. When she says "common sense" she means the lies that prop her own ugly old sow elite money-grubbing self-serving worldview, not the actual sensibilities that make the world go 'round. Everything that c**t says is false in some way. Everything. If she stated that today was Thursday I'd double-check the calendar.
  22. My kind of guy. Well, sortof, like in a platonic way. He's doing what few of us have the guts to do.
  23. The Federal Judge told me the case will start when I get my t-shirt and thank you for donating.
  24. You three Shetland ponies of the apocalypse are confusing issues and yelling about completely different topics. Welcome to the Greater New Jersey Gun Debate. NJ knife law provides very broad leeway within lawful uses of common objects, which is more or less sensible and a potential model for gun rights (or driving rights or paper clip rights). The key word is "lawful" (as in the standard justification for obtaining a NY carry permit: "For all legal purposes"). Guaranteed if these guys were stopped in a state that respects constitutional carry, and had run their mouths off about rescuing a crack whore from oxycontin dealers in Middlebury or Fargo they would also be arrested, or at least detained. Their firearms in most places would be ancillary to their intent to commit a crime, associate with criminals, and engage in potentially lethal activity with (presumably) known criminals. I think everyone here is in agreement that merely possessing firearms as they did should not be a crime. Which brings up the third point, namely that in NJ that behavior will get you arrested, tried, convicted, and sentenced to a much longer term than if you actually shot someone, provided you possess the right degree of melanin and are on the NJ "catch and release" list, on which the financial security of our corrupt legal system depends. See this article if you think I'm merely being a racist exaggerator. Every time an incident like this arises we have the same discussion of whether "they should have known." As I've pointed out numerous times there are 1000s of Federal laws on the books that can get you Graves Act-like or longer sentences in Federal prison with no parole and 99% conviction rates. Some involve such nefarious acts as possessing a lobster of a certain size or draining a 5x10 patch in your back yard. There are literally 10s of 1000s of regulations with equally dire consequences that hold the force (or critically, the "color") of law. We can't possibly know all this bullshit, or expect individuals who grew up with guns all around them to consider that such ridiculous pseudo-laws as we have exist. Put yourself in their shoes. They don't lurk the NJGFs debating the finer points of "justifiable need" or "reasonable deviations." That stuff is as foreign to them as 3rd century BC Japanese philosophy is to you. It's out of the realm of their consciousness. I don't care if they're from Arkansas or just crawled out of the swamps of Lake Valhalla and began walking upright last Thursday. Let's also cut some slack for the potential Stockholm Syndrome that affects many NJ gun owners. It's hard to watch the other kids playing when you're stuck inside with a lifelong case of the grippe. Ignorance of the law being no excuse was valid back when our legislatures actually passed laws that were based on common sense. As far as I'm concerned it ceased to be a valid legal principle at least forty years ago when we transitioned from a nation of laws to a nation of administrative whim.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.