Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Newtonian

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Newtonian

  1. Then you agree that negotiating with something would have been better than just bending over and pointing to the Vaseline jug, because that's what we've done and that's what we're facing.
  2. Not by any means Zeke. Nobody's perfect, especially me. I admit when I fukc up. I've done it a dozen times. I admit when I've been stupid or ignorant. In this instance I am merely reporting reality.
  3. So you believe that Governor Weinberg would have vetoed all those bills and pardoned all those individuals (or asked her AG for clarification that let them off). And future Gov. Sweeney will do the same. You believe that given the circumstances of CC's presidential run there were no opportunities, no openings, no possibility of holding his feet to the fire, nothing. You're still mad about that ad from 1993 aren't you? Admit it. You prefer to await time travel and 7,000 heretofore undiscovered signatures, and crying in your beer. Amazing. I have news for you: We now have nothing, no opening, no possibilities, no hope of moving forward. We're in far worse crap than we were six months ago, one year ago, etc. And just wait. By mid 2018 you'll be lighting candles at St. Alphonzo's, wishing that CC could run again. I wonder how some of you guys get through life, bitter and resentful, spiteful and dogmatic, unforgiving to the point of cutting off your own noses, unwilling to take advantage of the silver linings, few as they may be. But don't feel so bad, our state leadership is right behind you. Encouraging you, lecturing on theology and constitutional law, riling you up, scoffing and threatening nobody, for nothing. Welcome to the hard-assed, insane world of New Jersey gun culture. We should change the tagline of these forums to, "And through out efforts they all soiled their drawers."
  4. This tradeoff stuff is theoretical. At the time Gottlieb was hoping the UBC bill would get out of committee, where it could be debated and potential horse-trading might have occurred. He mentioned reciprocity as one possible trade but WTF knows? The senate would still have to vote on it, not that that's much of a consolation. We have a constitutional right to keep and bear arms, period, and to everything those plain words imply. We don't have a constitutional right not to have our names NOT appear on an ineligibility database that might be used for several things, including determining eligibility for a gun purchase. It may be argued as well -- and I'm not making that point just raising it -- that qualifications may be imposed on gun purchases which fall within the reasonable boundaries of sensible regulation. We can begin with: Should a seven year old be allowed to purchase a handgun? Again, I'm not saying where a reasonable line may be drawn but just raising the point. For my own curiosity, are there any types of individuals, are there any circumstances, that would cause you to renege on a private handgun sale? Use your imagination That is what all these databases and background checks purport to do. Whether they are capable of doing that I can't say.
  5. I love the drama in some of these posts. I raised a question as to what reasonable regulation might be, that's all. I wasn't asking anybody to give anything up. A national database of terrorists, criminals and institutionalized individuals who should not own guns is not such a bad idea on surface, and as SAPPA has pointed out it is precisely the OPPOSITE of registry. The problem is who winds up on it. Does an anti-(whatever) editorial get me on the list? How about being falsely arrested for a "hate crime"? Before you know it the definition of terrorist will drift as surely as occurred for the term "sexual assault." And as with any federally-run enterprise it is bound to have gaps and inefficiencies. But let me turn this around. Is it all about you? What would you trade of your peripheral personal freedoms to assure the rights of people in three states? If I read you correctly the answer is "nothing." Not even acquiescing to a list that will not have your name on it. Theoretically, because we don't know what they'll get in return. But you won't even consider it. And that, individuals reading this from outside the glorious 21 counties of a former state known as New Jersey, is why a growing number of residents of said 21 counties who value their rights feel betrayed.
  6. The real problem is that we have so many people in this country who might reasonably or even unreasonably be suspected of engaging in or sympathizing with terrorists, and that there are so many "crimes" today that so many individuals may be deemed guilty of one. I categorize someone who mistakenly miscalculated his checking balance in a whole other category from a person who plays the knockout game, yet I'll bet that many many check-bouncers have received longer sentences than those animals on the streets of major cities. Our mass immigration has become a convenient excuse for classifying whole swaths of people as dangerous, eventually leading to me, and as a result gives life to these scary arguments about trading liberty for (false) security. As we saw from today's events in California the fears are not completely unfounded. As the crime stats from our invaders from the south suggest, we should be concerned. They're here, guys. I've received pushback before for saying that no right is absolute, e.g. shouting "Fire!: in a crowded theatre, peaceably assembling on Rte. 80 on a Monday in late April around 7:30 am. The definition of legal search has evolved back and forth as well. Similarly 2nd Amendment rights are also subject to reasonable regulation. Does a national database fall into that category or is it an unacceptable intrusion? I'm not sure. We sort of know though from the post-Sandy Hook hysteria, when the passage of laws requiring universal background checks barely failed despite efforts from the national 2nd Amendment Foundation, which backed the proposed law as a potential bargaining chip for freeing NJ, MD, and HI (and I believe Illinois) from their draconian and unconstitutional gun laws. At the time Gottlieb suggested that we might trade that intrusion, which I admit would have been a pain in the ass, for universal reciprocity. Predictably, the NRA lobbied against even considering the law and that was that. From where I'm sitting that sounded like a pretty good deal though. Horse-trading. I've been criticized for whining that NRA does nothing for NJ. After all, don't I care about gun owners in the rest of the country? Let me turn that one around. Don't you care that you enjoy your 2nd amendment rights more or less unfettered, and I barely enjoy them at all? That I got harassed by some asshole ranger for transporting my shotgun in a box but not a "case"? If you trade the background check crap for me getting the right to carry when I'm out hiking or driving through Essex county I promise to support your right to carry at the Girl Scout July 4th Barbecue at the Holy Spirit of Jesus Shrine in Abilene, KS. I promise.
  7. Pity you guys are all the way down in Delaware, practically. Is anyone interested in a separate/parallel meeting somewhere in northern NJ? Anywhere north of Rte. 80 would be convenient. We could even do it between Christmas and New Year's.
  8. Well put. One of my favorite commentators, Mark Steyn, has written that had we squandered the last $10 trillion on our infrastructure, protecting our cities from floods, or hardening the electrical grid at least we could point with pride to some accomplishment. Instead we've beefed up the Dept. of Harassment of Individuals whose Properties are Inundated with Errant Rain Waters, just in case some hapless snake should perish.
  9. It depends on who introduces them. 18 months ago my older daughter was as anti as her mother. Then she visited her fiance's grandfather's farm in Alabama, and the rest is history. Now she thinks my favorite round, the lowly .22, is wimpy. Her cousin, same mid-20s age, a semi-professional classical soprano, was also introduced by her boyfriend to the manly arts. The first step, and how you get there, is critical. Sometimes peers are more persuasive than parents.
  10. Many states were "lost causes" 25 years ago. Even today 11 U.S. states have large democrat majorities on both legislative houses. Eyeballing them I'd say most are veto-proof. They can pass any anti-gun legislation they like. Five of those states, which are shall-issue or constitutional, also have democrat governors so they too can turn "hopeless as New Jersey" whenever they want. NRA's activities in those states and others are incremental: Increase the instances and locations where carry is permitted for example. Maintain the status quo w/ respect to scary rifles and background checks. Lobby for general sanity. NRA is good at that. Ground is occasionally lost as in NY, CT, and CO post Sandy Hook and if I lived in one of those states I'd be mad as hell. But their problems are almost laughable, on an absolute scale, compared with ours. Like a previous poster, I'd be a life member if they helped bring about substantive change in my state. Those who want to add Buddhist equinox festivals to places they can carry in Idaho can pay for those efforts themselves.
  11. I didn't say he was good for the country or anything else. He's all we have at this point. He's the governor. He's a lot more receptive than the next one will be. You want to wait until the right pro-gun governor comes along in this state go right ahead. If the only people we dealt with were those who were 100% aligned with our views we'd still be living in caves.
  12. In other words because he has not received an A+ rating from the NRA he's not worth talking to. You guys claim he can change justifiable need by picking up the phone yet he's not worth talking to. Instead we should insult and exclude him from the discussion. He and his AG have intervened in several important cases but we don't need that crap any more. Let the next Shaneen Allen rot in jail. He's running nationally now in a lot of gun-friendly states but let's not give him the opportunity to clarify his positions on firearms, and hold his feet to the fire afterward. Let's not even try because he's not worth talking to. By the standards of this forum my donation of time, money, and thought is fine. I posted frequently and followed up on my get-out-the-vote idea that nobody was interested in, including 99% of y'all and the state Republicans. The problem, as stated many times, is a lack of coherent leadership state-wide and a total abandonment from national organizations. NRA has fought some tough battles during the last 25 years and won a good many of them, but they're totally absent in NJ except to ask for dues. I can expect spitefulness from the average Joe but we pay them to approach these problems professionally.
  13. Pardon for resurrecting this thread. I hope we can continue a sane discussion of the value of the NRA without threats. As I've said many times gun rights issues in PA and most other states are debated on a totally different level than in NJ. You talk about the AWB...we still have it. You talk about magazine limits...we still have them. You talk about limits on carry, particularly in Texas...fuggedaboudit that's not even an issue here because it doesn't exist. Went shooting with my son-in-law a while ago, kid from Alabama. His most common response to my explanations was, "are you shittin' me?" His move to PA was the motivation behind my question to you, Mipa, about bringing guns up north. In an ideal world, if we were remotely equal, then of course most of us would support the NRA. But we're clearly not, and NRA (and our state organizations) are pretty much dedicated to maintaining the status quo. The quote about becoming like New Jersey clearly shows that NRA needs NJ like the military industrial complex needed communism. Imagine if Pennsylvania suddenly restricted driving privileges to all PA licensees. Say they banned driving in reverse, but permitted drivers from Massachusetts to drive any damn way they chose. Would you donate money to the "National Drivers Association" that lobbied for their driving privileges but ignored yours? What would be your motivation if the NDA decided that Pennsylvania was "hopeless"? IMO NRA should dedicate ALL the dues it receives from NJ, MD, and HI towards establishing and funding efforts towards reasonable parity with the remaining states, preferably to the de jure and de facto shall-issue states. 'Till then the minutiae of CC laws in Nebraska interest me only theoretically. Yeah we should all be allowed to carry anywhere in the USA with only the Constitution as our permit. I believe that. But if they don't believe that, if they're not dedicated to the same uphill struggle in NJ that they undertook in 35-40 other states, they can stick it up their pointed a**holes.
  14. I've been doing this for years. I go up to black people all the time. "Yo Bro, yo sis, wanna gun?" They look at me strange. I told the cop it was all a misunderstanding. My trial has been postponed to February. Thank God Nappen is defending me. We're planning a defense of jury nullification or perhaps the insanity clause. Please send any excess Crisco supplies to the address posted in the Recall Sweeney thread a few months ago. Having failed with the females in my own family and realizing how much NJ women desire, no crave, the right to self-defense I began approaching women on the street. I'm talking nice looking broads, not the usual Sussex County skunk-headed "blondes." Got kicked in the balls at ShopRite the other day but her grandmother was actually cute. What's the word...sort of a synonym for mountain lion. I'm beginning to think this outreach thing isn't going to work. Just sayin'.
  15. Well then why don't they use some of those votes to affect NJ elections as I've advocated many many times? There's a huge difference between kissing somebody's ass for no reason and trying to engage them in discussion. Too many posters believe that negotiation and persuasion equal capitulation. They do not. Mutual propaganda notwithstanding Nixon went to China and Reagan met with representatives of the "evil empire." CC is a Republican (even if in name only), he's softened on gun issues since the 1990s, he's vetoed all the right legislation. Is he pro-gun in his heart of hearts? Almost certainly not, but he's far from hopeless on the issue. You guys make me laugh with your "sending messages" and promises of soiled diapers, which can only be achieved by voting them out, which you lack the will to do. If you're too high on your horse to speak with someone like Christie wait until January, 2018, when the lion emerges from his slumber, hungry for a lavish dinner where we're the main course.
  16. You guys don't get it. A professional advocacy organization is not supposed to behave like a spiteful little playground brat. They're not supposed to tell anybody to "pound sand." First of all that gets you nowhere. Have you ever received anything positive from anybody by trying to humiliate them? What freaking school of achievement did you experts graduate from? Second it tends to antagonize rather than convince. Maybe inviting CC would have had the exact same effect as telling him to pound sand. But inviting him can never be worse than not inviting him and then making a big deal about it. Imagine if he had made pro-2A statements, no matter how insincere, and afterward were held accountable for those statements. Now all we have is "elect a Republican legislature." And yes, under the right circumstances invite even Obama, even Hillary, even Sens. Sweeney and Weinberg.
  17. So you prefer giving up out of spite to opening a potentially beneficial dialog. Not to kiss his a**, not to "get him more votes" because he's never winning anyway, but to DO WHAT YOU"RE SUPPOSED TO DO which is to advocate for gun rights.
  18. YES WE SHOULD BE MAD AT THEM. Their job is to promote gun ownership, Second Amendment rights, etc., not to make political choices or to rule on other issues. Our rights are not negotiable, they have nothing to do with how the wind blows, of democrat or republican. 47 states issue carry permits, including BLUE states. Wake up. The NRA should have viewed inviting Christie as an OPPORTUNITY. As a way of helping us. However small the chance. Instead they acted like assholes. F**k 'em. You guys in PA and FL and TX keep fighting for your rights to carry at county fairs and may the NRA help you forever. Not on my dime however.
  19. If I follow up on this I will get my third "warning point" and probably be kicked off forever, but yeah bruh. No illusions here. Still, we can bitch and moan but the NRA should be professional and meet with anybody who can possibly help. For a while perhaps CC could have. Now that he's 99.8% lame duck there's no chance. Perhaps the NRA could, by inviting him, have shamed him into doing something, anything. Now the f** fU***** p**** of SH** s********* is basically planning his lecture career. He's hiring the Clintons' business manager, I suspect. Another great public figure who by the time he's in a nursing home will have written more books than he's read.
  20. From the above-cited article: Christie was snubbed by the NRA last April when it excluded him from speaking at its annual convention in Nashville, but invited a dozen other 2016 GOP hopefuls. Reason 17-b not to send any more money to the NRA. It's not their f-ing damn business to "snub" anybody who is remotely capable of helping gun owners anywhere, especially someone who is at best on the fence, especially in a state like NJ. It is their business to engage such people in a respectful manner, to educate them.
  21. Very sorry. The lesson I learned last week with the sudden passing of my mother's husband, a truly wonderful man, is never wait. Never put anything off when it comes to loved ones. Tell them you love them, apologize if you were a jerk. Don't wait until tomorrow. I was one block away last Tuesday when he was apparently healthy but I was in a rush. I'd stop by next time I was in town. Besides, I'd see him at Thanksgiving. There was one less setting at the table today.
  22. First time I see this. Disgraceful. But I already decided not to give them another penny. I'm 1000000 x more interested in my rights than in Oklahomans being able to carry at county fairs or church bake sales.
  23. I don't want to say too much and get my range privileges revoked, but my mother has a comment I trot out every few months: "tits on a bull."
  24. To me concealed carry is or should be the signature 2nd Amendment issue. It reflects the degree to which 2nd Amendment rights are respected statewide and all that signifies. I've never seen a survey of individuals in Pennsylvania who, like me for many years, owned a shotgun and killed a couple of birds per year and that was that, so I can't comment on their general commitment to gun rights. I'd bet, however, that the percentage of CC permit holders in some way mirrors a state's respect for gun rights. So why the uneven correlation between liberal/conservative state politics and shall- or true may-issue laws? Why do legislatures in Massachusetts, Wisconsin, New Hampshire, and New York not simply adopt NJ-style gun laws? More significantly, why do states with very low carry numbers still respect that right? By your logic they'd just shrug off the gun nut vote. I haven't checked but some of these states have got to be Democrat-controlled, just like here. This would make a tremendous topic for a PhD thesis in the social sciences or perhaps political science.
  25. "Le page n'existe pas." Big f-ing surprise.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.