Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Newtonian

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Newtonian

  1. This seems to me like the wrong venue for what needs to be accomplished. The time I need with him could range from five minutes (if he shoots us right down) to half an hour if it reaches the point of discussing strategy. That forum would not give me half an hour, and spending the entire day for five minutes seems like a waste for me. In either case I'd rather pay him $200 for 20 minutes than spend an entire day down at GFH and shell out $400. The "shoot don't shoot" seems like it could be fun but it's really not for us. If someone breaks in they get shot; if he's holding my wife close by he doesn't get shot. Outside the home well, you know the story.
  2. Thanks. I don't see it on their March calendar. Must be next month.
  3. Yes, yes, yes. This has been in the back of my mind since reading the first post on this crazy idea. They tell you to produce A, B, and C. You produce only A. They just turn you down. At the next stage they ask if you met all three criteria and you say no. End of case. That's why I wanted to speak with Nappen. But he hasn't responded, even though I offered to pay for his time. Let's give him a few more days. This notion is a frail reed on which to base any kind of legal challenge. Serious crime has been going down everywhere, including in NJ, especially in NYC, since the "shall issue" craze began. Viewed nationally, yeah this is a valid point. Viewed at level of individual states the case is not so strong. The basis has to be experience in shall-issue states, and maybe 4th down the list individual rights. I know this will anger some of you but it's reality.
  4. The best way to keep the cost of his consultation down is to do it by phone, and to have a list of questions to ask. The first might be, "Is this a complete waste of time?"
  5. I have emailed Nappen to request a telephone meeting. I'd like to ask him how this idea might play out. If he responds I'll post his answers here. Meanwhile if anyone has any questions they'd like me to ask please post them here.
  6. I was wrong then. Chances were not 50-50, but 0-100. Not a big surprise. Anyone who wants to "scale down" this project has no idea whatsoever what it's about. Representing a class or group of 3000 is not that much more work for them as representing 30. But the statistical power of 3000 is much greater. I assume most of the scut work would be done by volunteers, for example holding meetings, collecting and copying paperwork, tallying results.
  7. The purpose of doing this as a large group is so nobody need put out tens of thousands. I'm forseeing something like this: * some number of people get the paperwork and complete the forms. The more the merrier. We'd need a critical mass, say 300 * ask the various organizations if they'd be interested in taking up our cause * we'd also need to be prepared to shell out our own money, say $200-$500 (I can see y'all slumping in your chairs)
  8. Agreed but a sound strategy would not require that kind of outlay: 1. 500 people apply on the same day, at the same hour if possible. 2. Where they ask for justifiable need DO NOT MENTION ANYTHING ABOUT TRAVELING TO NEWARK or EMPTYING CASH MACHINES. Don't play into their hands. Put in something like "every-day self defense" or "for all legal purposes." This part needs very deep consideration because it will become the face of this movement. 3. Wait until we're all turned down. 4. In the meantime see if NRA, 2AS, NJ2AS, ANJRPC, etc. will take up our cause. I estimate the odds here as roughly 50-50. 5. Be prepared to kick in some money of your own to keep this going. As I mentioned I will participate but ONLY as part of an organized, concerted, intelligent, well thought-out plan. I'm not interested in twenty guys from these forums vowing that they'll do it, and then just 7 of them following through. You might as well flush your application fee down the toilet. You'll be wasting your time. Another point: We must avoid confrontational language and all mention of 2A or God or James Madison and all that stuff in all publicity related to this strategy. It's all true of course but that crap doesn't work, hasn't worked, will never work in this state. And it makes us look like kooks. If the judges who've ruled against us gave a screw about the Second Amendment or natural rights they would be on our side already. Focus on the facts and current experience with CC in nearby states.
  9. You bring the front loader, I'll bring the SKS. We meet here:
  10. Not to alarm you but have you drunk any of it? Do any of the particles look like this:
  11. I had a chance to purchase an unissued Russian SKS for $400-450. By the time I decided to buy it it had sold for something like $300. I wound up buying one for $500, almost new, with the bayo and accessories. IMO it is not a safe harlot. It's a gun to enjoy.
  12. What I fear is the compromise bill that the likes of Chuck Sch******ker (D., NY) and his turncoat c**t w***e Kirstin Gilli***t will propose, namely that they'll vote for the bill only if the permit holder has resident documentation. Hahaha wouldn't that be a gas. I hope that as I advocate 2A rights I have stayed within the narrow restrictions of 1st Amendment rights as defined by the owners of the N** Jer*** ********s website.
  13. If something is illegal in NJ for me why would it not be illegal for you?
  14. Drive speed limit +3 mph. Shave your beard and get a haircut. Remove all Grateful Dead stickers from your car. If stopped deny everything, completing every sentence with "Sir-r-r-r-r-rrrrr!"
  15. Not to nitpick but 12th and Park is within a mile of anywhere inside the "Mile Square City." Hudson and Essex are probably tied in terms of the worst B.S. in this god-forsaken state. I visit Hobo' often because of my parents. Do you know they used to have a police range down on Jackson St. (I believe)? Don't know if it was open to the public. When I was growing up you really needed a gun to venture down there. My mother let me wander all over the place when I was like 8-9-10 but she told me in no uncertain terms not to go down there, even at noon on Easter Sunday.
  16. You totally, completely missed my points. I'm not at all unfriendly to the idea of 500 people applying en masse, on the same day at the same time. I would eagerly support such a project through my own participation and financial donation. I would go through the process if it were part of an organized effort. Let's call a meeting! I'll attend. I would supply as my justifiable need "for all legal purposes" like the do in upstate NY. Or whatever the group decides on. But for me to blow tens of thousands of dollars in money and time -- hundreds of thousands depending on how far I get -- just to get mentioned in a dozen blogs and eventually to be turned down like everyone else is a complete and total waste. Just as it is a total utter waste for the 2AS to blow its wad one futile carry permit application at a time.
  17. Albert, I hope you will continue to update in this thread. My criticisms have nothing to do with you. Sure court cases may arise from your application but the focus of further appeals would be whether you demonstrated justifiable need within the context of your specific circumstances and how that policy exists in law and practice. That is the problem. Defining JN on the basis of number of trips to unsavory neighborhoods, or whatever criteria you're presenting, strengthens the concept instead of weakening it. It would indeed be miraculous, given the unsavory judicial/legal history of gun cases in NJ, that somewhere out of the blue a judge hearing one of your appeals would have the authority and inclination to order NJ to change its ways. You realize that the state gets to appeal that ruling, all the way up to the Supreme Court which recently declined to hear a NJ 2A case. As has been amply demonstrated we will never win by that route. There is another issue, also raised in this thread, that they will simply grant you a permit to shut everybody up. Where are we then? In my opinion the 2AF or 2AS or whoever they are are wasting money on a one-off case that will benefit only you and serve no purpose whatsoever in broadening our rights. You do not have any more of a right to carry a handgun than the people who actually LIVE in the unsavory neighborhoods you frequent. Or occasional visitors. Or people who live in small, safer cities. Or small towns like Newton. Or individuals who live out in the boonies on farms where the crime rate is 0.0000. Again, my gripe is not against you but against the 2AS.
  18. Interesting. I grew up in Hoboken. 12th and Park. How long does it take to get a permit there?
  19. It wasn't funny. I'm facing 2-5.
  20. I think it was actually the cop's own dash cam that did him in. Poor bastard. With all the gay opportunities available in 2015 -- you guys know far more about that than I do -- he has to drop his drawers at the intersection of Pecker and Bunghole Sts.
  21. And his balls too. One witness said he showed him "his package."
  22. I just bought a Beretta as well but I'm ashamed to mention the model. I have bought Czech, US, Russian, German, Bulgarian firearms. Let's give our paesani some business.
  23. I live in a small town. I've never had to wait more than 30 days for anything except for once, when the officer was being sued by some insane people. Previous poster: How does your employer not know your SS#? Are you from Honduras? Carcano, you and I normally agree but I'd rather wait 6 weeks for a purchase permit than spend 7 years getting anally impregnated by a child rapist in Rahway.
  24. Even this is a fallacy. It will open no doors because what happens to Almeida doesn't automatically apply to Jones or Smith. They, and everyone after them, will need to shell out their own $$$ to fight their own individual battles. 2AF is living in a fantasy world if they believe this will open or chip away at anything. What did the last 10, 20, 30 permits to ordinary citizens open up???
  25. Vlad what's the caliber of the one all the way on the right with the circular aluminum butt?

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.