Everything posted by Mrs. Peel
-
How can this be good?
BTW, a very detailed article about this topic was just posted on National Review Online. Interestingly, the author hit on one of my initial concerns, but went even further, saying, "There were a host of reasons to object to this measure. On separation-of-powers grounds, the prospect of the Social Security Administration playing judge, jury, and executioner is flatly intolerable..." and then he goes on to list all the other reasons it was simply bad law... and further, lists a large array of diverse groups who opposed it, including the ACLU and many groups concerned about the rights of disabled people. So, yeah, that may have been just incredible overreach on the part of the SSA. Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/444582/no-gop-did-not-just-repeal-background-check-system-or-give-guns-mentally-ill
-
How can this be good?
My nickname for you, Cereza, was already "The Citation Queen". Again, you didn't disappoint. I'm guessing you're in a career with some research? :-) On an admittedly quick read, I think the SSA is in a gray area... "we can do this because the citation doesn't specifically say it must be adjudicated by a court... and if you don't like it, you can argue the point... we won't charge you to argue it... however, you will have to go out, at your own expense, and get a doctor to attest to your mental health not only now, but for the last 5 years..." Of course, if you didn't have a mental health professional for that prior 5 years, how do you prove you were OK? Is that even possible? How much would that cost? It puts little protection, but all of the burden on the citizen. I guess I'm just not crazy (no pun intended) about an agency becoming judge and jury like that. There's a better system for that. It's called court. Maybe the SSA can technically do it. I just question whether it's the best approach. It seems like it could be an overreach and I can see why it stirred people up. Just my opinion....
-
Taking new shooters
Yeah, I think this is just great that you folks do this. Seriously. Fantastic! People contribute in different ways - donations to 2A organizations, political action, etc. - but I think bringing people to the range is something ANYONE can do. I mean, if you're going to the range anyway, how difficult is it to pull someone along? I'm still very much a newbie myself... and have been a bit hesitant to "fess up" to my new hobby, but I've decided to change all that. I was a recruiter in a former career, for goodness sakes... this should be a snap. :-) So, I did bring my very first guest to the range a couple of months ago - she loved it, btw!... and I've given myself the modest goal of getting 6 brand new people to the range in 2017. Thereafter, I'll look to increase it each year.
-
How can this be good?
I guess the devil is in the details... and I haven't read the legislation. Was this supposed to impact people formally diagnosed as mentally incompetent (severe dementia, etc.)? That I could understand. Or... was it also impacting someone who simply decided it was much easier/more convenient to pass the burden of their finances to their child, but was still otherwise sharp and aware? That would be wrong IMO. It is difficult in this country to get full guardianship over someone's affairs, for example. And that's by design - because the law takes the position that it should NOT be easy to strip away someone's rights. It takes lengthy court proceedings, the testimony of several doctors, etc. Again, I haven't seen the wording... but I'm left wondering if the SSA were setting a threshold that was far looser and broader that an adjudicated case of guardianship, for instance. The fact that the gun lobby was joined by disability rights activists makes me think that was perhaps the case. Edit: I do agree though... some people should NOT have guns! Absolutely.
-
Please vote for my Sister for Military Spouse of the Year
Done! Sending positive thoughts for a big win.
-
Hardiman, and Gorsuch: US Supreme Court
That we can certainly ALL agree with!!!
-
Hardiman, and Gorsuch: US Supreme Court
Well, I hope you're right, Indiana and HBec. The Supreme Court is a funny thing though... and sometimes the individual supremes rule in ways people wouldn't have envisioned (Roberts, anyone?). I guess we should all just cross our fingers and hope that he turns out to be a 2A supporter, because I would absolutely envision some 2A cases making it to the Supreme Court over the next few years... quite possibly from our own state. And those rulings will be hugely impactful as they might be on the books for a very long time.
-
Hardiman, and Gorsuch: US Supreme Court
Good lord, I'm so "link-challenged"... here's the article, from American Thinker, published yesterday: Judge Neil Gorsuch: Some Cause for Concern In recent days, news outlets have been reporting that 10th Circuit judge Neil Gorsuch has now risen to the top of President Trump's list of potential Supreme Court nominees. He apparently replaces Judge William Pryor, who was widely reported as previously leading the pack of potential nominees. Judge Pryor faced significant backlash from many on the right, including Evangelical Christians, criticizing Pryor's apparent support of the radical homosexual and transgender agenda. The danger in being the front runner for a spot on the High Court is that you receive intense scrutiny, and, as with most candidates, Judge Gorsuch is difficult to evaluate fully. Having spent some time digging into Judge Gorsuch's background, we have found many good indicators. First, we should say that we personally knew his mother – Anne Gorsuch Burford, a lawyer whom President Reagan appointed in 1981 as director of the Environmental Protection Agency. Anne was both principled and fearless – taking many arrows in her faithful pursuit of President Reagan's environmental agenda. Sadly, the Reagan administration failed to provide her the backing she deserved, leading to her early departure from that position. Judge Gorsuch's distinguished maternal pedigree should not be overlooked. As to Judge Gorsuch's judicial record, he authored the excellent opinion in United States v. Ackerman, 831 F.3d 1292 (10th Cir. 2016), which, in an alternative holding, determined that government accessing a person's emails constitutes a "search" under the revitalized property rights trespass test articulated by Justice Scalia in the case of United States v. Jones, 132 S.Ct. 945 (2012). Additionally, Judge Gorsuch wrote a concurring opinion in the 10th Circuit, in what became the Hobby Lobby case in the U.S. Supreme Court, determining that the religious freedom of Christian businesses trumps the "right" of a woman to have her employer subsidize the killing of her unborn baby. Finally, Judge Gorsuch is a vocal critic of the modern "Administrative State" – advocating the elimination of the doctrine of "Chevron deferense," which has given unelected and unaccountable federal bureaucrats vast and unconstitutional power over just about every aspect of our lives. On the other hand, there is reason for pause with Judge Gorsuch's record. Judge Gorsuch joined in one opinion, United States v. Rodriguez, 739 F.3d 481 (11th Cir. 2013), which causes us to have some concern about his understanding of the relationship between the government and an armed citizenry. To be fair, Judge Gorsuch did not write the Rodriguez opinion – his colleague, Judge Bobby Baldock, was the author. Nevertheless, Judge Gorsuch joined the opinion. He could have filed a principled dissenting opinion, or even a concurring opinion agreeing only in the judgment. The facts of the case are these. A New Mexico policeman observed Mr. Rodriguez, a convenience store clerk, carrying a concealed handgun. Carrying a concealed loaded handgun is illegal in New Mexico without a permit but legal if one has a license to do so. The officer, upon seeing a Rodriguez's handgun, detained him, then – acting first and asking questions later – forcibly disarmed Rodriguez. After finding out that Rodriguez did not, in fact, have a license to carry and, indeed, was a convicted felon, the officer placed him under arrest. Of course, hard cases make bad law. But the precedent from the Rodriguez opinion will affect police-citizen relations in New Mexico, and possibly elsewhere in the Tenth Circuit, for many years to come. Not bothering to figure out the legality of Rodriguez's firearm before detaining and disarming him, the officer's initial actions would have been the same even if Mr. Rodriguez had been a lawful gun owner. According to the 10th Circuit's opinion, the police are justified in forcibly disarming every armed citizen based on nothing more than the presence of a concealed firearm. This allows the police to treat every law-abiding gun owner like a criminal – which, in many cases we have seen, includes rough treatment such as grabbing him, twisting his arm behind his back, slamming him down on the ground, and handcuffing him. Far too many police officers do not like anyone to be armed other than themselves and have taken it upon themselves to intimidate those who dare to exercise Second Amendment rights. Under the Rodriguez decision, only after being forcibly disarmed and detained would a citizen be entitled to demonstrate that he was lawfully exercising his Second Amendment rights. The Circuit Court based this decision on Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968) – the "stop and frisk" doctrine. One of the holdings from Terry is that, if the police have "reasonable suspicion" that a person is both "armed and dangerous," they can temporarily seize his weapon to keep everyone safe. Of course, anyone with a smidgeon of common sense knows that just being an "armed" law-abiding citizen does not also make a person "dangerous" any more than a police officer with a gun should be considered dangerous. Unfortunately, the Rodriguez opinion allows the police to conflate the two concepts and treat all armed persons as if they were automatically dangerous. According to the panel opinion joined by Judge Gorsuch, the mere presence of a loaded concealed firearm "alone is enough to justify [the officer's] action in removing the handgun from Defendant's waistband for the protection of himself and others." To be sure, Rodriguez did not raise a Second Amendment claim before the court, and the court cited various Fourth Amendment cases to justify its bad decision. But judges cannot completely hide behind precedent. Judge Gorsuch was free to express his disagreements with those precedents, even if he felt obliged to concur in the result. But that is not what he did. Instead, the court went so far as to quote Justice John Marshall Harlan II in Terry for the pre-Heller assertion that "'concealed weapons create an immediate and severe danger to the public.'" Is that what Judge Gorsuch thinks of the 14.5 million law-abiding Americans with concealed carry permits? That they are an immediate and severe danger to the public? Fortunately, the Framers disagreed, emphasizing in the Second Amendment that an armed populace is not only beneficial to, but indeed "necessary to" the preservation of a "free state." Unfortunately, in almost all of the countries of the world, the government considers an armed citizen a threat. But in the United States, the police should consider an armed citizenry one of the sources of strength of the nation. It is hard to imagine a better way to discourage law-abiding people from carrying guns than to do what the 10th Circuit did, and sanction the police forcibly disarming anyone seen carrying a gun. At the end of the day, a single opinion such as this is not be enough to derail a Supreme Court nomination, especially since Judge Gorsuch did not even write the opinion. But he certainly did join the opinion. And if he is nominated to the High Court, a pro-gun United States senator or two should most certainly inquire as to this decision and ask Judge Gorsuch to explain whether he really believes that the police should be free to treat all armed citizens as though they were dangerous criminals. Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2017/01/judge_neil_gorsuch_some_cause_for_concern.html#ixzz4XOSXpYOj Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook
-
Hardiman, and Gorsuch: US Supreme Court
That's kind of what I'm seeing... no DIRECT 2A decisions, but he was criticized just a tad by one conservative blog, for his position on one gun case. I'm no lawyer, hard for me to weigh in... but here's the link, so you can read for yourself: http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2017/01/judge_neil_gorsuch_some_cause_for_concern.html
-
I did it l, I'm a big boy!
Congrats! :-)
-
WhiteHouse.gov second amendment petitions
That's good, thanks! I didn't even know about all these groups. :-) I just sent detailed emails off to SAF and Ammoland through their websites. I did not send to the Firearm Blog - because their tagline is "FirearmsNotPolitics" and I scanned through their articles and noticed there was NO 2A activism, but there were several political disclaimers. (I know some non-profits are precluding from political activity - I'm guessing that's the case here. It didn't seem to be the right forum).
-
Scotch plains area
Hmmm... do I remember an earlier thread saying EFGA was also building a 250 yd range? If so, do you know what's the ETA on that? Just curious. I want to try out some rifle shooting in Spring and have that range "tucked in the back of my mind" - because it's still a very affordable outdoor range from what I understand.
-
My dog loving the snow this morning...
Good choice of soundtrack there...!
-
WhiteHouse.gov second amendment petitions
Yes, IMO, the problem with that system is that someone ("any Joe Schmo") posts a petition topic (they might be doing it from mom's basement)... and so no one even knows it's there. I also reached out to my ladies shooting group today via email - it's a local chapter of a national organization. Maybe they can pass the word? Hmmm... isn't there another much feistier 2A organization than NRA? GOA, I believe? I'll call them tomorrow too. Any other suggestions? I'm still very much a dabbler in this topic - don't know the landscape as well as some of the others on here. But, I can certainly pick up a phone and call if I know who to call! Again, I can see that this Whitehouse petition thing is best if it's pre-planned and with an organization behind it with a big membership... so they strategically open the petition and immediately release all of the pre-vetted marketing actions to put a push on for signatures. Just my opinion.
-
Crystal River FL?
Enjoy your vacay! Nice time of year for a Florida jaunt.
-
WhiteHouse.gov second amendment petitions
Bump.
-
Valentines ideas
Fishnut had me until he said porkroll... perish the thought! Nothing but Taylor Ham Men for this woman.
-
Valentines ideas
Hissing cockroaches? Handjobs?
-
Constitutional Carry Marches On [Article]
Interesting article about the spread of constitutional carry... hmmm, makes the coastal anti-gun states of CA, NY & NJ seems a tad out of step with a growing trend. http://www.nationalreview.com/article/444212/constitutional-carry-states-adopting
-
WhiteHouse.gov second amendment petitions
Hmm... on the back of my NRA card there's an 800 # for their lobbying group. So, what the heck... I just called them and spoke with a rep. I never assume people are aware of things they should be aware of. I asked "do you even know these petitions are on there? And wouldn't it be helpful if you plugged your members to sign these through your email alert system? Just to show the Whitehouse that there's a strong interest?" The guy I spoke to wasn't personally aware they existed, but he looked them up as we were on the phone and said he would pass it along. I know some of you are cynical about the NRA --- I'm not (yet). So, let's see what happens. I made the specific point of saying, "even if your groups didn't generate the petitions, it would be smart to get behind them, just to strike while the iron is hot with this new administration." Now, who the hell is she... this guy might be thinking, LMAO. I don't know... but, if you don't ask, you don't receive. He seemed genuinely interested (unless it was feigned). Who knows? Meanwhile, those links should be posted to NJ gun sites. Wouldn't it be nice not only to get 100,000 votes on each petition - but to see a whole slew of NJ residents? As far as I'm concerned, we should demonstrate to the Whitehouse a strong grassroots activism among gun owners, a group that arguably helped put Trump in office.
-
WhiteHouse.gov second amendment petitions
I have no doubt if Trump takes steps, NJ will fight it and then have cases that end up in court eventually. However, the mix on the Supreme Court will be favorable... so isn't it worth getting the wheels in motion? Again, my knowledge of this stuff is still in the early stages. But... Trump being president does seem like an usually favorable moment in time for 2A. Might as well strike while the iron is hot, and then prepare for the inevitable long, hard slog as cases are filed and wind their way through the system.
-
WhiteHouse.gov second amendment petitions
Signed both. Recommend cross-posting the Whitehouse links on some gun groups' Facebook pages, etc. -- so if you belong to any, pls share. And maybe broader sites like Ammoland, etc.? If any of you have logins/passwords to other sites, pls pass along the links. It ticks me off that the petition about him releasing his tax returns is at 100,000 signatures already... sheesh! We should at least be as determined as the people who would so love to strip our rights away, don't you think?
-
WhiteHouse.gov second amendment petitions
I'm posting this here, not the 2A lounge, so it gets ample views... I know the new Whitehouse.gov webpage has been mentioned in a couple of threads... but did anyone notice that there's a "petition page"? People can list an issue, gather signatures and if there's enough signatures within a specified period the Whitehouse will (at least) give a reply to the original poster. It apparently also puts anyone who signed it on a mail list to get updates on that issue. Well, progressives haven't wasted any time creating petitions that show they want their LGBT and climate change pages returned to the website (I kid you not). Interestingly, apparently some ambitious gun owner also made a petition to repeal the National Firearms Act of 1934 (NFA). Now, I'm still enough of a newbie that I lack the breadth and depth of knowledge that many of you have on firearm laws and the political strategy surrounding them. So, what say you, peanut gallery? Is this something people should be signing? It would seem to me the answer would be "yes" - if for no other reason than this >>> a hearty response to any petition like this would be a strong reminder to the administration that gun owners are eagerly awaiting action on the 2A issue. But, I'll leave it to the peanut gallery to debate/discuss before I (personally) do anything. I like to "ponder" before I sign things... that's just me... I mean, does signing put us on a "list" for scrutiny by a later administration unfriendly to 2A...? (...gingerly removing tin foil hat now...) Mrs. P. UPDATES IN RED: --- and here's the link to that specific petition btw: https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/repeal-nfa [This one garnered over 250k votes!] Update: just putting all direction in 1 place... so you don't have to scroll the thread... >>As poster "accline" pointed out, there's also a 2nd petition to repeal the 1986 Hughes Amendment to the NFA: https://petitions.wh...ughes-amendment >> as poster "Upfitter21" let us know on 2/20, the first Hughes Amendment petition (above) just missed the mark - but someone did another petition. If you want to sign, it's here: https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/repeal-1986-hughs-ammendment-firearm-owners-protection-act >>And as poster "lou" said, you MUST check your email afterwards and click on a provided link to make your signature register.
-
Got my first ticket, can I fight it ?
Sounds like you just nailed all the key points. Dress nicely too, of course --- most people look like the dregs of society in traffic court, I swear!
-
Got my first ticket, can I fight it ?
Do go back and look at those signs though. I was ticketed several years ago for turning right on red illegally. I went immediately back to the spot after the ticket and took a picture with my smart phone... then I morphed into a Philadelphia lawyer for a few days, LOL. I had a perfect driving record; I was ticked. Measured the sign, looked up NJ traffic sign specs, found out the damn thing was nearly a foot too short... and absolutely impossible to see if you were in a normal passenger vehicle and there was an SUV or van parked along the curb (which was the situation that day). Then, out of curiosity, put in an OPRA/FOIA request (can't remember which) and spent an hour looking through 6 months of their paper tickets. My hunch was right... town was making disproportionate revenue on that one intersection. By the time I went to talk to the prosecutor... they knew who I was and just wanted me to go away and not start writing letters to the editor! No points, very low fine. (BTW, years later... same illegal sign is there... I'm sure they're still making money off of it - what a scam). Regardless, I don't personally think you need a lawyer for something so small. If you're polite and have a good record otherwise, prosecutors are happy to deal with you. IMO, lawyers are for serious stuff ---- multiple offenses, injuries, DUI's, etc.