Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Mrs. Peel

Moderators
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Mrs. Peel

  1. And only a scant amount of these are prosecuted! It's a known problem that gangbangers will even dupe their own grandmother into making a gun purchase for them. What happens all too often is that local prosecutors don't want to "throw granny in jail" - so they don't prosecute the case, or they at least plea it down to practically nothing. And THAT is why straw purchases continue to be as prevalent as they are. Similarly, when ex-felons apply to get a gun and are (rightly so) rejected by the NICS check -- the prosecution of those cases (by the Feds) has been abysmally low as well. The fact is that there have been numerous large, credible crime studies that specifically studied the backgrounds of the people who committed crimes with a gun. These studies (by DOJ, large universities, criminal justice think tanks, etc.) are all remarkably similar in their findings. Typically, 70-90% are committed by ex-felons (typically about half of them while still on parole from the previous crime), about 3% are cops, less than 1% are legal gun owners - and the remaining fall into the "other" category (like people who got the gun illegally, perhaps had a long history of misdemeanors, etc.) I've seen the same basic "pie chart" across too many studies to think that it's not actually a true picture! That's why the phrase "common sense gun control" makes me batty!! How did we let these anti-2A zealots hijack that term? Trying to impact crime by going after the people least likely to commit it is actually the opposite of common sense! Aggressive prosecution of straw purchasers (and the criminals that put them up to it), aggressive prosecution of ex-felons who get caught in a NICS check, a serious re-examination of parole procedures, less plea bargains... and heavy, sustained investment in community programs that keep high-risk kids out of gangs... now THAT would be "common sense". When trying to solve a problem, you must address the obvious and largest root cause.
  2. I assure you, that wasn't my intention! In fact, I've stated on NJGF more than once that applying "en masse" seemed like a good strategy to me for a multitude of reasons. I simply got leery when I heard what sounded like people "assuming" they'll be invited to join as a plaintiff, etc. There's no guarantees of that, of course. That said, I guess there's no downside to applying either. What's the worst that happens? You get denied for lack of justifiable need and maybe you can't afford the lawsuit on your own? So... you don't sue. You're really no worse off, I guess, than you were before you applied! You still don't have a CCW permit. And the NJSP rep has already confirmed it doesn't hurt your chance to reapply at some future point, either within NJ if the law changes... or in another state.
  3. Ah, ok, I did misunderstand. Frankly, I haven't delved into those previous cases! But, I see your point... once the permit was in hand, the harm to those plaintiffs was effectively "undone" and the case ended from a legal standpoint. Makes total sense! Presumably that's why this case is structured as it is... why it's including other plaintiffs, both individuals and an unnamed large group of gun owners (e.g., "10's of thousands"). I'm guessing... the plan might be that even as individual plaintiff's permits might get granted (forcing them to drop out), ANJRPC will backfill them with more plaintiffs... to keep the case rolling and rolling and rolling... all the way to SCOTUS? But, honestly, I have to go back and listen to the rest of that radio program - this is getting interesting! Either way, I am delighted the game is afoot! I hope this case is "the one", and if not, that there's another one right on its heels. I'd like to see ANJRPC/NRA become a freakin' NIGHTMARE for this new governor!
  4. Ummm... it's a discussion, not a competition... (Men!! LOL).That said, in the radio show, I noticed what ANJRPC didn't mention was any kind of date for inclusion (like having applied before the case was filed), so I'm going to assume that's not an issue (from a legal perspective)... and they may assess prospective plaintiffs on a case-by-case basis going forward. And I know you won't agree with me on this next point... but I'm sure you and others will apply to (as you say) hedge your bets that the state will grant your permits just to make this case "go away". Sorry to sound like a meanie, but I personally hope like hell that ANJRPC has added some kind of fail-safe to prevent that... for instance, a signed agreement stating if an individual exits the case, they owe their portion of the legal fees. It seems only fair to me! This case is being funded by members' fees and the donations of the 2A community - why should it benefit just a small handful of people? I think people are sick of being duped by other plaintiffs that have come before. In any event... Godspeed on your applications, Gentlemen... and Ladies, too... whoever you are! I'd like to say this will be exciting to watch... but realistically, as slow as the legal system moves, it will be more like watching paint dry. LOL. Nonetheless, I LOVE to see lawsuits rolling forward. I think it's fantastic! This state has been stomping on people's constitutional rights for far too long!!
  5. Must we really rehash the facts... again? Poor Mr. Taylor was the victim of an overreaching U.S. government whose petty bureaucrats forced him to re-name his fine product to the incorrect/generic name of "pork roll" (as evidenced on the later packaging which you see above). As an originalist (and a proud preservationist), I refer to the product by it's PROPER traditional name - as it was lovingly known by it's many fans back in the day: "Taylor Ham". To refer to it by any other name is to embrace bureaucratic meddling! Who, but a frightened mouse, would do such a thing? Thus, Taylor Ham will forever live on... in this woman's heart... and the hearts of proud, clear-thinking Americans everywhere. We salute you, Mr. Taylor!
  6. Purple Patrick and I are simply correct. Nothing more than that.
  7. FAKE NEWS!!! He was the Creator of Taylor Ham. But, I'll let that pass... and thank you at least for your deferential acknowledgement of this very sad anniversary. RIP, John Taylor!
  8. I was out today (shooting, yay!)... hence my delayed response. I'm not sure "standing" is quite as cut and dry as many people think. Again, I'm not a lawyer... but I can read and interpret. And, as a layperson, I read through these simple Wikipedia definitions (below) and it appears to me that "standing" may come from direct harm -or- indirect harm. Further, it shows that the mere threat of harm can cause a "chilling effect" on people exercising their "constitutional" rights specifically - and that indeed confers a indirect form of "legal standing". Hmmmm....! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standing_(law) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chilling_effect If you read that second citation, it notes that it's the fear of "legal sanction" that causes this (legal) chilling effect. So, with all of that in mind, I went back and reread that lawsuit. Let me draw your attention to Para. 36 which states: Plaintiff ANJRPC has numerous members who wish to carry a handgun outside the home for self-defense but have not applied for a Handgun Carry Permit because they know that, although they satisfy or can satisfy all other requirements of N.J.S.A. 2C:58-4, they are unable to satisfy the “justifiable need” requirement. But for Defendants’ continued enforcement of the New Jersey laws and regulations set forth above, those members would forthwith carry a handgun outside the home for self-defense but refrain from doing so for fear of arrest and prosecution. [boldface//underlining added by me]. Words matter! And, usually, every phrase in a well-constructed lawsuit is there for a very specific legal reason... (lawyers don't like adding superfluous "ideas" that could muddy the waters, so to speak). Though it appears that the chilling effect doctrine is most commonly applied to 1st amendment cases, it sounds like they're trying to apply it in this case to the 2nd amendment. Paragraph 36 makes the argument that (aside from the 2 plaintiffs) - this "chilling effect" is far broader and impacts a very large number of people. (I'm sure this is the wrong legal phrasing, but I think the way this lawsuit is structured almost lends a "class action" vibe). Members of the jury... I rest my case! (LMAO!!)
  9. I'm no lawyer, but I suspect this is why they used the wording about representing "10's of thousands of gun owners who would apply..." I suspect they're making it harder for NJ to just make the case go away... or at least they have a related "phase 2" planned. I could be wrong. In any event... I wish you luck!
  10. My concern is more related to: hey, and I'll bring a reporter! I can see that going badly 50 different ways. I also don't think people should assume they'll be added to the case. Lawyers add plaintiffs to a case based on 100 different factors - I don't want to see anyone feeling (unreasonably) angry or disappointed if they're not added. I think that's reasonable!
  11. Again... I just think you need to pose that question to THEM (ANJRPC). They're the ones with the brainy lawyer, after all... (hey, don't ask me... I'm just a freelance writer in the "peanut gallery" with the rest of you)!! Your post just had me kinda chuckling to myself... because, yeah, there IS a lot of pent-up demand, obviously! But, does that mean everyone should suddenly go off half-cocked at such a pivotal time? Sheesh. Let cooler heads prevail, that's all I'm saying. Pick up the phone, send them an email... before you rush in. That's all I'm saying!
  12. @Downtownv WHOA!!! You can't just "join" someone's lawsuit, can you? I don't think that's how it works. You have to be invited. We've FINALLY got a legitimate 2A org, with NRA backing, and a winning attorney...filing a serious lawsuit... is this really the time to willy-nilly start going it alone? And then giving out that "legal" advice to everyone else??!! Pull in the reins, pls! What if the AP reporter manipulates the story and uses it against you/the case? What if you realize they had a better reporter they could have recommended... if you had only asked? What if they APPROVE a handful of these new applications, use it as a way to weaken the larger case, and then later, find a way to yank the ones they previously approved? Then everyone's screwed! I mean, you're a free citizen, clearly you can do whatever the hell you want! That's your right. I'm merely asking... why not just reach out and contact them first? I appreciate your passion, I really do. (I mean that! ) But, I'd rather see you acting strategically, rationally and as part of a coordinated approach - for everyone's sake! Just my 2 cents.
  13. YES! Frankly, I felt this guy was the highlight of the SAFE conference. After 5 minutes, I was thinking to myself, "this guy is SUPER bright..." Even more important, I could see he reveled in the detailed analysis and the strategy. That might be mind-numbing to some, but it's a critical skill for a great attorney. And get a load of his pedigree - Wharton (one of the top business schools in the country) and a J.D. from Univ of VA School of Law (consistently ranked in the top 10 of U.S. law schools). See his bio here: http://www.hartmanwinnicki.com/attorneys/daniel-schmutter-esq/ What strikes me (aside from the education, and of course impressive wins)... is Speaking Engagements (at the bottom)... where you spend your personal time reveals your passions & this guy is clearly passionate about 2A rights. Now, I've seen occasional complaints on these forums about whether the 2A groups shouldn't be bringing in "out-of-state" legal talent... well, that may apply to some of the lawyers that have worked on NJ cases, but I don't think it applies to this guy. After seeing his presentation, I was personally delighted to see his name on the lawsuit. IMO, Schmutter's no schmuck!
  14. I thought that was why the wording of the suit was particularly clever. By saying (don't have exact words in front of me) - we represent 10's of 1000's of gun owners who would apply, but who don't simply because they know they'll never meet the definition of "justifiable need" - it infers that the law alone is blocking people from applying. Now, whether that's enough to meet the threshold of the phrase "legal standing", I don't know. But, it certainly gives the case much broader "emotional punch" - which I sort of liked.
  15. BTW, I came into the show a few seconds late - missed the intro. Who was the red-headed woman? She spoke very briefly, but was effective as well - in terms of Murphy stripping away the right to self-defense from women in particular.
  16. I watched it. It was brief, but effective. I thought Bach's best point was this: under the current law you're allowed to defend yourself inside your home... is your life any less valuable once you leave your house? I thought that was a very simple, thought-provoking way to look at it. I'm glad to see the issue on a TV interview too. Edit: my post hit at same time as the one above - I concur with Lead's comments.
  17. From ANJRPC's website: Please tune in tonight at 11 p.m. to watch ANJRPC Executive Director Scott Bach discuss the case with host Bill Spadea and other guests. Tune in at 11p.m. to WWOR-TV (Ch. 9, in the NY metro area) Here's the link (with a link to view it online instead) - 2nd item on page btw: https://anjrpc.site-ym.com/page/RutgersBillPasses
  18. I can't speak to any political actions - real or perceived - that happened in the past with these groups. It's honestly just beyond my scope of knowledge (probably pre-dates my interest in shooting). I'm only speaking from a communications standpoint. IMO, as a general rule, ANY 2A spokesperson in this state when speaking with the press should: 1) promote the 2A cause, 2) certainly, promote their own business or group, and concurrently, 3) refrain from trashing any OTHER 2A individuals/orgs/businesses. Sure, squabble and fight for members & donations (that's just life, big deal)... but for goodness sakes, keep the infighting out of the damn press (and social media pages too). Really, is that such a high bar to meet? When someone starts a squabble in a public venue, squawking to the press like a moron, trashing other 2A entities... they are hurting the LARGER 2A cause. And don't we have enough challenges in this state already? People who do that crap won't get my support, it's that simple. Hey... that's just me. Everyone is free to follow their own values/personal guidelines.
  19. It's not that they don't give interviews - I've seen interviews with Anthony Colandro (he not only owns GFH but he's on ANJRPC's board too).. and I know Rosey has done interviews (for CNJFO). They've both done well. My point is that if NJ's legitimate 2A groups think someone isn't the best representative (or is liable to use the interview to promote their own goals OVER and ABOVE 2A goals), they might be well-served by competing for the attention of that reporter/media contact. That's all. And as volunteers join, I think all these orgs will do better at that.. because they'll have the HELP! Everything takes time & effort to do it well.
  20. Ohhhhh! Was THAT the guy? Yikes. OK, I totally didn't place the name! I remember that - and it was swarmy. Well, what should happen now is that legitimate groups should reach out to that reporter/paper - touting their credentials (X # of members, etc., etc.) and say "we'd love to be a contact for future articles" - then build a relationship with the reporter, always be responsive to their calls, etc.. - and simply nudge the other guy out of the favored position. That's how that should be handled, IMO! Sadly, we have a few knuckleheads in the 2A community who are good at "grabbing camera time" and using it to throw their perceived competitors under the bus - but we ALL lose when they do that. Thanks, again, for bringing that to my attention! I retract my flattery of him (LOL). I really despise opportunistic, disloyal types.
  21. He struck me as very sincere and interested in improving things. We all bitch about NJ's various guns laws (rightly so!)... but it's also nice to see when something is done to improve the situation. We can (and should) cheer when this happens. Every step in the right direction is a "win" in my book. I just hope this practice spreads to other PDs swiftly.
  22. Who the media reaches out to has to do with: who is in their community? who has done he best job of keeping their org/business on the radar screen of local press? So, yeah, we see all kinds of individuals and groups getting interviewed - with sometimes a questionable degree of veracity. That said, I thought this Ira guy did a pretty good job in the interview.
  23. There was an older thread about just this topic - various aids to help people rack a gun. Might be of some use to you...? Of course, your mom could also consider a revolver - and avoid the issue entirely. I have to admit, when @GRIZgenerously guested me into his range and let me try a lot of his handguns, I had a preconceived notion that I would NOT like revolvers. True, I still haven't bought one (yet, lol!)... but I must say, I was pleasantly surprised. Revolvers have a simple, user-friendly design that eliminates the hand strength issue that comes with racking a semi-auto. Here's the thread:
  24. I never understood why they'd waste their staffs' time doing extensions... it only increases the workload on their troopers. This sounds like smart streamlining. Good for them!

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.