Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Neighbor called the police while I was cleaning my handguns

Featured Replies

I was at the range this weekend and shot both my handguns (a Sig Sauer P6 and a S&W Model 59). Just a little while ago today, I was sitting on my back deck, cleaning them both. I was cleaning them outside because the cleaning supplies (solvent) gives me a headache if I do it inside the house, even with an open window and fans.

 

I had just finished cleaning and oiling the S&W, and was starting to field strip the Sig, when the doorbell rang. I set the gun down on the table, and answered the door to find two police officers. Apparently, they had received a call about a "man with a gun" on my property.

 

I told them that I legally own two handguns, had taken them to the range over the weekend, and was cleaning them out on my back deck. They asked what kind of guns they were, and asked to see my FID card and ID. After looking at my FID and driver's license, they asked if I had pointed the gun at anyone. I told them of course not, I was just stripping them down to clean and reassembled them, and never had them pointed anywhere except the ground (well, technically, my back deck), even when the slide was off the frame.

 

They then handed me back my license and FID card, apologized for the inconvenience, and told me that they were just required to respond after getting a nondescript "man with a gun" call. They never asked to see my firearms or to enter the house. I'm not sure what I would have done if they asked or demanded to enter my house or search my property.

 

I actually was pretty impressed by how the two officers handled the situation; both were very polite and professional about the whole thing. I'm not sure which neighbor actually called the police. I can see three houses from my back deck (one on each side, and a third is also visible because my lot goes back further than one adjacent neighbor's lot), but each is bordered by a fence, and I can see only a small portion of each of their yards, and can just barely see the first story windows of each neighbors' house.

 

Of course I'm quite a bit annoyed, not at the police, but because one of my neighbors called them on me, apparently claiming that I pointed it at them or their house.

 

Has anyone else ever had to deal with a neighbor calling the police for cleaning your (legally-owned) guns, or something similar, on your own property? How was that situation handled by the police?

 

If asked by an officer to inspect your firearms or to otherwise search without a warrant, what would be the best course of action? Do they need a warrant if a neighbor calls the police about seeing a gun (i.e. is that probable cause)?

I'm really glad to hear the officers were reasonable. It would be easy to get mad at them off the bat but they are just doing their job, you had the right attitude.

When SHTF, you'll fortunately know already that one of your neighbors will be absolutely useless :doh:

But seriously, I agree that you (and the police officers) handled the situation well. I've been wanting to clean my firearms outside myself, but I'm positive the same thing would happen to me as I know for a fact I have peeping neighbors.

A firearms purchaser ID is only good for long guns, what is the point of asking for one?

When SHTF, you'll fortunately know already that one of your neighbors will be absolutely useless :doh:

 

But bbk, the S will never HTF, we live in a civilized society! The police will help us, or FEMA! :dance:

 

You guys are making me put "private back yard" on the list of the next house I purchase for sure.

A firearms purchaser ID is only good for long guns, what is the point of asking for one?

 

Really? Can you buy a pistol without one? The Firearms ID card shows that you went through and passed the necessary criminal background check and are qualified to own a firearm in accordance with NJ law.

A firearms purchaser ID is only good for long guns, what is the point of asking for one?

 

Really? Can you buy a pistol without one? ...

Absolutely. As said many times here, a FPID is for PURCHASING long guns.

I know you can purchase a long gun with only a FID card. Are you saying that someone can walk into a police station, and request a pistol purchase permit without first having a FID card? Hmmmmmm...

  • Author
A firearms purchaser ID is only good for long guns, what is the point of asking for one?

 

Really? Can you buy a pistol without one? ...

Absolutely. As said many times here, a FPID is for PURCHASING long guns.

 

You need a FPID to obtain a handgun purchase permit. Hence, you cannot buy a handgun without an FID/FPID.

You need a FPID to obtain a handgun purchase permit. Hence, you cannot buy a handgun without an FID/FPID.

NO YOU DON'T.

You would be foolish not to request one, but you don't need it to buy handguns. You will be assigned an SBI#, if you don't already have one. That number will be your FPID card #. It will also be on your permits. They both do different things. YOU CAN GET EITHER OR BOTH.

 

In reference to the topic, no FPID or Permit is required by law to possess firearms on your own property.

PK90 - You may be more knowledgeable than me on this but I find this difficult at best to swallow. I do not mean to improperly challenge you on this but I find it hard to believe. I will do my research. It may have been said here many times, but there is also tons of mis-information on internet blogs. Can you please explain what an SBI# is and how it is issued?

You need a FPID to obtain a handgun purchase permit. Hence, you cannot buy a handgun without an FID/FPID.

NO YOU DON'T.

You would be foolish not to request one, but you don't need it to buy handguns. You will be assigned an SBI#, if you don't already have one. That number will be your FPID card #. It will also be on your permits. They both do different things. YOU CAN GET EITHER OR BOTH.

 

In reference to the topic, no FPID or Permit is required by law to possess firearms on your own property.

 

Absolutely right.

 

Oh, and SBI= state bureau of identification. You are issued a SBI number anytime your fingerprints are taken or entered into AFIS. Whether as an applicant for a job, for an arrest, or a ID card.

I was at the range this weekend and shot both my handguns (a Sig Sauer P6 and a S&W Model 59). Just a little while ago today, I was sitting on my back deck, cleaning them both. I was cleaning them outside because the cleaning supplies (solvent) gives me a headache if I do it inside the house, even with an open window and fans.

 

I had just finished cleaning and oiling the S&W, and was starting to field strip the Sig, when the doorbell rang. I set the gun down on the table, and answered the door to find two police officers. Apparently, they had received a call about a "man with a gun" on my property.

 

I told them that I legally own two handguns, had taken them to the range over the weekend, and was cleaning them out on my back deck. They asked what kind of guns they were, and asked to see my FID card and ID. After looking at my FID and driver's license, they asked if I had pointed the gun at anyone. I told them of course not, I was just stripping them down to clean and reassembled them, and never had them pointed anywhere except the ground (well, technically, my back deck), even when the slide was off the frame.

 

They then handed me back my license and FID card, apologized for the inconvenience, and told me that they were just required to respond after getting a nondescript "man with a gun" call. They never asked to see my firearms or to enter the house. I'm not sure what I would have done if they asked or demanded to enter my house or search my property.

 

I actually was pretty impressed by how the two officers handled the situation; both were very polite and professional about the whole thing. I'm not sure which neighbor actually called the police. I can see three houses from my back deck (one on each side, and a third is also visible because my lot goes back further than one adjacent neighbor's lot), but each is bordered by a fence, and I can see only a small portion of each of their yards, and can just barely see the first story windows of each neighbors' house.

 

Of course I'm quite a bit annoyed, not at the police, but because one of my neighbors called them on me, apparently claiming that I pointed it at them or their house.

 

Has anyone else ever had to deal with a neighbor calling the police for cleaning your (legally-owned) guns, or something similar, on your own property? How was that situation handled by the police?

 

If asked by an officer to inspect your firearms or to otherwise search without a warrant, what would be the best course of action? Do they need a warrant if a neighbor calls the police about seeing a gun (i.e. is that probable cause)?

 

 

You should have a weekly outdoor gun cleaning. Next time bring out the rifles and shotguns, and if you have any of the "scary" guns that would be better. Bring a few guns out and sit there cleaning your pistol, maybe turn on the radio have a ham sandwich and a Pepsi after your done admiring your work. Your neighbor will have a meltdown and might say something to you instead of calling the police next time, maybe you can smoke her out. (Excuse the sexism, but it has to be a woman)

SBI = State Bureau of Identification issues you a number, i.e. 123456E, when you get fingerprinted, either for a FPID, Permit, job, or arrest, etc.

 

Early SBI# are 12345 without the letter at the end. The Old-Timers possess these. I believe that the newer numbers end in F.

 

Mine has an E. Issued in March.

 

I'm not sure if the feds have any info retained on me as I purchased other guns in the 90s when I lived in Ohio but I'm sure that didn't impact NJ at all.

  • Author

According to http://www.njguns.com/permit.htm:

 

There are two types of purchase permits in New Jersey. The first is the Firearms ID card and the second is a Pistol Permit. You will need to apply for both if this is your first time buying a firearm. The Firearms ID card is used in two ways. First it allows you to purchase any long gun (rifle/shotgun). Second it has an SBI number on it which is required for your NIC check at the time you purchase a pistol. You must have the FID card even if you don't plan on buying a long gun.

According to http://www.njguns.com/permit.htm:

 

There are two types of purchase permits in New Jersey. The first is the Firearms ID card and the second is a Pistol Permit. You will need to apply for both if this is your first time buying a firearm. The Firearms ID card is used in two ways. First it allows you to purchase any long gun (rifle/shotgun). Second it has an SBI number on it which is required for your NIC check at the time you purchase a pistol. You must have the FID card even if you don't plan on buying a long gun.

 

Sorry JE - this link you reference is just another internet blog. Go the the NJ statutes and interpret the law yourself.

PK, How long have you had the rubber room,, I might need to try it some day.. :lol::lol:

 

And dam dude you are awfully skinny, I will bring burger's.. :lol::lol::lol::lol:

Does this argument really matter? Sure the law dictates otherwise, but the courts couldn't give two **** in this state. The trial might get thrown out, but it'll still force some hardship on the law abiding citizen. So, instead of trying to highlight minor loop holes of sorts, why cause more trouble then good?

 

Though, if you guys are arguing for arguments sake-- I won't stop you.

I am glad it all worked out, but what was the point of asking for your FID card on your property. You do not need one to have a gun on your property. I personally think they asked more than they had to. I may be legally wrong in my opinion, but I still think it was a violation of your rights. If you did not have a card would they have arrested you?

 

You need the sign pointing to your liberal neighbors house for the criminals to rob.

...also, you can be legally in possession of handguns in your home without a FPID card or PPP if you obtained them legally while a resident in another state and moved to NJ or you inherited them, or you obtained them before the PPP. There might be other scenarios, but the point is, not having a FPID card doesn't mean you not legally in position of your handguns.

 

Of course, that doesn't mean that the police officer at the door knows that.

 

In Evan Nappan's new book, he has a blurb about what he would do if a police officer asked to search his car. I think it applies here. He responds by asking the officer why he is asking. If the officer responds with a standard answer like, "I'm required to ask" then he respectfully declines. If the officer says "because there are spent shell casings on your back seat" then he knows the officer already has probable cause to search the vehicle if he can't produce a permit, so he would cooperate.

 

Smity

I clean all of my guns on the deck becouse I have 4 little ones running around and I really don't think that them breathing in the chemicals would be a good thing becouse they are really highstrung as it is! :doh: :doh: Plus, my if neighbors get a little curious they just come on over and B.S. wondering when am I gona take them shooting! There are about 12 neighbors that are armed in my neighborhood. I really don't think that anyone has a problem.

As far as "probable cause," I think it's best not to challenge or question an officer on probable cause directly at the scene, you're likely not going to get an intellectual or congenial conversation started about the finer points of Amend. IV at that time and could find yourself "in contempt of officer" (which is not a crime, but can bring about physical pain).

 

As for any search/seizure, I would deviate from Nappan in one sense; I would not ask why the officer is asking to search or why he's asking me to step out of my car.

 

The default answer to any officer request is: "if you are asking my permission (or if you are asking me to voluntarily step out of my car), my answer is 'no.' If you are giving me an order, then I will comply, officer."

 

It may be best to use this quote with every order/request the officer presents to you. In my mind (I'm not a lawyer), this establishes a very clear delineation that you are not consenting and you can later challenge in court, also, you are also not obstructing or resisting.

 

 

On a much happier note, I'm glad the officers were professional and courteous.

Depends, If the officers seemed interested in checking out the firearms as gun enthusiasts rather than for snooping purposes, I would be happy to let them see the guns. I would probably say to em "I'll show you mine, if you show me yours". :lol:

first of all.

pols_feature12-1.jpg

 

now that thats out of the way,

 

you should not have to explain your actions on your private property to the police.

You are issued a SBI number anytime your fingerprints are taken or entered into AFIS

 

To clarify that statement somewhat, you aren't issued a SBI number every time prints are enters. The number issued originally is used for the subsequent entries. Under the manual system multiple SBI number were issued at times but later merged when found to be duplicates.

 

I have to say that in the last ten years of admin work, I've NEVER seen anyone come in and ask for a PPP without also requesting a FID card. One will be issued under all new applications regardless of their desire to have one or not. Would make it interesting when they request a change of address or modification. While technically correct, there is absolutely no benefit do doing it that way. Time frames are identical for both.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.