Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Fairview police chief blasted for supporting felon

Featured Replies

Some "arsenal"

 

The guy was a felon, so legally he shouldn't have guns, but in a different state, this is hardly criminal.

 

 

--------------

Fairview police chief blasted for letter supporting Cliffside Park man sentenced on gun charge

http://www.northjersey.com/news/121409_ ... harge.html

 

A federal prosecutor blasted Fairview

but in a different state, this is hardly criminal.

 

How so?

He illegally had a NFA item unless registered with the feds and the tax stamp is required it's a crime.

I also do not know another state where you can be a twice convicted felon and own firearms legally.

 

I think the upsetment is more about the fact that the Police Chief tried to use his office as leverage to

get this man a lesser sentence. He claims no but I would bet my lunch money that it was written on paper

with his official letter head and I guess he also failed to mention in that letter that it's his girlfriends brother.

  • Author
but in a different state, this is hardly criminal.

 

How so?

He illegally had a NFA item unless registered with the feds and the tax stamp is required it's a crime.

I also do not know another state where you can be a twice convicted felon and own firearms legally.

 

I guess that was poorly written.

 

It's entirely possible to have silencers in other states. In NJ it's not. That was the genesis of my statement. I also realize, as I noted that being a felon prohibits gun owner ship.

It's entirely possible to have silencers in other states

 

Yes it is in some I agree but this guy does not sound like the type to ask the feds for one. :D

Also the silencer was fitted to a chopped down weapon, that's not legal anywhere.The guy is a twice now three time convicted felon; not to mention the second charge of cocaine, I think everyone knows what drugs and now guns is bringing to the neighborhood. My Grandfather lives in Cliffside Park and for the most part it's pretty peaceful but if you know anything about Cliffside you know it's corrupt as hell just like Fairview,N.Bergen, J.C, Secaucus and on and on.

When is it legal to chop down a gun to machine it for a silencer?

Even if you have a class III you cannot alter the weapons and still be legal.

Not to mention the gun was illegal from jump.

When is it legal to chop down a gun to machine it for a silencer?

Even if you have a class III you cannot alter the weapons and still be legal.

Not to mention the gun was illegal from jump.

 

There's no laws on chopping pistols afaik (either state or federal) I can take my 5 inch pistol and make it a 2 inch if i want. Please provide links if I'm wrong

 

The threaded barrel would be ok on a semi-auto pistol in NJ if you don't have any other evil features per title13ch54

 

(All this is not withstanding the past felonies.. I'm talking about the gun itself without the silencer)

You cannot chop a gun down legally with the intent of threading the barrel to fit it with a silencer. I don't need a link to tell me this. The whole reason this guy got in hot water is because he shouldn't have had the guns in the first place. When you are a 2 time convicted felon and you have an arsenal of whatever size guns you just became a 3 time felon no matter what. NJ of all places is like the gestapo when it pertains to firearms now add this guys past it just escalates the situation. We can't even own a rifle with more than 15 round mags it's not feasible to think that chopping gun barrels would fly here.

You cannot chop a gun down legally with the intent of threading the barrel to fit it with a silencer. I don't need a link to tell me this. The whole reason this guy got in hot water is because he shouldn't have had the guns in the first place. When you are a 2 time convicted felon and you have an arsenal of whatever size guns you just became a 3 time felon no matter what. NJ of all places is like the gestapo when it pertains to firearms now add this guys past it just escalates the situation. We can't even own a rifle with more than 15 round mags it's not feasible to think that chopping gun barrels would fly here.

 

I'm not debating the fact that the gun laws in NJ Suck. I am not debating, nor do I care what happens to this felon who is not legally allowed to have a gun... I hope they put him in prison and throw away the key.

 

What I am debating.. is your own ignorant interpretation of firearms laws.

 

It's this kind of fear that helps perpetuate the agenda that scumbags we have to call "elected officials" push. I see countless guys at my range who are scared and don't believe me when I explain how my guns are 100% legal. There could be hundreds of new potential firearms owners reading your baseless posts and it's not right to scare them off needlessly.

 

Stick to the facts and only the facts.

 

Provide me with some law or documentation that cutting and threading a pistol barrel is illegal in NJ or the USA and I'll gladly eat my own hat and buy you lunch.

 

BTW.. a normal citizen can't own any magazine designed for a semi-auto firearm with a capacity over 15 rounds in NJ.. it's not just rifles.

You cannot chop a gun down legally with the intent of threading the barrel to fit it with a silencer. I don't need a link to tell me this. The whole reason this guy got in hot water is because he shouldn't have had the guns in the first place. When you are a 2 time convicted felon and you have an arsenal of whatever size guns you just became a 3 time felon no matter what. NJ of all places is like the gestapo when it pertains to firearms now add this guys past it just escalates the situation. We can't even own a rifle with more than 15 round mags it's not feasible to think that chopping gun barrels would fly here.

 

I'm not debating the fact that the gun laws in NJ Suck. I am not debating, nor do I care what happens to this felon who is not legally allowed to have a gun... I hope they put him in prison and throw away the key.

 

What I am debating.. is your own ignorant interpretation of firearms laws.

 

It's this kind of fear that helps perpetuate the agenda that scumbags we have to call "elected officials" push. I see countless guys at my range who are scared and don't believe me when I explain how my guns are 100% legal. There could be hundreds of new potential firearms owners reading your baseless posts and it's not right to scare them off needlessly.

 

Stick to the facts and only the facts.

 

Provide me with some law or documentation that cutting and threading a pistol barrel is illegal in NJ or the USA and I'll gladly eat my own hat and buy you lunch.

 

BTW.. a normal citizen can't own any magazine designed for a semi-auto firearm with a capacity over 15 rounds in NJ.. it's not just rifles.

 

Since you know so much about facts then you are familiar with this little thing called the NFA or for the ignorant National Firearms Act. Try reading it. When you get to the part that talks about criminal conduct reread it and you'll see where it states the act makes certain conduct a criminal offense, including but not limited to: engaging in business as a manufacturer when you alter a guns barrel length and thread it you are now considered a manufacturer which according to the NFA is criminal conduct.

I can't find what your talking about, but.. perhaps you forgot this part:

 

(10) The term "manufacturer"

means any person engaged in the

business of manufacturing firearms or

ammunition for purposes of sale or distribution;

and the term "licensed

manufacturer" means any such person

licensed under the provisions of

this chapter.

 

Perhaps you should re-read it and pay better attention.

 

I never said ANYTHING about manufacturing firearms (The receiver) for sale or distribution. I said there is nothing wrong with cutting and threading a pistol barrel. Barrels and threads are not registered nor are they even serialized for the most part. So every machine shop that turns AR barrels is an illegal manufacturer?

 

That's like saying you can't put new wheels on your car because you don't have a mechanic's certification.

 

How do you explain away these guns? Do I need my NFA tax stamp for these?

 

Sig Mosquito

sig-mosquito-pistolbig.jpg

 

Sig P220 Combat

sig_220_combat_thread.jpg

There is this thing in the law called intent and when you alter a gun with the intent of threading a barrel for a silencer you are committing a criminal act and that will be proven in court. If you want to have threaded barrel guns by all means enjoy them. If you want to cut your barrels down knock yourself out. In fact the only reason why I even responded is because you came across like a condescending know it all for lack of a better term, but the truth is the reason why anti-gun lobbyist in NJ have no problem stomping all over our 2nd amended right is cause people like you who foolishly misinterpret they laws that they are providing. I don't agree with the way NJ provides these laws but I'm not going to start reading them and interpreting them how I want because every law provider will do his best to make an example, so I'm glad you're stepping up to be that example.

Alright you two, now we are name calling and it is time to knock it off. I have enjoyed the exchange because it is a gray area open for interpretaion. I would like a definitive answer as well. But I will close the thread if we make it personal.

There is this thing in the law called intent and when you alter a gun with the intent of threading a barrel for a silencer you are committing a criminal act and that will be proven in court. If you want to have threaded barrel guns by all means enjoy them. If you want to cut your barrels down knock yourself out. In fact the only reason why I even responded is because you came across like a condescending knowi t all, but the truth is the reason why anti-gun lobbyist in NJ have no problem stomping all over our 2nd amended right is cause people like you who foolishly misinterpret they laws that they are providing. I don't agree with the way NJ provides these laws but I'm not going to start reading them and interpreting them how I want because every law provider will do his best to make an example, so I'm glad you're stepping up to be that example.

 

Well now your being childish with the name calling... but that's OK.. I'm above that.

 

You are correct on one thing.. I am a condescending know it all when I know I'm right. You are more than able to prove me wrong and I welcome you to. All you are doing is posting your own opinion. Lets see some facts posted. Statues, case law, liberal newspaper articles, even Wikipedia pages for gods sake. Prove me wrong.. I will stand up to my end of the deal. I will post an apology thread here and buy you lunch. But.. I don't see that happening.

 

You go from saying that if you cut your pistol barrel down, it makes you an illegal manufacturer. Then when I prove to you that pistol barrels have nothing to do with being a manufacturer.. you say that intent to install a silencer is illegal based on your own opinion and then call me names and say nasty things.

 

So let me get this straight as we stand now.. if I take my new pistol.. and cut and thread the barrel.. without intent to install a silencer (how would you prove that anyways?).. I'm now ok? (Despite what you said before)..

 

But.. if I want to install a silencer on my threaded pistol.. I'm not ok? (Despite not actually having a silencer, parts to build a silencer.. and not trying to buy one illegally?)

 

I'm just trying to get your web of tangled confusion sorted out.

 

Edit: I was typing this out as TBtrout replied.

I don't care what you think do whatever it is you want. I was asked to edit and bow out so I am. Hence the "done" post

I don't care what you think do whatever it is you want. I was asked to edit and bow out so I am. Hence the "done" post

 

You weren't asked to Bow out at all. You were asked to keep it civil and not stoop to a level we don't need on this board. We are all for debates, its when name calling and wishing death upon someone is what we don't need.

 

Ed I edited your post since you qouted what Klutch had fixed. This thread is now cleaned up, please don't make me do it again, or like Tim said, it'll be locked.

 

Now whose got the right answer with statues etc??

Anybody see Manswers tonight?.....freaking awesome.

Anybody see Manswers tonight?.....freaking awesome.

How about those giants :?

When you say to clean it up or lock the thread to me that means bow out I have tried several times now to leave it alone but apparently Ed can't figure this out I have nothing further to say.

Anybody see Manswers tonight?.....freaking awesome.

 

I could say hey you stay on topic, but this topic is so far off topic I can't.

 

But manswers and 1000 ways to die was AWESOME tonight

When you say to clean it up or lock the thread to me that means bow out I have nothing further to say

 

It only means bow out if you can't handle yourself in a grown up matter and leave the trash talk at the door. If you can leave the trash talk behind and act in a civil manner, by all means, debate until your heart is content.

When you say to clean it up or lock the thread to me that means bow out I have nothing further to say

 

It only means bow out if you can't handle yourself in a grown up matter and leave the trash talk at the door. If you can leave the trash talk behind and act in a civil manner, by all means, debate until your heart is content.

you have made your point several times now and I'm pretty sure I got it the first time. I made retarded post and cleaned it up as asked how many more time does it need to be said?

How about changing out the barrel on a pistol....Surely thats legal..and why couldnt you change out the barrel with a different length barrel? I have 2 S&W model 10 pistols..one with a 4 inch barrel and one with a 2 inch barrel...both are 100% kosher. There are laws against turning a rifle into a pistol by cutting it down...maybe thats what you are thinking of?

How about changing out the barrel on a pistol....Surely thats legal..and why couldnt you change out the barrel with a different length barrel? I have 2 S&W model 10 pistols..one with a 4 inch barrel and one with a 2 inch barrel...both are 100% kosher. There are laws against turning a rifle into a pistol by cutting it down...maybe thats what you are thinking of?

 

Did you ever see the Dan Wesson Kits on gun broker where the revolver comes with multiple length barrels that are user changeable?

How about changing out the barrel on a pistol....Surely thats legal..and why couldnt you change out the barrel with a different length barrel? I have 2 S&W model 10 pistols..one with a 4 inch barrel and one with a 2 inch barrel...both are 100% kosher. There are laws against turning a rifle into a pistol by cutting it down...maybe thats what you are thinking of?

 

Did you ever see the Dan Wesson Kits on gun broker where the revolver comes with multiple length barrels that are user changeable?

 

nevermind the Myriad aftermarket barrels available for all types of semis that come threaded.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.