Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

TSA to swab airline passenger hands in search for explosives

Featured Replies

Just wonderful. I shoot, I fly pretty regularly. In fact, back in September, we had an NJGF meet and I flew out to Germany 6 hours later.

 

There's probably Gunpowder residue all over the place in my house. It's unavoidable. This really sucks.

 

-------------

http://www.cnn.com/2010/TRAVEL/02/17/ts ... index.html

 

Washington (CNN) -- To the list of instructions you hear at airport checkpoints, add this: "Put your palms forward, please."

 

The Transportation Security Administration soon will begin randomly swabbing passengers' hands at checkpoints and airport gates to test them for traces of explosives.

 

Previously, screeners swabbed some carry-on luggage and other objects as they searched for the needle in the security haystack -- components of terrorist bombs in an endless stream of luggage.

 

But after the Christmas Day attempted bombing of Northwest Flight 253 over Detroit, Michigan, the TSA began a program of swabbing passengers' hands, which could be contaminated by explosive materials, experts say. The TSA will greatly expand the swabbing in the coming weeks, the agency said.

 

"The point is to make sure that the air environment is a safe environment," Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano told CNN. "We know that al Qaeda [and other] terrorists continue to think of aviation as a way to attack the United States. One way we keep it safe is by new technology [and] random use of different types of technology."

 

Security experts consulted by CNN said swabbing hands is a good move, and privacy advocates said they support the new swabbing protocols, provided the agency tests only for security-related objects and does not discriminate when it selects people to be tested.

 

It's a "very good idea," said security expert Tony Fainberg. TSA screeners currently swab luggage handles and parts of bags that are likely be contaminated by human hands, he said, and swabbing a person's hands increases the chances of finding explosive materials. "Looking at the hands means you will probably get a better dose," he said.

 

Under the new protocols, tests will be conducted at various locations -- including in checkpoint lines, during the screening process and at gates. Newer, more portable machines make it easier to conduct tests away from fixed locations such as the checkpoint.

 

The TSA has more than 7,000 explosive trace detection (ETD) machines and has purchased 400 additional units with $16 million in federal stimulus money. The president's fiscal 2011 budget calls for $60 million to purchase approximately 800 portable ETD machines.

 

Napolitano said the tests will not significantly increase wait times at airport checkpoints.

 

The American Civil Liberties Union has "always supported explosive detection as a good form of security that doesn't really invade privacy," said Jay Stanley, an attorney and privacy expert with the organization.

 

Stanley said the ACLU is chiefly concerned that the TSA does not discriminate when selecting people for enhanced screening -- something the agency said it does not do -- and that it treat people with dignity.

 

"We would not want to see it implemented in a discriminatory fashion, for example, in a disproportionate way against Muslims and Arabs or, for example, people with red hair or anything else. Security experts from across the spectrum will tell you that that's not just unfair and unjust and not the American way, it's also a terrible way to do security," Stanley said.

 

Swabbing also should not be used to test for nonsecurity-related contraband, such as drugs, he said. "Under the Constitution, searches in airports are only for the purpose of protecting the security of airline transportation; they are not general law enforcement stops. And so it wouldn't be permissible for the government to use these trace portal detectors to look for drugs," Stanley said.

 

The TSA said the machines test only for explosives. It declined to specify which explosives, citing security reasons.

 

Because some legal substances -- such as fertilizers and heart medicines -- can result in "false positives," Stanley said the ACLU also wants to ensure that people who test positive be treated respectfully.

 

"It's important that the government treat people who do show up as a positive -- fairly and with dignity -- and not parade them off in handcuffs and treat them as terrorists, but do rational things to investigate what the problem might be," he said.

 

But swabbing hands does not, by itself, raise civil liberty problems, Stanley said. "There's really not a big privacy interest at stake here," he said. "They are basically looking for particles of explosives, which is not something that people normally have."

GSR vs explosive residue - I would believe that the chemical compositions are different.

"It's important that the government treat people who do show up as a positive -- fairly and with dignity -- and not parade them off in handcuffs and treat them as terrorists, but do rational things to investigate what the problem might be," he said.

 

But swabbing hands does not, by itself, raise civil liberty problems, Stanley said. "There's really not a big privacy interest at stake here," he said. "They are basically looking for particles of explosives, which is not something that people normally have."

Unless you're coming back from a shooting event or show, or you're a recreational shooter in a hurry to get on a flight to Germany, or own a gun shop, or reload ammo, or or or or.

Yea, my understanding is that the compositions were different as well.

I don't see the problem, obviously if you own guns you are a terrorist...

This reminds me of an incident I witnessed ~15 years ago.

 

While I was returning from Yuma Proving Grounds in Arizona a uniformed Army Captain was being detained and yelled at because the scanner detected explosive residue on his bag.

 

While anyone with any knowledge of the YPG knows that one of the base's main functions is to test and evaluate military weapons and ammunition.

 

The poor captain had been stationed at the Proving grounds for a month overseeing some of this testing and had residue from the tests on his laundry and bag.

 

Nice to see that for doing the country a service you can get publiclly abused and maligned.

I don't see the problem, obviously if you own guns you are a terrorist...

If I see that quote in the NY times tomorrow, you've got some 'splainin' to do, Lucy.

Couple years ago I had a family reunion out in Iowa for the 4th of July and I shot off a metric crap-ton of fireworks right before I drove to the airport. Didn't wash the clothes I was wearing, just changed and threw the black powder smelling ones right in the suitcase.

 

Started sweating when I got to the airport and saw they were opening up suitcases and rubbing patches on the contents, then putting the patches in a "sniffer" to check for explosives.

 

I passed without a hitch. Guess fireworks powder doesn't count...

" "Under the Constitution, searches in airports are only for the purpose of protecting the security of airline transportation; they are not general law enforcement stops. And so it wouldn't be permissible for the government to use these trace portal detectors to look for drugs," Stanley said."

 

And what Constitution may that be?

More fodder.... The person who builds the bomb isn't usually the guy blowing himself up.... I've seen enough movies to know that

" "Under the Constitution, searches in airports are only for the purpose of protecting the security of airline transportation; they are not general law enforcement stops. And so it wouldn't be permissible for the government to use these trace portal detectors to look for drugs," Stanley said."

 

And what Constitution may that be?

 

Actually this WAS true...until they Federalized Airport Security into TSA. When the airports were PRIVATE securoty, they could search whatever they wanted to Constitution or not because they werent a part of the Government, or Law Enforcement (PAPD WOULD fall under the Constitutional limits becuae they are considered "Police" evne though the PA is a private entity), and werent bound by the limits of the Constitution and the 4th Ammendment.

GSR vs explosive residue - I would believe that the chemical compositions are different.

 

The machines look for nitrates, which I believe is a major component of most propellants. Wash your hands. Most home made explosives also involve some form of nitrates. Also TSA has only been around 8 years 15 don't count. The machines have been upgraded since 9/11. If used properly they are extremely sensitive.

 

An alarm means a more though check not an arrest. Any illeagal items found at a security check point can lead to an arrest. If you enter for screening you have given legal consent for a search.

 

If our friend the under wear bomber had had his hands checked he would have been caught.

 

TC

GSR vs explosive residue - I would believe that the chemical compositions are different.

 

The machines look for nitrates, which I believe is a major component of most propellants. Wash your hands. Most home made explosives also involve some form of nitrates. Also TSA has only been around 8 years 15 don't count. The machines have been upgraded since 9/11. If used properly they are extremely sensitive.

 

An alarm means a more though check not an arrest. Any illeagal items found at a security check point can lead to an arrest. If you enter for screening you have given legal consent for a search.

 

If our friend the under wear bomber had had his hands checked he would have been caught.

 

TC

 

The Swab machines will actually tell exactly what the Substance is. GSR will test positive for Nitrated and Lead Styphenate, but it will also be classified as GSR. Try going through one after spending some time on the Bomb Range though.... :evil:

The Swab machines will actually tell exactly what the Substance is. GSR will test positive for Nitrated and Lead Styphenate, but it will also be classified as GSR. Try going through one after spending some time on the Bomb Range though.... :evil:

 

Hey you'll get through it will take a little longer but with the proper ID and explanation you'll be fine. I Know, been there, done that.

 

If the TSA has a bit of sense, but like every where else common sense can be lacking.

 

TC

The Swab machines will actually tell exactly what the Substance is. GSR will test positive for Nitrated and Lead Styphenate, but it will also be classified as GSR. Try going through one after spending some time on the Bomb Range though.... :evil:

 

Hey you'll get through it will take a little longer but with the proper ID and explanation you'll be fine. I Know, been there, done that.

 

If the TSA has a bit of sense, but like every where else common sense can be lacking.

 

TC

 

What proper ID would that be? There isn't a bag I own that hasn't had ammo, loose grains of smokeless powder, and GSR and even burn marks on or in it. Since I don't have an X-ray machine, I'm sure I've inadvertently brought ammo or expended casings onto planes. It's pretty hard to find every little piece of that stuff. I have a computer case swabbed once that doubles as a gun case for SMG, suppressor, and ammo. It's been filled with spent ammo repeatedly, and it's been open at indoor ranges where the GSR was so thick in the air that I put on an OV relief dust mask.

Well, spent the morning shooting at the range, and the afternoon loading some rounds and cleaning my guns, and at 9pm I will be flying to London. I'll let you know what happens.....

The Swab machines will actually tell exactly what the Substance is. GSR will test positive for Nitrated and Lead Styphenate, but it will also be classified as GSR. Try going through one after spending some time on the Bomb Range though.... :evil:

 

Hey you'll get through it will take a little longer but with the proper ID and explanation you'll be fine. I Know, been there, done that.

 

If the TSA has a bit of sense, but like every where else common sense can be lacking.

 

TC

 

What proper ID would that be? There isn't a bag I own that hasn't had ammo, loose grains of smokeless powder, and GSR and even burn marks on or in it. Since I don't have an X-ray machine, I'm sure I've inadvertently brought ammo or expended casings onto planes. It's pretty hard to find every little piece of that stuff. I have a computer case swabbed once that doubles as a gun case for SMG, suppressor, and ammo. It's been filled with spent ammo repeatedly, and it's been open at indoor ranges where the GSR was so thick in the air that I put on an OV relief dust mask.

 

Proper ID meaning military, police, and commercial explosives contractor other wise exposure to explosives would be suspicious and need further investigation.

 

TC

The Swab machines will actually tell exactly what the Substance is. GSR will test positive for Nitrated and Lead Styphenate, but it will also be classified as GSR. Try going through one after spending some time on the Bomb Range though.... :evil:

 

Hey you'll get through it will take a little longer but with the proper ID and explanation you'll be fine. I Know, been there, done that.

 

If the TSA has a bit of sense, but like every where else common sense can be lacking.

 

TC

 

What proper ID would that be? There isn't a bag I own that hasn't had ammo, loose grains of smokeless powder, and GSR and even burn marks on or in it. Since I don't have an X-ray machine, I'm sure I've inadvertently brought ammo or expended casings onto planes. It's pretty hard to find every little piece of that stuff. I have a computer case swabbed once that doubles as a gun case for SMG, suppressor, and ammo. It's been filled with spent ammo repeatedly, and it's been open at indoor ranges where the GSR was so thick in the air that I put on an OV relief dust mask.

 

Proper ID meaning military, police, and commercial explosives contractor other wise exposure to explosives would be suspicious and need further investigation.

 

TC

 

So you are saying GSR will require some kind of ID and explanation or will not? I got lost in your transition to explosives.

Mipa, he was responding to me alone on the explosives issue..NOT on the GSR issue.

Mipa, he was responding to me alone on the explosives issue..NOT on the GSR issue.

 

Just out of curiosity, since nitroglycerin and nitrocellulose are ingredients of modern smokeless powder, does this mean TSA cannot discriminate smokeless powder from gelatin dynamite?

 

The theme of this thread, for the most part, has been people concerned about shooting a gun (oh my!) and getting on a plane. As I pointed out, outside of NJ, almost everybody in the country has their s**t covered with these chemicals. TSA must detect them on a minimum of 20% of swabs. Obviously they don't care about it.

 

Living in a state that makes firearms ownership criminal (with exceptions) can warp your mind and distort your perception of the real world.

This is why I refuse to fly. I know it precludes me from seeing alot of places, but its not worth it for me to have to deal with such stupidity and pay to have it heaped on me.

Mipa, he was responding to me alone on the explosives issue..NOT on the GSR issue.

 

Just out of curiosity, since nitroglycerin and nitrocellulose are ingredients of modern smokeless powder, does this mean TSA cannot discriminate smokeless powder from gelatin dynamite?

 

The theme of this thread, for the most part, has been people concerned about shooting a gun (oh my!) and getting on a plane. As I pointed out, outside of NJ, almost everybody in the country has their s**t covered with these chemicals. TSA must detect them on a minimum of 20% of swabs. Obviously they don't care about it.

 

Living in a state that makes firearms ownership criminal (with exceptions) can warp your mind and distort your perception of the real world.

 

Reading is Fundamental Tank and I had already Agreed that GSR was readily Identifiable because of certain taggants in Smokeless powder. YOU decided to take a personal comment between us that was anecdotal from a mutual experience and draw it out into something that did not concern either you or the issue at hand.

This is why I refuse to fly. I know it precludes me from seeing alot of places, but its not worth it for me to have to deal with such stupidity and pay to have it heaped on me.

 

That's a pretty radical response. I fly all the time, and have had 0 (ZERO, aka NADDA) bad experiences with security. Perhaps 1 out of 100 flights they search a carryon, always very carefully, quickly, respectfully. A few weeks ago they swabbed the outside of my carryon, but it tooked an extra minute, at most.

 

I flew today internationally covered with smokeless powder, without incident, although I didn't see any TSA swabbing happening.

 

In fact, i almost never see anyone being hassled in any way. Sometimes the security line is long and slow, but people get through, and I don't see anyone hassling anyone else.

 

I know that we see TSA debacles in the news every few weeks, but considering how many millions of people go through security every week, it's probably an unbelievably small percentage.

Reading is Fundamental Tank and I had already Agreed that GSR was readily Identifiable because of certain taggants in Smokeless powder. YOU decided to take a personal comment between us that was anecdotal from a mutual experience and draw it out into something that did not concern either you or the issue at hand.

 

It's a forum, I'll chime in where I want. Everything posted here concerns me. Be sure to let me know when there is a privileged discussion that does not concern me.

 

I did overlook your earlier post, so my mistake. And, I wasn't really responding to you, even thought I quoted you. I saw a tone in this thread that I wanted to respond to and just picked your quote out of opportunity. Second mistake. Sorry for my rather indiscriminate interjection. Now I feel like I was acting contemptuous and that makes me feel bad. I was a few down and sometimes that makes me shoot from the hip a bit, not that it's an excuse.

 

Taggants? Really? Another thing I've learned today. I though they never made it to the market (back in the 80s 90s). I'd like to hear about that, please (sincerely).

 

Seems that would mean a little smokeless powder on your articles would negate detections of plastic dynamites. Not a good system. If true at all.

Reading is Fundamental Tank and I had already Agreed that GSR was readily Identifiable because of certain taggants in Smokeless powder. YOU decided to take a personal comment between us that was anecdotal from a mutual experience and draw it out into something that did not concern either you or the issue at hand.

 

It's a forum, I'll chime in where I want. Everything posted here concerns me. Be sure to let me know when there is a privileged discussion that does not concern me.

 

I did overlook your earlier post, so my mistake. And, I wasn't really responding to you, even thought I quoted you. I saw a tone in this thread that I wanted to respond to and just picked your quote out of opportunity. Second mistake. Sorry for my rather indiscriminate interjection. Now I feel like I was acting contemptuous and that makes me feel bad. I was a few down and sometimes that makes me shoot from the hip a bit, not that it's an excuse.

 

Taggants? Really? Another thing I've learned today. I though they never made it to the market (back in the 80s 90s). I'd like to hear about that, please (sincerely).

 

Seems that would mean a little smokeless powder on your articles would negate detections of plastic dynamites. Not a good system. If true at all.

No, it wpouldnt, there is a HUGE difference Chemically between Nitrocellulose and ANY high explosive. the machines can, and WILL isolate each individual compound, whether its GSR , APP, PETN RDX, or any of a thousand others.

Yes, there is a huge difference between powder residue, and the compounds of most bombs.

 

It is fairly easy to any chemist to determine the difference.

 

As an aside... when I was in frankfurt, they took my camera to test it for residue. My camera is right next to my guns, and has been to many ranges, not an issue. Same thing when I traveled on El Al to Israel.... and was checked out by not only the TSA, but the Israeili security, both in JFK, in Jeruselem, and Frankfurt.

 

I had shot a day or two earlier, probably wearing the same pair of jeans, and had the same backpack as I took the range, as Carry-on. I am sure there was an empty brass case lodged there somewhere. lol.

 

I am traveling on Wed morning, and will be taking my range bag as carry-on, instead of paying for checked baggage, so will see.

No, it wpouldnt, there is a HUGE difference Chemically between Nitrocellulose and ANY high explosive. the machines can, and WILL isolate each individual compound, whether its GSR , APP, PETN RDX, or any of a thousand others.

 

I thought modern smokeless powder was nitrocellulose and nitroglycerin. Those are the explosive ingredients of plastic dynamites. The relative fractions may be off. But a bomber would not WANT dynamite on his luggage. So there would be only trace quantities (a few micrograms). The bomber would intentionally put smokeless powder on his luggage, so there would be much more (several milligrams). No longer would there be a distinguishable difference in the relative fractions. And you are telling me (I think?) that detections of nitrocellulose and nitroglycerin are qualified as not a threat by the presence of "taggants," which I did not even know where used in smokeless powder until yesterday. Am I missing something? And are taggants in use? I thought the idea died in the early 90s. Thanks.

No, it wpouldnt, there is a HUGE difference Chemically between Nitrocellulose and ANY high explosive. the machines can, and WILL isolate each individual compound, whether its GSR , APP, PETN RDX, or any of a thousand others.

 

I thought modern smokeless powder was nitrocellulose and nitroglycerin. Those are the explosive ingredients of plastic dynamites. The relative fractions may be off. But a bomber would not WANT dynamite on his luggage. So there would be only trace quantities (a few micrograms). The bomber would intentionally put smokeless powder on his luggage, so there would be much more (several milligrams). No longer would there be a distinguishable difference in the relative fractions. And you are telling me (I think?) that detections of nitrocellulose and nitroglycerin are qualified as not a threat by the presence of "taggants," which I did not even know where used in smokeless powder until yesterday. Am I missing something? And are taggants in use? I thought the idea died in the early 90s. Thanks.

taggants ARE in use in all commercial explosives produced. Nitrocellulose IS Nitroglycerine in a cellulose Binder. Plastic Dynamites use a different type of binder than smokeless powder. Frankly at this point, i'd have to do some checking before i can comment ANY further on this subject to ensure im not violating security restrictions. Suffice it to say that the machines in use, whether the swabs or the "puffers" are sufficinetly sensitive and disnriminatory to not give a false alert for GSR alone.

No, it wpouldnt, there is a HUGE difference Chemically between Nitrocellulose and ANY high explosive. the machines can, and WILL isolate each individual compound, whether its GSR , APP, PETN RDX, or any of a thousand others.

 

I thought modern smokeless powder was nitrocellulose and nitroglycerin. Those are the explosive ingredients of plastic dynamites. The relative fractions may be off. But a bomber would not WANT dynamite on his luggage. So there would be only trace quantities (a few micrograms). The bomber would intentionally put smokeless powder on his luggage, so there would be much more (several milligrams). No longer would there be a distinguishable difference in the relative fractions. And you are telling me (I think?) that detections of nitrocellulose and nitroglycerin are qualified as not a threat by the presence of "taggants," which I did not even know where used in smokeless powder until yesterday. Am I missing something? And are taggants in use? I thought the idea died in the early 90s. Thanks.

 

taggants ARE in use in all commercial explosives produced.

 

I thought you were suggesting taggants were used in smokeless powder, my mistake. If they were used in smokeless powder, that would explain with smokeless powder does not cause alarm during detection. If they are NOT used in smokeless powder, then smokeless powder (containing GTN and nitrocellulose) could mask certain dynamites made by terrorists - which are not commercial explosives and contain no taggants. Actually, either way.

 

Nitrocellulose IS Nitroglycerine in a cellulose Binder.

 

Nitrocellulose is nitrated cellulose and does not contain nitroglycerin. Nitroglycerin may be added to many nitrocellulose products.

 

Plastic Dynamites use a different type of binder than smokeless powder.

 

Plastic dynamites use whatever binder the terrorist chooses when he makes them, many of which could be ubiquitous in even consumer products.

 

Frankly at this point, i'd have to do some checking before i can comment ANY further on this subject to ensure im not violating security restrictions.

 

Understood!

 

Suffice it to say that the machines in use, whether the swabs or the "puffers" are sufficinetly sensitive and disnriminatory to not give a false alert for GSR alone.

 

I'm sure they are sufficiently sensitive. I doubt they could be sufficiently discriminatory if large amounts of smokeless power (milligrams, mostly GTN and nitrocellulose) were used to mask trace residues of improvised plastic dynamites (micrograms of residue, GTN and nitrocellulose).

Any alarm has to be checked out it doen't matter if its propellant or black powder. An IED can be made from those as well. The crazy with a PVC pipe stuffed with GSR or black powder is still a threat. He may not be a dedicated trained terrorist but he still has to be stopped.

 

The whole idea behind an IED is its improvised, it can be made out of anything that goes BOOM!

 

TC

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.