Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Scary morning at the house - how'd I do?

Featured Replies

So I had what turned out to be a non-incident at the house last weekend and I've been discussing the situation and my reaction/response with some folks and figured I'd ask for some input from here as well. Let me give some background.

 

My house is a relatively small ranch in densely populated Long Branch, where crimes happen probably more-so than some other towns in Jersey. I'm also just down the street from Oceanport where there have been countless day-time burglaries in the past few months including one where a man came home to find the burglar in his house and the home owner was stabbed, so I've been on edge lately. I don't want to post all of the details of my home security system but I'll say that it's nothing too fancy - the typical house alarm with alarms on the doors and windows and a few well placed glass breaking sensor and motion sensors. I also have my own few motion lights outside of the house along with a simple multi-camera system that I turn on when I'm not home and I have a few outdoor switches/motion sensors on the property that chime in my bedroom as a sort of "pre-warning" system as something approaches/enters my property in areas where there shouldn't be motion at night.

 

So as I said, the house is a small ranch, you can kind of think of the size being that of a long double-wide. Garage®/Living Room(L) in front, behind that a Bedroom®/kitchen-dining area(L), behind that at the back of the house is a spare bedroom/my master bedroom. Behind that is just my deck outside and my property backs to a 6ft fence and a small industrial property that should be quite at night.

 

In general, I have/had confidence that my somewhat multi-layered security system would alert me to problems in significant advance, so when I found myself awoken to 165DB of noise blaring from my two sirens rather than the sound of a gentle chime from my motion/entry way switches, I immediately sprung out of bed and had my .357, which sleeps loaded and inches from me, in hand. So here is where some folks disagree with my handling of the situation, I'd be curious to know what others, who might have had such a scenario and who didn't just freeze or run out the back door, have done.

 

As I put the gun in my hand I was already checking the immediate - the GF was still in bed trying to figure out what was making noise. My backdoor in the room was still closed, the dog was still in her bed, the alarm panel had all lights flashing so I had no idea where the intruder might have been. Gun pointed in the right direction, I approached the bedroom door at an angle that allowed me to check the rear spare bedroom door/window and also see that my GF's son was still in bed sleeping across the hall and he didn't set the alarm off. At this point I confirmed that my family was safe and the intruder was not already on me - this all within a second or two of being out of bed and I then gave a very loud and stern verbal warning "Get the F out of my house. I have a gun and I'll F-ing kill you". I waited a couple of seconds to listen for anything at all or see anyone at all - nothing. So I quickly moved up the hallway to where I could see into my kitchen/living room areas, clear. Nothing going on. Checked the doors/windows - nothing. Took a look outside... just a man... who had been kneeling down near my phone lines near my garage... and disconnected my phone, which triggered my alarm and I certainly scared the shit out of him when I approached, armed, probably almost as much as he'd scared the shit out of me by setting off my alarm while I was sleeping. Lucky for me it was just the ComCast man and lucky for him by this point I was processing what was going on and saw his ComCast badge/truck/etc so I approached with extreme caution but luckily didn't shoot the man. At the time I couldn't have told you if it was night or day, light or dark, but it turns out this was like 7:30am on a Sunday - really there was no sense of time or light when the alarm rang.

 

Overall I feel like I did the right thing(s) in that I

1) didn't freeze

2) secured myself and my family quickly

 

But I do wonder what the consensus is on the verbal warning and/or attempting to check/clear my own home? Should I have stayed quiet and waited to shoot? How long would I wait, until the police arrive? What if they come in when they hear my alarm going off and I'm not answering the door and they see me with a gun and shoot, or for that matter I see someone, who turns out to be a police man, with a gun and I shoot?

 

Some people here might be interested but I for one don't really want to engage in a firefight with anyone, esp in my own home. Some people are suggesting I'd of given away that I was armed at all orwhere I was and I should have been quiet and just covered the long hallway lying in wait to shoot the bad guy(s), other more liberal friends seem to suggest that I should have "escaped" out of my backdoor with my family until the police arrived (I do have a backup radio/cell if the phone line is down/cut).

 

I personally feel like the verbal warning should be the last possible chance for someone stupid enough to ignore the alarm signs/sounds so that if/when I have to shoot, there is no doubt in the mind of a jury that the intruder intended to me harm. I figure it should also scare off that idiot who figures on cutting the phone and banks on being out to rip a single siren out before a neighbor hears the noise (why I have two sirens). I also figure the verbal warning might cause an intruder pause just long enough to process my warning which bought my GF the extra couple of seconds she needed to get to her gun.

 

Any of you guys ever had to deal with an intruder, or late night/early morning (false) alarm? Ever practice any kind of home defense scenario(s) with your family? Aside from moving into a "better" neighborhood and/or a house with a second story to help separate me and the bad guys/buy me an extra few seconds, anything more I could do to help secure my property/deter anyone? Again, this time it was just a false alarm/phone line being disconnected to cause the scene, next time it could be the real deal and I'd like to be as prepared as possible, systems wise and mentally. In any case, sure was scary, but it makes for a kind of funny story with the GF now - the two of us with loaded guns, ready to shoot the cable man, and my killer guard dog sound asleep in bed. :-)

i believe the law will tell you.. you were justified in securing your home.. but should not have at any circumstance in NJ exited the home with a firearm.. if you do that and shoot someone.. good luck claiming self defense.. further.. unlike inside where walls will slow and or stop round... you are outside in the wide open.. miss the target and now you could have some innocent persons life on your hands..

 

that is my guess..

i believe the law will tell you.. you were justified in securing your home.. but should not have at any circumstance in NJ exited the home with a firearm.. if you do that and shoot someone.. good luck claiming self defense.. further.. unlike inside where walls will slow and or stop round... you are outside in the wide open.. miss the target and now you could have some innocent persons life on your hands..

 

that is my guess..

 

It's not illegal to carry on your own property.

i believe the law will tell you.. you were justified in securing your home.. but should not have at any circumstance in NJ exited the home with a firearm.. if you do that and shoot someone.. good luck claiming self defense.. further.. unlike inside where walls will slow and or stop round... you are outside in the wide open.. miss the target and now you could have some innocent persons life on your hands..

 

that is my guess..

 

It's not illegal to carry on your own property.

while I understand it.. and it IS totally legal to defend your life.. and the life of your family members.. I would be willing to face a jury (in NJ) for killing someone IN my home.. I would NOT be willing to face a jury for shooting someone on the front lawn (in NJ).. now if we were in another state.. I would likely go outside.. and there are some states where I would DEFINITELY go outside.. anyway.. I assume you get what im saying..

i believe the law will tell you.. you were justified in securing your home.. but should not have at any circumstance in NJ exited the home with a firearm.. if you do that and shoot someone.. good luck claiming self defense.. further.. unlike inside where walls will slow and or stop round... you are outside in the wide open.. miss the target and now you could have some innocent persons life on your hands..

 

that is my guess..

 

It's not illegal to carry on your own property.

while I understand it.. and it IS totally legal to defend your life.. and the life of your family members.. I would be willing to face a jury (in NJ) for killing someone IN my home.. I would NOT be willing to face a jury for shooting someone on the front lawn (in NJ).. now if we were in another state.. I would likely go outside.. and there are some states where I would DEFINITELY go outside.. anyway.. I assume you get what im saying..

 

I get you. Just clarifying. Lots of miss-informed newbies on this site and just passing through. Last thing we want to do is spread more mis-truths.

I had a similar situation years ago. Woke up to noises. Grabbed gun secured interior. Looked out and saw two guys with door open on my car 10 feet from the front door. I should and you should have called police immediately. If you go outside to confront them you are looking for trouble. If believe you have cleared the inside that is all you need to do. Why go outside? Yes, we would like to catch the bastards but, not our job. In the eyes of the law we are no longer defending ourselves at that time. That is all we have the right to do.

 

If you have a genuine bad guy and confront him outside at gun point, what's next? I did just that and he was not cooperative and the situation resulted in a round fired and me in trouble with the law. I lost my gun for a few months and had to defend myself in court. Luckily no one was injured. I did not shoot at the guy, just let him know the shiny chrome plated gun was real. When the alarm goes off call the police immediately. Then at least you should have backup on the way when you do catch them.

 

I think the only things you did wrong was not call the police immediately and you went outside. Let the police clear the outside areas.

I had a similar situation years ago. Woke up to noises. Grabbed gun secured interior. Looked out and saw two guys with door open on my car 10 feet from the front door. I should and you should have called police immediately. If you go outside to confront them you are looking for trouble. If believe you have cleared the inside that is all you need to do. Why go outside? Yes, we would like to catch the bastards but, not our job. In the eyes of the law we are no longer defending ourselves at that time. That is all we have the right to do.

 

If you have a genuine bad guy and confront him outside at gun point, what's next? I did just that and he was not cooperative and the situation resulted in a round fired and me in trouble with the law. I lost my gun for a few months and had to defend myself in court. Luckily no one was injured. I did not shoot at the guy, just let him know the shiny chrome plated gun was real. When the alarm goes off call the police immediately. Then at least you should have backup on the way when you do catch them.

 

I think the only things you did wrong was not call the police immediately and you went outside. Let the police clear the outside areas.

 

Can you give more detail on what happened with your situation? No worries if its not something you want to post online but i would be curious to hear what exactly happened and how the legal side of it works in NJ when something like that happens...

I would recomend you move the child in with the mother.

I would recomend not making any announcements.

I would recomend you had the GF dial 911 while you guarded the room.

I would recomend she make sure she alerted the PD of location in the house and armed status.

I would recomend you all have this plan practiced ahead of time.

Your security system sounds perfect. The warning was a great idea. As much as I would want to, I would not go outside armed- no matter what. Call the cops. Make sure your home insurance policy is up to date.

I would recomend you move the child in with the mother.

I would recomend not making any announcements.

I would recomend you had the GF dial 911 while you guarded the room.

I would recomend she make sure she alerted the PD of location in the house and armed status.

I would recomend you all have this plan practiced ahead of time.

 

This. Mostly. I think making an announcement once the family is secured to let any intruders know that you're calling the police and that you're armed and that it would be a good idea to vacate the premises promptly is probably warranted in most situations. It certainly would not hurt for 911 to have a recording of you attempting to verbally de-escalate the situation in case the intruder(s) chose to advance on your position after repeated warnings.

 

But other than that, I think Shane is spot on.

I would recomend you move the child in with the mother.

I would recomend not making any announcements.

I would recomend you had the GF dial 911 while you guarded the room.

I would recomend she make sure she alerted the PD of location in the house and armed status.

I would recomend you all have this plan practiced ahead of time.

 

This. Mostly. I think making an announcement once the family is secured to let any intruders know that you're calling the police and that you're armed and that it would be a good idea to vacate the premises promptly is probably warranted in most situations. It certainly would not hurt for 911 to have a recording of you attempting to verbally de-escalate the situation in case the intruder(s) chose to advance on your position after repeated warnings.

 

But other than that, I think Shane is spot on.

 

I agree with this. When I lived in CT and got my CCW there this is the biggest thing they stressed in the training class. Always be on the phone with 911 while you yell out to the intruders that you are armed (even though CT IS a castle doctrine AND a stand your ground state). Always a good idea to be on recording trying to de-escalate. Another good point they made regarding this is that if you shoot someone, no matter how justified, you WILL end up, at the very least, in civil court. the more proof you have the better.

  • Author

Agreed, going outside was one my biggest mistakes/the one thing I really regret for a few reasons and I'll certainly not make that mistake again.

 

First, it left my GF (armed) and her son alone in the house. If there were multiple intruders, one could have been around back and gaining entry. I'd like to think the two of us together, armed, stand better odds against persistent intruder(s) than either or both of us on our own.

 

Second, with me out of her sight, I had to yell over the sirens to her to let her know it was me coming back in and not to shoot me. I'd rather not get shot by my GF, at least not on a Sunday morning, or with a HP 9mm...

 

Third, the legal aspect of shooting someone outside. Again, I think that overwhelming feeling of "I have to stop the bad guy" led me out there. In hindsight, I more than understand this could have been a huge legal issue for me and regret that mistake. Not to mention, as noted, a firefight outside of my house could be worse than a firefight inside my house. And add to that I could be walking out into an ambush of sorts from multiple armed intruders around corners/behind cars/etc and it was just dumb, dumb, dumb for lack of any better terms.

 

Which leads me to Fourth and finally, luckily I had gone back inside to put the gun away and turn the alarm off before the police arrived. It could have ended badly for me if the police pulled up and saw me with a gun outside; mistake me for the bad guy on my own property and shoot me. Just as I don't want to be shot by the GF, I'd rather the local PD doesn't shoot me either.

 

In any case, seems like maybe the verbal warning is 50/50 or so here too. I guess it would be impossible to know if in real situations a verbal warning was a final stopping deterrent or a give away/bad idea. Either way, should there ever be another alarm, I can only hope that I can react as quickly, I'd probably give the same verbal warning unless someone can really come up with a great reason/explanation for why not to, and I'd hope I'm giving a warning to no-one again. :|

Agreed, going outside was one my biggest mistakes/the one thing I really regret for a few reasons and I'll certainly not make that mistake again.

 

First, it left my GF (armed) and her son alone in the house. If there were multiple intruders, one could have been around back and gaining entry. I'd like to think the two of us together, armed, stand better odds against persistent intruder(s) than either or both of us on our own.

 

Second, with me out of her sight, I had to yell over the sirens to her to let her know it was me coming back in and not to shoot me. I'd rather not get shot by my GF, at least not on a Sunday morning, or with a HP 9mm...

 

Third, the legal aspect of shooting someone outside. Again, I think that overwhelming feeling of "I have to stop the bad guy" led me out there. In hindsight, I more than understand this could have been a huge legal issue for me and regret that mistake. Not to mention, as noted, a firefight outside of my house could be worse than a firefight inside my house. And add to that I could be walking out into an ambush of sorts from multiple armed intruders around corners/behind cars/etc and it was just dumb, dumb, dumb for lack of any better terms.

 

Which leads me to Fourth and finally, luckily I had gone back inside to put the gun away and turn the alarm off before the police arrived. It could have ended badly for me if the police pulled up and saw me with a gun outside; mistake me for the bad guy on my own property and shoot me. Just as I don't want to be shot by the GF, I'd rather the local PD doesn't shoot me either.

 

In any case, seems like maybe the verbal warning is 50/50 or so here too. I guess it would be impossible to know if in real situations a verbal warning was a final stopping deterrent or a give away/bad idea. Either way, should there ever be another alarm, I can only hope that I can react as quickly, I'd probably give the same verbal warning unless someone can really come up with a great reason/explanation for why not to, and I'd hope I'm giving a warning to no-one again. :|

 

I think the biggest take away you can get from that incident is that the blaring shock of the alarm is going to add to the adrenaline cloud you will be in. Next time that alarm goes off you still might get that shot into the bloodstream, but you will be more aware of the fact that you need to be thinking, not just reacting.

I have Plans. I have fire plans, power outage plans, hurricane evacuation plans and I have home invasion plans. My wife and I tall about these plans and practice our emergency plans. In the case of a home invasion I grab the shotgun and she gets a handgun and the phone. We both proceed to our sons room and ensure it is clear and he is safe. My wife will then call 911 and lock herself and our son in his room. I believe in making an announcement "I have a gun, I will kill you, the police are on their way!" this is playing the odds, most home intruders will leave at the mention of a gun and/or the police. Like you my house is a small rancher, 1,100 square feet. There is little mystery as where I would be so I'm not concerned about giving away my location, I would rather state my intention. At this point I'll slowly clear the house. My wife and I have a safe word, if she does not hear it and someone touches the door she is to fire through the door and await the police.

She knows to tell th police there are armed individuals breaking into the house. She will tell them her location and tell them not to touch the door, she will stay on the phone with the police until the identity of the police are confirmed and she will describe me and tell the police not to shoot me. If there is a threat I will hopefully chase it away or eliminate it. If I am hurt/killed at least my wife and son will be sewhat safe.

I don't trust utility workers. Just because they work for some company and their presence appears to be legit does't convince me that the individual is not casing a house. Why would someone legitimately disconnect your phone line at 7:30 am? I would consider replacing the HP ammo with DRT ammo. It is designed to turn to powder when it strikes a hard surface. When it hits a person it will be the last B&E that D-Bag ever commits. Just an option to consider for an already sound plan.

Personally, I think you should have had the GF immediately call the police while you made your way to the sons room, gotten him out of bed and brought him back to your bedroom with the GF. Then locked/closed your bedroom door, with the GF, son, and you behind cover and your pistol at the ready pointed at the door.

 

I think too many people want to play the 'let me clear the house' game.

 

If your a civilian with decent training in clearing/room to room then I think you have more leeway. Same with if your in law enf or military.

I had a similar situation years ago. Woke up to noises. Grabbed gun secured interior. Looked out and saw two guys with door open on my car 10 feet from the front door. I should and you should have called police immediately. If you go outside to confront them you are looking for trouble. If believe you have cleared the inside that is all you need to do. Why go outside? Yes, we would like to catch the bastards but, not our job. In the eyes of the law we are no longer defending ourselves at that time. That is all we have the right to do.

 

If you have a genuine bad guy and confront him outside at gun point, what's next? I did just that and he was not cooperative and the situation resulted in a round fired and me in trouble with the law. I lost my gun for a few months and had to defend myself in court. Luckily no one was injured. I did not shoot at the guy, just let him know the shiny chrome plated gun was real. When the alarm goes off call the police immediately. Then at least you should have backup on the way when you do catch them.

 

I think the only things you did wrong was not call the police immediately and you went outside. Let the police clear the outside areas.

 

I don't like that. You should be able to defend your property (car) as well as your home. A car is most certainly not an easily replaceable asset, especially since most insurers will (to my knowledge) only pay you what the car was worth at the time, not what you paid for it.

 

Not saying I would given the local legal environment, but things should be like Texas, where shoot first, and shoot again are considered reasonable.

My thoughts on the announcement was that if the alarm didnt scare em off, there is likely a reason for the boldness so better not to give away your position.

In NJ theres no duty to retreat from inside your home but im not sure if thats the same outside on your property? That being said if your home is secure inside technically you and or your family are not in life threatning danger and the PD should be able to respond sufficiently. Countless times Ive heard that bump in the night, secured the family and house inside armed and went back to bed. If the motion lights arent on outside I dont even check outside but I do check their operation weekly. Overall Id say your better safe then sorry and if you felt what you did was necessary to protect you and yours then so be it! Just becareful securing your property armed.

Well, until you are in that situation woken up out of a deep sleep, it is easy to post what things you could have done better. I have an alarm system in my home and woke up by the alarm blaring. I'll tell you, first you are disoriented and takes 3-5 seconds to figure out wth is going on. Then once that is situated there are many things that could happen and we have a plan to minimize the "worse case scenario". I keep my handguns in a safe and will have ample time to simply open it (left open at night and about two steps from my bed). I have three children between 12 and 19 years old. We have a plan that we have practiced that they are to meet immediately in our room for a head count. I grab the 9MM and wife grabs her revolver and stays with the kids. When the alarm goes off we get a call back immediately from the alarm company. If no answer police are sent... However, the wife has her cell phone upstairs just in case. I know some people may not agree with this method, but I rather take the bullet and rely on my wife and cops for the back up over the possibility of shooting one of my own children... That is something I could NEVER live with.

I had a similar situation years ago. Woke up to noises. Grabbed gun secured interior. Looked out and saw two guys with door open on my car 10 feet from the front door. I should and you should have called police immediately. If you go outside to confront them you are looking for trouble. If believe you have cleared the inside that is all you need to do. Why go outside? Yes, we would like to catch the bastards but, not our job. In the eyes of the law we are no longer defending ourselves at that time. That is all we have the right to do.

 

If you have a genuine bad guy and confront him outside at gun point, what's next? I did just that and he was not cooperative and the situation resulted in a round fired and me in trouble with the law. I lost my gun for a few months and had to defend myself in court. Luckily no one was injured. I did not shoot at the guy, just let him know the shiny chrome plated gun was real. When the alarm goes off call the police immediately. Then at least you should have backup on the way when you do catch them.

 

I think the only things you did wrong was not call the police immediately and you went outside. Let the police clear the outside areas.

 

 

 

Thats what I call a BULLSHIT LAW...

Thats what I call a bs LAW...

 

Yes it is. I live in the same township as when I was a kid. My cousin and I used to shoot his 22 rifle in the back yard or up the driveway between the houses and no one cared. Of course that was about 55 years ago. The neighborhood is the same but the people sure are different. Today it would bring out the SWAT team and get us locked up. :cry:

This is a re-post from the previous thread on this subject, but it contributes I think:

 

A similar event happened to me a few months back. Long post, sorry, and also a false alarm.

 

2:45AM - Alarm goes off. As a side note: when the alarm was installed, I specifically asked for the bullhorn and other noise producing devices to be on the lower level of the house. That way, it's still loud enough to easily wake me up, but it's blaring loud downstairs (for the potential intruder to deal with), but not right in my ear. It still lets me hear something/someone coming up the stairs.

 

So I pop out of bed, arm myself, and quickly check to see which zone went off: Basement Window

 

It's just the wife and I, so she's dialing 911 and I park myself at the corner to the staircase. No need to clear the house, or even go downstairs. If they want to take all my personal possessions, that's fine with me, I have insurance. If they try and come upstairs, different story. And God forbid a body is found lying on the stairs when the cops arrive, at least it will collaborate my story that the intruder was coming up stairs with intent on bodily harm.

 

2:49AM Cops come screeching down the street, I disable the alarm so the noise stops, and my wife still on the phone with the dispatch tells them to have the cops check the basement windows. They say nothing is broken, and ask to be let in. My wife tells them I am armed (which I was hit or miss on since it led to the inevitable "You have a permit for that?" ) and heading downstairs to unlock the front door. They popped there head in, looked around, I showed them my permit/receipt, thanked them, and they left.

 

Turns out the window dropped in the jam just enough to separate from the sensor which caused the alarm. The next day the alarm company came out and fixed it so it won't happen again.

 

It was actually a very good experience all around. My wife was a little shaken up after wards, as was I. But I was glad my first instinct was not shock, and I was somewhat thinking clearly. If you have the option of seeing what zone was activated on your alarm system I highly recommend adding it as a step in your mental process.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.