July 18, 201016 yr http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/201 ... e-militia/ Constitution leaves room for Arizona to secure border By Ray Hartwell 7:08 p.m., Friday, July 16, 2010 Arizona has enacted a law that enables state and local police to support fed- eral immigration en- forcement, in a care- fully circumscribed manner. This moderate statute is under vicious attack by the Obama administration and assorted amnesty advocates. Yet Arizona and her sister states in the Southwest could take dramatically stronger actions to bring order to the border. And they would have both history and the Constitution on their side. History first. In 1916, criminal gangs rivaled the authority of the Mexican government. Led by Pancho Villa, they launched attacks against Americans on both sides of the border. Following a bloody raid that killed American soldiers and civilians in New Mexico, President Woodrow Wilson dispatched 15,000 state militia to the border and sent Gen. John J. "Black Jack" Pershing and thousands more soldiers into Mexico after Villa and his bandits. Once Pershing's force clashed with the Mexican army, Wilson ordered another 75,000 National Guardsmen to the border region. Supported by an enraged American citizenry, Wilson reacted swiftly and with substantial force to secure our southern border and drive out what was, in effect, a marauding army of Mexican invaders. Today, armed drug cartels openly challenge the Mexican government. Deadly battles occur frequently in Mexico, where more than 6,500 people were killed by cartel forces last year and more than 5,000 have been killed so far this year. Paramilitary bands have entered the United States illegally and set up sentry and command posts. Federal authorities have actually ceded control of public land in Arizona to these invaders. Cartels claim openly that Mexico's border with the United States has been moved northward to Interstate 8. Federal officials have even advised the public to avoid the Sonoran Desert National Monument, which is not on the border; it's 35 miles southwest of Phoenix. Pinal County Sheriff Paul Babeu reports that attacks on police and American citizens have increased in the past several months, saying, "It is literally out of control." Mitch Ellis, federal manager of the Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge in southern Arizona, warns that the area is "increasingly violent" because of "smugglers and border bandits." The police chief of Nogales, Ariz., has received threats that cartels may use snipers positioned just across the border to target law enforcement personnel in the U.S. Of course, this is not just about trafficking in drugs and illegals. According to reports, "hundreds of Somalis" with ties to "terror cells" have infiltrated the United States from Mexico. Al Qaeda, Hezbollah and kindred groups are all reported to be actively moving their members across the border. Trust me, these folks are not entering the United States illegally in order to get work in your neighbor's backyard. With Wilson's reaction to Pancho Villa's pistoleros as precedent, President Obama has declined to be Wilsonian. He has refused to step up border enforcement. He and Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. have attacked the Arizona law, dishonestly claiming that it promotes racial profiling and is "anti-immigrant." They have filed one lawsuit to block enforcement of the law and have warned that if the initial litigation fails, they will likely bring another case on a different legal theory. The administration asserts, disingenuously, that reports of crime by illegals are exaggerated. Funding for a fence has been cut. The president has ordered 1,200 National Guard troops to the region, but only to perform "support functions." Thus, Arizona's modest enforcement measures are under attack by the very federal government whose failure to secure the border precipitated their adoption. Is Arizona at the mercy of the Obama administration, or does it have some options here? For one thing, Arizona can form and expand its own state militia. Such forces were common when our nation was founded, and the Second Amendment recognizes that a "well-regulated Militia" is "necessary to the security of a free State." In short, Arizona and other states can raise and arm their own military forces. But, for what purpose can such forces legally act? The Constitution is informative here. In Article IV, Section 4, the federal government is required to "protect each [state] against Invasion; and [on request of the state government] against domestic Violence." As St. George Tucker noted, this provision guards against "the possibility of an undue partiality in the federal government," for example a "sectional" president who might, for political reasons, decline to protect states in a certain region. Today the federal government, at the direction of the president, has declined to carry out its duty under Article IV. Leaving aside its other possible consequences, this intentional failure to protect Arizona raises the question of what action the state is now entitled to take under the Constitution. This brings us to Article I, Section 10, Clause 3, which provides that "No State shall, without the Consent of Congress ... engage in War, unless actually invaded, or in such imminent Danger as will not admit of delay." So, the militias organized and armed by a state may go to war when the state has been invaded or is in imminent danger. This is clear under Article I, and plainly justified when the federal government has deliberately failed to protect against invasion as required by Article IV. As Joseph Story explains in his treatise on the Constitution, the prohibition against states engaging in war is "wisely" limited by "exceptions sufficient for the safety of the states, and not justly open to the objection of being dangerous to the Union." At the time of our nation's founding, the states surrendered certain limited powers to the federal government. Logically, foremost among the enumerated powers delegated to the new central authority were those relating to foreign affairs, including the war powers. But the states were prudent; they had a logical concern that if the federal government should fail in its duty to protect them from "invasion" or "imminent danger," perhaps for reasons of political "partiality," then the states should have a robust right to defend themselves, including by armed force. And so they do. Ray Hartwell is a Navy veteran and a Washington lawyer
July 18, 201016 yr I agree that the article is informative, but it misses some of the point. Cliff's Notes: The AZ law is being challeneged on racial profiling, doesn't really address border security and gives Repub's somethine to really scream about (don't think this whole thing isn't choreographed). First, my opinion is that it's disgusting that the federal government (not just Obama's administration, but prior administrations, also) has turned a blind eye to the gaping hole in our national safety and defense that is the US/Mexico border and to an extent the US/Canada border. Second, the article misses the point, a bit. From what I gather, the "attack" that the Obama administration is mounting is based on a theory that the law promotes, calls for or will result in racial profiling. I'm pretty sure the lawsuit is not an attack on Arizona's right to put more boots on the ground to stop illegal immigration (which would make MUCH more sense, IMHO). Rather than spend the money to put more boots on the ground, AZ has elected to use their existing police force to inquire as to the citizenship of "any person" whom they "reasonbly believe" is in the country illegally that they come into contact with while enforcing another law. They are entitled to pursue and detain the person until they are reasonably satisfied that the person is in the US legally. So, AZ's law doesn't secure our borders any better than any other piece of paper that AZ has produced. The people screaming about People Other Than Mexicans (POTMs) coming into our country with the intent of causing us harm are missing the fact that those POTMs more than likely leave AZ quickly, because there are few targets of interest to them and little support. Thus, the AZ law will likely not result in the capture of one, single Muslim Exremeist. The new AZ law does (arguably) make AZ a more hostile environment to illegal immigrants, but it also (arguably) makes the state more hostile to hispanics in the country and the state legally. AZ has foresaken the obvious solution of a militia/more boots and elected a post hoc attempt at border security. What the AZ law has successfully done, is push immigration up on the Obama list of priorities while they fight against and stonewall on any reform proposed in D.C., and it gives the Republican'ts another thing to drag out that "Obama has failed at," when their heroes Reagan, Bush I and Bush ver. 2.0 failed the same way along with the Dummycrat's hero, Clinton. Also, by making being in the country illegally a violation of state law, it provides AZ police with a "clear," Constitutional (Police Power) basis for inquiring as to the legal status of a person whom they reasonably believe is here illegally. However, I don't think AZ needed this law in order to secure and patrol its own south border. While the federal government cannot require state police to enforce its laws and policies, state police are certainly permitted to observe and make arrests based on violations of federal law. So, what this amounts to me, is a gigantic polical game that the Republican party is playing to defeat the Democrats as quickly as possible. Politics is as dirty and ridiculous as ever. I'd love to watch both parties implode on themselves and see a true party devoted to the people, rather than to itself, develop from the ashes.
July 18, 201016 yr I agree that the article is informative, but it misses some of the point. Cliff's Notes: The AZ law is being challeneged on racial profiling, doesn't really address border security and gives Repub's somethine to really scream about (don't think this whole thing isn't choreographed). First, my opinion is that it's disgusting that the federal government (not just Obama's administration, but prior administrations, also) has turned a blind eye to the gaping hole in our national safety and defense that is the US/Mexico border and to an extent the US/Canada border. Second, the article misses the point, a bit. From what I gather, the "attack" that the Obama administration is mounting is based on a theory that the law promotes, calls for or will result in racial profiling. I'm pretty sure the lawsuit is not an attack on Arizona's right to put more boots on the ground to stop illegal immigration (which would make MUCH more sense, IMHO). Rather than spend the money to put more boots on the ground, AZ has elected to use their existing police force to inquire as to the citizenship of "any person" whom they "reasonbly believe" is in the country illegally that they come into contact with while enforcing another law. They are entitled to pursue and detain the person until they are reasonably satisfied that the person is in the US legally. So, AZ's law doesn't secure our borders any better than any other piece of paper that AZ has produced. The people screaming about People Other Than Mexicans (POTMs) coming into our country with the intent of causing us harm are missing the fact that those POTMs more than likely leave AZ quickly, because there are few targets of interest to them and little support. Thus, the AZ law will likely not result in the capture of one, single Muslim Exremeist. The new AZ law does (arguably) make AZ a more hostile environment to illegal immigrants, but it also (arguably) makes the state more hostile to hispanics in the country and the state legally. AZ has foresaken the obvious solution of a militia/more boots and elected a post hoc attempt at border security. What the AZ law has successfully done, is push immigration up on the Obama list of priorities while they fight against and stonewall on any reform proposed in D.C., and it gives the Republican'ts another thing to drag out that "Obama has failed at," when their heroes Reagan, Bush I and Bush ver. 2.0 failed the same way along with the Dummycrat's hero, Clinton. Also, by making being in the country illegally a violation of state law, it provides AZ police with a "clear," Constitutional (Police Power) basis for inquiring as to the legal status of a person whom they reasonably believe is here illegally. However, I don't think AZ needed this law in order to secure and patrol its own south border. While the federal government cannot require state police to enforce its laws and policies, state police are certainly permitted to observe and make arrests based on violations of federal law. So, what this amounts to me, is a gigantic polical game that the Republican party is playing to defeat the Democrats as quickly as possible. Politics is as dirty and ridiculous as ever. I'd love to watch both parties implode on themselves and see a true party devoted to the people, rather than to itself, develop from the ashes. No, they are not. Without special Cirtcumstances, as in being assigned to a Federal jurisdicted Task Force, or trained under the 287-G program, Local, County and State police officers ARE NOT EMPOWERED TO ENFORCE FEDERAL STATUTE.
July 19, 201016 yr No, they are not. Without special Cirtcumstances, as in being assigned to a Federal jurisdicted Task Force, or trained under the 287-G program, Local, County and State police officers ARE NOT EMPOWERED TO ENFORCE FEDERAL STATUTE. So if an Az state trooper pulls over a car that is carrying several hundred pound of heroin they can't make an arrest. I would think that this is a DEA matter isn't it. Same with a murder across state lines, would an officer not be able to make an arrest of a person wanted for murder in another state?
July 19, 201016 yr No, they are not. Without special Cirtcumstances, as in being assigned to a Federal jurisdicted Task Force, or trained under the 287-G program, Local, County and State police officers ARE NOT EMPOWERED TO ENFORCE FEDERAL STATUTE. So if an Az state trooper pulls over a car that is carrying several hundred pound of heroin they can't make an arrest. I would think that this is a DEA matter isn't it. Same with a murder across state lines, would an officer not be able to make an arrest of a person wanted for murder in another state? If someone in AZ is in possession of ANY amount of heroin that is against state law and that person can be arrested. As for wanted persons, they essentially have a warrant out for their arrest... that has nothing to do with a federal statute.
July 19, 201016 yr No, they are not. Without special Cirtcumstances, as in being assigned to a Federal jurisdicted Task Force, or trained under the 287-G program, Local, County and State police officers ARE NOT EMPOWERED TO ENFORCE FEDERAL STATUTE. So if an Az state trooper pulls over a car that is carrying several hundred pound of heroin they can't make an arrest. I would think that this is a DEA matter isn't it. Same with a murder across state lines, would an officer not be able to make an arrest of a person wanted for murder in another state? Sure they can., because they make the arrest under Arizona LAW.. bank Robbery carries a federal offense...But it also calls under 2C..which is what I make the arrest on, NOT the 18 USC Charge. Counterfeiting..Carried an NJ 2C Charge, whicvh we arrest under, if the Federales decide THEY want it, then they step in and charge on their own. As far as the Murder across state lines..IF the Suspect has a warrant, yes they can. But they can't just arrest someone for a crime committed in another state..although they can Hold a Suspect for investigation. So far you havent give ONE example of a "Federal" Law that is enforced by "Joe Cop" on the State/County/local level. Immigration is an oft-used example. I CANNOT arrest someone for an immigration violation only...unless i've been trained under the 287-G program. I CAN hold someone arrested for another offense for ICE (Within a narrow list of offenses per our state AG) and turn that individual over to them for Investigation of Immigration offenses. Now, If i'm part of a DEA Task force, or a US Marshal Task Force, I can enforce Federal Law...but im NOT Doing so as an NJ Law Enforcement Officer, i'm doing it as a "Special US Deputy Marshal", and the credentials for that are revoked and must be turned in as soon as the assignment is over. Those of us who went to La during Katrina, were Deputized as temporary La Peace Officers. There are VERY Clear lines of Jurisdiction.. in fact it's actually easier for Federal LE to enforce State Law than it is for State LE to enforce Federal Law. If you Speed or commit an MV offense in Sandy Hook, you are charged with the Title 39 Offense, not a Federal statute..but it's HEARD in Federal District Court.
July 19, 201016 yr No, they are not. Without special Cirtcumstances, as in being assigned to a Federal jurisdicted Task Force, or trained under the 287-G program, Local, County and State police officers ARE NOT EMPOWERED TO ENFORCE FEDERAL STATUTE. HA! That's one part of my post that I wasn't sure about. Thank you for clearing my understanding up on that. Of course, that now changes my view of the AZ law a bit...actually significantly. Damnit, Kpd, now I have to go back to my thinking hole and chew on this thing a lot more.
July 19, 201016 yr No, they are not. Without special Cirtcumstances, as in being assigned to a Federal jurisdicted Task Force, or trained under the 287-G program, Local, County and State police officers ARE NOT EMPOWERED TO ENFORCE FEDERAL STATUTE. HA! That's one part of my post that I wasn't sure about. Thank you for clearing my understanding up on that. Of course, that now changes my view of the AZ law a bit...actually significantly. Damnit, Kpd, now I have to go back to my thinking hole and chew on this thing a lot more. That is why the Az law mirrors the federal law so closely, with the exception that the Az law SPECIFICALLY prohibits racial profiling.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.