Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Article about NJ FID card denial - national attention!

Featured Replies

Seems like there is pretty good reason to investigate this case further. I don't slam doors in anger, certainly not with force to damage them. I don't go around telling my wife (or any of my EX-gfs) that the idea of her dating someone else turns my stomach and immediately say I'm going to get a gun. Ya know... get a gun for what???? IMHO, "Them be fightin words", and I think the cops and judge has every reason to questions this persons mental state. Someone with a temper that's off the handle, borderline threatening to shoot someone, really should have no business owning a firearm. I think the dude needs to get some help finding peace in life, controlling his emotions, then he can get some guns. Anybody making statements like that SHOULD be denied.

 

I'm actually more interested in finding out how the cops caught wind of the ex-wife... you would think the guy would not put her down for the mental health form if he knows hes been actin a fool.

Seems like there is pretty good reason to investigate this case further. I don't slam doors in anger, certainly not with force to damage them. I don't go around telling my wife (or any of my EX-gfs) that the idea of her dating someone else turns my stomach and immediately say I'm going to get a gun. Ya know... get a gun for what???? IMHO, "Them be fightin words", and I think the cops and judge has every reason to questions this persons mental state. Someone with a temper that's off the handle, borderline threatening to shoot someone, really should have no business owning a firearm. I think the dude needs to get some help finding peace in life, controlling his emotions, then he can get some guns. Anybody making statements like that SHOULD be denied.

 

 

Except it's she said/he said.

 

How do you know she is telling the truth?

 

My X and her lawyer flat out LIED in divorce court and in the paperwork.

Seems like there is pretty good reason to investigate this case further. I don't slam doors in anger, certainly not with force to damage them. I don't go around telling my wife (or any of my EX-gfs) that the idea of her dating someone else turns my stomach and immediately say I'm going to get a gun. Ya know... get a gun for what???? IMHO, "Them be fightin words", and I think the cops and judge has every reason to questions this persons mental state. Someone with a temper that's off the handle, borderline threatening to shoot someone, really should have no business owning a firearm. I think the dude needs to get some help finding peace in life, controlling his emotions, then he can get some guns. Anybody making statements like that SHOULD be denied.

 

I'm actually more interested in finding out how the cops caught wind of the ex-wife... you would think the guy would not put her down for the mental health form if he knows hes been actin a fool.

 

did the movie order of chaos have anything to do with this reply :lol:

Yeah, obviously there can easily be some animosity over the divorce that made her start tellin lies just to throw him under the bus. I think in this case though, they should take a closer look before issuing permits. I'm not sure what that means... meeting with a shrink and talking everything over? What he allegedly said and did could have serious repercussions if they give him the card. People change too... someone in a crap relationship can really be a mean SOB and say some stupid hurtful stuff. When they get out of that situation they may turn into the nicest person every.

when you think about it... how do they know that people that say the person is mentally stable are telling the truth? The whole thing has a huge hole in it. I have signed off on a few people for their FID cards and specifically told them I would put in good word to help them get cards. I've only met one of the recent people a few times and they are more of my wife's friend than mine. I did go shooting with her a couple weeks ago... she seemed stable enough :lol::lol:

snif sniff

 

Smell that?

 

I smell an anti-gunner....

 

no person shall.....be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law;
A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

 

So he got angry and slammed a door. He said/she said. How do we KNOW he even said these things besides an angry ex-wife?

 

I'd like to see if you get angry and slam a door if your girlfriend/wife told you she was going to fuck some other guy. Yeah, I bet you'd be real happy with that new too :roll:

 

Fact of the matter is, the man was not convicted of any crime, and was denied his license purely on hearsay, and arbitrary authoritarian officials' judgement. Minority Report style pre-crime denied him his second amendment rights.

Yeah I understand what you're saying. Until we know how this all came about I'm not gonna call it one way or another. I think they key here is how the cops found out about the alleged threats on the ex-wife. Under normal circumstances I don't think they would ever get to hear her side. Ya know, the guy would have had two of his buddies fill out the mental health forms and they would say he's a cool dude. There's no way he would have put her name down if they were getting divorced or unhappy together.

 

Its very possible he applied for a FID, then went trash talking to her about getting guns and all this BF nonsense, etc etc. She freaked cause she considered it a threat, she called the local PD, they took a report then denied his FID app based on that report.

 

How else would the cops know about these alleged threats? Maybe they have reports on file for domestics at their residence? Ya know maybe a neighbor called cause of fighting, they cops arrived, took a report, and she never pressed charges out of fear of retribution? I'm makin all this shit up, but tell me how else they would have found out...

If its one emotionally charged persons word against someone elses, that shouldnt matter. Give him the damn card. If he commits a crime lock him up forever.

 

She should make the playing field level and get some damn guns of her own! :lol:

The whole point of the mental health form/requirement is to prevent people with higher probability to commit crimes from getting guns in the first place. Seems like to a certain degree that system worked... maybe she lied and maybe she didn't. If a shrink says the guy is good to go or they deem her statments hearsay, by all means issue. I'm not saying ban him for life... just take a closer look into it versus the normal FID app where everything adds up. I'm sure the guy will appeal it...then they can sort it out.

That was his appeal - the denial was sustained by the court because he didn't have "a need for self defense distinguishable from the general public".

He applied for FID for self defense? :shock: in NJ!? What a maroon! Did he think that was concealed carry permit?

 

(I know, I know, don't get your shorts in a knot on this ... 2A and all)

 

Guess he didn't think of it as a sport ... "target shooting"?

 

For once, sirsloop may be on to a good guess. There must be something in the "domestic situation" that prompted the cops to look into this. Of course, if the wife had a BF :mrgreen: , that's a situation! :lol:

was denied his license purely on hearsay

 

hear

The thing about this story that I can't get over is that, let's just say, he got the FID - next to happen would be she would say the he said the same things and he has a gun. Same result really. So if there were no denial there would be a gun, and then she would balk, and he would have it revoked by some order of protection.

 

Am I right?

There are alot of factors that arent represented in that article... have there been previous domestics, has she ever filed for a restraining order in the past, has he had a history of any other things. It hasnt come to pass yet, but I could see my Cheif denying an FID to some of our "Regular customers" in the DV arena just because of the numnber of times we've been to the residence for complaints. part of the check our BCI detective does is a CAD search of the residence to see if we've been there before and for what. yes it's a judgement call, but it's also a Liability call, because if the Chief DOES issue an FID to the guy with 20 Domestics and on #21 he shoots the wife with his new gun, that Chief and the City are going to be in a HUGE liability quagmire.

 

problem is there isnt enough detail int hat tiny little snippet from the case to call it one way or another IMO.

That was his appeal - the denial was sustained by the court because he didn't have "a need for self defense distinguishable from the general public".

 

Glad to see that I'm not the only one who noticed that Heller/McDonald didn't do squat for NJ.

Ok..... After doing a little reasearch, I found something that has a few more details of this case. While it appears Mr Novello has some issues...it sounds like the appellate division dropped the ball on this one. I forsee a bunch more appeals before this is over.

I withdraw my previous comments, there is NO indication that there was any type of regular Dv calls to this guy and the ex. Also the original complaint seems to date back to 2006.

http://www.leagle.com/unsecure/page.htm ... 0100715225

yeh.... def strange that they denied his initial application. They didn't go into detail on why he was initially denied, and it seems like the ex-wife's testimony came out in the appeal. You would think if there were a bunch of DV reports or other incidents they would have simply stated supporting their case.

@Cemetery - no, but those EXACT WORDS were used in the denial in Westchester County that SAF and Alan Gura are making a federal case of. *That's* going to be interesting; and more useful to NJ.

It is a common lie to say that they felt threatend by a spouse being angry, they just remember him being angry and later decide that hey were afraid. BS.

  • 2 months later...

It is a common lie to say that they felt threatend by a spouse being angry, they just remember him being angry and later decide that hey were afraid. BS.

 

This was my case back in 2007. Vindictive spouse got a restraining order on me saying she felt threatened. I have no criminal record, absolutely NO history of violence, and absolutely have NEVER verbally, mentally, nor physically abused her. Thenm to make matters worse, the TRO got turned into a FRO because I didn't make it to court that day BECAUSE I WAS AT COURT IN ANOTHER TOWNSHIP FOR A TRAFFIC TICKET. To make a long story short, we reconciled and the whole matter was dismissed. So hopefully, this won't be a problem when I try to get my permit in Egg Harbor Township. Its important to note that nowhere in the restraining order did it say I used physical force against her. (The whole thing was a lie from the start though. I'm just mad I never got to defend myself before it got dismissed.)

I think its going to be a problem for you. It's on record somewhere. Add to the fact that some dude just shot his brother and a neighbor with a rifle from the second story window a week ago and I bet your looking at a denial. I will however cross my fingeres for you because I know how in Domestic situations a woman will lie, lie, lie, lie.

If the ex-husband was going to cause her bodily harm it would be pretty stupid to carefully think it through, decide to get an FID card, get finger printed, wait 2 months get it, go buy a gun, then use this gun to harm her knowing full well he'll be the first one they look at in a criminal investigation and that he recently bought a gun that matches the bullet found, seems to be some logical fallacies

 

Although I am sure she "feels" safer now, knowing he can't (legally) buy a gun

If the ex-husband was going to cause her bodily harm it would be pretty stupid to carefully think it through, decide to get an FID card, get finger printed, wait 2 months get it, go buy a gun, then use this gun to harm her knowing full well he'll be the first one they look at in a criminal investigation and that he recently bought a gun that matches the bullet found, seems to be some logical fallacies

 

Although I am sure she "feels" safer now, knowing he can't (legally) buy a gun

 

This is exactly the thought process. They think someone will commit murder but only with a legally obtained firearm.

This is exactly the thought process. They think someone will commit murder but only with a legally obtained firearm.

 

 

Yes, because we all know criminals are sticklers for following the law.....

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.