Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

NJ LEGAL M1 CARBINE

Featured Replies

these guns kill peopleeeeee!!!!

 

Ahem:

If guns kill people, then...

-pencils miss spel words.

-cars make people drive drunk.

-spoons made Rosie O'Donnell fat.

  • Replies 201
  • Views 28k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • intercooler
    intercooler

    Yea. You can't have one

  • He's an Anti..no matter what he may tell you to his face. HE appointed a rabidly antigun democrat as the AG, under his watch the Auto-Ordnance Carbine copy was authorized, then rescinded, Direct CMP

AO should immediately create an NJ compliant "ML Carbine" - part number AOML10, print up some manuals for the "ML Carbine" and post a web page on their site all about their new NJ compliant "ML Carbine" complete with a 15 rnd magazine... Hell I'd even offer a second model - part number AOML20 with a damned bayonet lug dangling from the front of the sum-bit out of sheer principle...

uscarbine.jpg

AO should immediately create an NJ compliant "ML Carbine" - part number AOML10, print up some manuals for the "ML Carbine" and post a web page on their site all about their new NJ compliant "ML Carbine" complete with a 15 rnd magazine... Hell I'd even offer a second model - part number AOML20 with a damned bayonet lug dangling from the front of the sum-bit out of sheer principle...

uscarbine.jpg

 

That is truly brilliant however the cost associated with modifying the forging would probably not be worth it...

The Markings are stamped in, not part of the forging IIRC.

 

You give WAY too much credit to people Wolfy. This is EXACTLY the same kind of thing that killed CMP Sales. people calling and playing "Mother May I" instead of just trusting the damed FFL's in this case, and CMP's DECADES of shipping to NJ in that case.

 

 

Fascinating. But how could a phone call to verify a gun's legality change or jeopardize it's legality?

 

Or am I missing something overt here?

To be blunt, it showed too much interest....Much like the CMP issue. If everyone had played cool for a couple of months, and these rifles gad gotten out there it would have been too late for them to do anything. All of the interest drew attention to the letter, and probably the guy who wrote it.

 

It drew so much attention because the gun is a quintessentially American icon of freedom and liberty which should have never have been banned in the first place and a great number of people in the state have been wanting to add one to their collections for the past twenty years now... I can understand an idiot hoplophobe liberal wince at the sight of an AR-15 or an AK-47, their emotional, irrational and I can understand that. But how do you look at an M1 Carbine the same way? Even the "well their not after my guns" goober sportsmen types were scratching their heads at the M1 Carbine being on that list when the law was passed...

:facepalm:

 

I see it as...

 

One dealer gets an OK for it... keeps it to himself.

 

Other dealers want it too and start calling themselves.

 

Before you know, you have 100 FFL's from the NY/NJ/PA area calling NJSP to get the blessing.

 

NJSP backs up.

:facepalm:

 

I see it as...

 

One dealer gets an OK for it... keeps it to himself.

 

Other dealers want it too and start calling themselves.

 

Before you know, you have 100 FFL's from the NY/NJ/PA area calling NJSP to get the blessing.

 

NJSP backs up.

 

The Letter was to the Distributor, not the dealers Mak IIRC

:facepalm:

 

I see it as...

 

One dealer gets an OK for it... keeps it to himself.

 

Other dealers want it too and start calling themselves.

 

Before you know, you have 100 FFL's from the NY/NJ/PA area calling NJSP to get the blessing.

 

NJSP backs up.

 

The Letter was to the Distributor, not the dealers Mak IIRC

 

If your a dealer in a hostile state such as this are you going to take your chances on what the manufacturer/distributor tells you or are you going to verify what he says?

:facepalm:

 

I see it as...

 

One dealer gets an OK for it... keeps it to himself.

 

Other dealers want it too and start calling themselves.

 

Before you know, you have 100 FFL's from the NY/NJ/PA area calling NJSP to get the blessing.

 

NJSP backs up.

 

The Letter was to the Distributor, not the dealers Mak IIRC

 

no no, the letter was to the dealer. saw it myself.

Who called the SP? I would think buyers wouldn't because we knew it was legal. I would think it was dealers because they could have made a lot of money.

 

 

You give WAY too much credit to people Wolfy. This is EXACTLY the same kind of thing that killed CMP Sales. people calling and playing "Mother May I" instead of just trusting the damed FFL's in this case, and CMP's DECADES of shipping to NJ in that case.

+100,000,000

To be blunt, it showed too much interest....Much like the CMP issue. If everyone had played cool for a couple of months, and these rifles gad gotten out there it would have been too late for them to do anything. All of the interest drew attention to the letter, and probably the guy who wrote it.

 

 

So I must assume that what you are saying is that somehow the stated version of the weapon slipped through the legal cracks and has since been exposed, correct?

 

Even if so, the configuration either is or isn't NJ legal. Whether the violation is a lug or the engravings on the receiver, I just don't get all the confusion. Guess I need to spend more time on the local issues like I used to.

Saying that people asking if something is legal or not changed the status being the fault of the people asking, is idiotic. Does that mean if enough people call up NJSP and ask what the speed limit on the Parkway is, they will change it? That is pure bullshit on NJSP's part, not the FFLs/people calling. I don't blame ANYONE for wanting to triple-check the legality of something in this backwards state. If a law is a law, it has to be black or white, any law with massive grey areas subject to police interpretation need to be clarified or redacted and we as citizens ought to be working together to make that happen, not scolding our fellow citizens for wanting to make sure their gun owned for fun/hobby purposes does not land them in prison with rapists and murderers.

 

As for their decision, they state that the rifle labeled ML is an M1 because the web site calls it an M1, despite the law referring to the gun, not what the website calls it. By that logic, many ARs, SARs, WASRs, Saigas, etc. are referred to as ARs/AKs on manufacturer websites as ARs/AKs. This is very worrying because these rifles are called AKs and AR's on dozens upon dozens of sites, and if NJSP is going to use that as a reason to make something illegal it makes for a VERY dangerous situation for gun owners.

 

How far does the interpretation go? If a lot of people on a forum are calling their WASRs/Saigas AKs, does that make them illegal Avtomat-Kalashnikov types now? How about in print? This means we can call something something and that instantly makes it something else because people said so? Think of how ridiculous/unjust/dangerous that game can be. Hey look, this forum has an AK and AR section, does that mean NJSP can use THIS website and ban all people's rifles? How many people have a thread on here with their DPMS Panther or Bushmaster XM-15 saying "Check out my new AR". Makes you wonder, doesn't it?

 

This is idiotic, and people blaming FFLs/citizens need to pull their head out of where the sun don't shine and realize this is the result of a bureaucratic mess, not joe citizen or johnny businessowner wanting to make sure he doesn't land himself in prison due to police interpretation of a vague law written by people who don't know anything about firearms.

Saying that people asking if something is legal or not changed the status being the fault of the people asking, is idiotic.

 

 

I don't think I could agree with you more. Without further proof of this supposed chain of events, I suspect several comments in this thread are going to be the butt of someones joke at the state level. Almost can't believe what I am reading in a serious firearms forum.

 

However if there is proof of this, time still allows for disclosure.

You believe whatever you want....but that IS IN FACT how the CMP exemption was lost. People calling to see if it was legal brought the practice tio the attention of someone in the AG's office, who THEN decided it had to Stop.

You believe whatever you want....but that IS IN FACT how the CMP exemption was lost. People calling to see if it was legal brought the practice tio the attention of someone in the AG's office, who THEN decided it had to Stop.

 

 

You may be right, but my money is on some sort of initial assessment error made by someone along the line. And if the gun really is so borderline in legality then it certainly seems unfair to belittle anyone for checking it's status in that regard.

 

Also, if what you are saying is correct and can really happen as stated, then how is the Colt MT6400 still legal? There are thousands of them out there in NJ, so there would have been that many more calls. What allowed it to survive under what must have been very similar circumstances?

 

After all, it is an "evil black rifle". Surely they are more loathed by the AG than the smaller, wood stocked M1.

Pardon my ignorance here, but why is the State Police determining what is legal or illegal? Isn't that the job of the courts? I thought the courts interpret the law and the police just enforce it. Or, when I got a ticket way back when and the cop told me, "I don't make the laws I just enforce them." he was full of shit.

If you post this same question on another forum, one frequented with far more dealers and manufacturers, you will find that this is SOP with ATF and they will be happy to quote you a long list of things that were legal and then deemed not so much after repeated requests. One person gets it in writing and 300 more call up to confirm and to get it in writing. ATF, inundated with calls suddenly becomes wary and thinking they F'd up, go back, review and decide that on second thought we don't want to do this. Even if it is within the realm of legality they become suspicious and pull the plug. Maybe you should ask ATF whether or not your shoelaces are legal and see what they come back with too.

 

ETA: So as not to seem too vague, the ATF had classified shoelaces as a MG until very recently, when they realized how stupid it sounded.

Pardon my ignorance here, but why is the State Police determining what is legal or illegal? Isn't that the job of the courts? I thought the courts interpret the law and the police just enforce it. Or, when I got a ticket way back when and the cop told me, "I don't make the laws I just enforce them." he was full of ****.

 

Yeah, I'm having a hard time grasping this concept as well.

 

According to my 8th grade civics teacher:

 

The legislature makes the laws

The judicial branch interprets them

The police enforce them*

 

*Except in NJ, the police also get to decide what is legal or not?

 

:facepalm:

Pardon my ignorance here, but why is the State Police determining what is legal or illegal? Isn't that the job of the courts? I thought the courts interpret the law and the police just enforce it. Or, when I got a ticket way back when and the cop told me, "I don't make the laws I just enforce them." he was full of ****.

 

Yeah, I'm having a hard time grasping this concept as well.

 

According to my 8th grade civics teacher:

 

The legislature makes the laws

The judicial branch interprets them

The police enforce them*

 

*Except in NJ, the police also get to decide what is legal or not?

 

:facepalm:

No the Attorney General does.. But hey..since it's you i wont try to intrude on your clearly stated bias here with the facts.. so yes The Police DO make all the laws chicken little.

If you post this same question on another forum, one frequented with far more dealers and manufacturers, you will find that this is SOP with ATF and they will be happy to quote you a long list of things that were legal and then deemed not so much after repeated requests. One person gets it in writing and 300 more call up to confirm and to get it in writing. ATF, inundated with calls suddenly becomes wary and thinking they F'd up, go back, review and decide that on second thought we don't want to do this. Even if it is within the realm of legality they become suspicious and pull the plug.

 

 

Without anything more than second hand rhetoric to back these claims up, I stand by the suspicion that this is some sort of urban legend. If it isn't, I have to believe the lawsuits would have been too numerous to go unnoticed. Not so much on the M1 in NJ of course, but on the others included on your supposed "long list".

 

 

However since I happen to be a long time member of one the the implied forums frequented by manufactures (M4C) I will ask there and see what comes up. Always looking to learn if I can.

Being more filled in to the background of the story, all I can say is yes, it looks like 50 people a day calling in to verify is what killed it... and may possibly made it worse for others.

 

Tread lightly before this thread gets locked.

 

All I will say this is a public site and anyone can register and view.

:facepalm:

 

I see it as...

 

One dealer gets an OK for it... keeps it to himself.

 

Other dealers want it too and start calling themselves.

 

Before you know, you have 100 FFL's from the NY/NJ/PA area calling NJSP to get the blessing.

 

NJSP backs up.

 

The Letter was to the Distributor, not the dealers Mak IIRC

 

no no, the letter was to the dealer. saw it myself.

 

 

The letter was to the distrubitor.

And just to clear it up. The reason for the backup is on Auto-Ord's webpage they listed the gun as a Post Ban Compliant "M1 Carbine". So you can all blame Auto-Ord for this mistake in clearly stating that it is a M1 Carbine. Thats the reason for the switch in decision from the MAN himself. As the LT and I had a lengthy conversation about this firearm.

And just to clear it up. The reason for the backup is on Auto-Ord's webpage they listed the gun as a Post Ban Compliant "M1 Carbine". So you can all blame Auto-Ord for this mistake in clearly stating that it is a M1 Carbine. Thats the reason for the switch in decision from the MAN himself. As the LT and I had a lengthy conversation about this firearm.

 

Did anyone let Auto Ordnance in on this? All they have to do is change it from M1 to US on their page and they potentially have thousands of additional sales in 1 state?

And just to clear it up. The reason for the backup is on Auto-Ord's webpage they listed the gun as a Post Ban Compliant "M1 Carbine". So you can all blame Auto-Ord for this mistake in clearly stating that it is a M1 Carbine. Thats the reason for the switch in decision from the MAN himself. As the LT and I had a lengthy conversation about this firearm.

 

 

Now it seems to make much more sense, it almost slipped through the cracks until it was noticed due to the questions. But it was never really fully legal in the first place, just that no one initially noticed the M1 markings.

 

Or are you saying the designation was only on the website and not on the gun itself?

 

 

Edit: After looking on their sight I see the designation, but no close image of the receiver.

And just to clear it up. The reason for the backup is on Auto-Ord's webpage they listed the gun as a Post Ban Compliant "M1 Carbine". So you can all blame Auto-Ord for this mistake in clearly stating that it is a M1 Carbine. Thats the reason for the switch in decision from the MAN himself. As the LT and I had a lengthy conversation about this firearm.

 

 

Now it seems to make much more sense, it almost slipped through the cracks until it was noticed due to the questions. But it was never really fully legal in the first place, just that no one initially noticed the M1 markings.

 

Or are you saying the designation was only on the website and not on the gun itself?

 

The gun itself does not say M1 anywhere, only the website calls it an M1. The receiver of the gun is marked "ML"

 

The law says nothing about what websites call a gun, it refers only to the gun itself, not what websites, magazines, books, youtube videos, message boards, signs, etc. call it.

 

This sets a very bad and very dangerous precedent. Like I said before, what's to stop them from banning XM-15's and SAR-2's? After all, this website right here calls them ARs and AKs.

The gun itself does not say M1 anywhere, only the website calls it an M1. The receiver of the gun is marked "ML".

 

 

Now that is an absolute travesty. Holy Sh*t.

And just to clear it up. The reason for the backup is on Auto-Ord's webpage they listed the gun as a Post Ban Compliant "M1 Carbine". So you can all blame Auto-Ord for this mistake in clearly stating that it is a M1 Carbine. Thats the reason for the switch in decision from the MAN himself. As the LT and I had a lengthy conversation about this firearm.

 

 

Now it seems to make much more sense, it almost slipped through the cracks until it was noticed due to the questions. But it was never really fully legal in the first place, just that no one initially noticed the M1 markings.

 

Or are you saying the designation was only on the website and not on the gun itself?

 

The gun itself does not say M1 anywhere, only the website calls it an M1. The receiver of the gun is marked "ML"

 

The law says nothing about what websites call a gun, it refers only to the gun itself, not what websites, magazines, books, youtube videos, message boards, signs, etc. call it.

 

This sets a very bad and very dangerous precedent. Like I said before, what's to stop them from banning XM-15's and SAR-2's? After all, this website right here calls them ARs and AKs.

 

Maks, maybe you should change the name of the forums?

 

Exactly, and because so many people called in, it opened up that can of worms. But as far as the M1's... the ones I saw out of state, that looked like the ones coming here.. said M1.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.