Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SAF v NJ (MULLER et al v. MAENZA et al)

Featured Replies

well that's not good for the cause

 

WHOMP WHOMP WHOMP

  • Replies 1.3k
  • Views 177.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • WTF guys. Does nobody understand that probably 90% of members on the site are subscribed to this thread?! That means that 90% of members get an email EVERY SINGLE TIME someone posts in this thread.

  • Before you do. Zero chance is my opinion.

  • Definitely well thought out. But this was brought up a couple days ago in the other thread.

Posted Images

well that's not good for the cause

 

WHOMP WHOMP WHOMP

 

Maybe it isn't. Most people would agree that he has a legitimate need. It highlighted the ridiculous nature of New Jersey carry permits. Now that he has one, anti's can say that the permit process is rigorous but fair (b.s. of course). The rest of us need not apply unless we're being hunted down by kidnappers too.

Now that he has been granted a permit, does he lose his standing for the SAF case?

I don't think it hurts the cause. If anything, it shows that they system at present is broken and shows the hoops you have to jump through to get your carry permit.

Maybe it isn't. Most people would agree that he has a legitimate need. It highlighted the ridiculous nature of New Jersey carry permits. Now that he has one, anti's can say that the permit process is rigorous but fair (b.s. of course). The rest of us need not apply unless we're being hunted down by kidnappers too.

Now that he has been granted a permit, does he lose his standing for the SAF case?

 

I see a new business opportunity. For a fee I will attempt to kidnap you, then you can go before the judge to get your carry permit.

I am sure NJ will now use Muller as an example of how they do not infringe on 2nd amendment rights, because the permit to carry is issued in cases where it is justified.

 

All it took was to be kidnapped, beaten and escape. Get threatened by members of the kidnappers' gang. Then apply for a CCW, get denied, appeal, get denied again, bring a federal lawsuit against the state, and appeal again, get denied, and appeal one more time before being approved over the course of 18 months. Yes, clearly this falls under any common sense definition of "reasonable" regulation.

 

I look forward to the state defense making that case.

I am sure NJ will now use Muller as an example of how they do not infringe on 2nd amendment rights, because the permit to carry is issued in cases where it is justified.

 

All it took was to be kidnapped, beaten and escape. Get threatened by members of the kidnappers' gang. Then apply for a CCW, get denied, appeal, get denied again, bring a federal lawsuit against the state, and appeal again, get denied, and appeal one more time before being approved over the course of 18 months. Yes, clearly this falls under any common sense definition of "reasonable" regulation.

 

I look forward to the state defense making that case.

 

They'll make that case, and likely succeed. :icon_rolleyes:

^^^ Exactly. It's proof that a right can ever be based on subjective criteria.

 

Also, this is a civil rights case based on Title 42, Section 1983. His right to bear arms for self-defense was delayed, so he was still harmed because of the "justifiable need" requirement and therefore still has standing.

In fact I wonder why the SAF didn't make this argument. If the justifiable need requirement is what the State is going by, and someone does in fact show need, then he needs that permit Right Now. The mere fact that it takes them at least a month to even look at your application proves that the justifiable need is an impossible requirement which they do not take seriously, since you would not be able to get a permit until way after you begin needing it (assuming they approve it initially).

 

All this just means that in order for you to be able to protect yourself in case of need, you would need a permit before the fact (like we have been saying all along). The current requirement is something of a contradiction in terms within the context of the broader set of firearms statutes.

 

The proof for this argument is right here in this case. Finally, eighteen months later, they agree that Muller has need. What the heck was he supposed to be doing to protect himself for the past year and a half?

Exactly. The only thing that might change with this lawsuit is the name if Mr. Muller loses standing, which we can't be sure will be the case.

So, can I like carry a gun in New Jersey yet or what?

So, can I like carry a gun in New Jersey yet or what?

 

Sure you can Ray, just don't get caught :)

Ok, so this thread will be inactive till September again, got me all worked up seeing it come back to life. :icon_rolleyes:

 

Harry

In order for them to pass CCW in New Jersey an event would need to happen where a person who was denied a carry permit was either killed or assaulted. I hate to say it like that but how else can I put it.

In order for them to pass CCW in New Jersey an event would need to happen where a person who was denied a carry permit was either killed or assaulted. I hate to say it like that but how else can I put it.

 

No, that would be used as a reason to ban handguns or magazines over 6 rounds or something along those lines. You're trying to use logic. Stop.

No, that would be used as a reason to ban handguns or magazines over 6 rounds or something along those lines. You're trying to use logic. Stop.

 

I didn't say he would be shot or even stabbed, but I understand your logic of them NOT using logic.

  • 5 weeks later...

Don't get excited, nothing earth shattering. There was a filing on the docket today -- a new Magistrate Judge was assigned to the case, Judge Madline Arleo replaces Judge Cecchi. The case is still assigned to Judge Walls, the district court judge, but is referred to a magistrate. I'm not sure how much is decided by the magistrate judge -- I believe it's just discovery and pretrial issues but the District Court judge decides the case. In any event, based on reviews on the Robing Room (a website that rates judges), Judge Walls is supposed to be a very good and fair Judge and Judge Cecchi a good magistrate. Judge Arleo does not get very positive reviews.

Where'd you find the info? I've been searching for news on the case every week but never find anything except in this thread. :unknw:

Where'd you find the info? I've been searching for news on the case every week but never find anything except in this thread. :unknw:

Some of the members should work the Intelligence Community in the Government. I find information here that I couldn't find if it were staring me in the face.

 

What does this mean, the new magistrate coming on? Is he that horrible and biased, or what?

You can check the docket through the "PACER" system that gives access to all Federal court dockets if you have a password. I set up an alert through Bloomberg so I get an email everytime something is added to the docket (I am a lawyer). You won't find these kinds of minor filings reported in the news. In fact, I doubt anything will be reported in the news until a decision is rendered. I am not a litigator,so I am not exactly sure of the role the magistrate judge plays, but I don't think the replacement of the magistrate judge will be particularly significant.

  • 1 month later...

OK guys I've waited a month to make another post... anything new at all? Anyone have access to this PACER system?

 

Also sorry for bumping it up to the top and getting everyone to click on it, but I know the rest of you are just as eager for information as I am!

  • 4 weeks later...

Made ya look!

 

I hate you.

Made ya look!

 

Go to your room, and no dessert either!!!

 

Harry

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.