Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SAF v NJ (MULLER et al v. MAENZA et al)

Featured Replies

why not.  we all did :D

 

just from my experience the way government works, slow. i could be wrong but i dont see them mentioning it today.

  • Replies 1.3k
  • Views 178.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • WTF guys. Does nobody understand that probably 90% of members on the site are subscribed to this thread?! That means that 90% of members get an email EVERY SINGLE TIME someone posts in this thread.

  • Before you do. Zero chance is my opinion.

  • Definitely well thought out. But this was brought up a couple days ago in the other thread.

Posted Images

just from my experience the way government works, slow. i could be wrong but i dont see them mentioning it today.

 

 

i know.  i wasnt expecting anything today.  

 

 

i didnt see that supreme court blog site ever.  guess i'll have to regularly check it out

I think that we will find that even if SCOTUS rules for those who wish to carry in NJ, NJ will continue its policy and will stonewall any efforts contrary. It will be a step in the right direction, but the fight will be long from being over.

I think that we will find that even if SCOTUS rules for those who wish to carry in NJ, NJ will continue its policy and will stonewall any efforts contrary. It will be a step in the right direction, but the fight will be long from being over.

 

i imagine it will unfold similarly to what happened in illinois.  thats why i posted that i hope christie is still governor and still wants to be president.  the only thing that stopped illinois from being far worse than what they ended up with was the fact that the option of not passing legislation by the deadline nullified the laws on the books essentially making it essentially constitutional carry.  we'd have to hope to have christie in there to veto anything really bad.  

Yeah it's absolutely NOT going to be in today's conference. The state has to be given the opportunity to respond and file a brief in opposition (BIO). Other people or groups could submit amicus (friend of the court) briefs as well before it's distributed for conference.

 

It will be about 3 months and if it's granted cert will likely be heard in the fall with a decision at the end of the term in 2015.

 

So we have a while to wait still.

I think that we will find that even if SCOTUS rules for those who wish to carry in NJ, NJ will continue its policy and will stonewall any efforts contrary. It will be a step in the right direction, but the fight will be long from being over.

 

I don't know why people keep saying that. The offensive part of the law will be struck down and will take effect immediately or after a short stay.

I don't know why people keep saying that. The offensive part of the law will be struck down and will take effect immediately or after a short stay.

A+

Also, unlike IL, there is no appeal after SCOTUS, they decide and NJ has to comply. SCOTUS won't grant NJ 180 days to craft a law, we already have a law. So in a perfect world SCOTUS strikes down justifiable need and rules that self defense is a sufficient "need". Also they declare that the 2nd applies outside the home (big duh). Under those conditions the issuing judges in NJ can not refuse self defense in the "letter of need" when signing off on permits. The statute doesn't even have to change, that's the genius of the petition.

i really dont see them reading the 200 pages by today.

 

I dunno, they tend to be smart people. I read it in 40min or so. 

I dunno, they tend to be smart people. I read it in 40min or so. 

im not saying it as a matter of they cant do it. More that they wont do it by today. The brief was filed yesterday.

1. that is not the top of their agenda and where not waiting for it to be submitted so they can read it.

2. government works in a slow process even if they did read it we will not hear anything today.

please correct me if im wrong but my understanding was that there are 2 different ccw, right to bear arms, cases being brought to scotus this year. And from my understanding they will likely have to hear at least one of these cases. Again ianal so please correct me if im wrong.

http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/national-rifle-association-of-america-v-mccraw/

National Rifle Association of America v. McCraw is not assigned to conference yet, it deals with to bear outside the home and the rights of18-20 year old's.

The other is Drake v. Jerejian (ours, one named changed again)

Both cases are before SCOTUS waiting for a response to  a Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari

No telling if they will hear either, many are hopeful they hear Drake v. Jerejian, I'm still NJ optimistic they will, can't get over the fact that our dumb laws continue to stand with all that has gone on since Heller in 2008, but the majority in all three branches are statists so that's what you get I suppose.

Something VERY amusing crossed my mind. 

 

Lets say SCOTUS grants cert.  Who is NJ going to send to represent the case of the State? I'm only asking because if they send the same lady they sent to the Circuit court the hearing is going to be one for the ages, they don't suffer fools gladly. Even if they send someone else, they are still kinda stuck with the arguments she made. 

Something VERY amusing crossed my mind. 

 

Lets say SCOTUS grants cert.  Who is NJ going to send to represent the case of the State? I'm only asking because if they send the same lady they sent to the Circuit court the hearing is going to be one for the ages, they don't suffer fools gladly. Even if they send someone else, they are still kinda stuck with the arguments she made. 

 

Can you imagine the court asking the dingbat from NJ what Justifiable NAYED is?

http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/national-rifle-association-of-america-v-mccraw/

National Rifle Association of America v. McCraw is not assigned to conference yet, it deals with to bear outside the home and the rights of18-20 year old's.

The other is Drake v. Jerejian (ours, one named changed again)

Both cases are before SCOTUS waiting for a response to  a Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari

No telling if they will hear either, many are hopeful they hear Drake v. Jerejian, I'm still NJ optimistic they will, can't get over the fact that our dumb laws continue to stand with all that has gone on since Heller in 2008, but the majority in all three branches are statists so that's what you get I suppose

 

Texas did not file a response in McCraw. It was thought that this case would be denied but the S.Ct has now asked for a response.

 

I don't think it will be heard though.

I dunno, they tend to be smart people. I read it in 40min or so. 

 

They wouldn't. They want to give the state a chance to respond first.

 

It's not a quick process, it's slow.

Yeah it's absolutely NOT going to be in today's conference. The state has to be given the opportunity to respond and file a brief in opposition (BIO). Other people or groups could submit amicus (friend of the court) briefs as well before it's distributed for conference.

 

It will be about 3 months and if it's granted cert will likely be heard in the fall with a decision at the end of the term in 2015.

 

So we have a while to wait still.

 

i HATE waiting. but this seems like the most realistic timeline i suppose.  end of term is early or late 2015?  really the big wait is if they do or do not grant car

They wouldn't. They want to give the state a chance to respond first.

 

It's not a quick process, it's slow.

Will be entertaining to read the states' retarded response should they respond.

i HATE waiting. but this seems like the most realistic timeline i suppose. end of term is early or late 2015? really the big wait is if they do or do not grant car

End of term is June

Something VERY amusing crossed my mind. 

 

Lets say SCOTUS grants cert.  Who is NJ going to send to represent the case of the State? I'm only asking because if they send the same lady they sent to the Circuit court the hearing is going to be one for the ages, they don't suffer fools gladly. Even if they send someone else, they are still kinda stuck with the arguments she made.

 

Again, the beauty of the petition is Gura gets to argue the merits of the states win. Liberal judge says a long standing scheme that pre-dates Heller is constitutional ? Well now dumbalina from the AG office has to go with that.

Petition for a writ of certiorari filed. (Response due February 12, 2014)

http://www.supremecourt.gov/Search.aspx?FileName=/docketfiles/13-827.htm

 

We have a date for a first response. I'm assuming this means a conference vote will be made to decide if the court will review. At that point SCOTUS may ??? ask for the plaintiff (NJ) to file a brief. Not sure of the order of things but eventually a date for oral arguments are set and then an opinion is rendered after that. With Heller and McDonald the opinion was released the very last day before summer break. I'm not sure how this timelines but supposing we get our day in court, NJ is given a reasonable amount of time to file a brief, say by summer. They may ask for an extension but if everything falls as it should, this could be heard next fall at the earliest. 

Maybe NJ will decide not to file a brief and/or bother representing itself in arguments preferring to let the two lower courts decisions speak for themselves.. The AG has sorta no-showed with two state 2nd A cases. It may be an attempt by the big guy to get a favorable view going with the other 49 states if he goes national by covering his 2nd Amendment record.

Response date means the date NJ's response opposing the writ of certiorari is due, not the date the Court decides whether to hear the case.  NJ will almost certainly file a brief opposing cert, and the court will make the cert decision in the Spring.  If Cert is granted this will be heard late 2014 or in 2015.

If they skip this one they may take one out of Hawaii. That one is more cut and dry where they basically admitted that even though they have a statute, they just don't issue any permits. That's similar to NJ but a bit more extreme, if that were even possible!

  • 3 weeks later...

http://www.supremecourt.gov/Search.aspx?FileName=/docketfiles/13-827.htm

Jan 31 2014: SCOTUS grants Order extending time to file response to petition to and including March 14, 2014.

Attorneys for Respondents:     Mary Beth Wood State of NJ, Dept. of Law & Public Safety (609) 984-6998   P.O. Box 112, 25 Market Street     Trenton, NJ  08625-0112     [email protected]

 

Don't remember if this was the valley girl who argued for the state in the court of appeals, if so this will be a very entertaining audio file when it gets heard

http://www.supremecourt.gov/Search.aspx?FileName=/docketfiles/13-827.htm

Jan 31 2014: SCOTUS grants Order extending time to file response to petition to and including March 14, 2014.

Attorneys for Respondents:     Mary Beth Wood State of NJ, Dept. of Law & Public Safety (609) 984-6998   P.O. Box 112, 25 Market Street     Trenton, NJ  08625-0112     [email protected]

 

Don't remember if this was the valley girl who argued for the state in the court of appeals, if so this will be a very entertaining audio file when it gets heard

 

It's her. She neeyeds to be on this case and they neeyed to grant cert. 

ryan_j

 

i heard (maybe on GFH radio) that the state officially had 30 days to respond and most likely they would be given an extension (for up to 90 days) for a total of 120 days.  since this was filed on 1/9, i assumed they had until 2/9 to apply and be granted an extension and the extension could be given up until 5/9.  seems they were given until 3/14.  so really i have two questions.

 

a.)  was my dates given above correct?

b.)  is it possible for them to get another extension past 3/14 or is that the date we will hear what NJ nayeeds to come back with?

ryan_j

 

i heard (maybe on GFH radio) that the state officially had 30 days to respond and most likely they would be given an extension (for up to 90 days) for a total of 120 days.  since this was filed on 1/9, i assumed they had until 2/9 to apply and be granted an extension and the extension could be given up until 5/9.  seems they were given until 3/14.  so really i have two questions.

 

a.)  was my dates given above correct?

b.)  is it possible for them to get another extension past 3/14 or is that the date we will hear what NJ nayeeds to come back with?

 

 

The court can grant an extension to file a Brief In Opposition (BIO) for an initial period of 30 days. This is routinely granted. They can grant additional periods of 30 days but this is more difficult. So I suspect the state will file its response in March.

 

It's a stall tactic for them and is expected (MD also applied for an extension in Woollard.) But Pantano is in the pipeline so that may factor in. 

The court can grant an extension to file a Brief In Opposition (BIO) for an initial period of 30 days. This is routinely granted. They can grant additional periods of 30 days but this is more difficult. So I suspect the state will file its response in March.

 

It's a stall tactic for them and is expected (MD also applied for an extension in Woollard.) But Pantano is in the pipeline so that may factor in. 

 Is that 30 days, or "as much time as they want" like the rest of NJ laws?

It's the federal Supreme Court. I don't know much but I doubt they like it when they say 3-14 and you try to submit 3-15 or later.

Is that 30 days, or "as much time as they want" like the rest of NJ laws?

It's the US Supreme Court, not the nj pretend kangaroo court. So 30 days is 30 days, unless they have some major disaster that puts the NJ AG out of commission.

It's the federal Supreme Court. I don't know much but I doubt they like it when they say 3-14 and you try to submit 3-15 or later.

They have made it abundantly clear that if you file even a day late your filing will go in the round file.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.