Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Have around $350 to spend -- 9mm carbine or pump shotgun?

Featured Replies

I decided it's time to add a long gun to the collection. I currently own a SIG Sauer P6, a S&W 59, and a Ruger MKII.

 

I'd like to keep things at around the $300-$350 price range. I have a membership at Ready Aim Fire in Bristol, PA, a 25-yard indoor range. Shotguns, .22 LR rifles, and pistol-caliber rifles are all that are allowed as far as long guns. So I figure the top choices would be:

 

Kel-Tec SUB-2000 in 9mm

Hi-Point 995TS carbine

Mossberg 500

Remington 870

 

The Kel-Tec SUB-2000 looks to be a good choice. It can take S&W 59 magazines (14+1), which makes sense since I own a S&W 59. I would also consider the model that takes Glock 19 mags, since my girlfriend applied for her FID and will be purchasing a Glock 19 in the coming months.

 

The Hi-Point 995TS is cheaper than the Kel-Tec, and people seem to love it. While neither is pretty, I do prefer the looks of the Kel-Tec, and the fact that it folds for storage is pretty cool.

 

Or I could get a 12-gauge pump shotgun. The Mossberg 500 and the Remington 870 seem to be the popular options here. I would be looking at a short-barreled (18.5") version with a shoulder stock -- no pistol-grip-only versions please.

 

Then there is the Maverick 88, which costs so little that I could probably get that AND a Hi-Point carbine without stretching my budget too far.

 

The primary use would be range shooting, home defense would be a secondary use. Any thoughts or advice would be greatly appreciated.

Personally, I would buy the shotgun. Everybody should own one.

owning 3 of the 4 and shooting s high point a few times get the 500 or kel tec high point just feel cheap. i love my kel-tec super accurate and i have the 92fs package pistol and keltec takes same mags. but shotgun is supper handy for home defense or fun at range.

I'm biased toward the Kel-Tec. I have a Sub2000 in .40 S&W that takes glock 22 mags. It's awesome. Get it in .40 S&W. Great gun at $350.00.

Personally, I'd go with the Maverick 88 and the Hi-Point 995. I have both guns, and they are both very reliable. I know some people knock Hi-Points, but I've never had any kind of issues with mine with around 1k rounds through it. Best part is, you could easily get both of them for around $475 total. (I paid $239 for my Maverick 88 and $225 for my Hi-Point Carbine.)

I love shotguns. Most of mine are dedicated to either clay shooting, target shooting, and one for a secondary HD.

 

Comparing a 9mm carbine to a shotgun is oranges to apples, but I will say a shotgun is SO much fun to target shoot with and also use for HD. It's easy to take off a 28in for clays and throw on a 18.5in HD barrel. It's also interesting patterning different loads of buck or shot or whatever, I find shooting buckshot as one of the funnest things to do at the range.

 

You have so many options, but I would highly suggest (and agree with Flyersfan) that the Mav 88 is a great all around [shot]gun. Mine easily has over 10k rounds through it and the slide, trigger, and internals have run SO smooth from day one that it's incredible, I absolutely love it. It is definitely in my top 3 favorite guns I own.

 

As for a 9mm carbine, I have my eye on the Storm but that is about double your price range. I am unfamiliar with the Kel-tec and Hi-point, so I can't speak for them.

I have a Mossberg 500. The interchangeable barrels are fantastic. I have a muzzleloader barrel, a rifled barrel with cantilever scope mount and a 28" polychoke barrel. It's a versatile firearm which can fulfill many uses.

 

I am not familiar with the Mav88 but I see that it takes all the Moss500 barrels.

 

I vote shotgun for multiuse capability and all around performance.

There are not many differences between the 500 and 88, the few being that the 500 has the tang safety while the 88 has the crossbolt safety (I prefer). Some parts for the 88 are made in Mexico but the guns are assembled in Texas. I've also heard that Mav 88 barrels are thicker than 500 barrels (factory I guess?) and yes, the Mav 88 can interchange 500 barrels. Both guns can interchange most parts.

 

For the substantial price difference between each (Mav 88 usually around $200 while the 500 is around $350), and seeing how much of a beating the 88 can take (through my shooting and testing), I would go with the 88 but it's all up to you. Both shotguns are great shooting guns nonetheless and will run forever with a simple cleaning.

Buy what you like instead of what a bunch of people you've never met think you'll like. That being said, go for a shotgun with a slug barrel. You won't need binoculars to see how well you did at the range.

Buy what you like instead of what a bunch of people you've never met think you'll like. That being said, go for a shotgun with a slug barrel. You won't need binoculars to see how well you did at the range.

 

I don't believe you can shoot birdshot or buckshot out of a slug barrel, so you would be limited to slugs which sucks unless you hunt.

 

I think every thread is intended to suggest or help someone in their decision for whatever the OP is, rather than tell them they HAVE to buy this or that. You could get a Pardner for all I care, as with all my replies, I am just trying to help you out in deciding what might be some good options for the OP.

I vote on the 870. There is a reason why it has been around for decades....

Remi 870 all the way. So much more useful!!!!

I don't believe you can shoot birdshot or buckshot out of a slug barrel, so you would be limited to slugs which sucks unless you hunt.

 

I think every thread is intended to suggest or help someone in their decision for whatever the OP is, rather than tell them they HAVE to buy this or that. You could get a Pardner for all I care, as with all my replies, I am just trying to help you out in deciding what might be some good options for the OP.

 

 

He asked for my opinion, so I opined. Guns are a lot like woman and automobiles, some of us like em big and slowww, others prefer em a little zippier. Personal preference. :)

Shotgun - Remington or Mossberg; take your pick. I think you get a little more gun for the money with Mossberg. Some of what you're paying for with a Remington is the name (just my opinion).

Shotgun - Remington or Mossberg; take your pick. I think you get a little more gun for the money with Mossberg. Some of what you're paying for with a Remington is the name (just my opinion).

I have both an Rem 870 (late 80's vintage) and a Mossberg 590 and I would have to say the Remington is a better made gun.

  • Author

Thanks everyone. I think I'm starting to lean towards getting a shotgun. I didn't realize how cheap 12-gauge shells can be -- I figured they would be quite a bit more expensive than 9x19mm ammunition. But I am now seeing that a 25-round box of target loads (#8 shot or similar) can be had for around $6, about the same per round as the 9mm WWB stuff I get at Wal*Mart in Pennsylvania.

 

Is there anything I need to know about legality of a pump shotgun in NJ? If I'm reading things right, there is no limit on ammunition capacity (except of course the 15-round maximum, but no pump shotgun comes anywhere close to that anyways), nor is there any limitations on "evil features". So a pump shotgun with an adjustable stock AND a pistol grip is perfectly fine? And I could purchase a shotgun (or a 9mm rifle) in Pennsylvania? No matter which way I decide to go, I'd like to buy my first long gun at my PA range as long as their price is competitive with buying from a larger chain, or buying online plus shipping and FFL transfer fees. I know Dicks sells long guns, but do they carry shorter-barreled (18.5") shotguns, or just the longer ones for hunting?

I bought the Mossberg 500 at Dicks with a 20 inch barrel. I got the "persuader" model. It holds something like 8 shells total. Black synthetic stock on it. Cost approx 329 if I remember correctly.

 

If you don't care about the stock color you can always go with a hunting model with the wood stock and a little less capacity. Less cost too. You will get a longer barrel on that one. Then buy a short home defense barrel. It's cheaper then buying a gun with the home defense barrel and then buying a longer barrel for skeet or hunting.

 

A 18.5 or 20 inch barrel can be bought for approx 85 bucks. A longer barrel costs you approx 180 if I remember correctly.

870

 

And if you like shiny guns, get the mariner finish.

Shotgun - Remington or Mossberg; take your pick. I think you get a little more gun for the money with Mossberg. Some of what you're paying for with a Remington is the name (just my opinion).

Although I agree with this to some aspect....the difference between a Mossberg and Remington pump is small enough to sway me towards paying for a name brand. If it were the difference between say $3000 and $2000, then I would go for the cheaper model if it were proven....but when you are looking at $300 and $250....to me it's worth it. Just my opinion.

  • Author

Although I agree with this to some aspect....the difference between a Mossberg and Remington pump is small enough to sway me towards paying for a name brand. If it were the difference between say $3000 and $2000, then I would go for the cheaper model if it were proven....but when you are looking at $300 and $250....to me it's worth it. Just my opinion.

 

You don't consider Mossberg a "name brand"?

Good point. I wasn't trying to downplay Mossberg's name, but I do think that Remington is at least MORE of a name brand than Mossberg.

I think everyone should have a shotgun. Go look at the Moss 500 HD or the 870 Express Home Defense in your price range. I also like your idea of the KelTec and you smith using the same mags... there is something comforting in that feature.

 

Get what you like.... you will get the other later on.

the difference between a Mossberg and Remington pump is small enough to sway me towards paying for a name brand.

 

Mossberg IS a name brand and manufactures some great guns. We're not talking about Davis or Lorcin here... (or Charter Arms)

 

Personally, I would stay away from the 8 shot tube as it will be harder to find replacement barrels - most of the replacement barrels are for 5 shot tubes.

Mossberg IS a name brand and manufactures some great guns. We're not talking about Davis or Lorcin here... (or Charter Arms)

Good point. I wasn't trying to downplay Mossberg's name, but I do think that Remington is at least MORE of a name brand than Mossberg.

Although I told the OP that an 870 would be MY choice, a 500 would be just as good in it's intended role (home defense) as any other shotgun. Even with the cost of the shotgun, it's still one of the best pumps out there.

Now, if you really want the pistol carbine and you DON'T want a Cx4, then run the Kel-Tec with the mags for the Smith that you have. It's a fun gun, and very easy to shoot.

  • Author

I'm going with a (very lightly) used Mossberg 500, it was initially bought by the Las Vegas PD, and then sold to a private party. 18.5" barrel (inscribed "POLICE GUN"), wood stock, 5-shot mag tube. Approximately 15 years old, but the photos look almost brand new. I hope to be picking it up by Wednesday -- still waiting for the plows to come by my street, we got almost 2 feet of snow here.

Edited by jersey_emt

I'm going with a (very lightly) used Mossberg 500, it was initially bought by the Las Vegas PD, and then sold to a private party. 18.5" barrel (inscribed "POLICE GUN"), wood stock, 5-shot mag tube. Approximately 15 years old, but the photos look almost brand new. I hope to be picking it up by Wednesday -- still waiting for the plows to come by my street, we got almost 2" of snow here.

 

Congrats on the used Mossy.

 

I hope you mean 2 FEET of snow.

  • Author

Congrats on the used Mossy.

 

I hope you mean 2 FEET of snow.

 

LOL fixed, yes 2', not 2" of snow.

Pics when she's yours please.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.