January 2, 201115 yr Correct me if im wrong but i believe there is no such thing as open carry in a car. A gun in a car constitutes being concealed.... That depends on the state law. You are correct in PA there is no open carry in a car, that would be concealed. I lived in AZ in the late 70s, early 80s when they had no carry permits and the only way you could carry was open carry. At that time you had to open carry or keep the gun in a "normal storage compartment" in a car. It seems some are surprised that state law applies to anyone in that state. Just as anyone can be arrested in NJ for an "assault weapon" (unless it's an out of state resident travelling under FOPA), anyone can open carry in PA (within their restrictions). I go on a PA forum often and it seems to me that there are some who open carry in places that are legal but looking for confrontation (open carry in a bar or the airport). State laws, as far as firearms carry go, apply to anyone in that state. In many states you can carry that shotgun loaded in the rack in your pickup but not NJ. If you are from NJ you can carry concealed without a permit in Vermont, Alaska, or Arizona as long as you comply with any restrictions.
January 2, 201115 yr there should be no real debate or confusion.. the state can not stop you from traveling to another state.. you can legally take your guns to another state.. are they legal where you start? YES are they legal where you end up? YES NJ law does not prevent you from leaving the state and bringing property you legally own.. this was discussed to death here just a little while ago.. Exactly. The question is not whether or not it is legal, because it is clear that you would be protected under FOPA. Even so, you might get arrested and be in for a legal battle because LE and prosecutors don't understand the law. Revell v. Port Authority is an example. The question is whether or not you are going to give up your right to carry in a neighboring state because you fear the authorities in NJ may make that error. That is an individual decision for each person to make.
January 2, 201115 yr In many states you can carry that shotgun loaded in the rack in your pickup but not NJ. It must be nice.....
January 2, 201115 yr Exactly. The question is not whether or not it is legal, because it is clear that you would be protected under FOPA. Even so, you might get arrested and be in for a legal battle because LE and prosecutors don't understand the law. Revell v. Port Authority is an example. The question is whether or not you are going to give up your right to carry in a neighboring state because you fear the authorities in NJ may make that error. That is an individual decision for each person to make. Edited: - I misread the post. Open carry and concealed carry is legal in Philly with a LTCF. This is always the uphill battle. Those who are responsible for upholding the laws don't understand them. I was reading in a PA carry forum that people were getting harrassed by LE in Philly for open carry even though they have a LTCF. Perfectly legal. As for travel to and from PA, I agree FOPA is definitely designed to protect us. But alas, who wants to be that test case. Its unbelievable that we the people do not have realistic recourse for being illegally prosecuted. NJ can file charges and prosecute people all day long, wasting taxpayer money, while draining defendants bank accounts. People that shouldn't be in that position from the get go.
January 2, 201115 yr The LEO actually told the guy to cover up and conceal as that is the law. It is completely opposite of the law! There is no CCW even with a LTCF in Philly! The LEO was telling him to break the law! Whoa, whoa, whoa hoss, where'd you ever get that idea. Philadelphia is part of PA (even though most residents would prefer to give it to NJ) and as such it is perfectly legal to carry concealed there (providied you have an LTCF or reciprocal CCW). Given the attitude of the Philly PD, for me, it is the preferred method. The whole gist of this thread was about spreading misinformation - let's not be part of that. Adios, Pizza Bob
January 2, 201115 yr Whoa, whoa, whoa hoss, where'd you ever get that idea. Philadelphia is part of PA (even though most residents would prefer to give it to NJ) and as such it is perfectly legal to carry concealed there (providied you have an LTCF or reciprocal CCW). Given the attitude of the Philly PD, for me, it is the preferred method. The whole gist of this thread was about spreading misinformation - let's not be part of that. Adios, Pizza Bob Thanks, corrected my post. LTCF is needed for CCW and Open Carry in Philly... as opposed to being able to open carry in other non-Philly areas of PA without the need of a LTCF.
January 2, 201115 yr Whoa, whoa, whoa hoss, where'd you ever get that idea. Philadelphia is part of PA (even though most residents would prefer to give it to NJ) and as such it is perfectly legal to carry concealed there (providied you have an LTCF or reciprocal CCW). Given the attitude of the Philly PD, for me, it is the preferred method. The whole gist of this thread was about spreading misinformation - let's not be part of that. Adios, Pizza Bob +1 for clearing that up... I see no reason why you could not CCW in philly.. philly is the NJ of PA.. it has bizarre laws and restrictions.. but if you have a LTCF that PA honors you can carry in philly.. I believe the situation is that because it is a "class 1" city you NEED a LTCF to be able to carry there..
January 2, 201115 yr Exactly. The question is not whether or not it is legal, because it is clear that you would be protected under FOPA. Even so, you might get arrested and be in for a legal battle because LE and prosecutors don't understand the law. Revell v. Port Authority is an example. The question is whether or not you are going to give up your right to carry in a neighboring state because you fear the authorities in NJ may make that error. That is an individual decision for each person to make. I will not deprive myself personally out of fear of wrongful prosecution.. if I follow the law.. that is good enough for me.. and anyone who wants to challenge that LEO, government employee, etc... I say fine.. challenge me.. because as long as I know I am within the law.. I will not hesitate to do what I know to be right..
January 2, 201115 yr Author I certainly did not anticipate the flood of responses from my original posting. You folks are a great resource - thanks! One point regarding PA carry I have not seen mentioned, although I may have missed it: open or concealed carry in any privately owned venue (land, store, mall, restaurant, home, etc.) is at the sole discretion of the owner or management of the facility. You must comply with their desire whether it be written or verbal. I believe the charge if you fail to comply is defiant trespass. I also haunt the PAOFA forums. As with many contributory sources there is right, wrong and downright inflammatory input. You need to filter fact from fiction and, as always, be aware of some with agendas.
January 2, 201115 yr Exactly. The question is not whether or not it is legal, because it is clear that you would be protected under FOPA. Even so, you might get arrested and be in for a legal battle because LE and prosecutors don't understand the law. Revell v. Port Authority is an example. The question is whether or not you are going to give up your right to carry in a neighboring state because you fear the authorities in NJ may make that error. That is an individual decision for each person to make. I don't think Revell vs Port Authority is fully applicable. The crux of Revell vs Port Authority was that Revell, a non-NJ resident, had possession of his gun in NJ when he stayed overnight at the hotel. Although we conclude that Revell fell outside of § 926A’s protection during his stay in New Jersey, we recognize that he had been placed in a difficult predicament through no fault of his own. However, Section 926 clearly requires the traveler to part ways with his weapon and ammunition during travel; it does not address this type of interrupted journey or what the traveler is to do in this situation. Stranded gun owners like Revell have the option of going to law enforcement representatives at an airport or to airport personnel before they retrieve their luggage. The careful owner will do so and explain his situation, requesting that his firearm and ammunition be held for him overnight.18 While this no doubt adds to the inconvenience imposed upon the unfortunate traveler when his transportation plans go awry, it offers a reasonable means for a responsible gun owner to maintain the protection of Section 926 and prevent unexpected exposure to state and local gun regulations.
January 2, 201115 yr However, Section 926 clearly requires the traveler to part ways with his weapon and ammunition during travel; This is not so. You are covered by FOPA if you are a PA resident travelling through NJ to go to Maine via I95 through NJ, NY, CT, MA, RI, and NH. As long as your weapon is legal at the start and finish and you keep it conatined as outlined by FOPA there is no requirement to part ways with your weapons and ammo.
January 2, 201115 yr My interpretation of the ruling is that parting ways means the weapon is locked in the trunk of your car and is therefore inaccessible to you while you are traveling through NJ. Taking possession of the weapon while overnight in the hotel was declared by the court as non-compliance with 926.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.