Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

what's a good handgun for the wife

Featured Replies

my p226 is too big for her to shoot, and she has a lot of trouble trying to shoot in DA. I was thinking a 9mm p239 but would like some other suggestions. i like how its not much smaller than the 229 as im not looking at pocket pistols, but its thinner in the grip. the glock grips are a little big for her too. im not too familiar with the smaller stuff.

handling is such a personal preference I would save the hassle take a drive down to the local shop and just have her handle some... see what she likes the feel of...

echo vlad. let her decide.

I'm the 4th or 5th to say this but it is better for her to make the selection. Put the shoe on the otehr foot, how would you like it if she was picking a handgun for you?

One of the good things about Shore Shot is their rental board. Shoot as many guns of the same caliber for one price, and also shoot used guns she may be interested in during the same session, or another time. Take her there, or another range with a wide selection of rentals. This is the absolute best route to go, and she may surprise you with her choice.

 

My Girlfriend didn't make her first purchase until shooting 8 or 9 guns. She didn't care for Glock's or Beretta's. She likes my Ruger P90 .45 but hates my P95 in 9mm. She shot my S&W Model 10 and quickly found out that she really likes revolvers. She wound up buying a S&W Model 19, and then a Nickel plated Model 10 a few months later. She's a slow shooter and takes her time with every shot, unlike myself.

  • Author

she's not in the market for anything yet. she actually "doesnt mind" shooting the 226. i can just see she struggles with it. im not going to go buy her something without her knowing, but im pretty much responsible for figuring out the options and then presenting them to her. im thinking, if i can find a few ideas here of stuff for her to check out. than maybe i can get a chance to rent one or two for her to try out and when she finds one that fits her, hopefully she'll say that she found one that works for her. im just looking to make a list.

 

like xyz handgun is a small but not a pocket size handgun. a fullsize handgun for someone that cant hold a fullsize one easily you could say

then ill research, see what the inherent advantages and disadvantages are

then ill present that to her and see where we can rent them

then she'll buy

handling is such a personal preference I would save the hassle take a drive down to the local shop and just have her handle some... see what she likes the feel of...

Handling is only part of it. Might as well go to one of the meet ups and shoot everyone else's guns. Between members, she can fire pretty much anything without spending any on rental fees.

Handling is only part of it. Might as well go to one of the meet ups and shoot everyone else's guns. Between members, she can fire pretty much anything without spending any on rental fees.

 

This is the best option. There is no way to figure out what is best until she gets a chance to shoot a lot of different things on the same day. I brought my buddy and his wife(both new shooters) to a Brick Armory meet and they each shot between 10-20 different guns, ending up with a fantastic idea of what they both prefer in a handgun.

I agree with everyone else/ Let her decide and get her around as many guns to decide.

my p226 is too big for her to shoot, and she has a lot of trouble trying to shoot in DA. I was thinking a 9mm p239 but would like some other suggestions. i like how its not much smaller than the 229 as im not looking at pocket pistols, but its thinner in the grip. the glock grips are a little big for her too. im not too familiar with the smaller stuff.

 

Does it have to be 9mm? Is the purpose just for her to have fun while shooting? If so, consider a Beretta Neos, Ruger Mark 3, Browning Buckmark...

S&W Model 29 6"! That way when she does not like it, you can take it and then go buy her another gun to try... Like a Desert Eagle. Repeat process until... whenever.

As others have said, I'm all for letting her choose her own. If you are looking for a centerfire, one problem a lot of women have (not being sexist here ladies - this is born out by experience) is manipulating the slide. Make sure she can do this before you go any further with a semi-auto. The "overhand" method of racking the slide usually works well. If she has a problem with this, then move on to a revolver.

 

Your second stated hurdle is that she doesn't do well with double-action. That is something that may just work itself out with practice. I doubt any of us shot DA well the first several times we tried it. Another solution is to go with a single-action semi-auto, although I'd have some trepidation about a new shooter and a cocked and locked SA. If you can get past that - check out a Springfield armory EMP in 9mm. I have long been a critic of mini 1911's, but that applied to cut down 1911's. The EMP was designed from the ground up as a reduced size (in all components) 1911 platform and from all reports works well.

 

By all means let her try a variety of firearms. This is just where your statements led me.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

My wife loves her S&W 686

handling is such a personal preference I would save the hassle take a drive down to the local shop and just have her handle some... see what she likes the feel of...

 

What Vlad said

 

Vlad, I think I've agreed and/or gave you a + for so many posts I lost count! Maybe it's love?

 

:facepalm:

 

:wub:

Ruger SR9+SR9C is pretty thin.

I've heard that as well. The SR9 is getting great reviews on the Ruger forum. I was talking to one of the RO's at Shore Shot who shot one and said he was impressed, and he's a Spring Field Armory fan. I shot his SD .45 and man, what a sweet gun that is. Not too big and a nice light trigger.

SR9 has a nice light trigger? I'm sorry but I've fired Ray Ray's. That trigger feels muddy and horrible.

 

No, I said the SD has a nice light trigger. Never shot the SR9, but only heard good things. Well, until your post anyway :)

my p226 is too big for her to shoot, and she has a lot of trouble trying to shoot in DA. I was thinking a 9mm p239 but would like some other suggestions. i like how its not much smaller than the 229 as im not looking at pocket pistols, but its thinner in the grip. the glock grips are a little big for her too. im not too familiar with the smaller stuff.

 

As is always my answer, let's get back to basics. What is the purpose of this handgun? Is it for recreation or defense?

How much of an enthusiast will she be and how familiar is she willing to become with the handgun?

 

This dictates, pistol, revolver, DAO pistol, magazine safety or not. Having more info makes a reccomendation more relavant.

  • Author

99.999% recreation

 

she enjoys going with me, but probably wont do it on her own

 

i "think" she would enjoy something like a glock, where the trigger pull is always the same, but she really likes the SA mode of the 226.

 

i should have just started a thread asking "what handguns work for people with smaller hands" because thats all i am really looking for. 30 people telling me to have her shoot and decide herself isnt much of a help as that's just common sense. haha

A smaller gun like a P239 might be easier o hold but harder to shoot. Try the P30 or M&P9 with adjustable backstraps.

 

As for racking the slide this is almost always an issue of technique and aligning the hands and arms properly for leverage. Check out corneredcat.com for a great description of the technique for women.

99.999% recreation

 

she enjoys going with me, but probably wont do it on her own

 

i "think" she would enjoy something like a glock, where the trigger pull is always the same, but she really likes the SA mode of the 226.

 

i should have just started a thread asking "what handguns work for people with smaller hands" because thats all i am really looking for. 30 people telling me to have her shoot and decide herself isnt much of a help as that's just common sense. haha

 

 

I am picking up a Glock 27 for my carry gun but this will also be my girlfriends primary gun... it fits in her hands really well.. she shoots my 23 all the time and finds it very manageable.. she is pretty small also..

Also don't overlook a 1911. The single stack frame is very ergonomic for people of all sized hands. For a fun gun that does not get used for defense a 4" 1911 in 9mm would be fantastic.

One of the good things about Shore Shot is their rental board. Shoot as many guns of the same caliber for one price, and also shoot used guns she may be interested in during the same session, or another time. Take her there, or another range with a wide selection of rentals. This is the absolute best route to go, and she may surprise you with her choice.

 

My Girlfriend didn't make her first purchase until shooting 8 or 9 guns. She didn't care for Glock's or Beretta's. She likes my Ruger P90 .45 but hates my P95 in 9mm. She shot my S&W Model 10 and quickly found out that she really likes revolvers. She wound up buying a S&W Model 19, and then a Nickel plated Model 10 a few months later. She's a slow shooter and takes her time with every shot, unlike myself.

 

A nice revolver in 38 SP. Maybe a Model 10, 14, 64, or 67? I think a revolver is good in a high stress situation. No need to rack the slide, no safety to worry about and easy in double or single action. Just point and pull trigger. If she's not into revolvers, my wife chose a Ruger P95 because the slide was easy for her to pull back.

 

In the end, it's all going to come down to what she likes. Shore Shot for some test shooting is a good idea.

  • Author

i gotta take a trip down to shore shot. a revolver might be a good idea. whats the trigger pull on a typical DA/SA revolver? plus, 357 mag wouldnt be a bad nightstand choice

  • Author

thought about that. thought about the converting the 229 to 9mm e2 as well. but getting ANOTHER firearm is more fun. isnt it?

A nice revolver in 38 SP. Maybe a Model 10, 14, 64, or 67? I think a revolver is good in a high stress situation. No need to rack the slide, no safety to worry about and easy in double or single action. Just point and pull trigger. If she's not into revolvers, my wife chose a Ruger P95 because the slide was easy for her to pull back.

 

In the end, it's all going to come down to what she likes. Shore Shot for some test shooting is a good idea.

 

 

I think Rick is right but for totally different reasons though. I think with a suitable sized revolver she may kick your a**(this is a great reason for her WANTING to come to the range). With limited familiarity to firearms a revolver is considered inherently safer as well.

 

If you come to CR I can let her try out different handguns. Caliber? I like to see a solid group w/ a 22lr befor moving on.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.