Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

CT Man busted in NJ for carrying gun

Featured Replies

This post is in reference to SEVERAL members here. Anybody who thinks that an officer should apply his/her discretion to firearm laws is just ignorant. There are certain things that a patrol officer just does not do, and that is one of them. A gun is no laughing matter, and just because most of you handle it responsibly does not mean that everybody does. There is no reason why an officer should let someone go when they are found carrying a loaded weapon simply because they have the "license" to carry in other states. I say license in "" because there is no way for a NJ officer to verify if the license is actually legitimate or not. This is the most absurd argument I have ever heard.

  • Replies 78
  • Views 7.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • I've always believed it was a human right to defend yourself. The 2a was put in place to protects us from the government becoming basically what it is today. I mean sh8t, the revolutionary war started

  • Because the jury may decide that it is a bad law.   Vlad, I gotta disagree with you on this one. The point is that possession of a firearm for the purpose of self-defense by a law-abiding citizen i

  • my apologies then.. my understanding of the law is totally wrong.. NOT being a smart a**.. but my understanding is that the jury is to give a verdict based on the law that was broken that is in effect

This post is in reference to SEVERAL members here. Anybody who thinks that an officer should apply his/her discretion to firearm laws is just ignorant. There are certain things that a patrol officer just does not do, and that is one of them. A gun is no laughing matter, and just because most of you handle it responsibly does not mean that everybody does. There is no reason why an officer should let someone go when they are found carrying a loaded weapon simply because they have the "license" to carry in other states. I say license in "" because there is no way for a NJ officer to verify if the license is actually legitimate or not. This is the most absurd argument I have ever heard.

 

+1

that is how I feel.. if it is something that the individual truly did not know and it was some murky gray area.. that would be one thing.. illegally CCW is totally different..

This post is in reference to SEVERAL members here. Anybody who thinks that an officer should apply his/her discretion to firearm laws is just ignorant. There are certain things that a patrol officer just does not do, and that is one of them. A gun is no laughing matter, and just because most of you handle it responsibly does not mean that everybody does. There is no reason why an officer should let someone go when they are found carrying a loaded weapon simply because they have the "license" to carry in other states. I say license in "" because there is no way for a NJ officer to verify if the license is actually legitimate or not. This is the most absurd argument I have ever heard.

 

If you are referring to me.. In no way have I even hinted that LEO should use discretionary enforcement when it comes to illegal possession.

 

I'm merely stating that laws in general are selectively enforced at LEO's discretion, and juries can selectively apply laws in court cases (giving a not guilty even when it is clear the law was broken in its literal sense).

That is exactly why nullification is essential. What if all gun owning jurors refused to convict during cases of simple possession that did not involve criminal intent. That would send a heck of a message

 

just to go to extremes and illustrate the dangerous road that is returning verdicts based on feeling as opposed to facts..

 

what if a small town of minority hating inbreds refuse to convict some scumbag who beat some immigrant to death simply because they oppose illegal immigration..

 

right and wrong is subjective.. and will always vary from one individual to the next.... some people are upstanding.. and possess an excellent moral compass.. others are corrupt.. this is why FACT and LAW is important.. those items are not subjective.. I may not agree with the law.. but the law in most cases is fairly clear..

This post is in reference to SEVERAL members here. Anybody who thinks that an officer should apply his/her discretion to firearm laws is just ignorant. There are certain things that a patrol officer just does not do, and that is one of them. A gun is no laughing matter, and just because most of you handle it responsibly does not mean that everybody does. There is no reason why an officer should let someone go when they are found carrying a loaded weapon simply because they have the "license" to carry in other states. I say license in "" because there is no way for a NJ officer to verify if the license is actually legitimate or not. This is the most absurd argument I have ever heard.

I don't think there is any wiggle room with discretion on firearms infractions. I wouldn't expect anything less than arrest in every case.

Let's start from the beginning.

 

Do you believe that the Second Amendment guarantees a preexisting individual right to keep and bear arms for self-defense?

If you are referring to me.. In no way have I even hinted that LEO should use discretionary enforcement when it comes to illegal possession.

 

I'm merely stating that laws in general are selectively enforced at LEO's discretion, and juries can selectively apply laws in court cases (giving a not guilty even when it is clear the law was broken in its literal sense).

I'm not really going to name anybody in general, but I was not referring to you.

 

However, discretion can only go so far. Discretion doesn't mean that an officer can simply rule as they please without any blowback. I will use the example again. Let's say the officer let this guy go, and he turned out to be Jared Loughner? Just because someone has licenses to carry in OTHER states that NJ does not recognize does not automatically mean someone is of sound mind. If an officer found out Jared Loughner had a gun, let him go.....ASIDE from the huge blow to his emotional state, he would be fired, fined, and sued. Discretion only goes so far.

 

Let's start from the beginning.

 

Do you believe that the Second Amendment guarantees a preexisting individual right to keep and bear arms for self-defense?

Hell yes I do. To take it a step further.....I think that even if the 2A didn't exist, I should still have every right to protect myself from someone who intends to do me harm. The law shouldn't even matter, it should be common sense in a very basic state.

 

 

 

 

Joe, that is what judges tell us, but it is not true. A juror has the obligation to consider the law and may acquit based on good conscience. See above.

 

BTW, I wasn't aware of this either until about six months ago when I had jury duty. My experience prompted me to do some research. I posted about it here:

http://njgunforums.c...2Bnullification

 

I cant believe I am going to say this.......I have recieved summons to serve 3 times in my 40 years......My number has never been called and I did not know this. I will probably get served and my number will be called! Thanks Frank!

I cant believe I am going to say this.......I have recieved summons to serve 3 times in my 40 years......My number has never been called and I did not know this. I will probably get served and my number will be called! Thanks Frank!

I thought that's how it was, then I thought I was losing my mind. I may still be losing my mind, but at least Frank cleared that up for me too.

Let's start from the beginning.

 

Do you believe that the Second Amendment guarantees a preexisting individual right to keep and bear arms for self-defense?

I would go a step further and add that it's a protection from the government itself.

I would go a step further and add that it's a protection from the government itself.

 

I've always believed it was a human right to defend yourself. The 2a was put in place to protects us from the government becoming basically what it is today. I mean sh8t, the revolutionary war started over much less BS then we deal with today in this country. I dont get how people can really sit on the couch at home and be under the impression that our government is actually on your side.... we are cattle to them, the only reason they protect us is because 1) they live here too, and 2) we pay the bills. The government will always try to be bigger, and make the people smaller(while making them feel bigger), our founding fathers knew this, they didnt write the constitution based on there ideals of freedom, they based it on the BS they had to deal with under tyrants and wanted to prevent.

I've always believed it was a human right to defend yourself. The 2a was put in place to protects us from the government becoming basically what it is today. I mean sh8t, the revolutionary war started over much less BS then we deal with today in this country. I dont get how people can really sit on the couch at home and be under the impression that our government is actually on your side.... we are cattle to them, the only reason they protect us is because 1) they live here too, and 2) we pay the bills. The government will always try to be bigger, and make the people smaller(while making them feel bigger), our founding fathers knew this, they didnt write the constitution based on there ideals of freedom, they based it on the BS they had to deal with under tyrants and wanted to prevent.

 

 

we have never agreed more than in this one post..

 

+1

just to go to extremes and illustrate the dangerous road that is returning verdicts based on feeling as opposed to facts..

 

what if a small town of minority hating inbreds refuse to convict some scumbag who beat some immigrant to death simply because they oppose illegal immigration..

 

right and wrong is subjective.. and will always vary from one individual to the next.... some people are upstanding.. and possess an excellent moral compass.. others are corrupt.. this is why FACT and LAW is important.. those items are not subjective.. I may not agree with the law.. but the law in most cases is fairly clear..

 

... ah, but isn't that the moral equivalent of voting to convict a person who was helping runaway slaves?

Ever hear of the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850?

Jurors refusing to convict those that violated the Fugitive Slave Act is one of the things that lead to the passing of the Fourteenth Amendment.

 

I'm not worried about corrupt jurors, I'm worried about incompetent legislators and judges.

 

Nullification

 

In 1854, the Wisconsin Supreme Court became the only state high court to declare the Fugitive Slave Act unconstitutional, as a result of a case involving fugitive slave Joshua Glover, and Sherman Booth, who led efforts that thwarted Glover's recapture. Ultimately, in 1859 in Ableman v. Booth the U.S. Supreme Court overruled the state court.

 

 

In November 1850, the Vermont legislature approved the "Habeas Corpus Law," requiring Vermont judicial and law enforcement officials to assist captured fugitive slaves. This law rendered the federal Fugitive Slave Act effectively unenforceable in Vermont and caused a storm of controversy nationally because it was a "nullification" of federal law, a concept that had become highly charged in debates over slavery. The famous poet and abolitionist John Greenleaf Whittier had called for such laws and the Whittier controversy heightened angry pro-slavery reactions to the Vermont law. Virginia governor John B. Floyd warned that nullification could push the South toward secession, while President Millard Fillmore threatened to use the army to enforce the Fugitive Slave Act in Vermont. No actual events followed in Vermont, but the rhetoric of this flare-up echoed South Carolina's 1832 nullification crisis and in Thomas Jefferson's 1798 Kentucky Resolutions.

 

"Jury nullification" took effect as local juries acquitted men accused of violating the law. Secretary of State Daniel Webster was a key supporter of the law as expressed in his famous "Seventh of March" speech. He wanted high profile convictions. The jury nullifications ruined his presidential aspirations and his last-ditch efforts to find a compromise between North and South. Webster led the prosecution when defendants were accused of rescuing Shadrach Minkins in 1851 from Boston officials who intended to return Minkins to his owner; the juries convicted none of the men. Webster sought to enforce a law that was extremely unpopular in the North, and his Whig Party passed over him again when they chose a presidential nominee in 1852.

 

 

 

 

 

the guy gets what he deserves when i carried in virginia first mother friggin thing i looked up is what states honored my friggin permits the guy knew especially if the retard had multiple state ccw's. i still have my va state ccw i renew it every 5 years my mother still lives down there so when i take my 6 hour trip i get that 1-3 days of carrying again lol

  • 4 weeks later...

that is where we disagree.. in having dealt with several members of this forum IRL.. and having had in depth conversations with many other I do not believe that any responsible gun owner would neglect to realize he is missing a gun.. the scenario IMO is pretty far fetched... if I bring several guns to the range and "forget one" in the trunk.. I think I would know as I went to put my guns back in the safe.. a gun is not a cell phone... can of soda.. pair of sunglasses... ownership demands a certain amount of responsibility.. securing your firearms is IMO one of the most basic responsibilities..

 

Ok devil’s advocate, let change this up a little bit. You are on your way home for the range, every time you go to and from the range, never make a stop, you follow the letter of the law to a T but today you’re on your way home, halfway there and get a call your (wife, kid, family member) just got in a serious accident and they are at the hospital and are in critical condition. You change your route to the hospital. Now you are breaking the law.

 

How would you think this situation should be handled?

 

Just wondering, there is a lot of info out here and this is a quality thread.

 

Harry

Ok devils advocate, let change this up a little bit. You are on your way home for the range, every time you go to and from the range, never make a stop, you follow the letter of the law to a T but today your on your way home, halfway there and get a call your (wife, kid, family memmber) just got in a serious acident and they are at the hospitol and are in critical condition. You imidatly change you route to the hospitol. Now you are breaking the law.

 

How would you think this situation should be handled?

 

Just wondering, there is a lot of info out here and this is a quality thread.

 

Harry

 

 

you are actually not clearly "breaking the law"... the law is vague.. deviations from the route that are only reasonably necessary.. my wife and child being involved in a serious accident.. my presence being needed at the hospital.. might very well be a reasonable stop..

 

the law is extremely vague at best..

 

on way home from the range and stop at a friends house to say hi.. yeah.. you are likely breaking the law..

on way home from range and car overheats so you stop at a friends house to fill the radiator and let it cool down.. you are likely not breaking the law..

 

the law is very vague in that regard..

All weapons being transported under paragraph (2) of subsection b., subsection e., or paragraph (1) or (3) of subsection f. of this section shall be carried unloaded and contained in a closed and fastened case, gunbox, securely tied package, or locked in the trunk of the automobile in which it is being transported, and in the course of travel shall include only such deviations as are reasonably necessary under the circumstances.

I think the Popo court will find your scenario reasonably necessary under the circumstances.

you are actually not clearly "breaking the law"... the law is vague.. deviations from the route that are only reasonably necessary.. my wife and child being involved in a serious accident.. my presence being needed at the hospital.. might very well be a reasonable stop..

 

the law is extremely vague at best..

 

on way home from the range and stop at a friends house to say hi.. yeah.. you are likely breaking the law..

on way home from range and car overheats so you stop at a friends house to fill the radiator and let it cool down.. you are likely not breaking the law..

 

the law is very vague in that regard..

 

Like I said this has been a good thread, best this we can all do regardless of how we feel this situation turns out would be to continue to do what we can as a group of respectable firearms owners in NJ and help change to laws of this state and support the groups that are fighting for our rights.

 

I know many of us are and some are more active than others, but I hope a thread like this helps maybe some that were on the fence with joining groups or supporting these groups that are fighting for us to do more.

 

Harry

This post is in reference to SEVERAL members here. Anybody who thinks that an officer should apply his/her discretion to firearm laws is just ignorant. There are certain things that a patrol officer just does not do, and that is one of them. A gun is no laughing matter, and just because most of you handle it responsibly does not mean that everybody does. There is no reason why an officer should let someone go when they are found carrying a loaded weapon simply because they have the "license" to carry in other states. I say license in "" because there is no way for a NJ officer to verify if the license is actually legitimate or not. This is the most absurd argument I have ever heard.

 

However, discretion can only go so far. Discretion doesn't mean that an officer can simply rule as they please without any blowback. I will use the example again. Let's say the officer let this guy go, and he turned out to be Jared Loughner? Just because someone has licenses to carry in OTHER states that NJ does not recognize does not automatically mean someone is of sound mind. If an officer found out Jared Loughner had a gun, let him go.....ASIDE from the huge blow to his emotional state, he would be fired, fined, and sued. Discretion only goes so far.

 

"A gun is no laughing matter, and just because most of you handle it responsibly does not mean that everybody does."

 

And then, the guy might have been crazy because he does not have an NJ permit?

 

I'm trying to figure out if you are talking about a cop's need to cover his a**, or if you think people should be vetted by NJ to carry a gun in NJ, or some combination thereof. I believe you meant the latter.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.