Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

magazines. how many do you like to have for each pistol

Featured Replies

I keep about 10 per gun. I have found some 1911 mags DIRT cheap at a local shop and got one just to see how bad it was. I brought it out the other day and it performed perfect in all of my 1911's. The mag was $5.50. So now when I am in the shop if my total is like $4.00 I put a mag into my order to make it an even $10. I put about 300rds through that 1 junker mag and didn't have any issues, so I am going to pick up a couple extras. If you see a good deal, it pays to have some extras.

I keep about 10 per gun. I have found some 1911 mags DIRT cheap at a local shop and got one just to see how bad it was. I brought it out the other day and it performed perfect in all of my 1911's. The mag was $5.50. So now when I am in the shop if my total is like $4.00 I put a mag into my order to make it an even $10. I put about 300rds through that 1 junker mag and didn't have any issues, so I am going to pick up a couple extras. If you see a good deal, it pays to have some extras.

 

 

Mind sharing?

 

I am in the market for a few, CHEAP 1911 8 round mags for my Pt 1911.

 

If you wouldn't mind grabbing a few extra, I will send you some $$$$.

for my handgun I have 3... one in the gun... and 2 on the belt... if I can not stop whatever is causing a problem with 46 rounds of 40 S&W then something is seriously wrong..

 

but for what its worth I do agree having more is reasonable if you shoot competition and all.. I do not.. as of yet.. so 3 is plenty for SD and for practicing mag change drills..

3 for each handgun.

Question on keeping mags loaded for HD. I'd read in a few places that doing so is not a good idea long term because it will weaken the springs and you may find yourself in a situation where the ammo won't load properly.

 

True/false/old wives tale?

Question on keeping mags loaded for HD. I'd read in a few places that doing so is not a good idea long term because it will weaken the springs and you may find yourself in a situation where the ammo won't load properly.

 

True/false/old wives tale?

 

Well, that's a tricky one. How long do you keep the magazine loaded? And do you switch out magazines every so often? I usually switch out magazines on my home defense pistol every month. I also have 8 (I think) magazines so 1 magazine won't see ammo for a long time. To play it safe, switch out your magazine every so often and if when loading a new one it feels a little weeker than the rest, mark it as "range only" and buy a new one. As a matter of fact, buy a whole bunch.

Minimuns:

 

P220St - 4 mags @ 7-8 rounds each. Like the 7 rounders better.

P226ST - 4 mags @ 15 rounds each.

 

Multiple mags really helpful for range work.

 

Woild I turn down more if someone gave them to me? No, but not necessaary.

 

And only get good ones - factory or Mec-Gar

Well, that's a tricky one. How long do you keep the magazine loaded? And do you switch out magazines every so often? I usually switch out magazines on my home defense pistol every month. I also have 8 (I think) magazines so 1 magazine won't see ammo for a long time. To play it safe, switch out your magazine every so often and if when loading a new one it feels a little weeker than the rest, mark it as "range only" and buy a new one. As a matter of fact, buy a whole bunch.

 

 

I have been told that keeping a magazine loading will not make it wear out and/or become unreliable, however I must conceed that I did not take the extra step of doing the research to confirm the advice was accurate.

 

The long & short of what I was told is that springs wear out due to use. That is, the process of being compacted, then extended, then compacted again. In theory, an unused spring left in a compacted state should actually show even less wear & tear than magazines rotated in and out of regular use. At minimum, there wouldn't be a reason for them to wear out quicker by being stored in a compacted state. The exception might be if the spring is compacted beyond it's intended range(overloaded mag).

 

The example he provided to me was shocks on a car. The weight of a car puts constant tension on the shocks, even when sitting, but most people will agree that the life of shocks seems to vary considerably and cars driven more often usually need replacements sooner than cars that are seldom used.

I have two Glock 19 magazines that came with my Gen 1. They are old, and have been fully loaded for a while. The previous owner was a Port Authority cop and was carried with a 14 or 15 rounds in the magazines all the time. The springs don't feel as stiff as my other magazines so they don't get used in any type of real jobs. But they get droped and droped and droped at the range and they've never faultered.

I have been told that keeping a magazine loading will not make it wear out and/or become unreliable

 

A compressed spring does not wear out. A spring wears out as it is compressed and relaxed. I.E. You are doing more damage loading and unloading than just loading an HD mag and leaving it.

 

Go to a junk yard, look at the old cars that have been sitting there for 40 years. They're still sprung just fine.

A compressed spring does not wear out. A spring wears out as it is compressed and relaxed. I.E. You are doing more damage loading and unloading than just loading an HD mag and leaving it.

 

Go to a junk yard, look at the old cars that have been sitting there for 40 years. They're still sprung just fine.

 

+1

The only way to wear out a spring in this situation is either continued use or over compressing it. No matter how long a spring is in a certain position...if its within it's elasticity it will not degrade much at all.

So it would seem I got accurate advice. Good to know. Just leaving two dedicated HD mags loaded & out of my range use rotation may be the way to go.

Thanks for all the great input here. Love this place.

+1 on the mag spring advice. I typically get a new mag, load it fully, and let it sit for a week in order to loosen up the tight springs. Hk mags were not that bad, but Glock mags, xd mags and wilson 1911 mags came with such strong springs, it was nearly impossible to load it completely by hand, or to seat the mag on a closed slide.

I think I have 10 mags for my Glock, 2 for the .22 conversion for it, and a few for the other pistol I have. For me, sidearms are just that. I realize it is the weapon I am most likely to need to use. Therefore the weapons I train with the most. But that is outside my house when I don't expect trouble. Or inside my house at the rare moments I don't have a rifle, shotgun, or SMG within arm's reach.

 

In other words, if I perceive some sort of threat, I will have a more formidable weapon on my person inside or outside my home.

 

I do want to pick up some of the $6 Korean Glock mags for training. I've banged some of mine around quite a bit and replace them every couple of years at great expense with the real thing.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.