Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

High court denies man's gun arrest appeal

Featured Replies

Sigh. I was hoping someone would spank the PA police and any other dipshit involved in the Revell Case.

 

-----------

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5js35SIPSnT-zZ-3D-7BTM8IM6l2w?docId=30eeaafa8e0b4018aaef26112b7251fd

 

High court denies man's gun arrest appeal

 

(AP) – 9 hours ago

 

WASHINGTON (AP) — Missing a plane connection cost Utah gun owner Greg Revell 10 days in jail after he was stranded in New Jersey with an unloaded firearm he had legally checked with his luggage in Salt Lake City.

 

Nevertheless, the Supreme Court without comment refused on Tuesday to let Revell sue Port Authority of New York and New Jersey police for arresting him on illegal possession of a firearm in New Jersey and for not returning his gun and ammunition to him for more than three years.

 

Revell was flying from Salt Lake City to Allentown, Pa., on March 31, 2005, with connections in Minneapolis and Newark, N.J. He had checked his Utah-licensed gun and ammunition with his luggage in Salt Lake City and asked airport officials to deliver them both with his luggage in Allentown.

 

But the flight from Minneapolis to Newark was late, so Revell missed his connection to Allentown. The airline wanted to bus its passengers to Allentown, but Revell realized that his luggage had not made it onto the bus and got off. After finding his luggage had been given a final destination of Newark by mistake, Revell missed the bus. He collected his luggage, including his gun and ammunition, and decided to wait in a nearby hotel with his stuff until the next flight in the morning.

 

When Revell tried to check in for the morning flight, he again informed the airline officials about his gun and ammunition to have them checked through to Allentown. He was reported to the TSA, and then arrested by Port Authority police for having a gun in New Jersey without a New Jersey license.

 

He spent 10 days in several different jails before posting bail. Police dropped the charges a few months later. But his gun and ammunition were not returned to him until 2008.

 

Revell said he should not have been arrested because federal law allows licensed gun owners to take their weapons through any state as long as they are unloaded and not readily accessible to people. He said it was not his fault the airline stranded him in New Jersey by making him miss his flight and routing his luggage to the wrong destination.

 

Prosecutors said it doesn't matter whose fault it was: Revell was arrested in New Jersey with a readily accessible gun in his possession without a New Jersey license.

 

Lower courts have sympathized with Revell but refused to let him sue the police.

 

"We recognize that he had been placed in a difficult situation through no fault of his own," wrote Judge Kent A. Jordan of the U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia. However, the law "clearly requires the traveler to part ways with his weapon and ammunition during travel; it does not address this type of interrupted journey or what the traveler is to do in this situation."

 

The case is Revell v. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, 10-236.

  • Author

For that it's worth.

 

Revell was arrested in New Jersey with a readily accessible gun in his possession without a New Jersey license

 

This is the part that I go back to when I say that it doesn't matter what FOPA may allow you to do, NJ can still jack you up. "Legal at source, legal at destination" is all well and good but if you are not transporting according to NJ statutes, they can charge you. This is why you should never admit to guns in the car unless directly asked(don't lie) and you should always know which range you're going to in PA. "To CCW" is not a legal reason in NJ. "To Range 8 to target practice" is a legal reason. Once you're across the border, feel free to change your mind and skip the range session.

This guy had the charges dropped. I can't believe he tried to sue. He doesn't get he was very lucky. People think their freedoms hold any water in this toilet state get jammed up.

This guy had the charges dropped. I can't believe he tried to sue. He doesn't get he was very lucky. People think their freedoms hold any water in this toilet state get jammed up.

 

Although I agree he is indeed very lucky, why shouldn't he sue? NJ: Oh I know we didn't have a right to deprive you of your rights but hey, your off the hook now, you're actually very lucky you know? We could have done worse.

 

My friend brought up a really good point.

 

We are all/most of the same mindset as to the intent of the 2nd amendment. That the government is suppose to be for the People by the People. However after reading this latest story, my friend ask a good question. What is the point of us having these guns, if we are constantly willing to have our rights deprived? He was in the air force and did a tour or two in Iraq, so fighting for your rights hits hard with him I guess. But it seems we keep getting crapped on more and more and short of them coming to take our guns, we do nothing. My question is, what can we do?

This is the part that I go back to when I say that it doesn't matter what FOPA may allow you to do, NJ can still jack you up.

 

 

Yup.

Your not allowed to check a gun with your luggagein at a Airport in NJ?

This decision was simply wrong. It affirms the states boldness to trample on the rights of individuals and to hide behind "the law" where common sense would dictate this situation was clearly wrong and never considered in the statute. They get to continue to do this because there is no penalty to the state for being wrong, only the individual citizen. In other words its like the state locking up a heart patient because Nitro Glycerine is illegal as an explosive in NJ and telling him, "you may have reason but its illegal" He dies without his meds and they tell the family you cant sue! Why would the state ever care who they F over if theres never a penalty for it!

This decision was simply wrong. It affirms the states boldness to trample on the rights of individuals and to hide behind "the law" where common sense would dictate this situation was clearly wrong and never considered in the statute. They get to continue to do this because there is no penalty to the state for being wrong, only the individual citizen. In other words its like the state locking up a heart patient because Nitro Glycerine is illegal as an explosive in NJ and telling him, "you may have reason but its illegal" He dies without his meds and they tell the family you cant sue! Why would the state ever care who they F over if theres never a penalty for it!

Even more upsetting is that the Feds said no to the lawsuit, when they have laws and regulations to prevent this from happening. They should pay up for sending this guy to jail for 10 days. They would probably pay more attention to who they arrest and why if they got in trouble when they screwed up and had to pay out for it. And again, if the charges were dropped, what possible excuse can they have to keep the firearm for 3 years, im sure he fought for it too, had he not, he probably never would have seen it again. That's what i call robbery.

You have to allow a suit for unlawful arrest, or else how else can you insure the govt wont keep jailing people for no reason.

"Prosecutors said it doesn't matter whose fault it was: Revell was arrested in New Jersey with a readily accessible gun in his possession without a New Jersey license."

 

He took the guns to a motel room and returned to the airport the next day. He did not posess a NJ FID card. He should have gotten arrested which he was.

  • Author

"Prosecutors said it doesn't matter whose fault it was: Revell was arrested in New Jersey with a readily accessible gun in his possession without a New Jersey license."

 

He took the guns to a motel room and returned to the airport the next day. He did not posess a NJ FID card. He should have gotten arrested which he was.

 

A New Jersey Firearms Purchaser ID does not grant any legal status to handguns. He could have had one, the charges would have been identical.

 

The license he was missing was a license to carry. Even had he had the forethought to attempt to get a license, he would have been denied.

 

He was legally covered under FOPA, he was in transit from Utah to PA. Unforeseen circumstances landed him in NJ temporarily. This was a travesty of justice.

[q]Notwithstanding any other provision of any law or any rule or regulation of a State or any political subdivision thereof, any person who is not otherwise prohibited by this chapter from transporting, shipping, or receiving a firearm shall be entitled to transport a firearm for any lawful purpose from any place where he may lawfully possess and carry such firearm to any other place where he may lawfully possess and carry such firearm if, during such transportation the firearm is unloaded, and neither the firearm nor any ammunition being transported is readily accessible or is directly accessible from the passenger compartment of such transporting vehicle: Provided, That in the case of a vehicle without a compartment separate from the driver’s compartment the firearm or ammunition shall be contained in a locked container other than the glove compartment or console.[/q]

 

With regard to Revell, Revell has possession of gun in airport before he checks it in. Even if Revell followed the court's advice and took the gun to a local police station to store overnight, he still needs to take direct possession of the gun to take it from his car's trunk to the airport. I don't see how it's possible to follow FOPA and use commercial air travel. FOPA doesn't allow flexibility for air travel.

A New Jersey Firearms Purchaser ID does not grant any legal status to handguns. He could have had one, the charges would have been identical.

 

The license he was missing was a license to carry. Even had he had the forethought to attempt to get a license, he would have been denied.

 

He was legally covered under FOPA, he was in transit from Utah to PA. Unforeseen circumstances landed him in NJ temporarily. This was a travesty of justice.

 

Sorry but unless you are a judge in the 3rd circuit and can apply the law to the charge you are just an arm chair quarterback blowing wind as I am. The court applied the law correctly. FOPA did not apply in this case because he was not passing through the state. He took the gun from the airport to the motel and returned to the airport the next day. What was missing was the knowledge of gun laws in the state of NJ by the traveler. If you are stupid enough to travel with a gun in an airport without the necessary state license.

Furthermore, FOPA is too vague in this case to sue the police for damages. We can't create a situation where the police are afraid to act in borderline situations because that they might get sued. The police need to be able to do the job they are paid to do. They can't be expected to know every law and its nuances.

The police need to be able to do the job they are paid to do. They can't be expected to know every law and its nuances.

 

We, as citizens, are expected to know and follow every law and it's nuances.. Ignorance of the law is not an excuse, why should it be for LEOs?

I never wrote ignorance of the law is an excuse. I'm saying that if there is doubt to the law or its interpretation, LEO can make the arrest then the court system goes into motion to do its thing. Clearly, in the Revell case, the firearm being transported was readily accessible or was directly accessible from the passenger compartment of such transporting vehicle. This gave cause for the officer to make the arrest. Why should the officer be sued for doing his job?

Furthermore, FOPA is too vague in this case to sue the police for damages. We can't create a situation where the police are afraid to act in borderline situations because that they might get sued. The police need to be able to do the job they are paid to do. They can't be expected to know every law and its nuances.

 

Which was the meat of the problem. This wasn't a criminal case with Revell as the defendant - the charges were dropped and he never saw court on them. This was Revell suing the police officers and PANYNJ for violation of his civil rights, and damages for doing so. FOPA kept him out of jail, very likely.

 

Which sucks - but until Congress clarifies the law, the behavior of the PA police and Newark prosecutor is not clearly illegal - which was the threshold for damages.

  • Author

Furthermore, FOPA is too vague in this case to sue the police for damages. We can't create a situation where the police are afraid to act in borderline situations because that they might get sued. The police need to be able to do the job they are paid to do. They can't be expected to know every law and its nuances.

 

Invert your logic. If we can't create a situation where the police are afraid to act in borderline situations, you've created a police state where police can act with impunity because they don't fear any repercussions.

 

Revel was not a criminal. Someone with some authority should have examined this entire situation and pushed this man on his way. Instead, someone saw a political fortune or something else here to be gained and went after him. This is not why we have police. The public's interest was not served in this case.

  • Author

FOPA did not apply in this case because he was not passing through the state.

 

So he was a resident? He was planning on staying and sightseeing? I was hung up in Hong Kong after typhoons shut down the region. The airline put me up for a night in the hotel. By your logic, I wasn't traveling. I was, uhm, doing what then? Oh, right, I was still in transit but detained at one location longer than originally planned.

So he was a resident? He was planning on staying and sightseeing? I was hung up in Hong Kong after typhoons shut down the region. The airline put me up for a night in the hotel. By your logic, I wasn't traveling. I was, uhm, doing what then? Oh, right, I was still in transit but detained at one location longer than originally planned.

 

I agree with you.. he absolutely was traveling.. and even by goofy NJ laws he did not make any stops that were not reasonably needed.. he was stuck here.. because of something totally beyond his control.. the police had no right to even be involved.. he was passing through.. and since he is not a pilot.. with a plane.. when he was delayed.. it was only reasonable that he stay...

We, as citizens, are expected to know and follow every law and it's nuances.. Ignorance of the law is not an excuse, why should it be for LEOs?

 

The courts have already stated that cops are not required to interpret the laws. Only inforce them.

Sig2009, it troubles me that you think this guy did ANYTHING to contribute to his own issue. Your statement is along the lines of those that have "zero tolerence policies". I equate those to zero thinking policies. Dont make us think because we are beurocratically incabable of it. Or would have to accept some sort of responsibility and we cant have that! Malsua is 100% correct. An examination of the case, a realization of circumstance and lack of intent, and send him on his way intact. The lawsuit should be alowed without question! Making the state imune from its actions has a far greater reaching potential. Some of you need to wake up and understand that its clearly a habit of this state to bank on the fact most people dont have the descretionary income to even defend themselves properly. They count on it! So when someone does have the means to not have their rights trampled, its paramount that it be allowed. In the end it helps protect all of us.

Sig2009, it troubles me that you think this guy did ANYTHING to contribute to his own issue. Your statement is along the lines of those that have "zero tolerence policies". I equate those to zero thinking policies. Dont make us think because we are beurocratically incabable of it. Or would have to accept some sort of responsibility and we cant have that! Malsua is 100% correct. An examination of the case, a realization of circumstance and lack of intent, and send him on his way intact. The lawsuit should be alowed without question! Making the state imune from its actions has a far greater reaching potential. Some of you need to wake up and understand that its clearly a habit of this state to bank on the fact most people dont have the descretionary income to even defend themselves properly. They count on it! So when someone does have the means to not have their rights trampled, its paramount that it be allowed. In the end it helps protect all of us.

Sig2009, it troubles me that you think this guy did ANYTHING to contribute to his own issue. Your statement is along the lines of those that have "zero tolerence policies". I equate those to zero thinking policies. Dont make us think because we are beurocratically incabable of it. Or would have to accept some sort of responsibility and we cant have that! Malsua is 100% correct. An examination of the case, a realization of circumstance and lack of intent, and send him on his way intact. The lawsuit should be alowed without question! Making the state imune from its actions has a far greater reaching potential. Some of you need to wake up and understand that its clearly a habit of this state to bank on the fact most people dont have the descretionary income to even defend themselves properly. They count on it! So when someone does have the means to not have their rights trampled, its paramount that it be allowed. In the end it helps protect all of us.

 

Let me put this in terms that you can understand again.

"The courts have already stated that cops are not required to interpret the laws. Only inforce them." If you disagree with the law change it! Or better yet let the NRA finally spend some money in this state. They seem to like to take money from NJ residents and use it somewhere else. Don't forget we live in a communist state and being that our rights are trampled every day. CCW and and other pro gun laws will not change in this state until all the crooked politicians and judges are removed. So unless you have some magic potion to remove these people it will be business as usual.

Are you that naive to think that a DA wasnt called before he was indicted?

From Ohio Law website:

 

Revell's possession of the firearm in New Jersey was not his fault. That's why the New Jersey prosecutors wisely and fairly dismissed the criminal charges against him. On the other hand, 926A of FOPA doesn't really apply. Revell was not travelling in a vehicle when he was at the hotel or the airport. More seriously, the weapon and ammunition were "readily accessible" to Revell while he was at the hotel in Newark.

Sorry but unless you are a judge in the 3rd circuit and can apply the law to the charge you are just an arm chair quarterback blowing wind as I am. The court applied the law correctly. FOPA did not apply in this case because he was not passing through the state. He took the gun from the airport to the motel and returned to the airport the next day. What was missing was the knowledge of gun laws in the state of NJ by the traveler. If you are stupid enough to travel with a gun in an airport without the necessary state license.

 

U do not need a license in NJ to own a gun or transport one (locked in trunk of car) in NJ.

U do not need a license in NJ to own a gun or transport one (locked in trunk of car) in NJ.

 

Actually, your statement is wrong. According to 2C:39-5, you need a permit to carry to possess a gun in NJ. 2C:39-6 lists affirmative defenses that can be used in court, but since all of those apply to a place of business, or a residence, none of those exemptions would apply to Revell, making his possession of a handgun illegal under NJ law.

 

This guy had no way to legally possess a handgun in NJ. The second he claimed his bags he was in violation of state law, and had he notified the police at that time, they would have arrested him right there under the same charge. We officially have some of the dumbest laws in the country that clearly have no crime fighting/preventing purpose, but that exist solely to ensnare people who are trying to follow the law and to discourage others from engaging in what should be a legal activity.

This came up in another thread a few weeks ago. What is the exemption that allows us to drive to Newark Airport and check a firearm in to fly. I did it in Sep, TSA just checked that the gun was unloaded and locked in a case. They did not even know I was a NJ resident. They didn't ask me for ID, only the gate agent did. You can show a passport for ID, it doesn't show you are a resident of NJ or any other state.

 

Why would this guy get hassled and didn't? What makes it legal for me to do? FOPA? FOPA doesn't cover me driving to Newark, just driving out of the state.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.