Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Kimber to Wilson like Nissan to infinity?

Featured Replies

End of discussion right there.

 

DevsAdvocate, I'm not trying to be a jerk but sometimes the truth can cause a lot of butthurt, especially on the errornet. I'm sure you love your Kimber Custom, but you are sorely mistaken about the number of MIM parts in it. Taken from a thread specifically relating to the Custom, here is the list:

 

 

 

I'll take hand-fitted, forged parts over Metal-Injection-Molded any day.

 

Great, and you'll pay out the whazoo for it and you'll love it every day. The questions still remain:

-What's the difference in failure rate?

-What's the price-point to the consumer for those parts?

 

Why is a $900 Kimber with some MIM parts treated as a piece of trash (by some here and other places), but a similar 1911 at a similar price from another manufacturer (Springfield Armory) gets a pass?

 

Is it the typical internet armchair word of mouth? Or is it something that actually has some evidence to back it up? I get it, we all want to justify paying money for what we want... whether it's a BCM AR-15 over a DPMS or a Remington over a Mossberg. I even understand that Kimber FUBARed their attempt at an external extractor (I know, mine used to have one).

 

Quotes like "I wouldn't take a Kimber with a $1 strapped to it" reek of stupidity. Really? You wouldn't take a $900 gun with a $1 strapped to it?

Great, and you'll pay out the whazoo for it and you'll love it every day. The questions still remain:

-What's the difference in failure rate?

-What's the price-point to the consumer for those parts?

 

Why is a $900 Kimber with some MIM parts treated as a piece of trash (by some here and other places), but a similar 1911 at a similar price from another manufacturer (Springfield Armory) gets a pass?

 

Is it the typical internet armchair word of mouth? Or is it something that actually has some evidence to back it up? I get it, we all want to justify paying money for what we want... whether it's a BCM AR-15 over a DPMS or a Remington over a Mossberg. I even understand that Kimber FUBARed their attempt at an external extractor (I know, mine used to have one).

 

Quotes like "I wouldn't take a Kimber with a $1 strapped to it" reek of stupidity. Really? You wouldn't take a $900 gun with a $1 strapped to it?

 

Look, this isn't my fight, I personally don't have a dog in it. I made a statement, backed it up, blew a gigantic hole in your "I looked at my gun and didn't see any MIM in it" argument, and then listed MIM parts failures per your request. Cost cutting by replacing forged parts with MIM parts has not been met with a lot of love in the gun community.

 

Look up Ron Cohen. He's pretty much the source of much of this internet hate.

 

I don't have anything against Kimbers and I don't give two craps about armchair internet commando's. I can tell you that I've fired a Kimber and a Wilson and the Wilson felt a thousand dollars better.

 

Have MIM Parts failed?? Taken from a thread where gunsmiths discuss MIM parts in 1911's (and the offending broken parts in a Kimber Custom were replaced with Wilson parts :sarcastichand: ).

 

Without round counts, those comments are meaningless.

 

You do realize that MEU(SOC) runs 3-4 guns per Marine because given the volume of shooting that they do with their 1911s, stuff tends to break often. And they tend to use... ya know, high quality components and hand fitting.

 

It's not a matter of 'if' it fails, but 'when'.

 

MIM Extractors- the breakage I'v seen on these was at the Claw and the knuckle.

I've replaced two non MIM extractors because of breakage. In one of the guns the guy that owned it was dropping the slide on a round in the chamber. I don't know how many times he had done this, but to his best recollection it was several and he finally broke the claw on his extractor.

The other extractor was in a racegun that I was told had over 80,000 rounds fired thru it. The top corner of the claw was chipped off but the gun was still extracting.

 

Is 80,000 acceptable? At what price point? That's the question. Even then, many of these parts STILL functioned.

Why is a $900 Kimber with some MIM parts treated as a piece of trash (by some here and other places), but a similar 1911 at a similar price from another manufacturer (Springfield Armory) gets a pass?

 

Quotes like "I wouldn't take a Kimber with a $1 strapped to it" reek of stupidity. Really? You wouldn't take a $900 gun with a $1 strapped to it?

 

Maybe it is the sheer number of MIM parts on a Kimber and that they are critical parts like sear and disconnectors. I could live with a MIM mag catch or safety (i.e. parts that don't always have major stresses on them when shooting).

 

I agree that the quote is stupid. I would take the Kimber so I could sell it and buy something else.

Maybe it is the number of MIM parts on a Kimber and that they are critical parts like sear and disconnectors. I could live with a MIM slide release or safety.

 

I agree that the quote is stupid. I would take the Kimber so I could sell it and buy something else.

 

But doesn't SA use similar parts at a similar price point? Don't other manufacturers? Or is Kimber the only $800-1000 1911 with MIM?

 

It also goes back to the issue of round counts and failures. What does one reasonably expect out of a $4000 1911 versus a $800 one?

Here is a list of MIM parts for standard models of:

 

Colt:

http://forums.1911fo...ead.php?t=15201

 

Springfield Armory:

http://forums.1911fo...ad.php?t=256203

 

 

I think that Kimber earned their rap a few years back when they were mostly alone in their $1000-$1600 price range but were using the MIM parts when others weren't yet. I will also say that two custom gunsmiths I have spoken with do not like working on (one won't accept them) Kimbers for work because they consider their metallurgy to be inferior. I didn't get their take on SA, Para, RIA, etc though. In this category they rated the semi-customs, Colt and imported Norinco 1911's the highest. These brands make for the best platform for truly custom work.

I recall back in the 90's, Bill Wilson was using Norinco 1911's for some of his custom builds. I believe only the frame and slide were kept.

Here is a list of MIM parts for standard models of:

 

Colt:

http://forums.1911fo...ead.php?t=15201

 

Springfield Armory:

http://forums.1911fo...ad.php?t=256203

 

I think that Kimber earned their rap a few years back when they were mostly alone in their $1000-$1600 price range but were using the MIM parts when others weren't yet. I will also say that two custom gunsmiths I have spoken with do not like working on (one won't accept them) Kimbers for work because they consider their metallurgy to be inferior. I didn't get their take on SA, Para, RIA, etc though. In this category they rated the semi-customs, Colt and imported Norinco 1911's the highest. These brands make for the best platform for truly custom work.

 

This kinda makes sense... but I don't know if it's due to one metal being cheaper than another. More likely, it has to do with metal being easier to machine and tool by hand. Softer steels are easier to remove material from and smooth and hence bring to closer tolerances. I expect most custom smiths to be working with their hands with *some* machining. But then again: what do I know? Shane45 probably has a lot to say on this topic. I used to have a good background in metallurgy and MIM back in the day... it's been awhile though.

I recall back in the 90's, Bill Wilson was using Norinco 1911's for some of his custom builds. I believe only the frame and slide were kept.

 

RIA parts are used in a similar manner... It's one of the reasons folks flock to places like SARCOS

RIA parts are used in a similar manner... It's one of the reasons folks flock to places like SARCOS

 

Yup, that's were I got mine. I overpaid... as the store price was "different" from their AD. But got a good deal on the extra mags.

 

I didn't have any issues with the original parts but replaced the trigger, sear and hammer with STI parts.

I've disassembled my Kimber Custom, and I haven't noticed any MIM parts in it. Where is the evidence of this?

 

They are definitely in there, don't kid yourself. Short of buying a custom SVI, I don't think ANY manufacturer has zero MIM parts anymore.

 

 

Looks to me from those links that Kimber uses MIM parts in the same manner as most 1911 manufacturers do... SA, DW, etc. Not to mention the breadth and depth of the misinformation out there on the subject (aka MIM = bad).

 

There is a reason MIM has made it big in the firearms world, and it's not just because it's cheap. It's also easier to produce to a given tolerance to reduce the amount of machining and polishing (both are time and skill intensive processes). Is it worth the extra money to get hand-machined parts? Yeah, probably... maybe if you shoot 10,000+ rounds a year.

 

Now the question is: have MIM parts in any 1911 failed?

 

The argument here isn't so much if someone wants to spend, but to justify the cost of a brand/type of 1911. Would you spend $850 on a Taurus PT1911? Probably not... but a Kimber? Yeah.

 

 

Yes, MIM parts have definitely failed.

 

MIM parts have failed specifically due to issues caused by them being MIM parts even.

 

MIM is cheap and makes putting more detail into a mold worthwhile becuase molds last longer. Delicate molds last a LOT longer than traditional casting. MIM CAN be good, but inherent to the process is a greater chance of flaws in the metal. MIM without good QC can be a real problem because of that. I've got plenty of mim parts in guns I shoot a lot. I also have an M&P that is on striker revision 4 of at least 5 so far that is due to S&W trying to figure out how to use a MIM part where it is not appropriate. I've stopped keeping track, and just keep spares around.

 

MIM parts are not why Kimbers suck these days. Their series 80 safeties are just wrong. Their quality of fit and finish, and QC have gone down hill a lot.

 

AS for whose gun to buy? I dunno. Myt ake on it is aby a decent frame/slide kit and send it to a decent gunsmith if your budget is in the near $2000 range (i.e. wilson nighthawk terrtory). I've done it with some more complicated slide cuts, and gunsmithing was about $900. The box of parts for a 2011 was about $1500. My box of parts for a 1911 kit I built myself was about $900.

They are definitely in there, don't kid yourself. Short of buying a custom SVI, I don't think ANY manufacturer has zero MIM parts anymore.

 

 

 

 

 

Yes, MIM parts have definitely failed.

 

MIM parts have failed specifically due to issues caused by them being MIM parts even.

 

MIM is cheap and makes putting more detail into a mold worthwhile becuase molds last longer. Delicate molds last a LOT longer than traditional casting. MIM CAN be good, but inherent to the process is a greater chance of flaws in the metal. MIM without good QC can be a real problem because of that. I've got plenty of mim parts in guns I shoot a lot. I also have an M&P that is on striker revision 4 of at least 5 so far that is due to S&W trying to figure out how to use a MIM part where it is not appropriate. I've stopped keeping track, and just keep spares around.

 

MIM parts are not why Kimbers suck these days. Their series 80 safeties are just wrong. Their quality of fit and finish, and QC have gone down hill a lot.

 

AS for whose gun to buy? I dunno. Myt ake on it is aby a decent frame/slide kit and send it to a decent gunsmith if your budget is in the near $2000 range (i.e. wilson nighthawk terrtory). I've done it with some more complicated slide cuts, and gunsmithing was about $900. The box of parts for a 2011 was about $1500. My box of parts for a 1911 kit I built myself was about $900.

 

I'll agree with this. Especially at the end... 1911s are a matter of what you want to pay for and their intended use. I've decided long ago that they are more 'fun' and 'competition' guns than ones for HD. It's an old design, one with some manufacturing issues that makes it tough to be both smooth, accurate, and reliable while still being cheap to make.

 

Modern guns (Glock, XD, M&P, H&K) were designed from the ground up to be mass produced with CnC machines and almost 0 human polishing. 1911s can be loose and reliable, but suffer (in my mind, an almost indiscernible) loss in accuracy, or tight and hand-fitted to be ultra-accurate with the smoothest trigger ever.

 

The sky's the limit on a 1911, especially in terms of how much you want to spend.

 

Also, series 80 safeties in Kimbers are pretty much the only legit beef (outside of the external extractor fiasco) that I can understand with them.

MIM parts are not why Kimbers suck these days. Their series 80 safeties are just wrong. Their quality of fit and finish, and QC have gone down hill a lot.

 

 

Not going into the whole MIM thing other than to say there is good MIM and there is bad MIM. I also can't comment on Kimber's QC as I have no first-hand knowledge.

 

I will say that I agree about their firing pin safety, but have to point out that it is NOT like the Colt series 80 firing pin safety.

 

Colt's system requires that the trigger be pulled in order for the firing pin block to be lifted and allow total forward movement of the firing pin. It is a true third safety (manual safety, grip safety and FP safety). Kimber's firing pin block is lifted (deactivated) when the grip safety is depressed, which means, in essence, you still only have two safeties.

 

Both these systems are giving way to the titanium firing pin/heavier firing pin spring system, which makes getting a good trigger pull much easier.

 

In all these discussions about which 1911 platform to buy, I seldom hear anyone bring-up Sig. With the exception of the very early guns, which were problematic, I've heard a lot of good and very little bad about the Sig 1911's, and they are very price competitive with the likes of S/A, S&W and Kimber.

 

Just my $.02 worth.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

The whole Series 80 FPS issue was annoying. Thankfully, Colt makes two Series 70 1911 models (the 1918 and the Series 70 Repro). I went with the repro and have been happy. The front site blade is too thick and the gun has the standard crappy rear blade sights, but other than that it has been a pleasure.

That is just silly to think that Kimber's are the same as Ed Brown or Wilson.

 

I own a kimber and their QC is no where near that of the two I mentioned. The KImber mags are the worst also. Cust service from Kimber is so so also. I would choose a Sig 1911 over a KImber.

That is just silly to think that Kimber's are the same as Ed Brown or Wilson.

 

I own a kimber and their QC is no where near that of the two I mentioned. The KImber mags are the worst also. Cust service from Kimber is so so also. I would choose a Sig 1911 over a KImber.

 

Well of course... :icon_rolleyes:

 

A $950 isn't going to be as sexed up by a gunsmith as a $2000-4000 one. For the price, Kimber makes decent hardware... I would never pay MSRP on it (I mean, who would pay MSRP on anything??), but it's still a solid gun for what you pay for.

 

As for QC or CS, YMMV. I had a good experience with them (replaced a whole slide to give me an internal extractor versus an external one free of charge.)

As it was explained to me by a 1911 aficionado and fellow forum member:

 

The semi customs, Ed Brown, Wilson, Nighthawk, Les Baer etc have a lot of man hours of polishing and hand fitting. And that amount of time translates to a more expensive handgun.

 

To some people this finer fit and finish, the increased accuracy and an overall more reliable handgun are important and worth the extra cost.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.