Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

12GA vs 20GA slug gun for deer? Single Shot or Pump/Semi?

Featured Replies

Going to be looking for a slug gun for hunting deer in the near future. Is a 20 gauge slug gun preferrable over a 12 gauge, due to the heavy recoil of the 12GA? I have never fired a slug through a 12GA so don't know what the recoil is like, but from reading stuff on the interwebs... it sounds like it's a b*tch to shoot.

 

Also, are single shot slug guns good vs. pumps/semi's? I would think that you probably won't get a chance to squeeze off a 2nd shot if you miss, anyway... so why the need for pumps/semi's? If the first shot is a miss, then I'm sure the deer will be long gone before a 2nd shot is even possible. The H&R single shot slug guns look pretty nice, and are very reasonably priced... Anyone know anything about them?

 

Any advice from some of you seasoned deer hunters would be appreciated. I've hunted for a good portion of my life, but always small game... this coming season will be my first time huting deer and really looking forward to it!

 

Mod's... this post is kind of 50/50 and could go either into the shotgun or hunting forum... if it needs to be move into the hunting forum, please let me know.

I'll leave it here for now.

 

If you can handle the recoil of a 12ga, get a 12ga. Even with slugs, a 12ga offers better trajectory than the 20ga, and packs a much bigger punch. Single shot and bolt action guns are typically the most accurate, and personally I own an H&R USH in 12ga. That gun replaced my 870 w/ rifled bbl.

 

I have fired at a deer in a small herd before, and had time to rack the slide and watch the deer drop through my scope(15-20 seconds) and by the time I put the gun down, the other deer in the herd were still dancing around, not sure where to run.

 

Buckshot is also a very viable option for NJ, and most shotguns are capable of a deer-killing pattern out to 50-60yds. The location you intend to hunt should be the deciding factor between slugs/buckshot.

 

The choice between a pump/semi and the single shot would also depend on the distance you plan on shooting. One of the guys I hunt with routinely kills deer out past 200yds with his USH. If you're comfortable staying at 100yds and closer, whatever you feel most comfortable shooting will do.

I'll leave it here for now.

 

If you can handle the recoil of a 12ga, get a 12ga. Even with slugs, a 12ga offers better trajectory than the 20ga,not sure about that! and packs a much bigger punch. Single shot and bolt action guns are typically the most accurateTRUE, and personally I own an H&R USH in 12ga. That gun replaced my 870 w/ rifled bbl.

 

I have fired at a deer in a small herd before, and had time to rack the slide and watch the deer drop through my scope(15-20 seconds) and by the time I put the gun down, the other deer in the herd were still dancing around, not sure where to run.

 

Buckshot is also a very viable option for NJ, and most shotguns are capable of a deer-killing pattern out to 50-60yds. The location you intend to hunt should be the deciding factor between slugs/buckshot.VERY VERY TRUE![/b]

 

The choice between a pump/semi and the single shot would also depend on the distance you plan on shooting. One of the guys I hunt with routinely kills deer out past 200ydsOMG :hunter: with his USH. If you're comfortable staying at 100yds and closer, whatever you feel most comfortable shooting will do.

 

 

Jon you know I love you BUT....

Jon you know I love you BUT....

 

:icon_lol: I was waiting for your response.

 

In reference to the 20ga vs 12ga, a Federal 5/8oz 20ga slug moves at 1900fps and has 2190ft-lbs of energy. A Federal 3/4oz 12ga slug moves at the same speed, but hits with 2605ft-lbs of energy. Being they shoot at the same speed, the tiny difference in bullet coefficient will change the trajectory by less than the expected precision of the gun.

 

As for the guy I shoot with, I have personally seen him drop a dozen deer, all one shot kills, and missed only once. Half those deer were 150yds+. Can I do that? Hell no, but he can and does.

:icon_lol: I was waiting for your response.

 

In reference to the 20ga vs 12ga, a Federal 5/8oz 20ga slug moves at 1900fps and has 2190ft-lbs of energy. A Federal 3/4oz 12ga slug moves at the same speed, but hits with 2605ft-lbs of energy. Being they shoot at the same speed, the tiny difference in bullet coefficient will change the trajectory by less than the expected precision of the gun.

 

As for the guy I shoot with, I have personally seen him drop a dozen deer, all one shot kills, and missed only once. Half those deer were 150yds+. Can I do that? Hell no, but he can and does.

 

 

You know me too well... You know last year I shot buck for a few days.

You know me too well... You know last year I shot buck for a few days.

 

I carried buckshot a few days as well, didn't see squat while I had it with me though.

jon you need a new place to hunt dude.

 

You need some private property to hunt on, makes being in the cold that much more enjoyable lol

jon you need a new place to hunt dude.

 

You need some private property to hunt on, makes being in the cold that much more enjoyable lol

 

Meh, I did some private property hunting this year, and switched between the slug gun and scattergun throughout the day. Lots of fun, but something I'm only going to do if I strike out on public land.

  • Author

Meh, I did some private property hunting this year, and switched between the slug gun and scattergun throughout the day. Lots of fun, but something I'm only going to do if I strike out on public land.

 

Talking about public land... Do you guys know if Round Valley Reservoir is considered public hunting land, during deer hunting season? I only ask because I live right by there, and I've seen tons of deer while hiking there.

Talking about public land... Do you guys know if Round Valley Reservoir is considered public hunting land, during deer hunting season? I only ask because I live right by there, and I've seens tons of deer while hiking there.

 

To my knowledge deer hunting is not permitted there. Waterfowel hunting is permitted only from a boat. Clinton WMA is legal for deer hunting, though.

I believe any state late is huntable unless specifically noted within the digest. Best bet is to go to your local sports shop that sells hunting licenses and pick up the digest and it'll tell you.

 

OR you can attempt to navigate the NJ department of fish and wildlife website online and see if you can find any information.

 

As a side note, any Newark watershed property can be hunted on but you have to go to the watershed office and file for a separate permit that costs only a few dollars.

 

But once again, always check the digest before you do anything as that will have the most current laws at the time. They publish a new digest every year before the hunting season starts up again.

 

M

  • Author

I'll leave it here for now.

 

If you can handle the recoil of a 12ga, get a 12ga. Even with slugs, a 12ga offers better trajectory than the 20ga, and packs a much bigger punch. Single shot and bolt action guns are typically the most accurate, and personally I own an H&R USH in 12ga. That gun replaced my 870 w/ rifled bbl.

 

I have fired at a deer in a small herd before, and had time to rack the slide and watch the deer drop through my scope(15-20 seconds) and by the time I put the gun down, the other deer in the herd were still dancing around, not sure where to run.

 

Buckshot is also a very viable option for NJ, and most shotguns are capable of a deer-killing pattern out to 50-60yds. The location you intend to hunt should be the deciding factor between slugs/buckshot.

 

The choice between a pump/semi and the single shot would also depend on the distance you plan on shooting. One of the guys I hunt with routinely kills deer out past 200yds with his USH. If you're comfortable staying at 100yds and closer, whatever you feel most comfortable shooting will do.

 

I'm sure I can handle the recoil... as I'm 6'2" and 255lbs... but the question is do I want to? LOL! I own a 12GA shotgun that I've mainly shot tons of birdshot with, so that recoil isn't bad at all. How much heavier is the recoil when shooting slugs? Does it kick like a mule? Is it comparable to a 30-06 hunting rifle? I have one of those as well, and although it kicks hard.. it's not unbearable. From what I understand, the 20GA slug guns are much softer, recoil wise... but easily bring down deeer (at least that is what I've read on hunting forums). So... just trying to figure out which is best to go with.

I'm sure I can handle the recoil... as I'm 6'2" and 255lbs... but the question is do I want to? LOL! I own a 12GA shotgun that I've mainly shot tons of birdshot with, so that recoil isn't bad at all. How much heavier is the recoil when shooting slugs? Does it kick like a mule? From what I understand, the 20GA slug guns are much softer, recoil wise... but easily bring down deeer (at least that is what I've read on hunting forums). So... just trying to figure out which is best to go with.

 

I'm 5'10/170, and usually able to shoot up to 15-20 hunting slugs @ the range before I'm done. Keep in mind that's with just a t-shirt on. In the woods you'll have a heavy jacket, or at least several layers of clothing. Also, when the adrenaline starts pumping you won't feel the shot, nor will you hear it. Out of all the times I've fired slugs in the woods, not once have my ears rung, or did I ever feel any pain from the shot.

  • Author

I'm 5'10/170, and usually able to shoot up to 15-20 hunting slugs @ the range before I'm done. Keep in mind that's with just a t-shirt on. In the woods you'll have a heavy jacket, or at least several layers of clothing. Also, when the adrenaline starts pumping you won't feel the shot, nor will you hear it. Out of all the times I've fired slugs in the woods, not once have my ears rung, or did I ever feel any pain from the shot.

 

Thanks... Doesn't sound too bad. If it's comparable to my 30-06 rifle, then that's not too bad at all. Plus, you're right that the layers of clothign will further absorb some of the recoil.

 

Got another dumb newbie question... Can you use a scope on a slug gun, or are only the adjustable sights on the gun allowed by NJ hunting regulations?

I'm sure I can handle the recoil... as I'm 6'2" and 255lbs... but the question is do I want to? LOL! I own a 12GA shotgun that I've mainly shot tons of birdshot with, so that recoil isn't bad at all. How much heavier is the recoil when shooting slugs? Does it kick like a mule? Is it comparable to a 30-06 hunting rifle? I have one of those as well, and although it kicks hard.. it's not unbearable. From what I understand, the 20GA slug guns are much softer, recoil wise... but easily bring down deeer (at least that is what I've read on hunting forums). So... just trying to figure out which is best to go with.

 

 

Depends on what loads you shoot that developes the recoil. Lightfield 1 1/4oz are brutal and I developed a flinch. Hornady SST is a lighter prjectile recoils less and seem to be a little more accurate in my gun.

Thanks... Doesn't sound too bad. If it's comparable to my 30-06 rifle, then that's not too bad at all. Plus, you're right that the layers of clothign will further absorb some of the recoil.

 

Got another dumb newbie question... Can you use a scope on a slug gun, or are only the adjustable sights on the gun allowed by NJ hunting regulations?

 

Any form of adjustable sights are required when using slugs. Basically, no bead sights. Scopes are A-OK.

Also, just realized you're an SCFGPA member. Shoot me a message with your schedule for the next couple days. I need to sight in my USH with it's new ammo down in the tunnels, and you're more than welcome to fire a few shots through it.

  • Author

Any form of adjustable sights are required when using slugs. Basically, no bead sights. Scopes are A-OK.

 

Thanks j0n.

 

I've been trying to find out if my current 12GA semi-auto (Ithaca/SKB 300XL) will handle buck shot.. but can't find any info on it. It's an older gun.

Also, just realized you're an SCFGPA member. Shoot me a message with your schedule for the next couple days. I need to sight in my USH with it's new ammo down in the tunnels, and you're more than welcome to fire a few shots through it.

 

Indoors in the tunnel Jon? 12ga slug? You're rugged, man!!!

  • Author

Also, just realized you're an SCFGPA member. Shoot me a message with your schedule for the next couple days. I need to sight in my USH with it's new ammo down in the tunnels, and you're more than welcome to fire a few shots through it.

 

OK, will do. That would be great and appreciate the offer. I'm due for a range night... I'll PM you if I'm able to make it.

Thanks j0n.

 

I've been trying to find out if my current 12GA semi-auto (Ithaca/SKB 300XL) will handle buck shot.. but can't find any info on it. It's an older gun.

 

I don't see any reason why not... just stick to 2 3/4" shells(as i assume that's what it's chambered in).

Is that the long recoil gun or the gas gun? Ya have to pattern it no matter.

American Rifleman has a decent article on 20g slugs for hunting this month.

I've shot Hornady SST's in 12 ga. They're comparable to a Mosin.

 

You can get a slip on recoil pad for the butt stock too, it adds LOP to your gun (which I like).

  • Author

Is that the long recoil gun or the gas gun? Ya have to pattern it no matter.

 

Funny thing is that I don't know... I've had the gun for probably about 20 years... I bought it used but in great condition for $80 from an old guy I knew back then, but never fount out if it was gas operated. Is there any way to tell if it is? All I ever cared was that it worked well... Took plenty of small game with it over the years, and shot lots of skeet with it as well, and it has always worked like a champ.

 

Any advice on where I can look up some info on how to pattern it?

  • Author

I don't see any reason why not... just stick to 2 3/4" shells(as i assume that's what it's chambered in).

 

Yep, it's chambered for 2 3/4" shells.

Funny thing is that I don't know... I've had the gun for probably about 20 years... I bought it used but in great condition for $80 from an old guy I knew back then, but never fount out if it was gas operated. Is there any way to tell if it is? All I ever cared was that it worked well... Took plenty of small game with it over the years, and shot lots of skeet with it as well, and it has always worked like a champ.

 

Any advice on where I can look up some info on how to pattern it?

 

 

Make sure it is unloaded!! With the butt stock on the floor, push down on the muzzle. If it's spring loaded it's long recoil.

Pushing down on the barrel to see if it's recoil-operated is the quickest way to determine without removing the forearm as Old School noted. If yours is the XL, it should be the gas model. Considering you only paid $80 for it, that's a bargain, as these are good shotguns. Go to Corson's Barrels website and order up a slug barrel for it if you want to hunt with this and shoot 12 ga. slugs. The only consideration if there is a concern is you would be limited to shooting old style Foster slugs or similar-type projectiles. Smoothbores with iron sights can still turn in some impressive accuracy with the right loads for shooting under 100 yards. Considering what you've invested, it might be worth it. Ithaca Barrels

 

A lot of folks are going to the 20 ga., shooting rifled barrels with sabots. Some folks are getting tremendous accuracy out of their 20's, with less felt recoil than the 12's. Folks who scope their 12's & 20's with sabot rounds can reach out a long way accurately with the right gun/load combo. It's merely a preferential decision on the gauge. I don't think you can go wrong with either.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.